From the Glorious to the Failed Revolution: A British story.

3859843.jpg


From the Glorious to the
Failed Revolution: A British story.

***
Oh my...

Hiya. I bet you're a tad surprised.

Indeed. You're going out of your Spanish hunting grounds...


I needed a change. In the last few weeks I've been playing with several ideas: to restart my Carlist TL, to start a brief one about an Allied invasion of the Francoist Spain after WW2 and a very chaotic and bloody one based on present day Spain, but I've decided against all this, above all the last one, as I bet that the moderators would have used my skull to play cricket with it sooooooo... in short: I need to get rid of Spain for a while.

So... you've selected the United Kingdom... Is that a revenge?

What? Why?

For the Armada...

No.

Really?

Yes. Britons have enough punishment with their food.

Ahem...

Am I going to burn in hell for that joke? It's hardly worth a laugh... just as the British fo...

Let's see what you have in mind.

I'm going to retell a bit the British history to add some chaos and disorder into it. In fact, I was writting a new TL about a British PM and felt that I needed to go a bit back in time to explain a few things, so...

A British PM?

Yes.

Oh dear... Bearing in mind that your TLs sometimes end up with blood and guts spilling all over the place, I fear what you have in mind...

And you don't know the best part yet!

Oh dear, oh dear, oh dear...
 
1. Defeat
english-prisoners-in-the-spring-offensive-1918-c463y6.jpg

1. Defeat.

The Great War that had divided Europe in two migthy alliances led by Germany in one side, and a reluctant British Empire in the other, came to an anticlimatic end in 1919, after five years of failure. The collapse of Russia in early 1917 seemed to tip the balance in the Old Entente side, as London and Paris felt removed the Russian pressure from the Afghani-Indian and Persian-Turkish front, even if the Austrian Caporetto offensive and the French offensive in the Eight Battle of the Alps had been on the verge of crushing Italy. However, the effort to mount such an offensive had proved too much and the sudden outburst of social unrest that blew up the Austro-Hungarian Empire late that same year removed the dangerous Southern dagger that had threatened to cut Germany's throat after the Russian demise. The great German offensive of 1918, the so-called Kaiserchlacht, tored up throught the French army, which was still recovering from the mutinies of the last year and the bloody battles of the Itlian Front. Then, by July 15, with the German armies were fast approaching Paris, the capital was declared an open city. Two days later, Paris fell, and the war was all but over.

Berlin still attempted to punish the traitorous Turks that had changed sides and joined the Old Entente in 1915, and thus war dragged for another year without other results than the British occupation of Sardinia and Sicily and the decimation of the Italian Fleet in the battle of Otranto. Germany tried to play the Irish card and 1919 saw the failed Eastern Rising, a move that was met with the British support of the Red revolutionaries in Russia, much to changrin of Kaiser Wilhelm as the Russian turmoil was soon to spread into Hungary. The Arab rebellion was finally crushed that year, but the Ottoman Empire would, in the end, die from his old wounds and split in a (British) controlled way in 1920.

The so-called "Peace with Honour" forced the British Prime Minister Lord Beauchamp, who had replaced Herberth Asquith in 1919, to swallow the bitter pill of signing a peace treaty with Germany while Lord Kitchener, who had been the real ruler that had hid behind Asquith, departed to Canada, where he would live for the remainder of his life. Under the terms of the treaty, Britain and the other remaining members of the Old Entente were to acknowledge German gains in the war, while Germany would respect their overseas possessions. After all, in the Treaty of Compiegne, Germany had taken for itself a big loaf of the French Empire, so their colonial apetite was thus saciated. The British Empire remained largely intact, but the faith and support of the British people at home had not.
 
2. Twilight of an Empire?
large_000000.jpg

2. Twilight of an Empire?

The British Empire was shaken after the defeat. This obvious understatement was at the chore of what came next. For the average member of the Empire it was impossible to understand how things came to that point and even worse to accept that all the suffering and pain that the war had meant were for nothing. The grievous First Siege of Kabul, the muddy trenches of Flanders, the cold hills of the Caucasus and the German submarine blockade weighed heavily in the souls of the sons and daughters of the Empire.

The first signs of the incoming storm had been heard during the Turnip Winter of 1919, when the threat of starvation caused by the German Uboats became a reality. Britain had introduced rationing in London early in 1918 and extended it nationwide by the summer. The lost harvest of 1917 worsened even more the troubles and just the end of the war with the bitter "Peace with Honor" of 1920 avoided a worse fate to a Britain that was enduring more than it was possible. Malnourishment and illness kept claiming thousands of lives after the war due to malnutrition and disease that was commonplace amongst the British populace and the difficult post war situation made difficult to adress that. The deadly 1918 Spanish Flu didn't help to improve the situation either. Thus, morale of both civilians and soldiers continued to sink.

As I have just mentioned, the Turnip Winter saw the first rioting when some barns were assaulted and their orchads looted by starving Britons. Worker strikes were also common during this time as food shortages often directly led to labor unrest. The most notable strike took place in Birmingham in the winter of 1919 where workers complained of uneven food distribution. Then, the Dover mutiny of July 1919 shook the Empire when British soldiers mutinied after their protests against inedible rations remained unheard. For three days the soldiers took control of the base camp and had to be put down by reinforcements that were sent there in a hurry.

As the news from the peace negotiations at Paris crossed the Channel, the popular mood switched from a dark pesimism to sheer anger. Belgium, the cause of all that bloodshed, according to Mr. Grey, was abandoned to Germany while France was punished in such a way that the 1871 peace treaty looked lenient. Of course, Lord Beauchamp cabinet resigned in mass, being replaced by David Lloyd George, even if that action did not avoid the exiting ministers the hatred of the defeated. After all, they had signed a peace that looked as a surrender. Were not the guns still being fired in the Middle East? Was not the Royal Navy still standing on the way of any possible German invasion? The "Peace with Honor" was nothing but sheer betrayal, as many voices began to claim, among them Horatio Bottomley.

Having Lloyd George on Downing Street, though, it was a biter pill to swallow. He had been an opponent of war until the Agadir Crisis of 1911 and, when war seemed inminent, he seemed likely to resign if Britain intervened, but he held back, as he was deeply moved by news that Belgium had been invaded and made an impressive speech in the Parliament to ask the Commons to vote almost unanimously in favour of war loans, accepting that the war was a necessary patriotic, defensive measure. However, not many had forgotten his initial attitude.

Thus, when the first news of the French revolution arrived to Britain a few months later, no one was surprised.
 
I like it. Historically the UK was facing major unrest in 1918.

What about Ireland?
Was there an election in 1918? Under an equivalent of RotPA-1918?
 
I like it. Historically the UK was facing major unrest in 1918.

What about Ireland?
Was there an election in 1918? Under an equivalent of RotPA-1918?

Indeed, the UK was in a sticky situation in the home front by 1918. I'm going to worsen it a bit...

Ireland is going to appear soon, in the next chapter in fact. The election of 1918? Well... Ireland and a few things I have in store for Britain are going to delay it a bit, I'm afraid. The RotPA may suffer a bit of a change, too, because of the same things...
 
So it was Britain, France, Austria-Hungry versus Italy, the Ottomans (mid-switch), Germans and Russians? I expect the Empire will send some food aid but it may be too late.
 
So it was Britain, France, Austria-Hungry versus Italy, the Ottomans (mid-switch), Germans and Russians? I expect the Empire will send some food aid but it may be too late.

The Empire, you say? Weeeeeeeeell... the Dominions, the colonies and the rest have their own troubles, so... well, they are going to do something, indeed.
 
3. Na Trioblóidí: the Troubles.
K0B90nkforwardslashoNforwardslashRM

3. Na Trioblóidí: the Troubles.

The news of the French Revolution filled with shock and awe the British upper and middle classes and with hope to those who had endured the worst part of the war. The collapse of the French Republic and its replacement, after weeks of chaos, by a Provisional Government of Liberals and Socialists, and on the other the CGT (the Confédération Générale du Travail - General Confederation of Labour) made many to remember the Russian Revolution. Many wondered if the CGT would try to depose the Provisional Government as the Bolsheviks had attempted to do in theirl coup'd etat in October 1917 that led to the civil war and the assasination of Lenin on on August 30th, 1919 by Fanya Kaplin, a member of the Socialist-Revolutionary Party (SR).

However, France remained stable until early autumn 1919, when the Provisional Government attempted to disarm and demobilise the French Army following the conclusion of peace treaty with the Germans. Even if the treaty was the main reason for the demobilization, as its clauses marked that France was to demobilize sufficient soldiers by 31 March 1920 to leave an army of no more than 150,000 men. However, fearing the Government was being corrupted by the Left parties and were thus weakening the defence of the country, General Petain launched a coup d'etat in July 1919, which led the Socialist Party to ally with the CGT, who, then, declared the Provisional Government an enemy of the Proletariat. Inspired by the Russian revolutionaries, the CGT began to arm the workers and to rally the army units sympathetic to its cause while creating revolutionary "courts" all over the country. Of course, this led to war in France in a few weeks, too.

Then, Ireland that, before the war, had verged on civil war between Unionists and Irish nationalists, began to move. A rising had been on the works since May 1915, when Tom Clarke and Sean MacDermott established a Military Committee or Military Council within the IRB (the Irish Republican Brotherhood, a secret organisation dedicated to the establishment of an "independent democratic republic" in Ireland which had been founded in 1858) that included Patrick Pearse, to draw up plans for a rising. However, in spite of the demands of the Western Front, the British garrison in Ireland was reinforced through 1916 and the plans had to be postponed. Now, in 1919, Clarke and MacDermott thought that the time to strike had finally arrived. In that they were supported and helped by Michael Collins. When some attacks on the Royal Irish Constabulary (RIC) barracks took place in October 1919, the natural reaction of Lloyd George was to reinforce the British forces in the Green Island and to raise volunteeers units there. Germany, of course, keep a keen eye on the island, as Berlin provided full backing to the Irish rebels and began to send captured Mosin Nangat rifles, Maxim M1910 machine guns and ammunition to the Irish rebels.

The Unionist paramilitaries began to raid the Catholic communities in Ulster and soon the counties were bloodied by the killings and the ensuing reprisals of both sides while the the British Army had its hand full figthing Collin's guerrillas in an all-out war and the RIC was unable (or unwilling) to maintain order amd the spreading of violence. Thus, by early 1920, Casement, who had been travelling in the United States to raise money for the Cause, moved to Germany and asked for an audience with Wilhelm II in Berlin with the idea of demaning German help for Ireland. Then, on Easter 1920, Dublin rose in arms against the British and the Troubles developed into the Irish war.
 
Indeed, the UK was in a sticky situation in the home front by 1918. I'm going to worsen it a bit...
Excellent. If you're interested in a good book on the period I thoroughly recommend Webb's 1919: Britain's Year of Revolution (link).

Ireland is going to appear soon, in the next chapter in fact. The election of 1918? Well... Ireland and a few things I have in store for Britain are going to delay it a bit, I'm afraid. The RotPA may suffer a bit of a change, too, because of the same things...
BTW one of the interesting factors in radicalising Ireland after the historical Easter Rising (or 'Nine-Days Insurrection if you prefer the period description) was the Conscription Crisis of 1918 (wiki) which managed to unite a disparate group to oppose it. This led to the 'German Plot' (wiki) scare which was adroitly used by Tommy Gay (a Dublin city librarian and deputy to Collins) to effectively decapitate the leadership of Sinn Féin by allowing the British authorities to arrest the moderates, while warning the more extreme faction within the party. Thus the radicals gained control of the movement.

In an althist where Germany isn't defeated it's very likely they'll be interested in Ireland, to the point of providing supplies, support and diversionary maneuverings. The military leadership will be fully aware of the value of Irish bases for use against Britain in the inevitable Greater War.

ETA: some interesting pics here. Alas it's the Fail.
 
Last edited:
This sounds ominous.

A bit, a bit, indeed.

Excellent. If you're interested in a good book on the period I thoroughly recommend Webb's 1919: Britain's Year of Revolution (link).

It sounds jolly interesting... and it has given me some ideas...

BTW one of the interesting factors in radicalising Ireland after the historical Easter Rising (or 'Nine-Days Insurrection if you prefer the period description) was the Conscription Crisis of 1918 (wiki) which managed to unite a disparate group to oppose it. This led to the 'German Plot' (wiki) scare which was adroitly used by Tommy Gay (a Dublin city librarian and deputy to Collins) to effectively decapitate the leadership of Sinn Féin by allowing the British authorities to arrest the moderates, while warning the more extreme faction within the party. Thus the radicals gained control of the movement.

In an althist where Germany isn't defeated it's very likely they'll be interested in Ireland, to the point of providing supplies, support and diversionary maneuverings. The military leadership will be fully aware of the value of Irish bases for use against Britain in the inevitable Greater War.

ETA: some interesting pics here. Alas it's the Fail.

Yes, the Conscription Crisis was one of those moments in British history that, had it happened in any other country, would have ended rather badly. Mmmm... Gay and the German plot offer interesting opportunities....

I agree. If during the Great War Germany did his bit to create troubles in Ireland, in a victorious ending for them and with France in disarray, the tempation to mess there would be impossible to resist for Kaiser Billy.

Thanks a lot for the links and the pics!
 
4. Irish troubles, international meddling.
ai-war-2.jpg

4. Irish troubles, international meddling.

The Irish War, that lasted from 1920 to 1922, was an embroilled affair that goes beyond the scope of the present study, so this chapter will cover just the aspects that had a direct influence on British politics and not in the long and bloody campaigns that created what was later called "the Irish War". In one moment, there were five armies on the field and tey kept busy themselves fighting against each other. On the Loyalist side, there was the British army plus the various Loyalists militias, that sometimes carried out a war of its own in spite of the orders comming form London. On the Rebel side, there were the Irish Republican Army of Collins and De Valera; then the "German branch" of the IRA led by Casement and John Kenny, which was never nothing but a tool used by Berlin to trouble the already troubled British government; finally, the Irish Socialist Republican Army (ISRA) led by James Conolly and supported with very much troubles by the new French State, the Commune de France.

By 1921 it was clear to almost everybody but London that Britain had lost the control of Ireland. Most of the countryside was in the hands of the rebels, and it became the scenario of the open war between the IRA of De Valera and the one of Casement against the Syndicalist supported ISRA of Conolly. By the end of that year, two thirds of the Irish counties were lost and Lloyd George asked to Washington to mediate between the two warrying sides. It was a big mistake, as the then president of the United States, James M. Cox, was in no position to be of any help. Rising to the White House thought the growing discontent among the electorate over the interminable recession that had engulfed the nation after the end of the war and the rising star of Germany began to be a serious competitor the the US trade, President Cox's administration quickly proved a disappointment and turned his back to Britain.

However, Germany rose to the opportunity, and using a mixture of diplomacy and military threat, Berlin offered a solution to the current situation, a pleibiscite to decide the fate of the island. Pressed with the German threat of reinstate the submarine blockade against Britian unless peace talks began at once, Lloyd George accepted the pleibiscite option and so did De Valera and Casement. The result of the process was never in question in the areas dominated by the IRAs, while Conolly, that in the beginning refused the whole idea as a "capitalist trap", finally accepted it. However, by then the ISRA had been almost wiped out of the battlefield after the bloody battles of late 1920 and the lack of a continued French support, so Conolly's opinions carried little weight.

The pleibiscite was hardly a pacific solution, as both sides kept fighting each other, with the Loyalists militias, headed by the infamous Black and Tans, raiding the rebel areas and then carrying out a cleansing of the Loyalist counties by forcing the Catholic inhabitats of those areas to flee, which led to the popular uprising of April 1921 in Belfast and surrounding areas backed by the IRA. The Loyalist militias rushed to meet this uprising, and fighting on a large scale took place in the late spring and early summer of 1921. During this mad period, the German navy send a small detachement to Ireland and landed a marine force with the declared aim of "protecting German and other Foreign citizens and propierties" in Belfast. In fact, what they did was to help to increase the havoc, and London soon complained to Berlin that the German soldiers were prone to favor the insurrection by refusing to put down their violent activities or restore order.

In the end, the pleibiscite turned to be a dissapointment for De Valera and Casement and a relief to Lloyd Goerge that soon he came to regret. All of Ireland but for the northern counties of Ulster voted for independece, but the strong Unionist minority in the north refused plainly to do so. Thus, the war last until the end of the year, as the IRA pressed its actions against the bulwark of British unionism in the north, but to no avail. The Treaty Peace of 1922 created the Repubic of Ireland, but without the Ulster, that remained with the United Kingdom, and opened the way for the internal bickering among the Irish nationalist leaders and the usual mutual accusations of treason that would plague the new state for the next decade.

Similar charges were thrown in Britain, not only against Lloyd George, for his perceived "treason", but also against King George V, who, all of the sudden, discovered that he had too many German blood in his veins, according at least to some disgruntled Britons.
 
Last edited:
In fact, what they did was to help to increase the havoc, and London soon complained to Berlin that the German soldiers were prone to were favoring the insurrection by refusing to put down their violent activities or restore order.
*Points to the British Army and the Black and Tans*

Fair's fair.
 
*Points to the British Army and the Black and Tans*

Fair's fair.

True. The dialogue would have been like that:

London: You see, your guys here are doing nothing to stop the violence!
Berlin: What about the RIC?
London: What about the IRA?
Berlin: What about the Black and Tans?
London: What about the ISRA?
Berlin: Zose Britiz are hard to deal wiz...
 
but without the Ulster

How much of Ulster remained British seeing as Ireland was partitioned by plebiscite? All nine counties, the six counties that became Northern Ireland OTL, or the four Protestant-majority counties of Antrim, Armagh, Derry and Down? Seems like it might be the latter if the plebiscite was organised by county.

Also with Patrick Pearse and Joseph Plunkett still being alive and Germany being the dominant power that helped secure Irish freedom might there be an attempt to make Prince Joachim of Prussia the King of Ireland? From Wikipedia:
During the Easter Rising in 1916, some republican leaders, including Patrick Pearse and Joseph Plunkett, contemplated giving the throne of an independent Ireland to Prince Joachim.

While they were not in favour of a monarchy in itself, Pearse and Plunkett thought that if the rising were successful and Germany won the First World War, an independent Ireland would be a monarchy with a German prince as king, like Romania and Bulgaria before it.

The fact that Joachim did not speak English was also considered an advantage, as he might be more disposed to learning and promoting the use of the Irish language.

In his memoirs, Desmond Fitzgerald wrote "That would have certain advantages for us. It would mean that a movement for de-anglicisation would flow from the head of the state downwards, for what was English would be foreign to the head of the state. He would naturally turn to those who were more Irish and Gaelic, as to his friends, for the non-nationalist element in our country had shown themselves to be so bitterly anti-German.......For the first generation or so it would be an advantage, in view of our natural weakness, to have a ruler who linked us with a dominant European power, and thereafter, when we were better prepared to stand alone, or when it might be undesirable that our ruler should turn by personal choice to one power rather than be guided by what was most natural and beneficial for our country, the ruler of that time would have become completely Irish."
 
Last edited:
How much of Ulster remained British seeing as Ireland was partitioned by plebiscite? All nine counties, the six counties that became Northern Ireland OTL, or the four Protestant-majority counties of Antrim, Armagh, Derry and Down? Seems like it might be the latter if the plebiscite was organised by county.

Also with Patrick Pearse and Joseph Plunkett still being alive and Germany being the dominant power that helped secure Irish freedom might there be an attempt to make Prince Joachim of Prussia the King of Ireland? From Wikipedia:

Just the four majority Protestant counties, as there were still too many Catholics in the other two, in spite of all the cleasing carried out by the Black and Tans.

Yes, Germany is going to have a bit of weight in Irish politics. About Joachim (thanks for reminding me of him!), I have plans for him. I don't think that too many Irish would like the idea of a king, even if that could piss mightly off the Brits...
 
5. The road to Revolution.
battle-of-mons-56a61b225f9b58b7d0dff07c.jpg

5. The road to Revolution.

The first signs that the British Homefront was not quiet came in an anonymous leaflet that began to circulate. Its unknown author claimed in ti that "the present war in Ireland is not willed by the British people and and it is not waged in the interest of the Britons or any other people. It is an imperialist war, a war for capitalist control and the political domination of Ireland to have it wide open for industrial and banking plunder". Following this line, the Scottish Revolutionary Socialist John Maclean wrote in the newspaper he had helped to create in April 1919, The New Paper:

‘Bourgeois society is working so effectively towards its own downfall that we need merely wait for the moment to pick up the power dropping from its hands... Yes, I am convinced that the realization of our aims is so close that there are few of us who will not live to see the day.’

By that time the split of the Labour party became a reality. Maclean led the criticism of his ideological rivals by stating that Labour had given its back to the workers and began to call the Labour leadership as the "Royal Socialist League". He focused on how the Labour leaders had been ordinary people speaking the language of ordinary people. Now they were heard speaking the language of the rulers and were sharing the concerns of the ruling class. A certain alienation was inevitable and Maclean's criticism hit a nerve on many members of the Labour Party’s left wing, which splintered off on May 1919, that joined the Independent Labour Party (ILP) led by Tom Mann.

Thus, when Lloyd George finally resigned in December 1921 and was replaced by Ramsay MacDonald, the leaders of the ILP decried MacDonald as another traitor to the worker's cause. He was also criticised by the most conservative newspapers and journalists led by Hotario Bottomley, who used to blame the defest in the war and the Irish troubles to "the cowards in Washington, the Russian Bolsheviks, the Jewish controlling the City and the Huns in Westminster and the Huns in High Places!”.

When Ramsay MacDonald admited defeat on March 19, 1922 and announced to the Empire the end of the war, the Armistice Riots became the first scene of the Revolution.
 
<snip>
The Treaty Peace of 1922 created the Free State of Ireland, but without the Ulster, that remained with the United Kingdom, and opened the way for the internal bickering among the Irish nationalist leaders and the usual mutual accusations of treason that would plague the new state for the next decade.
I feel it rather unlikely that this term would be used. The new independent Ireland would almost certainly opt to immediately become a republic.
 
How much of Ulster remained British seeing as Ireland was partitioned by plebiscite? All nine counties, the six counties that became Northern Ireland OTL, or the four Protestant-majority counties of Antrim, Armagh, Derry and Down? Seems like it might be the latter if the plebiscite was organised by county.
It'd probably depend on how well the ethnic cleansing went. With Germany support I'd expect a minimal Ulster (four counties) remaining within the UK.

Also with Patrick Pearse and Joseph Plunkett still being alive and Germany being the dominant power that helped secure Irish freedom might there be an attempt to make Prince Joachim of Prussia the King of Ireland? From Wikipedia:
That scenario is highly unlikely, the idea was propounded by a small fringe.
 
Top