Could Robert the Bruce have won over the Lords of Ireland?

Simple question, really. The bruces wanted to prevent the english using Ireland as a launchpad to reinforce carlisle and attack the strathclyde area.

As a result they sent troops to Ireland during the years they weren't campaigning in England.

Their stratgey was to play on pan celtic sentiment and hopefully recruit gaelic irish armies to use against the anglo norman leadership in ireland while at the same time encouraging welsh rebellion.

Colin McNamee has made the argument that this strategy was ultimately hopeless and based on Edward Bruce's ambition rather than tactical matters (in particular setting off during bad weather) and that a wiser strategy might have been using a show of force in an attempt to bring the anglo norman leadership in Ireland over to Robert's side as they weren't happy with Edward II.

Is there any chance of that working?
 

VVD0D95

Banned
Considering it took a massive piece of luck for the English to defeat the Bruce's in Ireland I'd say they did almost succeed. Bruce had the support of a moat if not all the Celtic nobility
 
Top