AHC: Samaritan Population roughly similar in size to their Jewish Counterparts

The Samaritans for those who do not know are the Sister-Nation or Sister-Religion of Judaism, while not identifying as Jews they identify as Israelites a claim that their Jewish Brethren accept. Samaritans are the descendants of the Northern Tribes of Israel having remained in the Land of Israel when the Jews were exiled to Babylon. The Samaritans thus retained a distinct set of religious claims for example their belief that the Temple was on Mount Gerizim and not in Jerusalem, that the 10th Commandment affirmed this and rejected the post-Torah additions such as the Tanakh and of course other Rabbinic Texts. Above all the Samaritans managed to continue their line of High Priests and preferred the authority of Priests over Rabbis & Scholars.

Now that we've got a rough though obviously imperfect description of what separates the Samaritans from the Jews, what about a little background for why they are not as widespread as their cousins. Though there was a Samaritan diaspora, in fact one of the earliest Synagogues outside the Land of Israel, at Mount Delos is suspected to be a Samaritan Synagogue, this diaspora never had a figure like the Exilarch nor a religious tradition that included them into the narrative of the Samaritan Israelite nation (at least to my knowledge). Thus the Samaritans were always very centralised as a religious nation within the region of Samaria, especially at Shechem (Modern-day Nablus, which coincidentally is also the location of Mt. Gerizim and thus the Samaritan Temple)

Samaritans, while related to the Jews, were not one and the same and while the Jews were experiencing a time of turmoil and great persecution after the events of the Jewish Revolts, the Samaritans remained reluctant to come to the aid of the Jews. Indeed, in the years after the depopulation of Judea, the Samaritans took advantage of the situation to resettle those lands and reap its bounty. This Samaritan Golden Age saw the Samaritan population peak at about 500,000 but was almost immediately overshadowed by increasing persecution of Rome's now Christian emperors. Emperor Zeno was harsh on the Samaritans, reportedly he:

went to Neapolis (Shechem), gathered the elders and asked them to convert; when they refused, Zeno had many Samaritans killed, and re-built the synagogue as a church. Zeno then took for himself Mount Gerizim, where the Samaritans worshiped God, and built several edifices, among them a tomb for his recently deceased son, on which he put a cross, so that the Samaritans, worshiping God, would prostrate in front of the tomb. Later, in 484, the Samaritans revolted.

This would culminate in a series of revolts, four in total that would decimate the Samaritan population. The Samaritan population would receive some brief respite when the Rashidun Caliphate captured the Holy Land in the 7th century but would face multiple bouts of persecution, one of the most harsh being at the direction of Fatimid Caliph Al-Hakam. At their lowest recorded population, an Ottoman census stated that they were only some 100 strong, still after centuries the Samaritans have only recovered somewhat and are now some 820 strong. Sadly nowhere near the population of Samaritans in biblical times.

So the AHC Rules are as follows:

1. Have the Samaritan Population exceed a population of a Million
2. No Judaism-Screws (Nothing more than OTL at least)
3. Preserve the Samaritan Temple in some form


Bonus Goal(s):
1. An Offshoot of Samaritanism becomes noteworthy (doesn't have to be successful, but it has to make enough of an impact, E.g. Mandaeism with John the Baptist)
2. Samaritan Diaspora reaches China and/or India
 
Last edited:
Perhaps, during Roman times, Judea and Samaria are turned into two separate Roman-adjacent kingdoms and then two separate provinces; as a result, by the time the Jews revolt, the Samaritans shrug and, while the Jews are forced into the Diaspora, the Samaritans are not, as Samaria avoids the Roman banhammer. By the time Rome adopts Christianity, Samaritans make up the majority of the inhabitants of Samaria and make up a substantial minority in the surrounding provinces as well, up to and including Judea.

Despite persecution by the now-Christian Roman and, then, Byzantine leadership, the Samaritans largely stay put, influencing some local Christian sects; the same happens when the Muslims come knocking and, even though some Samaritans have adopted Christianity or Islam, they keep to themselves even under the Caliphs, that tolerate them as long as they pay their jizya, favouring them over their Jewish cousins.

By the late 19th century, they're a solid ethnic and religious community with their own millet under the Ottoman Empire, and Samaria may be 50% Muslim by now but, who cares - there's still more Samaritans than Jews in the Levant, and the French's establishment of a Samaritan colony in northern Palestine ensures the survival of the Samaritans, that end up sharing their Muslim neighbours' anti-Zionist tendencies.

Today, Israel and Samaria get along more or less as well as Croatia and Serbia in the 1990s, both peoples claiming the mantle of "The True Jewish People" for themselves.
 
Prevent the Samaritan revolts against Byzantium and have the Islamic leaders be laxer in seeking converts. There would still be a Samaritan majority in Samaria and probably a diaspora overseas.
 

kholieken

Banned
It might be better if Samaritan have refugium in some mountain (Lebanon mts?, Isaurian mts?) or outside Levant (Samaritan traders in North Africa ?) where they can survive inevitable persecution. Modern Jewish people survived by living in Spain and Polish-Lithuania during various centuries. Levant kind of hot spot for wars and empires.
 
Prevent the Samaritan revolts against Byzantium and have the Islamic leaders be laxer in seeking converts. There would still be a Samaritan majority in Samaria and probably a diaspora overseas.
Why would there be a Samaritan majority after the 3 major Jewish rebellions in the early Roman empire?
 

Philip

Donor
Today, Israel and Samaria get along more or less as well as Croatia and Serbia in the 1990s, both peoples claiming the mantle of "The True Jewish People" for themselves.
Jews and Samaritans might dispute who are 'The True Israelites', but Samaritans would not likely associate themselves with the southern Kingdom of Judah.
 
Top