A Murder in the Royal Palace in Edinburgh - a Timeline from 1566

Mary Queen of Scots, Henry Darnley, Princess Margaret
Saturday 9 March 1566 Holyrood Palace, Edinburgh. Mary Queen of Scots, her secretary and rumoured lover, David Rizzio, and a few other people, were enjoying an evening together in a private room in the palace. Armed men burst into the room, intent on killing Rizzio. He cowered behind Mary' s skirts. The men dragged him out of the room and butchered him. He was murdered with 56 kinife wounds in his body.

Mary clutched her womb in pain. She was bleeding. She miscarried her unborn son. That is the POD. The fiture James VI and 1 is not born. Lord Henry Darnley, Mary's husband, insisted that he had no part in the conspiracy to murder Rizzio. In the next few weeks they made love. Mary beca6me pregnant. She gave birth to a healthy baby girl on 22 January 1567 in Holyrood Palace. She and Darnley gave their daughter the name Margaret.
 
Last edited:
Mary Queen of Scots, Henry Darnley
Queen Mary was delighted with the birth of her daughter, but her husband, Lord Henry Darnley, was disappointed that he did not have a son. He was suffering from smallpox, or more probably syphilis, and was living in Holyrood Palace. So he was not murdered at Kirk o' Field in Edinburgh in the night of 9-10 February 1567, as he was in OTL.

Mary knew that her husband was vain, arrogant, dissolute and immature. When he recovered from his illness, he returned to going on nights of drinking and debauchary in Edinburgh's seamier taverns. In one such tavern, during the night of Friday 16 May 1567, he got onto a fight over a woman, and was stabbed to death. Mary made a show of mourning her husband, and arranged for his burial in Holyrood Abbey. He was only 21 years old.
 
Last edited:
So since it's a daughter and not a son, Mary does not get deposed ITTL?
Mary does not get deposed in this TL, because she gave birth to a daughter, not a son.
Also she was not suspected of complicity in the murder of Darnley, as she was in OTL.
 
Mary Queen of Scots, Earl of Bothwell
After the murder of her husband it was expected that Queen Mary would marry again. But it was not only for reasons of state policy that she wanted to marry. She was a beautiful and healthy young woman with strong appetites for food, dancing, hunting - and sex. The question was, who would she marry?

James Hepburn, 4th Earl of Bothwell, was high in Mary's affections. But since February 1566 he had been married to Jean Gordon, and divorce was rare and difficult to obtain. There were rumours that Mary wanted to marry Bothwell. Her supporters knew that he was unsuitable for her, and were aghast at the prospect of her marrying him. He had been involved in the plot in the spring of 1562 by the Earl of Arran to kidnap Mary and marry her. Though nothing came of it.
 
Mary Queen of Scots, Duke of Norfolk
Lord Herries, a supporter of Mary, begged her not to marry Bothwell, as did her half brother, James Stewart, Earl of Moray, and Sir James Melville. Queen Elizabeth wrote to Mary, her cousin. She was very sympathetic about the murder of Darnley. She was nine years older than Mary and like an older sister to her. She strongly proposed the Earl of Leicester or the Duke of Norfolk, as Mary's next husband. Mary rejected Leicester, but agreed to marry Norfolk.

Thomas Howard , 9th Duke of Norfolk was thirty-nine years old, a widower, a Protestant, and ambitious. Mary and Thomas were married in the chapel of Holyrood Palace on Tuesday 27 October 1567.
 
Last edited:
Mary Queen of Scots, Elizabeth I, Princess Anabella
Queen Mary gave birth to a baby girl in Holyrood Palace on 6 September 1568. She and her husband, Thomas, named their daughter Anabella.

The contrast with Queen Elizabeth could not be greater. The Queen of England was unmarried and childless. She wrote to Mary congratulating her cousin on the birth of a daughter. Meanwhile she was stringing out marriage negotiations with the Archduke Charles of Austria,

If Elizabeth died without an heir before Mary, then Mary would have the best claim to the English throne. If Mary died before a childless Elizabeth, then Princess Margaret would become Queen of England when Elizabeth died.

There was talk of to which Catholic European princes would princesses Margaret and Anabella be betrothed.
 

Deleted member 147978

I guess someone else is going to be ruler of England and Ireland now that Queen Mary is only boring Catholic Daughters ITTL.
 
Lord Herries, a supporter of Mary, begged her not to marry Bothwell, as did her half brother, James Stewart, Earl of Moray, and Sir James Melville. Queen Elizabeth wrote to Mary, her cousin. She was very sympathetic about the murder of Darnley. She was nine years older than Mary and like an older sister to her. She strongly proposed the Earl of Leicester or the Duke of Norfolk, as Mary's next husband. Mary rejected Leicester, but agreed to marry Norfolk.

Thomas Howard , 9th Duke of Norfolk was thirty-nine years old, a widower, a Protestant, and ambitious. Mary and Thomas were married in the chapel of Holyrood Palace on Tuesday 27 October 1567.

Wait, a Protestant Howard? Aren't Howards infamously Catholics?
 
Wait, a Protestant Howard? Aren't Howards infamously Catholics?
The 4th Duke of Norfolk (Thomas Howard) was raised Protestant. But in 1566 when he was serving as Earl Marshal to Queen Elizabeth I, he was already under suspicion. He was kept in post presumably in the spirit of "keep your enemies closer". I wonder how likely Elizabeth would be to recommend him as a husband for Mary given that Francis Walsingham was already petitioning her to strip him of his post and have him arrested.
 
Last edited:
Mary Queen of Scots, Prince James, Princess Margaret
In 1564 Queen Elizabeth had proposed to Queen Mary that she choose between the Earl of Leicester, the Duke of Norfolk, and Lord Darnley, as her husband. In OTL in November or December, when Mary was in custody in Bolton Castle in Yorkshire, Elizabeth asked Norfolk if he intended to marry Mary. He vehemently denied it. (1) In this TL Mary did not flee to England.

In September 1567, Princess Margaret was betrothed to the five year old Charles Emmanuel, the only child of the Duke of Savoy.
.
On Saturday 25 March 1570, Mary gave birth to a son in Holyrood Palace. She and Thomas named him James.

(1) See Elizabeth and Mary: Cousins, Rivals, Queens by Jane Dunn, London: HarperCollins 2003.
 
Last edited:
Mary Queen of Scots, France, Prince James, Prince Robert, Ridolphi Plot
The day before Queen Mary married the Duke of Norfolk in October 1567, she declared him to be King of Scotland. But she refused to grant him the crown matrlmonial, which would have given the rights of a king, independently of his relationship to her as Queen. It was the same with Lord Darnley.

Prince James was betrothed to Catherine Michelle (born 10 October 1567) the younger daughter of Elizabeth of Valois and Philip II of Spain. Elizabeth was the sister of Francis II of France, Mary's first husband and therefore her sister-in-law.

James Stewart, Earl of Moray, Mary's illegitimate half brother, was not murdered by a member of the Catholic Hamilton family. In OTL he was on 21 January 1570 because he was the Regent of James VI.

Pope Pius V excommunicated Queen Elizabeth in February 1570. The papal bull described Elizabeth as the pretended Queen of England. It released the Catholic faithful of England from any loyalty or obedience to her. It also threatened Catholics who remained loyal to Elizabeth with excommunication. All this was as in OTL.

The Ridolphi Plot was a plot by Roberto Ridophi, a Florentine banker and papal agent then living in London, in 1570 to 1571. It aimed to enlist a Spanish army to invade England in support of a rising of English Catholics, which would depose Elizabeth and put Mary on the throne of England.

Ridolphi travelled to the Netherlands where he met the Duke of Alba, Philip II's commander there. Alba poured cold water on Ridolphi's dreams. He would invade England only if Elizabeth was dead or at least held captive. Ridolphi then went to Rome. Pope Pius gave him moral support, but little else. From there he travelled to Madrid where he met King Philip. The Spanish king was enthusiastic about Ridolphi's plan and gave it his consent.

The Ridolphi plot was uncovered by the English government in April 1571. Mary knew about the plot. She wrote to Elizabeth, emphatically and truthfully declaring that she never consented to it. She swore by the child she was carrying in her womb, she was about five months pregnant, that she never gave the slightest approval to the plot. She addressed Elizabeth as her dear sister and professed her love and loyalty. . In OTL she was implicated in the plot. Mary gave birth to a son on 21 August 1571. She and her husband named him Robert.

The Saint Bartholomew Massacre of Protestants, Hugenots, in France took place on 23 and 24 August 1572. Tens of thousands were killed. Catherine de Medici, the Queen of France, was the mother of Franci s II, and Mary 's mother-in-law. She ordered the assasination of Coligny and other French Hugenot leaders.

Altnough Mary was a devout Catholic. she was not a fanatic nor a persecutor of heretics. As Queen she tolerated her Protestant subjects and accepted the reformed religion as the rwligion of Scotland. However she brought up her children in the Catholic faith. When she heard about the Massacre, she wrote to Elizabeth expressing her horror at the murder of so many innocent men, women and children.
 
Queen Mary gave birth to a baby girl in Holyrood Palace on 6 September 1568. She and her husband, Thomas, named their daughter Anabella.

The contrast with Queen Elizabeth could not be greater. The Queen of England was unmarried and childless. She wrote to Mary congratulating her cousin on the birth of a daughter. Meanwhile she was stringing out marriage negotiations with the Archduke Charles of Austria,

If Elizabeth died without an heir before Mary, then Mary would have the best claim to the English throne. If Mary died before a childless Elizabeth, then Princess Margaret would become Queen of England when Elizabeth died.

There was talk of to which Catholic European princes would princesses Margaret and Anabella be betrothed.
Anabella?
 
Ah I see. Anyway, out of curiosity, what would happen to Elizabeth I ITTL? She is likely to be allies with Mary
In this TL Elizabeth I will be Queen of England until 1603, as in OTL. Whether or not she and Mary will be allies remains to be seen.
 
Last edited:
Top