From the Daily Telegraph, Tuesday 15th December
The Future of Progressive Politics
Peter Kennedy
Recently, James Taylor claimed that “Progressive Conservatism”, as he called it, had eclipsed Thatcherism as the dominant political ideology in the Conservative Party. This “Progressive Conservatism”, a rebranding of the disastrous “compassionate Conservatism” experimented on by Henry Reed in the latter days of his premiership is supposed to be a concession to the opinion, now held by the majority of the British people, that the free market, which Thatcherites seem to view as an infallible deity, can cause terrible damage to ordinary British men and women. Mr Taylor claims that his party now sees the need to tame elements of the Thatcherite legacy that he introduced during the government of Maureen Graty. Well, we in the Labour Party should applaud such a Damascene conversion, as late as it may be. We have argued for years, both in Opposition and in government that the free market is the least bad solution, but that doesn’t mean we should ignore its victims.
However, Mr Taylor’s conversion is far more superficial than he’d like to believe, having come more from focus groups and polling than from any deep-seated conviction of his own, and it is one certainly not shared by his senior team. A “slash and burn” of the public finances is what one senior Shadow Cabinet minister is reported to have said on the Conservative spending plans for after the election. Because the Conservatives, no matter how hard they try, can never understand the need for pragmatic and sensible solutions. Even when they have recognised the need; and despite the long years that’s taken, they have finally recognised it, they are so bound by ideological baggage that they refuse to accept governmental solutions as anything but a last resort. Listen to James Taylor’s conference speeches: “government is not the first resort”, “the public should not expect the government to intervene in every situation”, “government needs to learn to take a step back” and you start to understand the Conservative’s mistakes. They accept the problems, and pay much lip service to them, but their dogma won’t allow them to accept the solutions.
So, now the Tory Party has decided to make a play for the progressive battleground of politics, what should we genuine progressives do? We should not be afraid of agreeing with the Conservatives over problems and causes, but we should make it clear to the public the division that exists; between a party that recognises but cannot act on the issues of the day, and one that is prepared, willing and able to do so. Between progressives-by-necessity; old-school Thatcherites who grudgingly accept a caring agenda in a last, desperate bid for power, and progressives-by-conscience, genuine caring solutions for the twenty-first century. It is clear that the modern Tory Party has not accepted pragmatism over its Thatcherite core, and we should not concede the progressive agenda to them on the back of a couple of speeches by James Taylor. Conservatives such as Richard Samuels, who argued for this throughout the Graty government, despite repeated threats by the whips, should be applauded, but Taylor has abandoned them in favour of dogmatic apparatchiks like Andrew Carter.
To be a progressive party today is to lead the progressive agenda, not just follow it as Mr Taylor claims to do. We need to challenge Mr Taylor on his claimed conversion, to challenge his so-called solutions, and to show the electorate that “compassionate Conservatism” is far more Conservative than it is Compassionate. Those who carry the banner of progressivism should not shy away from this fight; it is a fight for the heart and soul of Britain.
Peter Kennedy is the Deputy Prime Minister and Secretary of State for the Regions.