大陸戰爭: The Mainland War 1912-1969

Here is the map that goes with the section "The Federation in Peril", which can be found on the previous page.

tairiku_sensou_1928-1936_zps9120bd68.png

tairiku_sensou_1928-1936_key_zpsb6426ae6.png


-----------------------------------------------------
mcdo said:
Wow, 500,000 casualties? That's horrible. I can certainty see why that would have a lasting impact on Japanese politics and culture--especially since it ends with (seemingly) no gains for Japan.
Keep in mind that that figure includes the wounded.
But yeah, the average Japanese isn't too happy about this.

Karelian said:
The best way to stop jingoist militarism in a society is a crippling defeat in a long, attritional war. This war will have a long-lasting influence to Japanese society, no doubts about that.
The problem here is that instead of putting down their guns and writing pacifist poetry, the Japanese are strongly under the impression that that this stalemate is just the first in a series of events that will inevitably lead to Japan's colonization either by Russia or America. Even the growing opposition, of which many members are veterans, is not motivated by promoting international solidarity or lasting peace so much as it is by a sense that corruption and the shortcomings of capitalism are leading Japan into a trap.

MonAngel said:
Mongolia got some form of independence thanks to Socialist Russia.
Getting Buriyat and Tuva would be incredible. But it is impossible at the moment.
Pretty much this. Russia did have some chaos but there was less foreign intervention and pretty much every major Russian leader, Red or White, had the same idea of where the borders should be.
 
Here's the update about Russia and Japan I mentioned earlier. This is a rather large update, about 2,500 words.
-------------------------------------------------

SHADES OF CRIMSON: THE SOVIET AND EN'AN REVOLUTIONS 1907-1924

The War of 1911


The Russo-Japanese War had left both belligerents with severe domestic outrage. The Tsarist government and its feared secret police, the Okhrana, cracked down hard on demonstrations and dissidents in the following years up to the War of 1911. With tensions in Europe rising, Tsar Nicholas II gave his security forces free reign in persecuting any groups or individuals they suspected of rebellious or otherwise anti-establishment activity. This led to a campaign of terror as well as increased corruption among the elite. Though the creation of a proto-totalitarian atmosphere may not have been the Tsar's intent, this and the disaster that was the War of 1911 irredeemably taint the legacy of Russia's final monarch.

While the state terror suppressed revolutionary activity at home, the Russian Empire faced a formidable array of foreign enemies. None of her relations with other European powers were particularly good due to the Tsar being perceived first as a glutton who wanted the lion's share of the Chinese "cake", and then a brutal despot better suited for the days of Ivan the Terrible. Thus when a conflict in the Balkans led to direct engagement between Russian, Austro-Hungarian, and then German armies, the French and British made no action, preferring to see who would prevail and then act accordingly.

This conflict, the War of 1911, as it came to be known, was preceded by a massive modernization of the Russian Army. Tsarist generals had seen the effect of heavy artillery and machine guns, and paid special attention on their deployment. Unfortunately, corruption was rampant and coordination between commanders was hopelessly sabotaged by petty disagreements and ulterior motives. The Russian officer corps in general was affected by elitism and utter disregard for subordinates. Young conscripts were routinely beaten, starved, or otherwise maltreated as their superiors sold off supplies and rations meant for them to such ends as furnishing their headquarters, consuming fine wines, or enjoying the company of expensive prostitutes. In hindsight, it thus comes as no surprise that the vast Russian Army, which looked so mighty on paper, suffered such embarrassing defeats at the hands of a much smaller and, in some respects doctrinally and technologically inferior Austro-German force.

The War of 1911 was fought for three years, during which the Russians were continuously pushed back, from Poland and Serbia, then Byelorussia and Ukraine, where the front lines stabilized. Despite many isolated instances of tactical brilliance and bravery, the Russian Army was no match for the well-organized and disciplined Germans and their allies, who took advantage of their adversaries' incompetence. In addition, poor conditions and a pervasive feeling of hopelessness prompted whole units to kill their officers and either desert or surrender outright. In 1913 the Baltic peoples revolted and threw their lot in with the Germans, and an Ottoman invasion into the Caucasus led to uprisings by the myriad southern ethnicities. Aghast, the Tsar ordered hasty reorganizations of the military staff and for the Okhrana to ensure the punishment of "treasonous officers", actions which in practice further paralyzed the war effort.

Even the Franco-Russian alliance agreement of 1914 could not salvage the war. With little actual experience in fighting a large-scale modern war, the naive French offensives against the Saar and Ruhrgebiet were easily repulsed. After this failure, the Tsar was detained by his cabinet and coaxed into entering negotiations. In July 1914 representatives of all sides (except the French, who were still trying to rectify the situation at the front) met at and signed the Treaty of Riga, which stripped the Russian Empire of Ukraine, Poland, Byelorussia, the Baltic states, and the Transcaucasia region. It also forbade the alliance of Russia with any European nation and required the creation of a parliamentary system in which the Tsar was to be reduced to a figurehead. Increased German and Austro-Hungarian access to Chinese markets via the Trans-Siberian railroad was also granted.

Virtually all Russia was in uproar over the treaty. Patriots considered it treasonous and socialists saw it simply as the ruling class selling out the nation to save their own skins. The reforms promised by the terms also failed to materialize in any meaningful sense. The only difference, many commented, was that the corrupt officialdom no longer had to use the tsar as a puppet to run their unscrupulous activity. A new wave of dissent, like the one seen after the Russo-Japanese war, now swept across Russia. But unlike the last time, the government's ability to simply suppress undesirable elements was now very limited. Returning men, officers, and even agents of the Okhrana found common cause with the message of those they once persecuted.

The Soviet Revolution

By 1916, the so-called "constitutional government" had proven inept at actually implementing the reforms it had promised, and was in fact passing policies that went counter to those stated goals. An industrial scandal broke out in Moscow and was protested by thousands of workers, who were soon joined by ordinary folk. When troops were sent to crush the demonstration, the soldiers actually turned to the side of the demonstrators in a famous display of solidarity. The Moscow Soviet was formed and soon Tsarist authorities were driven from the metropolis. Following the Muscovite example, similar "Soviets" sprang up all across urban Russia. The Soviets took over the "constitutional government" and began issuing orders to the military. A large contingent sided with the Reds, as the Soviets were known, while officers and personnel still loyal to the old government scattered, mostly eastwards to Siberia and China. Some even famously fled to German-held territories such as Ukraine, where the loyalist government-in-exile was formed. The Tsar himself was apprehended, put on trial, and put under house arrest.

The Soviet government spent the next few years consolidating its power and implementing the reforms demanded by the people. A very liberal system was designed to protect workers' rights and improve their conditions. Salient industries were nationalized and entrepreneurial activity closely examined. Separation of church and state was established and civil and military conscription implemented to strengthen the country, which in 1919 was declared the Union of Soviet Sovereign Republics. The voting population of each subdivision would elect representatives to a local Soviet, which would in turn recommend members for the Supreme Soviet in Moscow. Rule of law was in theory ensured by an independent judiciary while the legislative and executive roles were combined into the authority of the Supreme Soviet. Officially, the USSR was not intended to have an individual head of state or government.

The effects of the Revolution could be felt abroad. In France, which was smarting from its defeat by the Germans, a similar attempt to set up a "second Parisian Commune" was crushed after a few days. Workers' demonstrations and strikes also occurred in Great Britain, Germany, and America, and people in Ukraine, Belarus, and the Slavic regions of the Austro-Hungarian empire rose up in a period of short-lived but highly-visible revolts. Soviet-aided partisan activity in some of these regions would continue for over a decade until after the "War of Slavic Liberation".

But perhaps the most startling event would be what happened in the Orient, in the Empire of Japan.

Workers and Peasants - The Rise of the Ronoto

Like Russia, Japanese society had been deeply impacted by the trauma of the war in Korea and Manchuria. Increasingly paranoid, the Japanese government deigned to allow the Choshu military clique to retain hegemony over the Imperial Army. In line with the political decision to raise and maintain strong modern army, conscription was continued even past the war; unfortunately, young soldiers had to train and serve under brutal conditions. Those who had finished their service often had to return to a life of poverty, be it the toils of a farm or a factory. Young officers not from the Choshu clique saw little opportunity to rise in the ranks, regardless their merit. They saw the Choshu hegemony as a reflection of society itself: an inefficient, self-destructive system that would bring the country down with it. The hope

As economic and political conditions became worse and worse for the common man, especially the peasants and soldiers, who were the most disenfranchised, various intellectuals and officers took note of this and their theories started becoming more radical in nature as many of them saw hope in the rural and urban poor. Many new soldiers and officers, patriotic and perceiving the capitalist system as the source of their ills, were endeared to the radical left.

In the 1910s, two main trends in Japanese leftist thought emerged: the so-called Urban and Rural blocs. The Urban bloc was more intellectually-driven and seen as more faithful to the original intent of the Western writings they studied, while the Rural bloc was more concerned with radical action and a more "organic" progression, by which it was expected that a revolution could happen any day.

By 1915, there were two significant leftist parties in existence: The Social Reform Party, founded in 1909, was associated with the Urbanists and the agrarian Workers' and Peasants' Party (Ronoto, founded 1915). While the SRP was more successful in urban movements and mobilizing labor forces, the Ronoto found a sort of crass support in the ranks of farmers and soldiers, especially soldiers. By 1920 inroads had been made among factory workers as well, and various scholars were commenting on the future of Japan as being driven by radical revolution.

The En'an Reorganization

In early 1922, the Taisho emperor and the heir to the throne, Hirohito, were assassinated by Korean anarchists. This led to great distrust of radicalism by politicians and pronounced anti-Korean sentiment in society at large. Fearful of a mass movement like in Russia, however, the Japanese government opts out of a harsh crackdown, instead targeting a few prominent leftist figures and dealing with them in a low-key manner. Ironically, this has little effect on the radical portions of the leftist movement and strengthens their resolve to fight the "elements of reaction".

The "elements of reaction" were not as united as the leftist radicals would have their subscribers believe. Many moderate and even conservative politicians and civil servants were against or at least had reservations against the two costly and inconclusive wars that had been fought against Russia. Furthermore, these indecisive wars, coupled with the increased hardship they levied upon the people, worried many patriots, especially soldiers who had fought long and hard only to come home and find their families in destitution. In this way, a radical core materialized from the emerging group of unsatisfied individuals of difficult background. The representation of their concerns, the Ronoto, was banned immediately but continued underground, advocating "unlimited revolution" and "accelerated development of the Japanese nation."

The Japanese leadership eventually decided, if very hesitantly, that, after failing to sufficiently satisfy the people for two decades, they would have to make more sweeping reforms to keep the radicals from gaining more influence and thereby threatening civil chaos or even war, as had been the case in Russia. High-level political debates and meetings resulted in the Enan Reorganization. Opposition* parties were permitted, new laws were passed to protect workers and women, and suffrage requirements were relaxed.
The characters making up the new era name "Enan"(延安)mean "lasting peace", reflecting the desire for Japan to remain united and not descend like China or Russia into civil war.

*= Notably, the Ronoto was not included in the list of permitted parties.

Of course, not all in Japan were satisfied with the reforms. Hardliners and those influenced by business obligations did their best to oppose the reform's implementation. The government lost control over some sections of the police and armed forces controlled by rightist officers. This angered the proletarian peoples. They responded with increased strikes and riots.

The new Emperor, Chichibu, was only twenty when he was crowned. He had been allowed to continue his studies until graduation in October 1922 from the Central Military Preparatory School. He had been sympathetic to the demands of the people and understood something of the anguish felt by returning soldiers. In September 1923 the Great Kanto Earthquake hit Japan, killing 150,000 people. In response to banditry and looting on the part of corrupt police and their criminal affiliates, the young Emperor took military initiative and ordered those who hindered the implementation of the En'an Reorganization to be actively punished.

Opinions on the Ronoto, known as the eminent radical organization, were quite polarized. More affluent people and even fellow socialists regarded it as a gang of soldiers-turned-bandits and uppity, uncultured proletarians. However, they provided a unique sort of security to the earthquake survivors and protected them from the corrupt police and looters. This was made known throughout Japan and improved their image greatly. The En'an Emperor officially removed them from the list of banned organizations and they were able to participate in elections. This gesture of goodwill strengthened the more moderate faction in the party.

The rehabilitation of the Ronoto was strongly opposed by conservative segments of society. As the 1924 elections were underway, the Ronoto's moderate candidate was murdered by right-wing thugs. Simultaneously, a reactionary general blockaded the residence of the En'an Emperor and prevented him from leaving, with the excuse that he be in danger as well.

The En'an Revolution

The Election Incident prompted an uproar and a series of riots. After some time, units of the army sympathetic to the Ronoto attacked first the general who had imprisoned the Emperor and then other enemies. For a couple weeks, chaos reigned as leftist troops marched through cities and countryside killing and arresting "reactionaries" and gathering any support they could find, mostly from the working poor. In Korea, a spontaneous and badly-organized revolt was crushed. Tokyo was controlled by leftist forces and became the location of the Ronoto's headquarters.

Occupying Tokyo and various government halls, the Ronoto, now clearly led by uncompromising radicals, declared the planned elections to be null and void and hastily held their own "people's election", and won 90% of the vote. They released the En'an Emperor on the condition that he was to give up his power and claim to divinity, and recognize the "people's election". The 22-year old Tenno could do nothing but comply with these demands. He would continue to reign for another sixty years until his death in 1984.

While the Soviet Revolution received some support from the West, due to Germany's new image as a hegemony threatening dominion over the European continent, the radical movement in Japan was seen as an abomination. Granted, the En'an socialists were also far more conscious and overt about the stated aims and anti-Western flavor of their ideology. Foreigners were largely excluded from the country, unless they were Russian or Chinese. The Anglo-Japanese alliance was terminated at the request of both parties. Japanese businessmen deemed public enemies fled the country and told sensational tales of revolutionary brutality. It seemed that a new sakoku or "closed nation" period was in the works. However, relations with Russia and the Federal Chinese, particularly with the latter, were warm. Though the USSR kept Yuan Shikai's, then Yuan Kewen's NROC as something of a client state, the Japanese government deigned to keep quiet about this annoyance. This was because the Japanese economy was now largely dependent on the good graces of the Soviet and Russian authorities. Aside from Siberian raw materials that fed Japanese production, large numbers of Japanese, barred from Manchuria, settled in the Russian Far East. They would come to form a multi-million diaspora.
 
Good Update Leo...
Liked the development in Russia and Japan... :)
So Korea remained under Japanese control. So Japanese Imperialism still intact.
Wondering what will happen to AH? I guess Victory gave them time.

What would happen to Russian Far East, with huge Japanese immigrants?
 
Last edited:
All right, this was the part I was most looking forward to!:D

I'll write a few small questions on the Japan section.
Feel free to ignore them.:p

  • You already wrote the section, but have you thought about including the Siemens Scandal (or a close analogue)? It seems like that would be a good way to spread the message of patriotic communism and overtaking the West. You could argue that the profit motive is both corrupting the government and hurting national security. They could argue that Japan could be building its own battleships with the latest equipment, but officials were bribed by unscrupulous foreigners into buying overpriced obsolete foreign tech, for example. It would be a good way to appeal to the masses by appearing more patriotic than the government.
  • You talk about how the rural masses have a more emotional and less theoretical understanding of communism. Are they motivated by any issues, like land reform, or is it all just an appeal for patriotism and strength and against poverty and corruption?
  • Prince Chichibu was a philanderer who lead a life of excess. He's hardly the kind to reign over a communist nation.:p Of course, that's not a problem if you take the old Shogunate approach of controlling access to and information about the Emperor. But he may have lead a very different life here.
  • One good thing (in my opinion) about Prince Chichibu is that he was a bit of an Anglophile. He consistently pushed for tighter ties with the UK (and to a lesser extent, the other Western powers) and against closer ties with a revanchist Germany. If he still had his European phase, I could see that being a useful way for the new government to maintain semi-official ties with the West if Japan goes through the same period of pariah-hood that the OTL Soviets did. Of course, that's only if the new Japanese government sees the value of maintaining a line of communication.
  • The assassination of the Emperor and his Regent is a scary thought. The failed attempt (the Sakuradamon Incident) lead to a crackdown in Korea, IIRC. Here, where the attempt was successful, I can only imagine what would happen. You mention that it lead to a rise in anti-Korean sentiment in Japan. Did it lead to any changes in the administration of Korea itself?
  • Random thought: the assassination itself could be a good chance to improve the image of the radicals, too. Maybe the Imperial Guards or the Imperial Household Ministry were all staffed by Choshu incompetents, and otherwise the attempt would have been stopped...

Anyway, as always it was well written, and I look forward to reading more.:)
 
Last edited:
mcdo, I'm pretty sure I answered most of your concerns in our conversations, and the others... well, we'll have to wait until The East is Red.

Good Update Leo...
Liked the development in Russia and Japan... :)
So Korea remained under Japanese control. So Japanese Imperialism still intact.
It's going to be a very different sort of imperialism. Far more centralized and more "civilized".
Wondering what will happen to AH? I guess Victory gave them time.
AH still exists, and has some influence in German-controlled parts of the former Russian Empire. However, they are still working on their own multiethnic issues as well as socialist radicals.
By 1935, almost a million Japanese immigrants to Siberia are working in farming and mining. They come from poor areas. Funnily enough much of their product gets traded to Japan. For the local Slavs, there is some worry about yellow peril, but the Soviet official policy is anti-racist and plus they like having extra people willing to work in harsh conditions to develop the empty land.
Sooo, Finland stays a part of Russia?
Yes, due to butterflies. If this is highly implausible I can change it, or they can help me write a short update similar to the Mongolia one.

Currently working on Manchurian developments from 1922 to 1939. I feel that the updates so far are covering too much ground in too few words. That's why I haven't updated for awhile.
 
Last edited:
Yes, due to butterflies. If this is highly implausible I can change it, or they can help me write a short update similar to the Mongolia one.

It's not, as most Finns found the idea of independence implausible even in OTL 1917 and much of the political elite preferred some kind of federative agreement with Russia - provided that they held up their own end of the bargain where Finns could mind their own business while Russia handled foreign policy and defense.
 
It's not, as most Finns found the idea of independence implausible even in OTL 1917 and much of the political elite preferred some kind of federative agreement with Russia - provided that they held up their own end of the bargain where Finns could mind their own business while Russia handled foreign policy and defense.
Okay, thanks. That's kind of what I imagined anyway. Finnish Soviet Sovereign Republic it is.
 
Update Part I

This is the first section of my current update.

BEIYANG MANCHURIA 1919-1939

nroc_flag_med_zps92e32a7c.png

Flag of the National Republic of China, adopted in 1922.

Beginnings

Since the late 1800s, many Han Chinese had looked to Manchuria (the Northeast) as a new frontier. By the time of the Four Uprisings and the rise of the Two Chinas, the Han far outnumbered the native Manchurians. Farmers and workers from northern and central China, in particular provinces such as Henan, Zhili, Shandong, Shanxi, and Anhui, were flooding the vast, empty landscape.

As warlords looked to make their power permanent, the entire country was rife with banditry and criminal activity. Manchuria was no exception. The extreme poverty faced by migrant men with dim hopes in life often made them turn to a life of violence. After the end of the Qing and throughout the 1910s, countless bandit gangs had formed in the Northeast, taking advantage of the loss of government.

Yuan Shikai's establishment of the NROC legitimatized his Beiyang Army's hold over Beijing and the Northeast. The civil legislation was in fact staffed entirely by Beiyang officers and minor toadies, while the Beiyang high command was vested with actual power and merely made use of the legislature as its mouthpiece.

The Beiyang regime set about instituting order across the Northeast. This was done not by upholding laws, but for the most part through military subjugation. Yuan's divisions fell upon and destroyed minor warlords while co-opting the larger ones, such as the army of Zhang Zuolin. If the armed elements of a region pledged their support to the Beiyang troops, that region could hope to receive gifts in the form of the loot plundered from restive ones. In the Anti-Restoration War, for instance, seized goods from Beijing and its environs were hauled off to the Northeast and used as bonus payment for turned bandit and warlord soldiers.

By the time of Yuan Shikai's death in 1919, the Beiyang regime had proven itself to be little more than a vast warlord army masquerading as a government. Using violence and bribery to keep other armed groups from challenging its rule while pandering to Western investors, it was disliked by nationalist and leftist intellectuals. These voices, however ardent, were crushed under the boots and bayonets of illiterate fighting men, and the regime remained firmly in place. The rise of Yuan Kewen would establish the sword as mightier than the pen. And before long, it was to be found also that the sword could be used to write in blood.

An Army With a Country

Yuan's lifelong fascination with the military began early on in his childhood. Having witnessed the destruction wrought by the 8-Nation Alliance in Beijing during the Boxer War and lost his elder brother, Keding, to the conflict, the 11-year-old Kewen was said to have been possessed - part awed, part traumatized - by the sounds of artillery and marching. His father, appalled at the loss of his firstborn, devoted to Kewen a newfound attentiveness. Ever since the foundation of the NROC, Yuan Shikai had intended for his second son to succeed him, and so Kewen was educated and prepared expressly for leadership. He mastered Russian, and instead of a conventional education, was made to command units of increasing size and importance. By 1919, he was a division commander. Even if imbued with an inevitable arrogance, Kewen was a charismatic figure. In his twenties, he had formed his own clique of officer peers - rising Beiyang soldiers, former bandits, and patriotic college graduates looking to serve their country. His status also granted him an audience with numerous foreign statesmen and industrialists. The extensive contacts he landed in this period would prove instrumental in his future political and military career immediately after his father's death.

Following the defeat of the Old Officer's Conspiracy in 1920 and the purge of the Beiyang commanders, a total rearrangement of authority had taken place. Senior generals who played direct roles in the conspiracy had been executed, while lesser offenders were sidelined to the command of rural militias. Yuan filled the empty ranks with his peers, most of whom were between the ages of thirty and forty, and Yuan himself was only 31 at the time of his attempted assassination. In a society that afforded such respect and authority to the elderly, he was anxious to build a name for himself and his military. With virtually all of the senior Beiyang officers dead, jailed, or sent to minor posts, the prestige of the army was in peril, to say nothing of the mess that was now the high command.

At a 1922 meeting with Guo Songling, Feng Yuxiang, Tong Lin'ge, Zhang Xueliang, and other military peers, Yuan presented his proposals for the future of the military. In order to secure the country, he stated, it was not enough to simply have the means to defeat external enemies. Instead, where adversaries could just as easily sprout up as "a disease of the internal organs" (a reference to Zhang Zuolin's conspiracy), it would be necessary to unite the entire people with a proper attitude towards not just authority, but specifically the military. The centuries-old social and cultural perception of soldiers as little more than bandits would have to change. The idiom "good men do not make soldiers" was to be stamped out. Chinese would have to realize that the country was at war, and that those who did not fight for their country and commander could not be good men. This led to Yuan's stated policy of "All Folk to Arms" (全民皆兵), introduced in 1924 after the abortive "Southern Expedition".

Actually bringing "All Folk to Arms" was, however, easier said than done. Even the professional Beiyang divisions had trouble finding the resources to equip itself properly, to speak nothing of the millions of young men and boys were put into militia service in the years 1924-26, ostensibly on a voluntary basis. The truth was laughable. Beiyang personnel scoured the factories and countryside for candidates between the ages of 12 and 30, who were "encouraged" to sign documents, mobilized into units, gathered for some ceremonies, and then sent home and into "reserve". Even uniforms could not be immediately delivered in most cases, and a militiaman's weapon, if he had one, was likely to be nothing more than a beheading knife, a scythe, or just an iron pipe. "Training" tended to consist of group workouts and hikes conducted once or twice a week.

Yuan was aware that his new multi-million-man "army" was anything but, and had no intention of actually sending the masses into combat. For the present, his goal was psychological. Making the warrior's occupation a universal one, even if in name only, would effect a cultural shift, and belittling the soldiery would become impossible. In the years of recruitment, the self-titled "Grand Marshall" Yuan and other top generals attended numerous military rallies composed of tends of thousands of recruits, where they gave polemic-filled speeches. The late Yuan Shikai was a disciplined visionary whose surviving second son would see his work through to the end; the old officers were in the same league as the "bandit Federation" that was supposedly condoning warlordism and destroying China's traditional foundations to allow for conquest by foreign powers; the soldiers of the Beiyang Army were heroes who would draw upon the people's strength and labor to march all the way to smash the federalists at Canton.

The now-exalted Beiyang troops found themselves in a new social class. Aside from public respect, they also received pay raises, property for their families, and easy access to advantageous civilian positions upon completion of their terms. In 1926, higher education (after 6th grade) was barred to anyone not in service or selected to serve with Beiyang formations. Unlike the ubiquitous "Republican Guard" (the name given to the militias), getting into the Beiyang Army was no easy task. Applicants had to first prove their loyalty and then either martial or intellectual merit. Interestingly, many of the skilled belonged to the "intellectual" category, due to Beiyang service being a requisite for high school or college education. This system, in place until 1930, would lead to the creation of a rather "scholarly" force. Since Yuan had originally planned for parts of the Republican Guard to be brought up to Beiyang standards, by 1930 there was an overabundance of new officers trained for this purpose. In practice, however, like the militiamen they were intended to teach, their status as soldiers was mostly for show. But even if not soldiers in the conventional sense, they would enter battle on a different front.



Part 2 of Manchuria 1919-1939: "The Military of Industry" and more will be up some time after.
 
Last edited:

forget

Banned
A fascinating way to increase the efficiency, by basing the whole of its society around the military.
I never thought Id say this but, the philosophy NROC seems even more purely militarised than that of the Soviets and the NAZIs.
It certainly seems like a much improved version of both cultures, a good reason to continue writing this TL.
 
Nice update Leo.
Lets see what this will lead. With such grand militarization, Yuan will need very strong economy. Military is sucking every possible human resources, so Yuan need to shift some of intelectuals to civil and manufacturing sector.
 
This is really an impressive piece of work, Leo先生.
Definitely worth the wait.:)
OK, first impressions:

Flag of the National Republic of China, adopted in 1922.
That flag looks familiar somehow, lol.:p
Yuan Shikai's establishment of the NROC legitimatized his Beiyang Army's hold over Beijing and the Northeast. The civil legislation was in fact staffed entirely by Beiyang officers and minor toadies, while the Beiyang high command was vested with actual power and merely made use of the legislature as its mouthpiece.
Poor Manchuria... no matter who takes control, it ends up being a military government.
By the time of Yuan Shikai's death in 1919, the Beiyang regime had proven itself to be little more than a vast warlord army masquerading as a government. Using violence and bribery to keep other armed groups from challenging its rule while pandering to Western investors, it was disliked by nationalist and leftist intellectuals. These voices, however ardent, were crushed under the boots and bayonets of illiterate fighting men, and the regime remained firmly in place. The rise of Yuan Kewen would establish the sword as mightier than the pen. And before long, it was to be found also that the sword could be used to write in blood.
This part is informative, plausible, and--especially in regard to the part about the pen and the sword--remarkably well-written.
Yuan's lifelong fascination with the military began early on in his childhood. Having witnessed the destruction wrought by the 8-Nation Alliance in Beijing during the Boxer War and lost his elder brother, Keding, to the conflict, the 11-year-old Kewen was said to have been possessed - part awed, part traumatized - by the sounds of artillery and marching. His father, appalled at the loss of his firstborn, devoted to Kewen a newfound attentiveness. Ever since the foundation of the NROC, Yuan Shikai had intended for his second son to succeed him, and so Kewen was educated and prepared expressly for leadership. He mastered Russian, and instead of a conventional education, was made to command units of increasing size and importance. By 1919, he was a division commander. Even if imbued with an inevitable arrogance, Kewen was a charismatic figure. In his twenties, he had formed his own clique of officer peers - rising Beiyang soldiers, former bandits, and patriotic college graduates looking to serve their country. His status also granted him an audience with numerous foreign statesmen and industrialists. The extensive contacts he landed in this period would prove instrumental in his future political and military career immediately after his father's death.
My personal preference in TLs is for the "story" style over the "textbook" or "news article" style, so I really enjoyed the bit about Kewen's childhood experiences and the effect they had on his adult leadership style and personality.

At a 1922 meeting with Guo Songling, Feng Yuxiang, Tong Lin'ge, Zhang Xueliang, and other military peers, Yuan presented his proposals for the future of the military. In order to secure the country, he stated, it was not enough to simply have the means to defeat external enemies. Instead, where adversaries could just as easily sprout up as "a disease of the internal organs" (a reference to Zhang Zuolin's conspiracy), it would be necessary to unite the entire people with a proper attitude towards not just authority, but specifically the military. The centuries-old social and cultural perception of soldiers as little more than bandits would have to change. The idiom "good men do not make soldiers" was to be stamped out. Chinese would have to realize that the country was at war, and that those who did not fight for their country and commander could not be good men. This led to Yuan's stated policy of "All Folk to Arms" (全民皆兵), introduced in 1924 after the abortive "Southern Expedition".
Hmm, societal/ideological engineering... that's always fun in a TL. I think the "all power to the militarists!" viewpoint makes sense in context, though. Maybe it's just my own background in Japanese history that is leading me astray, but it reminds me of the historical Japanese emphasis on the "spiritual" aspects of soldiering. If so, it's an interesting reversal. Also, I know that saying, lol. I like the use of Chinese here, it gives a nice flavor.
Actually bringing "All Folk to Arms" was, however, easier said than done. Even the professional Beiyang divisions had trouble finding the resources to equip itself properly, to speak nothing of the millions of young men and boys were put into militia service in the years 1924-26, ostensibly on a voluntary basis. The truth was laughable. Beiyang personnel scoured the factories and countryside for candidates between the ages of 12 and 30, who were "encouraged" to sign documents, mobilized into units, gathered for some ceremonies, and then sent home and into "reserve". Even uniforms could not be immediately delivered in most cases, and a militiaman's weapon, if he had one, was likely to be nothing more than a beheading knife, a scythe, or just an iron pipe. "Training" tended to consist of group workouts and hikes conducted once or twice a week.
Out of curiousity, does this government actually plan to field such huge armies, or is it more about getting as many men as possible into the army in order to indoctrinate them?
Part 2 of Manchuria 1919-1939: "The Military of Industry" and more will be up some time after.
I look forward to it.
 
"Don't waste good iron for nails or good men for soldiers."

Culturally the traditional contempt towards military was slowly fading after Boxer Revolution in OTL, when the new military academies started to create a new class of officers who could both read and write, and were thus part of the new educated elite. Warlord era ended this development, and the image of soldiers and military career returned to the old negative stereotype of an illiterate bandit and thug.

It will be interesting to see how this approach to military culture turns out.
 
"Don't waste good iron for nails or good men for soldiers."

Culturally the traditional contempt towards military was slowly fading after Boxer Revolution in OTL, when the new military academies started to create a new class of officers who could both read and write, and were thus part of the new educated elite. Warlord era ended this development, and the image of soldiers and military career returned to the old negative stereotype of an illiterate bandit and thug.

It will be interesting to see how this approach to military culture turns out.

The Chinese Army had illiterate officers up until then?!:eek:
 
The Chinese Army had illiterate officers up until then?!:eek:

I don't want to derail a good thread to discuss matters of Chinese classical education, but this link is a good read:

http://publishing.cdlib.org/ucpress...chunk.id=d0e1230&toc.id=d0e1187&brand=ucpress

"Traditionally, Chinese officers had been selected through a military examination system that stressed feats of strength and martial skills while only requiring minimal literacy. In a society where literary skills were highly prized, intellectually promising men from elite families generally sought advancement through the more prestigious civil service examination system. The military examinations in turn usually drew men from more lowly social backgrounds, often from the army's rank and file. In the new military schools the traditional priorities were reversed. Beyond general physical requirements, the main emphasis was now placed on literacy and intelligence, not on physical skills. In practice this meant that
military students, and thus China's future army officers, would largely be drawn from among the better-educated scions of elite families."
 
A lot of Chinese people in general were illiterate back then, same as in (for example) Italy or the Soviet Union. That's one of the things that encouraged Warlordism, actually, although certainly not the only factor. Prior to widespread literacy and so-called Pǔtōnghuà, it was necessary to have Min Nan speakers in one army and Cantonese speakers in another, as they wouldn't be able to understand each other.
 
The Military of Industry

Upon gradation, the excess of Beiyang officers were sent to "discipline" Guard units. As noted above, Yuan knew exactly how effective they would be as soldiers, so many formations were re-designated as "Republican Guard engineering units", which was in fact a euphemism for "state labor details. The millions of "soldiers" now set off to "combat" in the fields and factories from whence they had come. All that had changed was their management and temperament. This was an intentional part of Yuan's plan to have "the nation guided by the gun". By 1930, collaboration between generals and industrialists was so universal that the two were often indistinguishable. The aforementioned "engineering units", led by Beiyang officers, slowly developed into de facto corporations that engaged in all sorts of industrial endeavors. Legitimate private businesses were co-opted or forced to give up their assets when faced with sudden visits from squads of army "employees". Wielding the authority of the Republic in their grey fatigues and jackboots, they "mobilized" many a shop or factory for the sake of "national defense".

Inside the military-industrial framework, Yuan and his cohorts instituted a comprehensive legal system to regulate economic activity, thus maintaining a satisfactory level of discipline. Military officers risked court-martial if they engaged directly in illicit behavior. Beyond the military, however, the powerless Legislature allowed civil affairs to run amok. Economic crime (and crime in general) was hardly dealt with except by military units, if even then. Drugs, prostitution, human trafficking and slavery were all widespread to some extent, and, if run by civilians, could not be easily prosecuted unless deemed a "military threat". Though officers themselves could not safely break the military laws, they could and did establish contacts with civilian entrepreneurs to make a profit on the side by turning a blind eye to the latter's business for a share of the earnings. Foreigners in particular loved the environment because merely paying off the relevant officers would grant them access to and protection in the Manchurian free-for-all.

The higher echelons of the Beiyang military regime loved foreigners; more specifically, they were attracted to their technology and coffers. Higher officers made a point of purchasing expensive German automobiles, constructing Western-style houses and even castles, dining on exquisite French cuisine, bedding Russian emigre women, and flying in American airplanes. There was in particular a special relationship to be had with Russia, most "accessible" of the Western nations. In some cases, entire White divisions had escaped into Manchuria and given up their weapons, or were even directly incorporated into the Republican Army.

Ever since the Russian Revolution, the influx of White migrants fleeing the Soviet system had resulted in the arrival of a significant pool of skilled labor as well as wealthy individuals. Their know-how and financial wherewithal was attractive to the resident militarists, perhaps most of all Grand Marshall Yuan himself, who saw the future as being one dominated by industry and technology. Relations with the new Soviet Union were cordial. Yuan and his diplomats were careful not to disturb existing Russian influences in the region, such as control of the Chinese Eastern Railway or the naval base at Dalny (Dalian), which was turned over to the Soviets even before their final triumph in Siberia. 1911 War-era arms and artillery were sold dirt-cheap to the Beiyang Army through the 1920s as the Soviets modernized their own troops.

Further to the west, the Germans had begun to look into opportunities to expand their influence around the globe. Ever since 1900, German Qingdao served as a channel for Sino-German negotiations and business. Not a traditional colonial power, they lacked the military projection to hold on to anything beyond a few African possessions. Manchuria with its fast-growing population and lack of heavy regulation looked like a good area for German industrialists to develop by husbanding the latest European methods with expendable labor. Siemens laid the vestiges of an electrical infrastructure, including power stations, Krupp built steel works and later armaments factories, the newly-founded Daimler-Benz supplied Beiyang officers and government officials with their cars, and Henschel brought in improved locomotives and the new and mobile armored weapon, the ram.

The ram, known formally as just "armor", was originally a Russian development of the War of 1911, called the vezdekhodnyye boyevoy poyezd, meaning "all-terrain combat train". The German responded with their own Panzer, and Western observers called the weapons "rams", as they rumbled undeterred by virtually all fire across the front lines. The initial Russian design was a heavily-armed and armored, treaded locomotive with a powerful diesel engine. These behemoths equipped multiple cannons and had a dozen or more operators. Both sides deployed and improved on these war machines throughout and after the conflict. To Marshall Yuan, the ram was a perfect vision of what the wars of the future would look like. While it would be a long time before china produce her own such weapons, he saw to it that a number of rams be added to the Beiyang Army and given their own special unit. Additionally, he made plans for a Chinese tractor plant, which would be operational in the late 30s and built with German help. The industry would prove instrumental in both mechanizing Manchurian agriculture and laying the groundwork for indigenously-produced Chinese armor.

Aircraft was another area given special attention. Originally used for the rapid transport and prestige of officials and officers, their military usefulness was by no means overlooked. Even by 1916 the elder Yuan had procured several aircraft for the exclusive use of the Beiyang Army. The program was expanded considerably in the early 30s as generals like Zhang Xueliang solicited European and American firms for their planes. While impressive, the Beiyang "air fleet" was not immediately useful except in limited reconnaissance and support roles until the 1940s. The first Chinese-built interceptors would be deployed in 1944, yet even then they would prove lackluster.

The Republic's army was an army of laborers and businessmen. For the most part, the average soldiers were more interested in laying railroad tracks and making ends meet, just as they would as civilians, than training or conquest. In 1935, the richest Chinese were either soldiers, criminals, or both. The only legitimate way to success, even in civilian life, was to become a Beiyang officer. The lives of criminals were uncertain and dangerous, while once in the army, one had an ordered system to rely upon. The industrialization of Manchuria under the guidance of military business was looked upon with sad, cynical mockery. Meiji Japan, it was commonly said, had "enriched the country and strengthened the soldiers" (富國強兵), while Yuan and his underlings were "enriching the soldiers and bankrupting the country" (富兵貧國).

This overall state of affairs established the soldier, in particular the Beiyang officer, as the arbiter of order and authority. Every family wanted their sons to either get into the Beiyang divisions or build up amiable relations with their superior officers. A family or business with few military connections was likely to be victimized - their property seized, their sons sent to labor details, and their daughters abducted and sold as concubines or to brothels, the last being a result of Manchuria's unequal male-female population ratio. Officers and wealthy entrepreneurs made a point of flaunting their fortune by showcasing their collections of women, while disenfranchised workers and Guardsmen went unmarried. The human trafficking business skyrocketed. Traffickers made deals all over China and beyond, in places like Siberia and Korea to procure girls and young women for slavery. This barbaric practice would sadly continue, largely unchecked, for the next generation. The plight faced by hundreds of thousands, perhaps millions of victims would only be acknowledged after the Mainland war had been brought to an end.


Next up - Part 3 of Manchuria 1919-1939: "Writing in Blood"
 
Last edited:
So Manchuria is technically same as OTL Manchuko. Only this time lords of the Manchuria is Beyang and Marshal Yuan...
 
A fascinating way to increase the efficiency, by basing the whole of its society around the military.
I never thought Id say this but, the philosophy NROC seems even more purely militarised than that of the Soviets and the NAZIs.
It certainly seems like a much improved version of both cultures, a good reason to continue writing this TL.
Yeah, it's pretty much just nationalism/modernism focused around military strength. I'm not sure I'd call it "improved", but at least there are no openly genocidal tendencies...yet.

Nice update Leo.
Lets see what this will lead. With such grand militarization, Yuan will need very strong economy. Military is sucking every possible human resources, so Yuan need to shift some of intelectuals to civil and manufacturing sector.
A lot of the people in the military do not do purely military work. It's just that they have a rank and uniform, and had to go through some basic training. Even the officers are probably more suited for scholarly pursuits or business. The update, of course, explained this.

This is really an impressive piece of work, Leo先生.
Definitely worth the wait.:)
Thank you.

My personal preference in TLs is for the "story" style over the "textbook" or "news article" style, so I really enjoyed the bit about Kewen's childhood experiences and the effect they had on his adult leadership style and personality.
IOTL he was a playboy and liked impractical scholarly things. He had a bad relationship with his dad as well. I don't know if he was leader material but we'll just have to accept that he is. More of his personality will be revealed as the TL goes on, hopefully.

Out of curiousity, does this government actually plan to field such huge armies, or is it more about getting as many men as possible into the army in order to indoctrinate them?
It's mostly to keep an eye on them and to get them "matriculated" into the system. Most of them just do civilian work since they are technically in reserve. Even when the "engineering brigades" get formed, most people still do what they did before, just under the supervision of officers, who are similarly unfit for actual warfare. The main effect is to transfer economic power and authority to the military system.


"Don't waste good iron for nails or good men for soldiers."
That was the quote, yes. I forgot the nail part, though.

Culturally the traditional contempt towards military was slowly fading after Boxer Revolution in OTL, when the new military academies started to create a new class of officers who could both read and write, and were thus part of the new educated elite. Warlord era ended this development, and the image of soldiers and military career returned to the old negative stereotype of an illiterate bandit and thug.

It will be interesting to see how this approach to military culture turns out.
Civilians still have contempt for the military, but they can't really do anything about it here since the military is taking over politics and industry, and integrating with civil life in doing so.

I don't want to derail a good thread to discuss matters of Chinese classical education, but this link is a good read:
No problem. It's always interesting to read about this kind of thing, and I don't mind the "derailment" as long as we don't turn this thread into a Pony thread or whatever. You learn new stuff every day.

So Manchuria is technically same as OTL Manchuko. Only this time lords of the Manchuria is Beiyang and Marshal Yuan...
Kind of. But peoples' attitudes towards the Beiyang government here are going to be rather different from their thoughts on the Japanese puppet, as we will soon see.
 
Top