Germany vs Russian Empire (1914)

Who would win the war?

  • Germany

    Votes: 40 90.9%
  • Russian Empire

    Votes: 1 2.3%
  • Stalemate

    Votes: 3 6.8%

  • Total voters
    44
What if somehow a war broke out in August 1914 but in this alternate timeline, it's only Russian Empire fighting against Germany with no allies supporting either side. How would the war go? Who would win with the same developments in those two countries as we had in OTL?
 

TDM

Kicked
Given that Germany won this war with most of her forces in the west otl and the AH armies weren't really helping....

Yeah basically this.

Germany can't invade and take the entire empire of course. But it's going to take great big chunk out European Russia
 
You would need much earlier POD avoiding at least participation of France or then ASB getting only German-Russian War. But if this happen and anythign else not change (even still pretty ASB) Germany would defeat Russia pretty easily. Probably only one year depending how stubbornly Nicholas II tries fight and how willingful army is fighting against Germans.
 
Germany would win, but having imports/exports to get to russian through the black sea will help the russian cause, but not enough
 
You would need much earlier POD avoiding at least participation of France or then ASB getting only German-Russian War. But if this happen and anythign else not change (even still pretty ASB) Germany would defeat Russia pretty easily. Probably only one year depending how stubbornly Nicholas II tries fight and how willingful army is fighting against Germans.
Germany vs Russian and France would be a good match
 
Needs some kind of Franco-German deal for a plebiscite on Alsace-Lorraine - maybe as part of a somewhat different Moroccan affair in 1911. Without some fairly enormous bone to throw to Paris, France will mobilise as soon as it hears Germany has started, and once it has done so the balloon is going up in the west.
 
Germany vs Russian and France would be a good match

And this match would still be undisbuted German victory :p.

Needs some kind of Franco-German deal for a plebiscite on Alsace-Lorraine - maybe as part of a somewhat different Moroccan affair in 1911. Without some fairly enormous bone to throw to Paris, France will mobilise as soon as it hears Germany has started, and once it has done so the balloon is going up in the west.

Or simply, Germany never takes E-L.
 
Top