An Alternate Trek

After the Film-US

Paramount executives were to say the least flummoxed! A film which took under $200 million in the US should at best have garnered just under $100 million overseas. Conversely a film that took over $300 million overseas should have taken around $600 million in the US!

The reaction to the film in the UK was relatively easily explained, after all Star Trek was nearly as much a cultural icon as Doctor Who, but why the similar reaction elsewhere? For heaven’s sake Star Trek had outperformed Avatar in the CIS!

Despite what was felt in the UK there was always going to be a second Star Trek film, after all there were nearly $500 million reasons! However the executives at Paramount wanted to understand what had happened. So they commissioned research. This was delivered by the end of May 2010.

To be honest they should have just looked at what their predecessors in the late 60s had thought about the ITC Star Trek. All their expensive new research did was dress up the very same conclusions in modern day terminology!

In general, American audiences were less willing to invest time in getting to know the characters before any action started. Conversely European and Asian audiences didn’t mind having more talk and a more thoughtful plot.

They had to find a middle way to keep the rest of the world onside whilst getting a bigger American take. They were just about to announce Star Trek II in November when the BBC Children in Need Doctor Who special was aired in the UK. The executives were livid. However it was pointed out to them firstly that perhaps it would have been wiser to keep the BBC hierarchy in the loop and secondly look at the reaction to it on You Tube even in the US!

So Star Trek II was greenlighted in January 2011. There were two problems which had to be overcome. Firstly Chris Hemsworth was now tied to Marvel as Thor and Channing Tatum was involved in postproduction of “The Eagle of the IXth” (ITTL version of “The Eagle”- it is a FAR better film which sticks more closely to Rosemary Sutcliff’s book, for example Donald Sutherland’s character is far more faithful to the original’s Uncle Aquila).

However these were problems which were surmountable. They needed a screenplay that would satisfy all audiences and make a profit!
 
Star Trek II: Out of Darkness

Star Trek II: Out of Darkness is a 2014 American science fiction action film directed by J. J. Abrams and written by Roberto Orci, Alex Kurtzman, and Mark Gatiss. It is the second Star Trek film and the sequel to the 2009 film Star Trek. The film features Will Smith reprising his role as Captain Ben Franklin, with Zachary Quinto, Simon Pegg, Zoe Saldana, Chris Hemsworth, Channing Tatum, Bruce Greenwood, Colin Firth and Hugh Laurie reprising their roles from the previous film. Set in the 23rd century, Franklin and the crew of the CSS Endeavour are sent to a colony world due to archaeological discoveries made there.

After the release of Star Trek, Abrams, Burk, Kurtzman, and Orci agreed to produce its sequel. Filming began in January 2013. Out of Darkness's visual effects were primarily created by Industrial Light & Magic. The film was converted to 3D during its post-production stage.

Plot

The Endeavour is sent to the colony world New Columbia where Professor Joseph Bell has made a breakthrough in translating some stone tablets found in ancient ruins. They seem to foretell an era of destruction unless something is done. Unfortunately he cannot find what.

The planets align in a certain manner (as per prophecy and which occurs every 650 years) and a wormhole opens. A fleet of ships come through it and the planet is invaded by strange humanoids. The Endeavour battles the alien ships whilst Travis and CPO Blamire fight them on the ground.

Eventually Bell discovers what to do to defeat the invaders and together with Spock, Stein, Scotty and O’Gorman manage to repair and activate the planet’s ancient defence system.

The invaders are driven back and the wormhole closed.

Cast

Captain: Benjamin Russell Will Smith
First Officer: Commander Spock Zachary Quinto
CSO Commander: Richard Brynne Colin Firth
CEO Commander: Montgomery Scott Simon Pegg
Navigation: Lieutenant Caroline D'Alembert Rachel Adams
Helm: Lieutenant Gary Mitchell Channing Tatum
CSecO: Lieutenant Commander John Travis Chris Hemsworth
C Comms Officer: Lieutenant Commander Esther McKenzie Zoe Saldana
CMO: Lieutenant Commander Richard Fynely Hugh Laurie
Other characters
Engineering: CPO Aedh O'Gorman Colm Meaney
Doctor M'Beke Noel Clarke
Science Officer: Lieutenant Stein Nick Frost

Admiral Christopher Pike Bruce Greenwood

CPO Blamire Liam Cunningham

Professor Joseph Bell Benedict Cumberbatch

Production

Development

Greenlighted in January 2011, a release date of June 29, 2012, was set, with Gatiss announcing he had begun working on the script with Kurtzman and Orci. Pre-production was set for January 2011, although Burk said actual filming would probably begin during the spring or summer. Actor Zachary Quinto later said that these reports were untrue.

Abrams, Kurtzman, and Orci said that selecting a villain was difficult; according to Abrams, "the universe Roddenberry created is so vast that it's hard to say one particular thing stands out". Abrams admitted in December 2011 that there was still no script.

In January 2012, Abrams said he had not decided whether or not he would direct, since he had not yet seen a script. Paramount Pictures then approached him, asking that the sequel be in 3D. Abrams said that the film would not be shot in 3D, but filmed in 2D and converted during post-production. He was also interested in filming in IMAX: "IMAX is my favourite format; I’m a huge fan." In February, Orci tweeted that he (with Gatiss and Kurtzman) planned to deliver the script in March 2012. Although the script was not finished on schedule, Paramount began financing pre-production

Although a script was completed, uncertainty regarding the extent of Abrams's involvement led to the film's being pushed back a year from its scheduled June 2012 release. Other factors which precluded the release, ending up pushing it further back were the high budget and overall difficulty of finding actors to fit the roles. In June, Abrams confirmed that his next project would be the sequel, noting that he would rather the film be good than ready by its scheduled release date. Simon Pegg, who played Scotty, said in an interview that he thought filming would begin during the latter part of the year. Abrams stated he would prioritize the film's story and characters over an early release date. In September, Abrams agreed to direct the film, with the cast from the previous film reprising their respective roles for a summer 2014 release. In October, Orci said that location scouting was underway, and a comic book series (of which Orci would be creative director) would "foreshadow" the film. Michael Giacchino confirmed that he would return to write the score.

Filming

Out of Darkness began principal photography in January 12, 2013, with a scheduled release date of May, 2014. Cinematographer Dan Mindel shot the film using a combination of anamorphic 35mm film and 15 perforation IMAX cameras. About 30 minutes of the film is shot in the IMAX format, while some other scenes were also shot on 8 perforation 65mm. Out of Darkness was released in 3D. Production ended in May 2013.

Music

Composer Michael Giacchino composed the film's incidental music. Out of Darkness was Giacchino's fourth film collaboration with Abrams, which included Star Trek (2009). The film score was recorded at the Sony Scoring Stage in Culver City, California from March to April 2014. Its soundtrack album was released digitally in May 2014.

Epilogues

Similar in manner to the Marvel films which Paramount had produced there were two extra scenes. The first after the cast credits showed Franklin and Spock discussing that the Aliens would return in 650 years. After some musing on longevity of civilisations Spock says that he might have a way of leaving such a warning.

The second at the final end of the credits shows Spock meditating. He snaps awake and signals somebody. After a while the door to his room opens and we see that somebody (their face is in shadow so cannot be seen) ask

“What is it Spock?”

The person is wearing a uniform similar to that of the USS Enterprise!

Distribution

Dolby Laboratories and Paramount announced that Star Trek II: Out of Darkness would be released in Dolby Atmos, with Andy Nelson and Anna Behlmer handling the mix with supervision from Ben Burtt and Matthew Wood. The film was released on May 8th, 2014, in international markets and May 15th, 2014, in the United States.

Release

Box office

Out of Darkness earned $31.5 million on its opening day in the United States and Canada. The film earned $42 million the following Friday. It earned $110.6 million during its opening weekend, finishing in the US box-office top spot. Total weekend earnings were $134.1 million, including the early-showing grosses. These vastly exceeded Paramount's projected box-office earnings, studio vice-chairman Rob Moore said he was "extremely pleased" with the sequel's performance.

The film grossed $397 million at the foreign box office, less than its predecessor, given inflation, but still more than would be normally expected. Star Trek II: Out of Darkness ended its North American theatrical run on September 10th, 2014, with a box office total of $378,778,661, which places it as the highest-grossing film for 2014 in the US. It earned $775,365,246 worldwide, ranking it in 3rd place for 2014.

Critical reception

On Rotten Tomatoes the film has an approval rating of 86%, based on 271 reviews, with an average rating of 7.5/10. The site's consensus reads, "Visually spectacular and suitably action packed, Star Trek II: Out of Darkness is a rock-solid instalment in the venerable sci-fi franchise, even if it's not as fresh as its predecessor." On Metacritic the film has a score of 76 out of 100, based on 43 critics, indicating "generally favourable reviews". It received an average grade of "A" from market-research firm CinemaScore.

Critics called it a "rousing adventure" and "a riveting action-adventure in space". Cumberbatch's performance attracted praise from critics, with Peter Travers of Rolling Stone calling it a "tour de force to reckon with”. The New York Times praised his screen presence: "He fuses Byronic charisma with an impatient, imperious intelligence that seems to raise the ambient I.Q. whenever he's on screen".

However, not all of reviews were positive; The Independent said the film would "underwhelm even the Trekkies". Lou Lumenick of the New York Post gave the film one-and-a-half stars (out of four), saying it had a "limp plot" and the "special effects are surprisingly cheesy for a big-budget event movie". A.O. Scott dismissed the film in The New York Times: "It's uninspired hackwork, and the frequent appearance of blue lens flares does not make this movie any more of a personal statement".

However the film was received well by both fans of Star Trek and of Enterprise. There was much excitement about the extra scenes and what this meant. The internet was rife with speculation!
 
Last edited:
Fan Productions

Fan productions have been made since Star Trek was first broadcast in the 1960s. Most of them were student or home-made productions. In Britain they have tended to remain such. The difficulty of keeping the same people available for more than one production (or even one in one infamous case –The Fram which can still be found on You Tube) hampered the making of these in a way that Doctor Who did not. It was the advent of inexpensive digital cameras, editing and effects in the 1990s that made fan productions much easier to produce although this still tended to be in the US. The following is a list of some of the more prominent fan productions, it is not meant to be exhaustive.

Starship Hornet

An online series produced by Jimm and Joshua Johnson that focuses on the adventures of the starship USS Hornet, a sister ship of the USS Enterprise in the Star Trek: USS Enterprise era, with production design to match. It has been mentioned by The New York Times and Register-Guard (Oregon). Two episodes were released.

USS Farragut

Launched in July 2005, this series takes place during the United Systems era, and tells the story of the crew of the USS Farragut, sister ship of the Enterprise. Farragut stars John Broughton as Captain John Carter, Michael Bednar as Commander Robert Tacket & Holly Bednar as Chief Engineer Michelle Smithfield with an ensemble cast. The premise is simply put, "New Ship, New Crew, New Adventures". The episodes "For Want of a Nail" and "A Rock and a Hard Place" won the award for Best Fan Film at the Wrath of Con Film Festival in Panama City, Florida in 2008 and 2009 respectively. As of February 2016, Farragut has released 5 full-length episodes (most recently "The Crossing"), 3 short vignettes and 2 animated episodes.

Enterprise Continues

First produced in 2013, this series looks to chronicle what happens after Hunter prevents the invasion of the Carnyate. The series features anime voice actors Vic Mignogna and Todd Haberkorn as Hunter and Spock, respectively. Other notable cast include Chris Doohan (son of James Doohan) as Angus Montgomery, and voice actor Chuck Huber as Piper. It also co-stars Grant Imahara (MythBusters) as Nogura. The first episode, was released in 2013. Five full episodes had been released as of December, 2015. It has been praised for showing the now strained relationship between Hunter and Spock (Hunter remembers Spock’s betrayal whereas rather obviously Spock does not) and how it is painstakingly rebuilt.

Enterprise: Hidden Frontier

A series with fifty produced episodes, the series is set shortly after the end of Emissary and centres on the starship Excelsior and its home base, Deep Space 12, as they mediate disputes between various races and fend off attacks from a powerful new alien race, the Grey. Fan Films Quarterly listed Hidden Frontier as one of the ten most pivotal moments in fan film history in its Summer 2006 issue. The BBC in 2006 called the series "the most prominent" Enterprise fan film.


TNG: Intrepid

A U.K. based fan film, and presently the only such production from Scotland, Intrepid is set several years after Emissary, and revolves around the effort to colonise a distant and largely unexplored sector of the galaxy. TNG: Intrepid was filmed entirely in Scotland and was released on May 26, 2007. GMTV presenter Lorraine Kelly has a brief appearance in Intrepid and the production has received extensive coverage in both national and international media, such as CNN, BBC Radio Scotland the Guardian, and The Scotsman. Intrepid was featured on the UK Sci Fi Channel's Sci Fi 360 video podcast. Executive Producer and cast member Nick Cook has also collaborated with the Hidden Frontier crew several times

Enterprise: The New Voyages

Co-creators James Cawley and Jack Marshall aimed to fill in the gaps in both Star Trek: USS Enterprise and Enterprise, with actors cast as Hunter, Spock and the rest of the Enterprise crew on an exact replica of the original bridge set. Fan Films Quarterly listed New Voyages as one of the ten most pivotal moments in fan film history in its Summer 2006 issue, and it has been reported on by National Public Radio. New Voyages also won TV Guide's 2007 Online Video Award for best sci-fi Webisode.

Legal issues

The attitude of the Star Trek copyright and trademark holders toward fan works has varied over time. In early 1996, Viacom (which purchased Paramount in 1994) sent cease and desist letters to webmasters of Enterprise fan sites (but not Star Trek ones) that contained copyrighted film clips, sounds, insignia, or other copyrighted material. In the lead-up to the release of Enterprise: In Thine Own Image, then-president of Paramount Digital Entertainment David Wertheimer stated that Viacom was targeting sites that were "selling ads, collecting fees, selling illegal merchandise or posting copyrighted materials." Under threat of legal action, many websites shut down.

Jennifer Granick, a San Francisco criminal lawyer who went on to champion cyber rights, felt that the unofficial sites should be covered by the fair use doctrine in U.S. copyright law. In 1998, then-UCLA associate professor Howard Besser claimed the entertainment industry as a whole was, and cited Viacom's actions toward Enterprise site webmasters as an example of, "exploiting concerns over digitization and attempting to reshape the law by strengthening protection for copyrights holders and weakening public rights to access and use material."

Enterprise fan films have, until recently, operated in an informational vacuum, since Paramount has made few official statements regarding their existence. Fan filmmakers have generally kept a low profile, hoping not to draw attention to themselves. However, after the release of Enterprise: Emissary in 1998, the fan film community began drawing more attention in the media, and even a certain amount of recognition from the entertainment industry.

Enterprise: The New Voyages, one fan series, has established an understanding that Paramount must be properly credited as the owner of Enterprise-related intellectual property.

In June 2015 Paramount issued guidelines to assist fan-made productions from litigation; in summary:


Fan-made productions must be original stories and must be short (less than 30 minutes in total for a single storyline).

Actors and other creative talent must be amateurs; they cannot be compensated for their work nor be previous employees of official Enterprise productions.

The productions must be non-commercial. Crowd-sourced fundraising is permitted up to US$50,000, but distribution of fan-made works must be on a no-cost basis and must not generate revenue.

Fan-made productions may use bootleg props: on-screen props must be other fan-made or be official Enterprise merchandise.

Fan-made productions must be family friendly; they may not include profanity, nudity, obscenity, pornography, or depictions of harmful or illegal activities such as use of illegal drugs.

Fan-made productions must provide a disclaimer indicating that Enterprise intellectual property is owned solely by Paramount. Further, the guidelines restrict how the name Enterprise may be used in titling the production.

Because of the guidelines issued by Paramount many Enterprise fan productions ceased.

Enterprise Continues was the one hardest hit, although apparently they accepted the writing was on the wall after rumours about epilogue scenes for Star Trek II began circulating, and just finished the episode that was already in production.

Interestingly the BBC have adopted a far different approach to intellectual property rights over Star Trek. As long as the production recognises BBC copyright and has no advertising and is run not for profit then they have left well alone. However none of the fan productions of Star Trek have ever approached the professional standards reached by some of the Enterprise fan productions, so perhaps this is not surprising.
 
Last edited:
Out of Darkness II: USS Enterprise

Out of Darkness II: USS Enterprise is a 2016 American-Chinese science fiction adventure film directed by Justin Lin and written by Doug Jung, based on the series Star Trek and Enterprise created by Gene Roddenberry. It is the fifth film in the Star Trek film franchise and the direct sequel to Star Trek II: Out of Darkness.

Principal photography began in Vancouver on June 25, 2015. The film premiered in Sydney on July 7, 2016, and was released in the United States on July 22, 2016 by Paramount Pictures. The film is dedicated to the memory of Yelchin, who died a month prior to the film's release, as well as to Enterprise actor Leonard Nimoy, who died during pre-production. The film grossed $543.5 million at the box office and received positive reviews from critics, with many praising its performances, action scenes, musical score, visual effects, and its tributes to Yelchin and Nimoy.

Plot

The Enterprise has been in the future for three years. Hunter has finally resolved his distrust for Spock created by his memories of what originally happened. Whilst Spock is meditating he becomes convinced of the importance of being at a certain set of co-ordinates.

Hunter orders the Enterprise there and they find the world being attacked by aliens passing through a stable wormhole. There are a series of encounters with the aliens, one of which results in Spock and Kutusov being captured. They are taken back through the wormhole to the aliens’ home planet, where they meet Krall its leader.

Krall is bemused by Spock as he is the spitting image of one who had successfully opposed him 650 years before. Spock realises that this must be his ancestor and he now understands why he felt that those co-ordinates were so important.

Hunter defeats the aliens on his side of the wormhole and takes the Enterprise through to rescue Spock and Kutusov. A series of encounters ensue during which we discover why the aliens keep raiding the planet.

After a final showdown Hunter defeats Krall and the machinery which creates the wormhole is destroyed. The Enterprise makes it back through just before the wormhole collapses in on itself.

Cast

Chris Pratt as Captain James Hunter, commanding officer of USS Enterprise.

Zachary Quinto as Commander Spock, first officer and science officer.

Karl Urban as Doctor "Doc" Piper, chief medical officer.

Sydney Tamila Poitier as Lieutenant Thackery, communications officer.

Gerard Butler as Angus Montgomery, chief engineer.

John Cho as Nogura, third officer and helmsman.

Anton Yelchin as Kutusov, the ship's navigator.

Idris Elba as Krall, a powerful alien warlord.


Production

Development

Abrams returned only as a producer so he could focus on directing Star Wars: The Force Awakens. Writer-producer Roberto Orci was announced as director in May 2014. He would have been making his directorial debut.[13] However, in December, Orci's role was also listed as a producer only, with Edgar Wright considered to replace him as director, along with a shortlist of others, including Rupert Wyatt, Morten Tyldum, Daniel Espinosa, Justin Lin and Duncan Jones. Also, Enterprise actor and director Jonathan Frakes expressed interest in the job. At the end of the month, Lin was announced as director of the film.


Screenplay

In 2014, Orci had begun writing the script with Patrick McKay and J. D. Payne, with Payne saying of the script in March, "We really want to get back to the sense of exploration and wonder. The kind of optimistic sense of the future that Star Trek and Enterprise have always kind of had at their core. It's the Chicago Bulls in space, in terms of these people who are all awesome at their job." In January 2015, after Orci's departure as director, Doug Jung was hired to rewrite the screenplay, with Jung saying on the previous draft, Paramount "had a script that wasn't really working for them. I think the studio was worried that it might have been a little bit too Star Trek-y." Jung had been asked to make the new film "more inclusive", stating that the solution was to "make a western or a thriller or a heist movie, then populate that with Star Trek characters so it's more inclusive to an audience that might be a little bit reticent."


Casting

Chris Pine had been considered for the role of James Hunter, but post production of Jurassic World required his involvement so he was not available so Chris Pratt got the role. It was decided early on that the Enterprise needed a McKenzie type character and Sydney Poitier was cast with her character’s name Thackery being a nod to one of her father’s roles.

Zachary Quinto was the only actor considered for the role of Spock.

Filming

Principal photography on the film began on June 25, 2015, in Vancouver, and Squamish, British Columbia, after several delays caused by script rejections. Additional filming locations were Seoul, South Korea, and Dubai, United Arab Emirates. Principal filming ended on October 15, 2015.

Music

In August 2015, composer Michael Giacchino confirmed that he would return to write the score. On June 26, 2016, singer Rihanna released a teaser across her social media accounts for a single for the film entitled "Sledgehammer", and the song premiered the following day.


Release

The film was released in 2D, RealD3D, IMAX 3D and Barco Escape. In August 2014, it was announced that Paramount had pushed back the release of the film to 2016. In December, it was announced that the film was to be released on July 8, 2016. In September 2015, the film's release date was pushed back to July 22, 2016. The film was released in Dolby Cinema format in selected cinemas. The film had its Australian premiere in Sydney on July 7.


Marketing

A teaser trailer for the film was released on December 14, 2015, and was criticized by some fans for focusing too much on action. Quinto expressed similar thoughts of dissatisfaction with the teaser, saying that he "didn't like it" because "I know there's a lot more to the film." He interpreted the trailer to be a way of the marketing team saying, "Come and see this movie! It's full of action and fun!" A second trailer was released on May 20, 2016, to warmer reviews. A third and final trailer was released on June 27, 2016, featuring Rihanna's single "Sledgehammer".


Home media

Star Trek Beyond was released on Digital HD on October 4, 2016, and on Blu-ray and DVD on November 1, 2016.


Reception

Box office

The film performed poorly at the box office. Scott Mendelson of Forbes observed that one factor contributing to the film's underperformance was its untimely release in a crowded summer in which it was surrounded by other tentpole films like Ghostbusters, Jason Bourne and Suicide Squad. He also noted that had Paramount released the film for the Star Trek's 50th anniversary in either December 16 or January 17 the film could have benefited from that occasion, as demonstrated in 2012 when MGM released the James Bond film Skyfall (which went on to gross over $1 billion) for that series' 50th anniversary.


Star Trek Beyond grossed $258.8 million in the United States and Canada and $284.6 million in other countries for a worldwide total of $543.5 million, against a production budget of $185 million. It had a global opening of $129.2 million and an IMAX opening of $51.6 million on 571 IMAX screens. Industry analyst Danny Cox had previously estimated that in order for the film to break even, it would have to earn $340–350 million worldwide, and ended with a profit of $200 million, less than the $300 million that Paramount had expected.


Critical response

On Rotten Tomatoes, the film has an approval rating of 85% based on 271 reviews, with an average rating of 7/10. The website's critical consensus reads, Out of Darkness II continues the franchise's post-reboot hot streak with an epic sci-fi adventure that honours the series' sci-fi roots without skimping on the blockbuster action." On Metacritic, the film has a score of 68 out of 100, based on 50 critics, indicating "generally favourable reviews". Audiences polled by CinemaScore gave the film an average grade of "A–" on an A+ to F scale.


Richard Roeper of the Chicago Sun-Times gave the film 3 stars out of 4 and said, "Even with its big-screen pyrotechnics and its feature-length running time, Out of Darkness II plays like an extended version of one of the better episodes from the original series, and I mean that in the best possible way”

He also added “Quinto manages to make this Spock different to the previous one. In fact as different as Leonard Nimoy was to Stuart Damon."

Scott Collura of IGN awarded the film 8.4/10, describing it as being: "terrific, a fun and exciting entry in the series that balances subtle fan service while also feeling fresh and modern”

Despite its international success, Out of Darkness II was met by critics who were less taken with the film. Kyle Smith of the New York Post gave the film 1½ stars out of 4 and he commented that the filmmakers "should have called it Into Drowsiness." Smith later added, "Beyond is tepid when it’s trying to be emotional, moronic when it’s trying to be thrilling and unfunny when it’s trying to be non-unfunny. It lacks a storytelling module”

James Berardinelli of Reelviews gave 2½ stars out of 4, writing: "Out of Darkness is an Enterprise movie, although not an especially good one; the action sequences are frenetic, kinetic, and at times incoherent. This isn’t unexpected; it’s Lin’s trademark. But the plot, credited to Doug Jung, is pure Trek. Unfortunately, it’s also instantly forgettable."

Dave Robinson of outlet Crash Landed writes that “it fails to push beyond its own roots and becomes just another very safe sci-fi popcorn movie in an increasingly crowded market that will likely have you leaving the theatre feeling exactly as you entered." Chris Nashawaty of Entertainment Weekly gave the film a C+ and wrote, "It feels like just another summer tentpole with not enough going on underneath the tent."

Despite this the film was enthusiastically received by Prisers and even Trekkies gave it a warm reception.
 
A new Television Series

USS Roosevelt is an American television series created for Amazon Prime by Bryan Fuller and Alex Kurtzman. It is the first Star Trek series since Enterprise: The Next Generation concluded in 1994. Set roughly two decades before the events of Enterprise: The Next Generation, Roosevelt explores the last New United Systems–Tellurian war while following the crew of the USS Roosevelt. Gretchen J. Berg and Aaron Harberts serve as showrunners on the series, with producing support from Akiva Goldsman.

Sonequa Martin-Green stars as Michael Burnham, Chief Science Officer on the USS Roosevelt. Doug Jones, Shazad Latif, Anthony Rapp, Mary Wiseman, and Jason Isaacs also star. The new series was announced in November 2015, with Fuller joining as showrunner and wanting to make an anthology series. CBS asked him to make a single, serialized show first, with the prequel to TNG idea further developed. After further disagreements with CBS and struggles with other commitments, Fuller left the series in October 2016, replaced as showrunner by Berg and Harberts.

USS Roosevelt premiered on September 19, 2017, at ArcLight Hollywood, before debuting on Amazon Prime on September 24. The rest of the 15-episode first season was streamed weekly. The series gained very positive reviews from critics who highlighted Martin-Green's and Isaac’s performances. A second season was ordered in October 2017.

Premise

Set roughly twenty years before the events of Enterprise: The Next Generation, the show sees the Tellurian Empire in a war with the New United Systems that involves the crew of the USS Roosevelt.

Cast and characters

Sonequa Martin-Green as Lt. Cmdr Michael Burnham:

A Science Specialist on USS Roosevelt. Burnham is a human who was raised following Vulcanian culture and traditions by Savek, who rescued her after a Tellurian attack on a science outpost as she had no living relatives. Unlike the protagonists of previous Star Trek series, she was not made a starship captain, in order "to see a character from a different perspective on the starship—one who has different dynamic relationships with a captain, with subordinates, it gave us richer context". Fuller deliberately gave the character a traditionally male name, which he had done with the female leads of his previous series.

Doug Jones as Commander Saru:

First Officer of the USS Roosevelt. Saru is the first Kelpien to enter Starfleet. Kelpiens, a new species created for Roosevelt, were hunted as prey on their home planet and thus evolved the ability to sense the coming of death, giving them a reputation for cowardice. Jones based Saru's walk on that of a supermodel, out of necessity thanks to the boots he had to wear to portray the character's hooved feet, forcing Jones to walk on the balls of his feet.

Shazad Latif as Lt. Ash Tyler:

Tyler is Chief of Security for the USS Roosevelt. Tyler was held as a prisoner of war by the Tellurians. Latif described his character as "a very complex and painful and deep character", and noted that "there's a chemistry, a relationship" with Burnham.

Anthony Rapp as Lt. Paul Stamets:

Chief Engineer aboard the USS Roosevelt. He is the first openly gay character in a Star Trek series, and the showrunners "wanted to roll out that character's sexuality the way people would roll out their sexuality in life." Rapp noted that Nogura was portrayed as gay in the film Out of Darkness II, calling that "a nice nod. But in this case, we actually get to see me with my partner in conversation, in our living quarters, you get to see our relationship over time, treated as any other relationship would be treated".

Mary Wiseman as Ensign Sylvia Tilly:

Roosevelt is Tilly’s first assignment after graduating from the Academy. She works under Stamets in engineering. The character was included to represent people "at the very bottom of this ladder" of the Fleet hierarchy. She is "the most optimistic ... has the biggest heart", and showrunner Aaron Harberts described her as "sort of the soul of our show."

Jason Isaacs as Captain Gabe Lucas:

Captain of the Roosevelt, a "brilliant military tactician". Isaacs described the character as "probably more f—ked up than any of" the previously seen Star Trek captains. He plays the character with a slight Estuary English accent, and ad-libbed a catchphrase for the character feeling that all Star Trek/Enterprise captains should have one, coming up with "on my command”.

Episodes

There were 15 episodes in the first season of USS Roosevelt. Seven shown before Christmas and 8 after the New Year.

Development

On November 2, 2015, Paramount announced a new Enterprise television series to premiere in January 2017, "on the heels" of the original series' 50th anniversary in 2016. It is the first Star Trek series since Enterprise: TNG concluded in 1994, and the first show to be shown by streaming. Alex Kurtzman, co-writer of the films Star Trek and Star Trek II: Out of Darkness, and Heather Kadin were set as executive producers on the series, which is "not related" to the 2016 film Out of Darkness II: USS Enterprise.

In February 2017 Bryan Fuller, who began his career writing for Enterprise: TNG, was announced as the new series' showrunner and co-creator alongside Kurtzman. In March, Rod Roddenberry, the son of Star Trek creator Gene Roddenberry, and Trevor Roth of Roddenberry Entertainment also joined the series, as executive producers. Fuller said that working with people previously involved with Star Trek was "really about making sure that we maintain authenticity. An ability to ground science-fiction in a relatable way, and also making sure that we're telling character stories."

Fuller announced in June 2016 that the first season would consist of 13 episodes, though he would prefer to produce 10 episodes a season. A month later, Fuller announced the series' title to be USS Roosevelt, and revealed that it would be set between Enterprise and Enterprise: TNG to keep the concurrent series and films separate, so "we don't have to track anything [happening in the films] and they don't have to track what we're doing". During pre-production on the series, Fuller and Paramount continued to disagree on the direction of the show, which was starting to overrun its per-episode budget, and was falling behind schedule due to Fuller supervising all aspects of the series as well as another new show, American Gods. This caused frustration among Paramount executives who felt Fuller should be focused on having Roosevelt ready for release by the January 2017 premiere date. By August 2016, Fuller had hired Gretchen J. Berg and Aaron Harberts, who he had worked with on Pushing Daisies, to serve as co-showrunners with him. A month later, he and Kurtzman asked Paramount to delay the series' release so they could meet the high expectations for it, and the studio pushed the series premiere back to May 2017." At the end of October, Paramount asked Fuller to step down as showrunner, and announced a restructuring of the production: Berg and Harberts were made sole showrunners, working from a broad story arc and overall mythology established by Fuller; Kurtzman and Fuller would continue as executive producers, but with Fuller moving his attention fully to American Gods; and Akiva Goldsman would join the series in a supporting producer role, similar to the role he held on Fringe alongside Kurtzman. Paramount reiterated that they were "extremely happy with [Fuller's] creative direction" for the series, though some elements of the series that came directly from Fuller were dropped, including some designs and "more heavily allegorical and complex story" points. Fuller later confirmed that he was no longer involved with the series, but expressed interest in returning for future seasons.

After the series' premiere, Kurtzman said that the producers wanted to avoid announcing release dates and having to delay those for any future seasons, due to the external pressure that caused with the first season, but that he hoped a second season would be available in early 2019. The second season was officially ordered in October 2017, for 13 episodes.

Writing

"The defining factor of Roddenberry's vision is the optimistic view of the future ... Once you lose that, you lose the essence of what Star Trek/Enterprise is. That being said... Star Trek/Enterprise has always been a mirror to the time it reflected and [the topical question now] is how do you preserve and protect what the Fleet is in the weight of a challenge like war and the things that have to be done in war."

—Executive producer Alex Kurtzman on the balance between classic Star Trek/Enterprise and new elements in Roosevelt

The titular ship was named after Robert Peary’s ship on his Arctic expeditions, in a nod to the naming convention used by the ITC Star Trek (although it is also the surname of two US Presidents undoubtedly helped in its choice). Fuller saw the series as a bridge between Enterprise and TNG—which are set around 100 years apart—but set much closer to the latter to allow the series to "play with all the iconography of those ships and those uniforms". In May 2017, Sullivan described the series as "a genuine prequel" to Enterprise: TNG. The choice to feature a single serialized story throughout the first season was inspired by the general change in television to tell more realistic and serialized stories rather than the "new destination-based adventure each week" format mostly used in previous series

Casting

By June 2016, Fuller had met with several actors, and said that "we want to carry on what Enterprise: TNG did best, which is being progressive. So it's fascinating to look at all of these roles through a colour-blind prism and a gender-blind prism". A month later, Kadin clarified that the series would feature minority, female, and LGBTQ characters. In August, Fuller said the series would feature "about seven" lead characters, and would star a lieutenant commander, rather than a starship captain like previous series, to be played by a non-white actress. He said the series would also include more alien characters than other series, and would feature at least one openly gay character.

Fuller anticipated casting announcements in October 2016, but none had been made by the end of that month. The majority of the series main characters were believed to have been cast by then, but no actress had been cast for the series' lead role. This was a source of "some internal stress" at Paramount. Several African American and Latina actresses were being looked at for the role, with Paramount "not seeking a huge star and [preferring] a fresh face for the part." In October, the cast was believed to include "a female admiral, a male Tellurian captain, a male admiral, a male adviser and a British male doctor", with one of those male leads played by an openly gay actor. The next month, Doug Jones and Anthony Rapp were revealed to be cast, as Saru and Stamets, respectively. The former is a Kelpien, an alien race created for the series, while the latter is the first Star Trek/Enterprise character to be conceived and announced as gay. Sonequa Martin-Green was cast in the lead role in December, which was officially confirmed in April 2017, with the character's name revealed to be Michael Burnham. Also in December, Shazad Latif was cast as Tyler. In March 2017, Jason Isaacs was cast as Captain Lucas of the USS Roosevelt, and Mary Wiseman joined as Tilly, an Ensign.

Design

Mark Worthington and Todd Cherniawsky served as initial production designers for the series; Gersha Phillips and Suttirat Anne Larlarb designed the costumes; veteran designer John Eaves designed starships, along with Scott Schneider; and Glenn Hetrick and Neville Page of Alchemy Studios provided prosthetics, props, and armour. The series also employed seven art directors, over nine illustrators, more than thirty-five set designers, and over four hundred and fifty painters, carpenters, sculptors, model makers, welders, set dressers, and prop builders.

The opening title sequence for the show was created by Prologue using 2D motion graphics. The sequence, which uses a "vivid, sepia-soaked palette", depicts elements from throughout the history of Star Trek—such as phasers, communicators, and the Vulcan salute—and deconstructs them, which was intended to be an homage to past Star Trek series as well as an introduction to the more grounded and gritty tone of Roosevelt.[90]

Filming

Star Trek: Roosevelt is filmed at Pinewood Toronto Studios. Some of the series' sets took over six weeks to create, and new sets were being built up until the end of production of the season. Roosevelt took advantage of multiple soundstages at the studio, including the largest soundstage in North America. Some episodes for the show were filmed solely on existing sets, making them bottle episodes, though Harberts said the series would not do anything "as bottle-y as 'everyone is stuck in the mess hall!'"

Visual effects

Visual effects producers were hired to begin work on the series during the initial writing period, with Fuller explaining that the series would require such things as "digital augmentation on certain alien species" and "the transporter beams". He said, "We're trying to cultivate distinct looks for all of those things that are unique to our version of Star Trek and carry through the themes we love seeing in fifty years of Star Trek, but doing a slightly different approach." The shuttle bay of the Roosevelt is completely computer-generated, with actors performing in front of a green screen for scenes in that environment; using the digital set is more expensive than any other set created for the series, including the practically-built ones.


Music

The first teaser for the series featured music composed by Fil Eisler, which he "threw together as an audition" within three weeks. Before production on the series began, Charles Henri Avelange had also composed and recorded music for the series. Russo recorded the series' score with a 60-piece orchestra. The show's main theme incorporates elements from the original Enterprise theme. Soundtrack albums for two chapters of the first season were released on December 15, 2017, and April 6, 2018, respectively.

Marketing

The first full trailer for the series was released in May 2017. Forbes's Merrill Barr noted that the trailer was a good sign for many who believed the series would never be released following the many production setbacks and delays, saying, "Having a legitimate trailer that can be watched over and over again brings signs of hope, particularly for fans that have been waiting over a year for this moment. USS Roosevelt is real, and now we have proof.”

Reception

Ratings and viewership

According to Nielsen Media Research, the broadcast of the first episode was watched by a "decent" audience of 9.5 million viewers. According to "app analytics specialist" App Annie, the premiere of the series also caused the number of downloads of the Amazon Prime mobile app to more than double.

Critical response

The review aggregator website Rotten Tomatoes reported a 92% approval rating for the first season, with an average rating of 8.07/10 based on 61 reviews. The website's critical consensus reads, "Although it takes an episode to achieve lift off, USS Roosevelt delivers a solid franchise instalment for the next generation—boldly led by Sonequa Martin-Green." Metacritic, which uses a weighted average, assigned a score of 82 out of 100 based on 20 critics, indicating "generally good reviews".

NOTE: USS Roosevelt is the ITTL equivalent of Star Trek Discovery. It is MUCH better received by fans and is generally thought of as a good but not exceptional addition to the franchise.
 
Last edited:
If it's still written by Kurtzman, I'm still gonna hate it. The man's a hack and the only time I've ever enjoyed something he wrote was when I watched that shitty Michael Bay clone movie while stoned off my ass on painkillers after a minor operation. His greatest triumph was the '09 Trek reboot, and even that barely scraped the bottom of mediocre.
 
Also, how is the show described any different from STD other than the set dressing? You seem to have literally taken the Wikipedia article for STD and changed the names around. Highlighted in bold are the largely identical parts.
Sonequa Martin-Green as Lt. Cmdr Michael Burnham:

A Science Specialist on USS Roosevelt. Burnham is a human who was raised following Vulcanian culture and traditions by Savek, who rescued her after a Tellurian attack on a science outpost as she had no living relatives. Unlike the protagonists of previous Star Trek series, she was not made a starship captain, in order "to see a character from a different perspective on the starship—one who has different dynamic relationships with a captain, with subordinates, it gave us richer context". Fuller deliberately gave the character a traditionally male name, which he had done with the female leads of his previous series.

Doug Jones as Commander Saru:

First Officer of the USS Roosevelt. Saru is the first Kelpien to enter Starfleet. Kelpiens, a new species created for Roosevelt, were hunted as prey on their home planet and thus evolved the ability to sense the coming of death, giving them a reputation for cowardice. Jones based Saru's walk on that of a supermodel, out of necessity thanks to the boots he had to wear to portray the character's hooved feet, forcing Jones to walk on the balls of his feet.

Shazad Latif as Lt. Ash Tyler:

Tyler is Chief of Security for the USS Roosevelt. Tyler was held as a prisoner of war by the Tellurians. Latif described his character as "a very complex and painful and deep character", and noted that "there's a chemistry, a relationship" with Burnham.

Anthony Rapp as Lt. Paul Stamets:

Chief Engineer aboard the USS Roosevelt. He is the first openly gay character in a Star Trek series, and the showrunners "wanted to roll out that character's sexuality the way people would roll out their sexuality in life." Rapp noted that Nogura was portrayed as gay in the film Out of Darkness II, calling that "a nice nod. But in this case, we actually get to see me with my partner in conversation, in our living quarters, you get to see our relationship over time, treated as any other relationship would be treated".

Mary Wiseman as Ensign Sylvia Tilly:

Roosevelt is Tilly’s first assignment after graduating from the Academy. She works under Stamets in engineering. The character was included to represent people "at the very bottom of this ladder" of the Fleet hierarchy. She is "the most optimistic ... has the biggest heart", and showrunner Aaron Harberts described her as "sort of the soul of our show."

Jason Isaacs as Captain Gabe Lucas:

Captain of the Roosevelt, a "brilliant military tactician". Isaacs described the character as "probably more f—ked up than any of" the previously seen Star Trek captains. He plays the character with a slight Estuary English accent, and ad-libbed a catchphrase for the character feeling that all Star Trek/Enterprise captains should have one, coming up with "on my command”.
Wikipedia said:
  • Sonequa Martin-Green as Michael Burnham:
    A Science Specialist on USS Discovery. Burnham was First Officer of the USS Shenzhou, where she was referred to as "Number One" to honor the character of the same name portrayed by Majel Barrett in the original Star Trek pilot "The Cage".[4][5][6] Burnham is a human who was raised following Vulcan culture and traditions by Sarek.[4][7] Unlike the protagonists of previous Star Trek series, she was not made a starship captain, in order "to see a character from a different perspective on the starship—one who has different dynamic relationships with a captain, with subordinates, it gave us richer context".[1] Fuller deliberately gave the character a traditionally male name, which he had done with the female leads of his previous series.[8]
  • Doug Jones as Saru:
    First Officer of the USS Discovery, Saru was previously Science Officer of the USS Shenzhou.[9] Saru is the first Kelpien to enter Starfleet. Kelpiens, a new species created for Discovery, were hunted as prey on their home planet and thus evolved the ability to sense the coming of death, giving them a reputation for cowardice.[10] Jones based Saru's walk on that of a supermodel,[7] out of necessity thanks to the boots he had to wear to portray the character's hooved feet, forcing Jones to walk on the balls of his feet.[11] The producers compared Saru to the characters Spock and Data from previous series.[10]
  • Shazad Latif as Voq / Ash Tyler:
    A Klingon who undergoes surgery to pose as the human Tyler, chief of security for the USS Discovery.[12][13] Tyler believes he was held as a prisoner of war by the Klingons. Latif was originally cast in the role of Kol.[14][13]Voq was initially credited as being portrayed by Javid Iqbal, an invented actor named for Latif's father, to hide the connection between the characters.[12] Latif described his character as "a very complex and painful and deep character",[13] and noted that "there's a chemistry, a relationship" with Burnham.[15] Latif's accent for Voq is Arabic-inspired, and he tried to maintain "a kind of pharyngealness" to Tyler's American accent.[12]
  • Anthony Rapp as Paul Stamets:
    Chief engineer aboard the USS Discovery and science officer specializing in astromycology (the study of fungi in space) whose research led to development of an experimental organic propulsion system on the Discovery.[9][16][17] The character is inspired by a real-life mycologist of the same name.[18] He is the first openly gay character in a Star Trek series, and the showrunners "wanted to roll out that character's sexuality the way people would roll out their sexuality in life." Rapp noted that Hikaru Sulu was portrayed as gay in the film Star Trek Beyond, calling that "a nice nod. But in this case, we actually get to see me with my partner in conversation, in our living quarters, you get to see our relationship over time, treated as any other relationship would be treated".[19]
  • Mary Wiseman as Sylvia Tilly:
    A cadet in her final year at Starfleet Academy, assigned to the Discovery.[20][21] She works under Stamets aboard the Discovery, where she becomes roommates with Burnham.[21] The character was included to represent people "at the very bottom of this ladder" of the Starfleet hierarchy. She is "the most optimistic ... has the biggest heart", and showrunner Aaron Harberts described her as "sort of the soul of our show."[22]
  • Jason Isaacs as Gabriel Lorca:
    Captain of the Discovery,[23] a "brilliant military tactician".[24] Isaacs described the character as "probably more f—ked up than any of" the previously seen Star Trek captains.[7] He plays the character with a slight southern U.S. accent, and had initially wanted to ad-lib a catchphrase for the character feeling that all Star Trek captains should have one, coming up with "git'r done" which the writers turned down due to it being widely used and trademarked by Larry the Cable Guy.[25]
 
If it's still written by Kurtzman, I'm still gonna hate it. The man's a hack and the only time I've ever enjoyed something he wrote was when I watched that shitty Michael Bay clone movie while stoned off my ass on painkillers after a minor operation. His greatest triumph was the '09 Trek reboot, and even that barely scraped the bottom of mediocre.

Fair enough. I didn't claim that you would love it, just be happier with it. However Kurtzman ITTL is not as much a "Hack" as OTL and actually cares about the franchise (Also other writers have reworked behind the scenes!.) ITTL the two franchise movies with which he was involved were decent efforts.

You're also correct I rewrote the wiki, which must be a CBS job as I don't recognise the programme that I watched from it, as it saved me the hassle of gushing about Roosevelt as it was done for me. USS Roosevelt if compared to OTL Trek shows is about on a par with middling DS9 episodes.

Apologies if I upset you @Worffan101, but it seemed at the time, a quick way of showing that this WAS NOT as bad as Discovery, with hindsight not a very good one.
 
It’s a wrap!

Space: the final frontier.

These have been the voyages of the starships Endeavour, Erebus, Enterprise and Roosevelt.

Their continuing missions: to explore strange new worlds.

To seek out new life and new civilizations.

To boldly go where no human has gone before!

That’s it. Since November 2013 when I made the first post, until April 2018 now I make the last (OK there might be some appendices but nothing else). Four and a half years creating a relatively complete alternate history of the Star Trek franchise all starting from WI Star Trek had been made in the UK.

My thanks go to all of you who have read this but especially @viewcode who helped with uniform, design of the Endeavour and understood some of the quirks of my names and castings in the ITC Star Trek. Also @HonestAbe1809 , @Some Bloke and @nick_crenshaw82 and finally @Brainbin , who’s TWR gave me inspiration and who wrote a post in this thread that made me think carefully about what I had planned and modify accordingly (although it might not have been very apparent!).

The future of ITTL Star Trek certainly includes another USS Enterprise film released in 2019 and also seasons 2 and 3 of USS Roosevelt (2019 and 2020) beyond that who knows!

Again thank you and I hope that you have enjoyed it.
 
It’s a wrap!

Space: the final frontier.

These have been the voyages of the starships Endeavour, Erebus, Enterprise and Roosevelt.

Their continuing missions: to explore strange new worlds.

To seek out new life and new civilizations.

To boldly go where no human has gone before!

That’s it. Since November 2013 when I made the first post, until April 2018 now I make the last (OK there might be some appendices but nothing else). Four and a half years creating a relatively complete alternate history of the Star Trek franchise all starting from WI Star Trek had been made in the UK.

My thanks go to all of you who have read this but especially @viewcode who helped with uniform, design of the Endeavour and understood some of the quirks of my names and castings in the ITC Star Trek. Also @HonestAbe1809 , @Some Bloke and @nick_crenshaw82 and finally @Brainbin , who’s TWR gave me inspiration and who wrote a post in this thread that made me think carefully about what I had planned and modify accordingly (although it might not have been very apparent!).

The future of ITTL Star Trek certainly includes another USS Enterprise film released in 2019 and also seasons 2 and 3 of USS Roosevelt (2019 and 2020) beyond that who knows!

Again thank you and I hope that you have enjoyed it.

What do you plan on writing next?
 
Well I have 3 very different eggs still in the air!
The Madman and his Blue Box which is Doctor Who in this same universe. It's in After 1900
Picard v the Federation in Fandom. A crossover between Star Trek TNG and Blakes' 7 except the Doctor has taken it over:pensive:
and last but not least
In Britannia Salutem in Before 1900 (my take on Post Roman/Arthurian Britannia with the odd glimpse into its future)

At some point I'll reboot Northumbria more Successful in Before 1900 but that's in the future.
As to the further future? Well I have a hankering to make Star Cops a success but thats ASB to the nth power:biggrin:
 
Last edited:
Top