Macmillan at Suez

I've been away for a long, long time but I've decided I need to come back and enjoy some AH! The POD here is that, on 12th April 1953, Anthony Eden dies on the operating table. IOTL, the operation was horribly botched and destroyed his health, and it required corrective surgery- surgery that due to its timing stopped Churchill standing down after his own stroke in June that year.

The 13th April 1953 proved to be a sombre day across the United Kingdom. Winston Churchill announced to Parliament the death the previous day of the popular Foreign Secretary, Anthony Eden. A veteran of the Great War and a high-profile figure from the Second World War onwards, Eden was well-known and well-loved. He had died on the operating table after complications from an operation to remove gallstones, but instead had badly damaged his bile duct and secondary complications had caused his demise.

Churchill was bereft. Eden had been his clear, chosen successor, and was married to his niece. A state funeral was rejected by Eden's wife, Clarissa. In the meantime, he decided to promote the Housing Minister, Harold Macmillan to the role of Foreign Secretary- Macmillan had done a sterling job in his previous role, and Churchill was well-disposed to him. Eden's seat in Parliament was won (after a respectful waiting period) by the former Smethwick MP, Roy Wise.

Macmillan wasted no time in imposing his views, helped by the fact that Churchill was himself in poor health and willing to delegate. Which was ideal, because Macmillan's plans would have horrified the old man if he'd known the full plan.

Although Rab Butler, the Chancellor, and Macmillan were not particularly friends, they could at least work together. Macmillan's plan was to start decolonisation- he could smell that there was change in the air, and Butler did as well. More importantly to both men, there was an opportunity for costs to be reduced and to trim spending, and simultaneously reduce the need for cuts in the near future- and to use this as a stepping stone to Number Ten. Working together, but primarily directed by Macmillan, they quietly came up with a plan to arrange to exit a number of colonies once the opportunity arose, and once they could persuade Churchill- or more accurately, to wait for him to be unable to refuse. [1]

However, the chance did not come. On the 23rd June 1953, just two months after Eden's death, more drama occurred. At a dinner held for the Italian prime minister Gasperi, Churchill suffered a minor stroke [2]. His doctors advised him to step down immediately. Churchill, tired by now and depressed by Eden's demise, went to see the newly-crowned Queen.

[1] Of course, Macmillan did just that when he became Prime Minister, and got Iain MacLeod to do the work.
[2] This occurred IOTL- Churchill did not stand down because Eden himself was ill.
 
I've been away for a long, long time but I've decided I need to come back and enjoy some AH!
You certainly have been away for a long time! How long as it been? How the devil are you?

You've made a good start here, I shall follow this with interest.
 
A New Prime Minister

Churchill had asked the Marquess of Salisbury to sound out the Cabinet as to who would be acceptable. Butler was too unpopular; the Home Secretary, David Maxwell Fyfe, did not command much support within the Cabinet (as he was regarded as overtly ambitious), but did in the country; Harry Crookshank had zero support; and the rest were either not serious candidates, or peers.

Salisbury, like Churchill, was supportive of Macmillan, and sounded out Macmillan as a compromise. After all, his work at the Housing Ministry had been a triumph and wildly popular amongst the wider population- and he was 59, which seemed comparatively young but not too young, and was a decorated Great War veteran. Salisbury cunningly referred to him as "Captain Macmillan" as much as possible. The Cabinet were broadly in favour- and after all, with no real mechanism for a new leader to be selected, Churchill's recommendation would count for an awful lot.

And so it was that Churchill went to Buckingham Palace to resign. The Queen was disappointed, but understanding. Half an hour later, Macmillan (unaware that he had been selected, and hoping to be made Chancellor in a Butler government for now) was summoned to Buckingham Palace to kiss hands. That evening, the Conservative Party Chairman Lord Woolton made sure that Macmillan appeared on the BBC. It was a masterstroke- despite the small number of viewers, it gave Macmillan a thoroughly undeserved image as a modern prime minister, but one that was not tough after the elderly Churchill and the technophobic Attlee.

Macmillan made few changes to the Cabinet. Butler, whose pride was somewhat wounded, was appeased by being given the job he had craved- Foreign Secretary. Some of the other key positions filled were:
Leader of the Lords: Salisbury
Leader of the Commons: Harry Crookshank
Home Secretary: David Maxwell Fyfe
Agriculture, Fisheries and Food (a merged office): Sir Thomas Dugdale
Colonies: Iain MacLeod
Education: Florence Horsbrugh
Health: Gwilym Lloyd George
 
You certainly have been away for a long time! How long as it been? How the devil are you?

You've made a good start here, I shall follow this with interest.

I'm well thanks, and your good self? I've probably been away from this for a good two years.
 
The arrival of Macmillan at Number Ten was a source of surprise to the general public, although he was well-known. The circumstances of his elevation meant that there was no outcry about an unelected prime minister. Regardless, Macmillan was viewed as a popular choice and benefited from Churchill's clear approval, although Churchill himself was quickly retiring from public life.

The new (well, nearly new) administration wasted no time in making quick, obvious changes to demonstrate its energy. In late July, sugar rationing was finally ended, although meat rationing continued for now (it would be abolished in December 1953, with all remaining rationing abolished in February 1954.

There were also some very quick foreign policy manoeuvres. In August, Butler and MacLeod met with the Jamaican PM, Alexander Bustamante, and agreed to grant Jamaica its independence on 1st March 1954- although the MoD retained sovereign rights to a tract of land in Clarendon to be used as a naval station, subject to paying a lease to the Jamaican government.

Macmillan dispatched MacLeod to visit General Nasser, and end the Anglo-Egyptian condominium in Sudan as quickly as possible. Nasser was surprised by the proactive nature of the new administration, and readily agreed- although discussions about funding the proposed Aswan Dam did not go brilliantly well and this would rear its head again. [1]

[1] As IOTL.
 
Domestic Bliss

As 1953 drew to a close, Macmillan was reasonably entrenched and could point to concrete achievements. Rationing was almost over. Sudan, a drain on finances, had been palmed off. Early independence agreements had been thrashed out with Jamaica, Sierra Leone (with Britain maintaining rights to use Freetown for naval purposes, for a fee), and Barbados to gain their independence in 1954, with the protectorates lifted in Iraq and Kuwait that year as well. This was not without controversy, as Churchill quietly remained opposed, but he remained quietly fuming in Woodford and knew the game was up. Other attacks were easily repelled by Macmillan, drawing on his history in the army, serving the Empire. Naval presence in the Caribbean was increasingly drawn down, with most naval bases being abandoned in favour of Trinidad, Jamaica and Bermuda.

All of this presented Rab Butler with a huge financial fillip. The scaledown of colonial engagement meant less haemorraghing of cash. He now firmly expected to save millions of pounds going into the 1954 Budget, and now engaged in debate with Macmillan as to how this money should be kept in the country. A decision was taken that this money should be used to start the construction of a planned "motorway" on the lines of the Italian autostrade- this was already planned, but now the preparatory work could begin within six months. This initial road would go from Watford to Coventry.

And speaking of Coventry, Butler found money for an unsubtle piece of pork-barrel politics, funding the sympathetic rebuilding of the Georgian and medieval Cathedral Quarter in that city's centre, reconstructing many lost buildings (and parts of the city wall) much in the way that Cologne was currently creating. There is no doubt that this was the doing of Coventry's Conservative parliamentary candidates and the Conservative opposition on the county borough's council, given the number of marginals in and around Coventry.

In November 1953, proposals for commercial television passed through Parliament. This would manifest itself the following year, and was another sign that Britain was modernising slowly but surely.
 
Interesting start! Alternate Suez's are a favourite of mine and I don't think I've ever seen it approached from this angle, it's often what if Eden hadn't had his health problems instead of him not being in charge. More please! :)
 
How original, a timeline devoted to saving Coventry!

A timeline set 13-14 years after the Coventry Blitz, 7-8 years after the reconstruction of the Broadgate, and during the building of the Precinct.

Not exactly saving Coventry. Saving a bit more of the historic centre beyond Spon Street, and restricting the damage wrought by the ring road, yes.
 
A timeline set 13-14 years after the Coventry Blitz, 7-8 years after the reconstruction of the Broadgate, and during the building of the Precinct.

Not exactly saving Coventry. Saving a bit more of the historic centre beyond Spon Street, and restricting the damage wrought by the ring road, yes.

Close enough!
 
Ups and Downs

Early 1954 started with a little local difficulty, as the Crichel Down affair led to the Agriculture Minister, Thomas Dugdale, resigning. Thankfully for Macmillan, Dugdale's decision to take full responsibility took the flak and Derick Heathcoat-Amory was swiftly installed as his replacement in early January. More damaging to Macmillan's later image was the revelation in the same month that there was a link between smoking and cancer- Macmillan ordered Gwilym Lloyd George not to reveal this to the wider public as he believed the revenue to the Exchequer was too important, and as he was a smoker himself. [1]

The early months of 1954 continued to be dominated by economic matters. This began with attempts at economic pseudo-devolution (Macmillan was opposed to political devolution), and began with the Post Office's telecommunications powers. Determined to force regionalised, if not municipal, control of telecommunications, as had been the case many years before, Macmillan and the Postmaster-General Earl de la Warr came up with a plan to revert some of these powers [2]. As a result, and with significant and surprising Labour support, the 1954 Telecommunications Act allowed city corporations, or syndicates thereof, to purchase their municipal networks with government support. The first syndicate to do so would be made up of the Corporation of Manchester, the county boroughs of Salford and Stockport, and the boroughs of Stretford and Urmston, who formed Mersey & Irwell Telecom later that year. Over the next two years, local control of telecoms would be handed to council syndicates around Liverpool, Bristol, Southampton and Middlesbrough.

Against enormous Labour opposition this time, the government began to break up, but not privatise, British Coal. Kent Coal, Mercia Coal (Notts, Derbyshire, Staffs and Leicestershire) and Lancashire Coal were spun off as separate boards, with regional bases. Macmillan again had no desire to privatise, but plenty of desire to push better-paying jobs (but not the very top jobs) out to the regions.

Across the Channel, France was struggling. The economy was booming, but politically, there was great trouble. In Indochina, the French were engaged at Dien Bien Phu and Algeria was starting to become a headache, although revolt would not break out until later that year. The Prime Minister, Joseph Laniel, was in a bind- he was inspired by Macmillan's removal of colonial control, but politically he had no room to manoeuvre, especially in North Africa.

On 1st Match 1954, there were mass celebrations as Jamaica claimed its independence. The Governor, Sir Hugh Foot, handed over power to Alexander Bustamante, the Chief Minister, who now became Prime Minister. Foot took over the new role of Governor-General. Barbados and Sierra Leone followed the next week. Sierra Leone, somewhat bizarrely, was increasingly in hock not to their ex-colonial rules but to the Cadbury chocolate company, as Macmillan had arranged for significant cocoa concessions. This was partly for strategic reasons (securing a supply chain for a British "national champion"), but for the most cynical reason imaginable- Macmillan wanted to increase the amount of chocolate on British shelves in advance of a coming general election, in order to make it seem as if his administration was having a hugely positive impact.


[1] This happened IOTL, but it actually happened in 1956. The link was originally reported in January 1954.
[2] This had once been common- now the only city in control of its own telecom in any way is Hull.
 
Labour Pains

March saw a surprise result that did a great deal to ensconce Macmillan in his position. The high-flying Labour MP William Field had been forced to resign after being arrested on morals charges [1] and there was a by-election in Paddington North. This seat had been Labour since 1945, but the nature of the scandal and the selection of a relative of Anthony Eden meant that John Eden won the seat for the Conservatives by 14 votes, overturning a majority of 4,049. However, the seat would be lost at the subsequent general election.

There was great discontent within the Labour ranks, many of whom thought Clement Attlee was now too old to be leader. But unfortunately for the Labour party, in-fighting between the Left and Right continued, with Aneurin Bevan pitched against Hugh Gaitskell. This allowed Macmillan a great deal of free rein, especially when he put forward certain ideas that attracted sections of the Labour Party. Bevan eventually resigned from the shadow cabinet in April 1954 [2].

May saw the French defeated at Dien Bien Phu, and Laniel's government collapse, to be replaced by Pierre Mendes-France. But there was a strong sense that the Fourth Republic was in very bad shape.

Less heavily, West Bromwich Albion became the first team in the 20th Century to win a League and Cup double. The FA Cup was presented at Wembley by a baffled and uninterested Macmillan.


[1] I've moved this on by a few months, but this did happen.
[2] As IOTL.
 
Interesting. This seems to be a time which gains little coverage on here (from what I've seen), so I'm interested in seeing how this continues.

Subscribed
 
I am very interested in this period of history, I am even toying around with a similarly timed point of departure.

This time line has been fascinating so far.
 
Top