Impact of non-partitioned Vietnam post 1954

Could Vietnam not be divided and go in it's entirety to the Viet Minh

What would be the impact of undivided communist Vietnam post-1954

What would be the impact on the neighboring countries

What would Vietnam relationship be like with Soviet Union and China
 
Well there would likely be another million Vietnamese people. Maybe a smart US administration could make it an Asian Yugoslavia (as in communist neutral not collapsing with ethnic tensions). Plus there might have been less brutality.

Of course Lyndon Johnson would have the reputation of a great President
 

marathag

Banned
Plus there might have been less brutality.
Probably not, look how Uncle Ho's 'Land Reform' turned out, then stretch that to all Vietnam, with all the Catholic population trapped.

Collective Farms across the whole country means that Vietnam would no longer be a Rice exporter.
 
Well there would likely be another million Vietnamese people. Maybe a smart US administration could make it an Asian Yugoslavia (as in communist neutral not collapsing with ethnic tensions). Plus there might have been less brutality.

Of course Lyndon Johnson would have the reputation of a great President

That assumes JFK still wins in 1960.
 

longsword14

Banned
Could Vietnam not be divided and go in it's entirety to the Viet Minh
Not unless the French do something disastrously wrong.
What would be the impact of undivided communist Vietnam post-1954
Collectivisation everywhere. Failure of agriculture and starvation.
I am not sure about Communist intentions towards Laos and Cambodia in such a scenario.
What would be the impact on the neighboring countries
Extremely worried. Expect US involvement to bolster the rest of old French colonial possessions, i.e. Laos and Cambodia.
What would Vietnam relationship be like with Soviet Union and China
Positive, at least initially. Without Chinese aid the Vietnamese communists would not have been capable of offensive moves.
Butterflies make it hard to predict how the party itself evolves. This evolution would decide how Vietnam operates during the Sino-Soviet split.
 
Top