AHC: 'Taiwan' your country

Take your home country of residence and create a timeline where their main territory has been occupied by a communist group, but their government has managed to retreat to an island and set up a government there, just like what happened with the RoC.
 
*is a city-state*

Uhhhhhhhhhhhhh... I'll take the easy way out then. Peninsular Malaysia is overrun by the Malayan Communists, forcing the government in Kuala Lumpur to set up a government-in-exile in East Malaysia (Sabah and Sarawak), on Borneo. Of course, this assumes that Indonesia under Sukarno doesn't just finish the job, even though I believe they probably would have a lot of trouble trying.
 
I'd love to see the politics of the United States of America and its two controlled states of Alaska and Hawaii (although they'd probably admit Guam and CNMI as one state, maybe with American Samoa). Communist USA is pissed they don't have their own Siberia since Montana and Wyoming just don't cut it. Could be the best way to get a libertarian US (maybe even under the alt-Libertarian Party).

I'm fascinated in how someone from Taiwan would answer this.

They keep those two island groups between Taiwan and the mainland?
 
I'd love to see the politics of the United States of America and its two controlled states of Alaska and Hawaii (although they'd probably admit Guam and CNMI as one state, maybe with American Samoa). Communist USA is pissed they don't have their own Siberia since Montana and Wyoming just don't cut it. Could be the best way to get a libertarian US (maybe even under the alt-Libertarian Party).



They keep those two island groups between Taiwan and the mainland?

Kinmen and Penghu, yea. Kinmen, especially, is a curious case as it's right next to Xiamen, and the PLA's amphibious operation basically went belly up for reasons I can only sum up as sheer hubris and misfortune.
 
Last edited:
Taiwan - it's not recognized as an independent state because China is important/powerful enough but at the same time it's kept around by the worlds super power as a check on China.

There's few other countries where something like Taiwan can be set up - for example Germany is not powerful or imortant enough to make the UK, Russia and USA do a "Taiwan" on Austria if there was no WW2 and they somehow rebelled out of Germany. It would be recognized as independent right away.
 
Sweden doesn't give acess to Germany and is invaded. The Soviets commit to the scandinavian front and manages to conquer Sweden, but Britain seizes Gotland. Post-war Britain refuses to give the island to the new Swedish Soviet Republic, using it as a naval base and to intercept Soviet Radio in the baltics.
 
The most obvious POD for a Communist Britain is the General Strike of 1926. If the government failed to adequately prepare (unlike OTL), if the response was more heavy-handed and violent, and if the King did not adopt a conciliatory tone, there could have been an attempted overthrow of the government. It's unlikely - there were significant revolutionary elements among the strikers, but revolution was not their declared objective.

Nevertheless, if they succeeded, then the government and royal family would flee abroad. Most likely to Canada, but if some of the colonies can be kept together they would still administer these themselves. George V refuses to leave, not willing to abandon his subjects to socialist tyranny. He suffers the same fate as his cousin, Tsar Nicholas. Edward VIII becomes King, and is crowned in Ottawa.

Meanwhile, as decolonisation accelerates (probably earlier for a 'British' Empire without the metropole) and the legitimate British government feels the need to leave Canada as the constitutional links are slowly severed, a new headquarters for Parliament is established on Bermuda. All remaining Crown Colonies willing to remain British (probably most of today's Overseas Territories, possible excluding the Chagos Islands and the Sovereign Base Areas on Cyprus due to British weakness) are united into one 'nation' with their own Parliamentary constituencies, electing MPs to the 'British' House of Commons in Hamilton, Bermuda. The King shares his time between Canada, Bermuda, and the other Commonwealth Realms.

The Channel Islands, the Isle of Man and the Shetlands fall under Communist control, but I suspect that Gibraltar would remain legitimist (or possibly be taken by Spain, depending on how much military power the legitimate government can muster).
 
For Germany, that seems rather difficult. But well, I will give it a try: The 20 July Plot succeeds partially, at least in its objective to kill Hitler. However, the conspirators are still outed eventually, yet because of the chaos within the Nazi leadership during the struggle over Hitler's succession, manage to get away with loyal elements of the Wehrmacht and establish themselves on the island of Rügen. Once there, they are able to hold out until the end of the war, as the various factions of the Nazis descend into some sort of civil war and are thus distracted. After the war, Germany is split into various occupation zones (US, French, British, Soviet) and protectorates (e.g. Saarland, Rügen), relatively similar to OTL. In this scenario, Rügen is occupied by American troops, but located right off the shore of the Soviet occupation zone. In 1952, the Stalin Note is accepted by the Western Allies, leading to the reunification of Germany as a neutral buffer state. However, the island of Rügen is left out of the agreement, and subsequently serves as a second German state under heavy American protection, especially after the unified Germany slowly slips into the Soviet orbit in the 1950s and 1960s, leading to her eventual transformation into the German Socialist People's Republic and her subsequent accession into the Warsaw Pact.

It’s hard to do it again, so how about...
Maoist uprising takes over the mainland. The present day PRC takes refuge in Hainan?
Careful! If you do that trick too often, you'll eventually run out of islands!
 
The Republic of Greece is suspiciously looking out from Crete (and a handful other islands and later Cyprus) at the people's Republic of Greece that took over the mainland in 1944.
 
Italy is occupied by Stalin in 1945 or Communists wins a Civil War following Togliatti's successful assassination in 1948. Italian Goverment (Monarchist in the first hypothesis, Republican in the second) fled in Sicily or Sardinia and run an "Italian Taiwan" from there.
 
The Republic of Greece is suspiciously looking out from Crete (and a handful other islands and later Cyprus) at the people's Republic of Greece that took over the mainland in 1944.

Something similar is happening in McGoverning, though it's the Colonels who flee a democratic revolution and take up residence on Cyprus.
 
Top