1920: Progressivism Triumphant, the Fifth Party System and Beyond A Wikibox TL

The Hoover Administration, March 15th, 1921
a62ae197f8d729772d2d36e1c421b752.jpg

"Freedom is the open window through which pours the sunlight of the human spirit and human dignity."

The Hoover Cabinet
Vice President- William Borah
Secretary of State- Charles Evans Hughes
Secretary of the Treasury- Friend Richardson
Secretary of Agriculture- Arthur C. Townley
Secretary of War- Leonard Wood
Attorney General- Henry L. Stimson
Postmaster General- Mark Sullivan
Secretary of the Navy- Edward Eberle
Secretary of the Interior- James Garfield
Secretary of Commerce- John P. Kennedy
Secretary of Labor- William Wilson
 
Last edited:
The Polish-Soviet War
Eastern Europe had been a land destroyed in the aftermath of the First World War. Notably in Poland, war waged between the newly-independent Poland and Soviet Union, with Ukraine caught in the middle. While Poland originally appeared to have the upper hand, a massive Soviet counteroffensive had driven the Poles all the way back to their capitol in Warsaw. However, a miracle of a battle, resulting in a massive Polish victory, had put the Poles back on the offensive, and they pushed against the Red forces, managing miracle after miracle. Such a miracle occurred during the Battle of Komarów, where not only did the Polish forces beat an army that outnumbered them 10:1, a lucky (or unlucky, depending on who you ask) shot killed Semyon Budyonny, the man behind several important Calvary battles during the war. In the ensuing chaos, Polish forces were able to kill several thousand Soviets, and take over 1,000 prisoners.
polishwar1920.PNG

Semyon Budyonny.png

This battle, along with several others, had severely crippled Soviet morale, leading them to seek a peace settlement in late 1920, an offer which was accepted by the tiring Polish forces. In the peace settlement, Poland expanded its borders eastward, while agreeing on the official establishment of the Ukrainian National Republic, which was contained east of the Dnieper river. As part of the treaty, Poland ceded part of Eastern Galacia to the new Ukrainian Republic, due to their support of Poland.
Rigatreaty.png
 
Will we see a White Remnant cling on to Crimea as some sort of Interwar version of Taiwan or are the Whites in Crimea still doomed?
 
Defense of Crimea and the Armenian-Turkish War
With the Ukrainian National Republic being reinvigorated due to the strong Polish counteroffensive in mid-1920, they also sought to push back against the Soviet Union, while they had the upper hand. With assistance from Poland, they moved to secure the Crimean peninsula against the forces of the Red Army. for 10 days in November, a large Polish detachment, along with the Ukrainians, assisted the White Army in defending the Crimea, and then proceeded to route the Red Army, losing only 4,000 men. The Soviets would not try to invade Crimea again during the Russian Civil War, and the peninsula would become a safe haven for fleeing White Army forces, though it fell under de facto Ukrainian control.
crimeandefense.png


Around the same time in the United States, President-elect Herbert Hoover was weighing his options. Hoover, an interventionist, believed that the United States should intervene in the war between Armenia and Turkey on the side of Armenia, due to the ongoing persecution of Armenians. The war had devolved into a stalemate, as Turkey lacked foreign support, but Armenian forces were disorganized. Hoover lacked the votes to have Congress approve of accepting an Armenian Mandate, and therefore having to intervene in the war, as he was blocked by isolationists within all major parties. Hoover was given an opportunity when news of the Turkish government seeking assistance from the Soviets was published in newspapers across the nation. Upon taking office, Hoover used this to push for Congress to approve of an Armenian mandate, along with a small detachment of troops to be sent over to support the Armenians in their conflict, which had still remained in a stalemate, with the tide very slowly turning against the Armenians. Narrowly, these motions were passed, due to support from interventionist Progressives, and a sizable amount of Democrats and Republicans that feared Soviet influence.
armenianturkishwar.png

The small detachment of American troops would arrive in Armenia by April of 1921, and finally turned the months long assault on Kars around, resulting in an Armenian victory. The war would end the next month, with the Treaty of Philadelphia, that formally established the borders of the new Mandate of Armenia. As part of the bill that formally established the Armenian Mandate, an election for Governor of the mandate, and it's legislature, would take place on the 8th of November.
 
Last edited:
I'm guessing due to their alliance in the war, the Ukrainians in Poland will get better treatment then they got OTL?
Yes, Poland already returned a portion of Galacia to the Ukrainians in exchange for their assistance in defeating the Soviets. Also, unlike OTL, the Polish didn’t go back on their alliance with Ukraine at the peace conference with the Soviets.
 
The Harrison Court, By the People
Merely two months after the inauguration of Hoover, Chief Justice of the Supreme Court Edward Douglass White had died. Many wondered what direction Hoover would take with his nominees. In an incredibly unconventional pick, Hoover nominated former Representative from New York, and Governor-General of the Philippines, Francis Burton Harrison. Harrison was largely uncontroversial, however, Hiram Johnson would heavily oppose this nomination, as he feared that Harrison's pro-Filipino policies during his time as Governor-General would translate to pro-Asian policies on the Supreme Court. Harrison was approved in a vote of 72-16, surprisingly with the support of Southern Democrats, who would later come to despise the Harrison court by the end of the decade.
1921harrisoncourt.PNG

Another important development during the 1920s was the advent of radio. With the Progressive Era coming back in full swing, some reformers took their message to the airwaves. One of the most prominent, and most popular, was William Simon U'Ren, who had associated with the movements for both direct election of Senators, and the creation of Presidential Primaries. After his withdraw from politics in 1914, U'Ren had also withdraw from the national stage, but with the election of Herbert Hoover in 1920, U'Ren had returned with his election to the Senate in 1920. He also opted to begin a radio program, which originally broadcasted mainly in California in New York City. On his program, he advocated for the expansion of the primary system, and Australian-style Instant-Runoff Voting. His ideas would gradually catch on during the 1920s, and gradually begin to be adopted.
1921radioshow.PNG
 
Last edited:
1921 elections
The first year of the Hoover Presidency had been quite a successful one. Leonidas C. Dyer, one of the original defectors to the Progressive party, re-introduced his 1918 Anti-Lynching bill to Congress. It passed the House quite easily, and though Southern Democrats in the Senate attempted to filibuster the bill once more, a powerful block of Pro-Civil Rights Republicans and Progressives, joined by the 2 Socialist Senators and singular Prohibition Senator, opted to push back against these Southern Democrats. After a several days long filibuster, the bill was passed in July of 1921. This, along with the successful intervention in Armenia, and recovering economy, gave hope for the fledgling Progressive Party.

As Progressives picked up successes over the course of the year, Republicans and Democrats slowly crumbled. Democratic Kentucky Senator Augustus O. Stanley would defect to the Progressive Party, while his fellow Senator J.C.W. Beckham would defect to the Prohibition Party, over one of their many disputes over Prohibition. In July, muckraker Paul Anderson would publish a report that New Mexico Senator Albert Fall had accepted bribes from several oil companies to pass legislation that would enable them to monopolize the production of oil for the United States government. This was widely published among several newspapers, and pressure mounted for Fall to resign. In late August, with the Republican machine of New Mexico turning against him, Fall resigned from his seat. Governor Larrazolo appointed Progressive suffragist Adelina Otero-Warren to the seat, and scheduled the special election for the seventh of October. Notable was the presence of a Fusion ticket, between the Democratic, Prohibition, and Socialist tickets. However, the Fusion ticket wouldn't come close, and Warren became the first Latina elected to the Senate.
1921newmexicosenate.png


In Virginia, a woman would triumph as well, but under much different circumstances. With Governor Westmoreland Davis refusing to seek re-election, multiple candidates stepped up to try and fill in the gap. A surprising addition to the race was former First Lady Edith Wilson, who shockingly ran for the Prohibition nomination, winning it easily. Wilson would win the race by nearly 20,000 votes, both due to vote-splitting between other candidates and lackluster efforts by Democrats. Also helping her was campaign appearances by her husband, which hurt his ever-fragile health even more.
1921virginia.png


Over by the Black Sea, the Mandate of Armenia was scheduled to elect its first Governor. Armenia was practically a one-party state prior to the establishment of the mandate, with the Armenian Revolutionary Federation having a super majority in the legislature, but after the end of the war with Turkey, problems started to set in. Refugees began flowing into the new territory, and the U.S. congress debated over further aid expenditures to the area. As a humanitarian crisis loomed, opposition to the ARF began growing, but they couldn't agree on a suitable candidate to run against the ARF nominee. Eventually they settled upon the respected general Christophor Araratov, who ran on a platform of bringing stability to the region. He would win the election, and several opposition parties picked up seats against the ARF.
1921armenianmandateelection.png
 
Top