Christmas Truce

GREAT IDEA!!

Eckener! GREAT story idea!!!! I had a similar one (which, due to your inspiration) I might run with. Instead of Christmas, 1914, its motivation would be the 1916 Olympics. These were planned to be held in Berlin but were cancelled due to the war.

This isn't the right place to ask this, but what if the still-living founder of the Olympic movement, a Frenchmen, asked his Swiss friend to speak to the German committee member to ask the Kaiser if he was willing to agree to a truce for the Games?

More of a political problem to stop the War for the Olympics, but once stopped, why not an armistice and peace talks instead of a renewal of hostilities between people who have just competed in peace with each other?

Just a thought . . .

I will watch with interest as the Christmas Peace progresses!!:eek:
 
Here Eckener. Hope this can be of good use:)

http://www.worldwar1.com/sfgrank.htm

Here is the reorganization of the armies and the structure from divisions to platoons, including the composition of each level

http://www.worldwar1.com/sfgermreorg.htm

Just thought I would throw this out there

http://www.worldwar1.com/sfgcross.htm

Here is a list of leaders


Kaiser Wilhelm II of the German Empire- The idiot that ruined the German Empire( I say this with all the love possible that I can, and I love the German Empire)
Admiral of the Kaiserlichemarine Franz Von Hipper- Successor to the great Admiral Tirpitz.

Chief of Staff 1914-1916 Erich Von Falkenhayn- Successor of Helmuth Von Moltke the Younger. Also was sacked and assumed command of the 9th Army in Translyvannia after Verdun.

Generalfeldmarschall Paul Von Hidenburg-
At the start of November 1914 Hindenburg was given the position of Supreme Commander East (Ober-Ost) – although at this stage his authority only extended over the German, not the A-H portion of the front – and units were transferred from East Prussia to form a new Ninth Army in south-western Poland. Later in November 1914, after the Battle of Lodz, Hindenburg was promoted to the rank of Generalfeldmarschall. A further battle was fought by the Eighth and newly-formed Tenth Armies in Masuria that winter. Ober-Ost eventually consisted of the German Eighth, Ninth and Tenth Armies, plus other assorted corps.

General der Infanterie Erich Ludendorf-
With the outbreak of World War I, then called The Great War, Ludendorff was first appointed Deputy Chief of Staff to the German Second Army under General Karl Von Bulow. His assignment was largely due to his knowledge and previous work investigating the dozen forts surrounding Liege, Belgium. The German assault in early August 1914, according to the Schlieffen Plan for invading France, gained him national recognition. The Germans experienced their first major setback at Liège. Belgian artillery and machine guns killed thousands of German troops attempting frontal assaults. On 5 August Ludendorff took command of the 14th Brigade, whose general had been killed. He cut off Liège and called for siege guns. By 16 August all forts around Liège had fallen, allowing the German First Army to advance. As the victor of Liège, Ludendorff was awarded Germany's highest military decoration for gallantry, the Pour le Merite, presented by Kaiser Wilhelm himself on 22 August.
Russia had prepared for and was waging war more effectively than the Schlieffen Plan anticipated. German forces were withdrawing as the Russians advanced towards Konigsberg in East Prussia. Only a week after Liège's fall, Ludendorff, then engaged in the assault on Belgium's second great fortress at Namur, was urgently requested by the Kaiser to serve as Chief of Staff of the 8th Army on the Eastern Front. Ludendorff went quickly with Hindenburg, who was recalled from retirement, to replace General Prittwitz, who had proposed abandoning East Prussia altogether. Hindenburg relied heavily upon Ludendorff and Max Hoffman in planning the successful operations in the battles of Tannenberg and the Mausaurian Lakes. After the Battle of Lodz(1914) in November 1914 Ludendorff was promoted to Lieutenant-General

Generalmajor Paul Von Lettow-Vorbeck-
In August 1914, during the early phases of the WW1, von Lettow-Vorbeck was the commander of a small garrison of just 2,600 German nationals and 2,472 African soldiers in 14 Askari field companies. Realising the need to seize the initiative, he ignored orders from Berlin and the colony's governor, Heinrich Schnee, who had insisted on neutrality for German East Africa. Von Lettow-Vorbeck simply ignored the governor and prepared to repel a major amphibious assault on the city of Tanga. The attack began on 2 November 1914, and for the next four days he fought one of his greatest battles. He then assembled his men and their scant supplies to attack the British railways in East Africa. He scored a second victory over the British at Jassin on 18 January 1915.

Oberleutnant Max Bauer-
Expert in artillery tactics and during the First World War had a hand in destroying the Liege fort in Belgiu, in 1914. In July 1915 he became a chief of the Section I of the General staff. He mobilized industry to produce ammunition and wrote a booklet about defensive tactics. In December 1916 he was awarded the Pour le Merite, with oak leaves added on March 28, 1918.

Colonel Hans Von Seeckt-
Seeckt held the rank of colonel and served as chief of staff in the German III Army Corps. Seeckt marched with the Corps in the German offensive, and "distinguished himself" in fighting near Soissons, then in March 1915, he became chief of staff to General August Von Mackensen of the German Eleventh Army

Political Leades


Chancellor Theobald Von Bethmann-Hollweg-
Following the assassination of Archduke Franz Ferdinand in Sarajevo on June 28, 1914, Bethmann Hollweg and Foreign Secretary Gottlieb Von Jagow were instrumental in urging the Austrians to take a tough stand against Serbia, and later, took steps to prevent Grey's efforts to impose a peaceful solution on the quarreling parties. In the last days before the outbreak of war, however, he seems to have had some second thoughts, and he took half-hearted measures to support Grey's proposals of mediation, until Russia's mobilization on July 31, 1914, took the matter out of his hands. Much of his foreign policy before the war had been guided by his desire to establish good relations with Britain, was particularly upset by Britain's declaration of war following German violation of Belgium's neutrality in the course of her invasion of France, reportedly asking the departing British Ambassador Goschen how Britain could go to war over a "mere scrap of paper" (the Treaty of London 1839 which guaranteed Belgium's neutrality), a remark which would become infamous for its demonstration of German insensitivity to international law and treaty rights.

Foreign Minister Gottlieb Von Jagow-
In the July Crisis of 1914, Jagow was confident that an Austro-Serbian war would be localized, and that Russia was not yet prepared for a continental war. This belief was incorrect, which indirectly led to the outbreak of WW1. After the war, Jagow attributed deeper reasons for the outbreak of war to "...this damned system of alliances."

Matthias Erzberger-
Like many of his party, he initially supported Germany's involvement in The Great War. He drafted Germany's war aim's that were published on 9 September 1914. By this stage he was rapporteur to the Reichstag's Military Affairs Committee, and the "right-hand man" of the Bethmann-Hollweg. He wrote letters to leading military authorities, later published, with extravagant plans for German annexations. Seen as an opportunist, he was said to have "no convictions but only appetites"

Arthur Zimmerman-
In late 1914 Zimmermann was visited by Roger Casement, the Irish revolutionary. A plan was laid to land 25,000 soldiers in the west of Ireland with 75,000 rifles. However the German general staff did not agree. In 1916 Casement returned to Ireland in a U-boat and was captured and executed. A German ship renamed the "Aud", flying Norwegian colours, shipped 20,000 rifles to the south Irish coast but it failed to link up with the rebels and was scuttled. Planning on this support, a minority of the Irish Volunteers launched the Easter Rising in Dublin. Though the Rising failed, its political effect led on to the Anglo-Irish in 1919-1922 and the formation of the Irish Free State.

Gustav Stresemann-
In 1914 he returned to the Reichstag. He was exempted from war service due to poor health. With Bassermann kept away from the Reichstag by either illness or military service, Stresemann soon became the National Liberals' de facto leader. After Bassermann's death in 1917, Stresemann succeeded him as party leader.

Philipp Scheidmann-
During the Great War, Scheidemann, along with Friedrich Ebert was leader of the majority faction of the party, which continued to vote for war credits, limiting his opposition to the war to urging the negotiation of a compromise peace.

Friedrich Ebert-
When Ebert was elected as the leader of the SPD after the death of August Bebel, the party members of the SPD were deeply divided because of the party's support for The Great War. Ebert supported the Burgfrieden and tried to isolate the war opposers in the party. After the war and the end of the monarchy he served as the first President of Germany from 1919 until his death in office.

George Von Hertling-
Bavarian Prime Minister. Supporter of Bethmann-Hollweg. Declined to be his successor, but was elevated to Count by King Ludwig the III of Bavaria.

Counsillor of the Embassy to the Ottoman Empire Richard Von Kuhlman-
Successful counsillor of the embassy in the Ottoman Empire

George Michaelis-
In 1909 he won appointment as undersecretary of state to the Prussian Treasury in Berlin. From 1915 onwards he headed the Reichsgetreidestelle, an office responsible for the administration of Prussian corn and wheat in The Great War.

Hanns Freiharr Von Wagenheim-
n 1914, after the assassination of Franz Ferdinand, Ismael Enver, the Ottoman General Minister of War, asked if an alliance with Germany could happen. Andrew Mango continues with the history at this time in his book Ataturk. Here he describes the jumbled alliance-structure that existed that would threaten the current relationship between Germany and the Ottoman Empire. For instance, Germany had already claimed war against Russia and it had an alliance with Austria-Hungary. This agreement with the Ottoman Empire would allow Germany to take a leadership role in alliance-making before The Great War. It would also force Russia and Serbia to alliance-make to condemn the assassination.

Generalfeldmarschall Colmar Freiharr Von Der Goltz-
At the outbreak of the First World War Goltz was recalled to duty and appointed the Military Governor of Belgium. In that position, he dealt ruthlessly with what remained of Belgian resistance to German occupation, mostly sniper-fire and damaging rail and telegraph lines. As Martin Gilbert notes in The First World War, in early September 1914, the newly appointed Goltz proclaimed: "It is the stern necessity of war that the punishment for hostile acts falls not only on the guilty, but on the innocent as well." On 5 October, he was even clearer when he ordered: "In the future, villages in the vicinity of places where railway and telegraph lines are destroyed will be punished without pity (whether they are guilty or not of the acts in question). With this in view hostages have been taken in all villages near the railway lines which are threatened by such attacks. Upon the first attempt to destroy lines of railway, telegraph or telephone, they will immediately be shot." Soon after he was removed from that position and became the aid to Sultan Mehmed V.

Generalleutnant Otto Liman Von Sanders-

Reorganizer of the Ottoman Empire's Armies.

Western Front

ColonelGeneral Alexander Von Kluck
-
With the outbreak of World War I, Kluck was placed in command of the German First Army. According to the Moltke revisions of the Schlieffin Plan, the First Army was part of the strong right wing and positioned on the outer western edge of the German advance through Belgium and France. This western flank was to advance alongside Karl Von Bulow's Second Army to Paris. Upon reaching Paris in concert, the First and Second armies were to threaten Paris from both the west and east.
After fighting the British at Mons and Le Cateau, the First Army pursued Lanrezac's French Fifth Army during the great retreat. However, thirty miles from Paris and anticipating an encounter with the French Fifth Army (commanded by Lanrezac), the cautious von Bulow halted his Second Army's advance and demanded von Kluck's direct support. By this time, the aggressive Kluck had advanced his First Army well south of von Bulow's position to 13 miles north of Paris. On August 30, Kluck decided to wheel his columns to the east of Paris, discarding entirely the Schlieffen Plan. Although frustrated by Bülow's caution, on 31 August Kluck turned his army southeast to support the Second Army. In so doing, Kluck created a 30-mile gap in the German line extending toward Bülow's stalled Second Army. Critically, the move exposed Kluck's right flank in the direction of Paris where (unknown to Kluck) General Michel-Joseph Maunoury's new Sixth Army was being created. The French learned of Kluck's change in course n September 1, when a French patrol captured a German dispatch car, containing a map showing the changed position. The following events were critical to the future course of the war. Passing to the east of Paris, Kluck exposed his right flank to the new French Sixth Army (General Maunory). On 5 September, Maunoury attacked Kluck's right flank, marking the opening of the First Battle of the Marne. Kluck parried the blow by borrowing two corps in the space between the First and Second army. A surprise attack on 8 September by Franchet de'Esperey's (who had replaced Lanrezac) Fifth Army against Bülow's Second widened the gap which the BEF marched to exploit. The attack, as Winston Churchill said, "probed its way into the German liver." On 9 September a representative of the German Headquarters, Hentsch, considered the situation of Bülow's Army as very dangerous and ordered a retreat of all the armies, even though by that time von Kluck had overcome most of his own problems, (except presumably, the problem of keeping in contact with his headquarters and letting his chief of Staff, and therefore Hentsch, from knowing how he had solved his problems). The Germans retreated in good order to positions forty miles behind the River Aisne. There, the front would remain for years in the form of entrenched positions as World War I continued. Kluck and Bülow's lack of coordination and the ensuing failure to maintain an effective offensive line was a primary contribution to the failure of the Schlieffen Plan which was intended to deliver a decisive blow against France. Instead, the long stalemate of trench warfare was ready to begin. The British at the time called him "old one o'clock". Many German experts, however, hold Kluck and especially his Chief of Staff, Kuhl, in the highest esteem. Germany could have won the Battle of the Marne, they think, if only Bülow had matched the courageous initiatives of Kluck's Army, although this doesn't explain the near encirclement of his army.

Generaloberst Hans Hartwig Von Beseler
-
In 1914 Beseler was brought out of retirement and was given command of the 3rd Reserve Corps in the German First Army led by Generaloberst Von Kluck. The German Army took Brussels on 20 August, and the German command considered the Belgian Army defeated. The main force of the German armies marched toward France, leaving the 3rd Reserve Corps behind. Beseler was ordered to take possession of the city of Antwerp on 9 September. The Siege of Antwerp ended on 10 October, when the Antwerp Mayor, Jan De Vos, surrendered the city. Beseler followed the Belgian army and was halted in the.

Feldmarschall Karl Von Bulow
-
Assigned to the German 2nd Army at the beginning of World War I in August 1914, Bülow invaded Belgium, capturing the fortress of Namur on August 22–23. Advancing into France, Bülow defeated General Charles Lanrezac of the French Fifth Army at Charleroi on August 23–24 and again at St. Quentin on August 29–30. As the 2nd Army and General Alexander Von Kluck's 1st Army neared Paris from August 31 to September 2, Bülow, concerned about the growing gap between the two armies, ordered Kluck to turn the 1st Army on his right towards him. This decision, however, resulted in Kluck's advancing south and east of Paris, instead of north and west as specified in the Schlieffin Plan. Bülow crossed the Marne on September 4, but decided to retreat to Aisne after the successful counterattack by combined French and British forces against Kluck's 1st Army at the First Battle of the Marne from September 5–10.
Bülow was promoted to Feldmarschall in January of the following year. After suffering a heart attack two months later, he was allowed to retire in early 1916, living in Berlin until his death.

General Max Clemens Lothar Freiherr von Hausen
-
Upon mobilization in August 1914, the Royal Saxon Army became the German 3rd Army and Hausen was given command. His army participated in the Battle of the Frontiers, mainly in the battles of Dinant and Charleroi, and he and his army were responsible for the destruction of Reims in September 1914. After the 2nd Army's retreat after the First Battle of the Marne, Hausen saw his own flank exposed and ordered a retreat. After the stabilization of the front on the Aisne River, on September 9, 1914, Hausen was relieved of his command due to illness and replaced by General Karl Von Einem. Hausen held no further field commands during the war, and died shortly after the war ended.

Generaloberst Karl von Einem genannt von Rothmaler-
Einem succeeded General Max Von Hausen as commander of the 3rd Army in September 1914. Successfully repulsing the French Champagne-Marne offensive from February–March and September–November 1915 respectively, Einem would take part in all three Battles of the Aisne.

Generalfeldmarschall Albrecht Herzog von Württemberg
-
4th Army commander, central German army with the 5th Army. Led them to victory in the Battle of the Ardennes in August 1914. Following this victory, the 4th Army saw action in the First Battle of the Marne before being transferred to Flanders in October, where Duke Albrecht commanded them during the Battle of the Yser. Duke Albrecht also commanded the German forces during the Second Battle of Ypres, where poison gas was used on a large scale for the first time. Duke Albrecht was awarded the Pour le Merite in August 1915 and was promoted to Generalfeldmarschall in August 1916. The newly formed Army Group Albrecht was placed under his commanded in February 1917 and he was responsible for the southern sector of the Western Front until the Armistice.

Kronprinze Wilhelm Von Preussen of Germany
-
He led the 5th Army until November 1916, a two-year period which included the battle of attrition known as the Verdun Offensive. From April 1916 onward, he tried in vain to convince the supreme command that the Verdun offensive no longer made any sense, but the campaign continued until 2 September of that year.General der Infanterie Schmidt Von Knobelsdorf served as his Chief of Staff. He would very often clash with Knobelsdorf who was totally committed to achieving victory at Verdun.

Kronprinz Rupprecht Von Bayern of Bavaria
-
He commanded the German 6th Army at the outbreak of WWI in Lorraine. While part of the German army was participating in the Schlieffen plan, the Crown Prince led his troops on to the Battle of Lorraine. The appointment to command of the Sixth Army was as a result of his royalty, but the level of study he had performed before he took command was a factor behind his successful direction of the Sixth Army, and he proved to be a highly able commander. Rupprecht's army gave way to the French attack in August 1914, in the Battle of Lorraine, and then launched a counteroffensive on the 20th. Rupprecht failed to break through the French lines. He was later in command of the 6th Army in Northern France and remained on the Western Front during the stalemate that would last until the end of the war. Rupprecht achieved the rank of Generalfeldmarschall in July 1916 and assumed command of Army Group Rupprecht on 28 August that year, consisting of the 1st, 2nd, 6th and 7th Army. Rupprecht has been considered by some to be one of the best Royal commanders in the Imperial German Army of World War I, possibly even the only one to deserve his command. Rupprecht came to the conclusion much earlier than most other German generals (towards the end of 1917), that the war could not be won, seeing an ever increasing material advantage of the allies. He also opposed the "scorched earth" policy during withdrawals, but his royal position made a resignation on those grounds impossible for him, even though he threatened it. He eventually resigned from his command on 11 November 1918.

Generaloberst Josias Von Heeringen
-
Took command of the Seventh Army in August 1914- the army which was being used as a decoy for the attempted German invasion of France- and successfully defended Alsace against the French in the Battle of Mulhouse, for which he was awarded the Pour le Merite. He commanded the Seventh Army until 1916 when he was transferred to coastal command in Germany for the duration of the war.


Generaloberst Felix Graf Von Bothmer
-
In 1917 he was appointed to command the 19th Army in Lorraine. He remained there until 8 November 1918, while to his north the German front crumbled. Bothmer retired from the army later in November 1918. Bothmer’s last job in the army, again along with von Hemmer, was to be an adviser for the Bavarian Ministry for Military Affairs, from November to December 1918, mostly overseeing the demobilization of the soon-to-be-disbanded Bavarian Army(not reall mentionable, due to him having no effect on your
POD)

Eastern Front


General der Infanterie Otto Von Below-
Commander Eight Army in East Prussia. During World War I, Below took part as a commander in the Battle of Gumbinnen, for which he was promoted to General der Infanterie, the Battle of Tannenberg(1914) and the 2nd Battle of the Mausaurian Lakes (February 1915).

General Max Hoffman-Deputy Commander of the 8th Army through all its incarnations.

General der Kavalerie August Von Mackensen-
On 2 November 1914 Mackensen took command of the Ninth Army from General von Hindenburg, who had been named Supreme Commander East (Oberbefehlshaber Ost). On 27 November 1914 Mackensen was awarded the Pour le Merite, Prussia's highest military order, for actions around Lodz and Warsaw. He commanded the Ninth Army until April 1915, when he took command of the Eleventh Army and Army Group Kiev (Heeresgruppe Kiew), seeing action in Galicia, and assisting in the capture of Przemsl and Lemberg. He was awarded oak leaves to the Pour le Merite on 3 June 1915 and promoted to feldmarschall on 22 June. After this campaign, he was awarded the Order of the Black Eagle, Prussia's highest-ranking order of knighthood. During this period, he also received numerous honours from other German states and Germany's allies, including the Grand Cross of the Military Max Joseph Order, the highest military honour of the Kingdom of Bavaria, on 4 June 1915.

The 11th and 12th armies did not come into existence until about 6 months after your POD so I did not think to mention them.

Hope you like the info Eckener! Looking forward to helping. Although this is the furthest extent my knowledge goes. It gets extremely 'ard to distinguish different army groups, as I think they were consolidated and separated many times. Also, I had a hard time finding members of the general staff, so I used my knowledge as best as I could. Although I will go look up in my books on WW1 to see if I missed any prominent figures. Tell you if I come across anything.
 
Last edited:
Thank you!!! That's quite a lot of needed information. That'll be helpful I'm sure.

Anyone else have any other ideas or suggestions or just helpful information?
 
Eckener! GREAT story idea!!!! I had a similar one (which, due to your inspiration) I might run with. Instead of Christmas, 1914, its motivation would be the 1916 Olympics. These were planned to be held in Berlin but were cancelled due to the war.

This isn't the right place to ask this, but what if the still-living founder of the Olympic movement, a Frenchmen, asked his Swiss friend to speak to the German committee member to ask the Kaiser if he was willing to agree to a truce for the Games?

More of a political problem to stop the War for the Olympics, but once stopped, why not an armistice and peace talks instead of a renewal of hostilities between people who have just competed in peace with each other?

Just a thought . . .

I will watch with interest as the Christmas Peace progresses!!:eek:

It is a cool idea, I'll grant you that. My one concern is whether or not the Olympics were a big enough deal to have the clout to convince the nations to stop the War for the games. Another possible issue is that by 1916, the war had become a lot nastier and entrenched that it was in 1914. I believe that 1914 was the only year that there was even some sort of truce that broke out on Christmas, that the armies gave orders specifically to avoid a repeat.

I actually was watching a short clip from a WWI documentary on youtube that was talking about the 1914 Christmas truce, and one of the historians being interviewed referred to it as one of the last dying breaths of the 19th Century and the Victorian Era.

If you run with this story I'd definitely be interested in it though. I'm sure you can find ways around the possible issues I've pointed out. And it would be cool. Good luck :)
 
So, I'm *hoping* to be able to start writing an update to this TL soon.

Still thinking about some details to come up with further along in the TL. One item: an anthem for the "Christmas Republic". I was wanting to use a christmas carol. A few ideas: "O Tannenbaum", "Silent Night", or "Joy to the World".

On a totally unrelated note: RUSSIA. First off, with the war ending in 1915, this could possibly prevent the Russian Revolution. For one, Lenin would probably not end up returning to Russia. Secondly, with the war ending early, the stress and hardships put on that country will be over and it's possible that the country could reform and prevent the revolutions of OTL 1917. Another thing for Russia: Christmas is going to probably have greater world-wide importance than it does OTL, so I could see Russia adapting the Gregorian calendar sooner that OTL so that they celebrate Christmas on the same day as the rest of Europe.
 
"Silent Night",
On a totally unrelated note: RUSSIA. First off, with the war ending in 1915, this could possibly prevent the Russian Revolution. For one, Lenin would probably not end up returning to Russia. Secondly, with the war ending early, the stress and hardships put on that country will be over and it's possible that the country could reform and prevent the revolutions of OTL 1917. Another thing for Russia: Christmas is going to probably have greater world-wide importance than it does OTL, so I could see Russia adapting the Gregorian calendar sooner that OTL so that they celebrate Christmas on the same day as the rest of Europe.

Silent Night is probably the most somber sounding carol, so it could be used in a way that makes the soldiers think about home, bringing memories back, and forcing them to get out of the trenches to make peace with their foe.
Hmmm, the Rodina is a troublesome beast. I always like to see a surviving Russian Empire, and if you do, you either take it to a more autocratic/police state with more military funding(proper barracks and food for the army, which I do not think will help anyways because the Russian Soldiers supported their families and would rise up to), or instigate sweeping reforms on limiting the Tsar's powers and have a more liberal Duma, though this is still hard to do. Unless you bring back a more liberal politician that had support...
 
Who would be a good leader for the "peace faction" in Britain
How about George Lansbury? A pacifist and a Labour MP (1910-12, 1922-40) who became leader of the Labour Party in 1932.

An added 'butterfly' bonus could be that his grand-daughter (the actress Angela Lansbury) remained in the UK and thus spared us from endless TV repeats of 'Murder She Wrote'.
 
Last edited:
Silent Night is probably the most somber sounding carol, so it could be used in a way that makes the soldiers think about home, bringing memories back, and forcing them to get out of the trenches to make peace with their foe.
Hmmm, the Rodina is a troublesome beast. I always like to see a surviving Russian Empire, and if you do, you either take it to a more autocratic/police state with more military funding(proper barracks and food for the army, which I do not think will help anyways because the Russian Soldiers supported their families and would rise up to), or instigate sweeping reforms on limiting the Tsar's powers and have a more liberal Duma, though this is still hard to do. Unless you bring back a more liberal politician that had support...
That was my thoughts behind having Silent Night. My only hesitation is that it's not really a good march-style anthem, where as I've heard the other two played as such.
As for Russia, yes I agree, it is a troublesome beast.
I suppose there still could be a revolution, but without agitators like Lenin, perhaps the revolution turns Russia into a Republic?

How about George Lansbury? A pacifist and a Labour MP (1910-12, 1932-35) who became leader of the Labour Party in 1932.

An added 'butterfly' bonus could be that his grand-daughter (the actress Angela Lansbury) remained in the UK and thus spared us from endless TV repeats of 'Murder She Wrote'.
Thanks!! I have heard of Mr. Lansbury before. That would actually be pretty cool.
American television without "Murder She Wrote" :eek: the horror :p
 
Realized I'd let this slide to the back burner.

Still not sure on some details for this, as far as military commanders that would be involved and what not. At least for the English and French.

Also, not sure what style I'd like to use overall. I know the very start was first person, but I was thinking mixing that in with "primary documents" like the newspaper format that I've used in my Airship President TL (would probably have a mix of newspaper articles, book articles, and military communiques).

Any other thoughts or suggestions?
 
"O Tannenbaum" has been used as a political song melody twice, once by British Socialists/Communists ("The Red Flag") and one by American pro-Confederates ("Maryland, My Maryland").
This promises to be an interesting idea!
 
That was my thoughts behind having Silent Night. My only hesitation is that it's not really a good march-style anthem, where as I've heard the other two played as such.
As for Russia, yes I agree, it is a troublesome beast.
I suppose there still could be a revolution, but without agitators like Lenin, perhaps the revolution turns Russia into a Republic?

Yea, Silent Night is not good marching music, but workable if you do a slow march, like they do for the funerals of fallen soldiers. Hmmmm Russian Republic. Well without Lenin you could have anarchist Russia:D:D:D and they will not piss off anybody as they believe in no government or imperialistic Tsar. The Black Army was pretty strong OTL. It could be used in this case to make the Tsar lighten up, but I think that their would be a call for constitutional monarchy, keeping the Tsar as a figurehead.
 
"O Tannenbaum" has been used as a political song melody twice, once by British Socialists/Communists ("The Red Flag") and one by American pro-Confederates ("Maryland, My Maryland").
This promises to be an interesting idea!
Really? that's interesting. I didn't know that. :)

Yea, Silent Night is not good marching music, but workable if you do a slow march, like they do for the funerals of fallen soldiers. Hmmmm Russian Republic. Well without Lenin you could have anarchist Russia:D:D:D and they will not piss off anybody as they believe in no government or imperialistic Tsar. The Black Army was pretty strong OTL. It could be used in this case to make the Tsar lighten up, but I think that their would be a call for constitutional monarchy, keeping the Tsar as a figurehead.
I could see Silent Night being used in an annual remembrance to the War Dead. With O Tannenbaum being the state anthem.
Maybe.

Honestly, as silly as this will seem, THIS song is what I often listen to when trying to get in the mindset to work on this TL. If I could figure out some legitimate lyrics to replace the silly stuff, I'd honestly try and have this song be written to ITTL as an anthem for the Christmas Republic lol :p
 
Forgive me again everyone for resurrecting this thread, but I've actually done some work on this TL and wanted to post it here. I'll also be posting it on my blog if you wish to follow it there.

Silent Night

Prologue: The Truce Begins
It was a cool December evening as Sergeant Thomas Coals climbed out of the main trench and onto the parapet to relieve the previous sentry. He’d have the latest shift, and be out until about 4 in the morning before his shift ended. He glanced out across the grim landscape that was no-man’s land, and across to the German lines beyond. He reached the pervious sentry, Sergeant Lewis McGregor, and relieved him of his post. “Have the Huns been silent?”
“Yes, for the most part, just a little movement, nothing out of the ordinary. Maybe tonight will be totally quiet.”
“Well, I hope so. I don’t like it when my sentry duty isn’t quiet.” Coals said with a grin.
“Ha, no I don’t like it either mate.” McGregor said as he walked down into the trench. “Oh, by the way, Merry Christmas if I don’t see you tomorrow.”
“Thanks Lewis. Merry Christmas to you too.”
It was sometimes hard to remember that the joyous holiday was now upon them, what with all the gloom of war totally surrounding the soldiers of the British Expeditionary Force. So much violence, so much death. Just a month before, the Battle of Ypres, which had raged for nearly 6 long weeks, had finally ended, with over 79,000 good men dead and another 16,000 wounded. This on top of the massive losses at the Marne. In all the BEF had lost over 100,000 men since the war broke out 4 months ago. All hope of a short and glorious war against the German Empire had long since been dashed. The war would now definitely continue into 1915, possibly 1916 if Fortune decided to be stingy. Coals himself just hoped he could make it through this bloody conflict and back to his young wife Sophie, who was expecting their first child.
As Coals looked out across the wasteland that existed between the British and German lines, he began to imagine what his own family would be doing. They’d be all gathered at his childhood home north of London, father in the parlor with his brothers and sisters trimming the tree, his mother and his wife baking some snacks in the kitchen. In a few hours they’d get into the carriage and ride to the near by St. Gregory’s church for the midnight Christmas service. Tomorrow they’d awake to prepare for the big holiday feast with his aunts and uncles and grandparents, and exchange gifts afterwards. How he wished he could be with them tonight. But he was proud to serve his country. Or at least, he had been when he and so many other young men had volunteered to join the army at the outbreak of war. Now though, after living through the horror of Ypres, where the Germans had briefly taken the town before being driven out by the British, and having heard of the horrors of the Marne, he wasn’t so sure. Why were he and his fellow compatriots out here dying on the fields of France?
While the sergeant began to drift in his thoughts, a light of in the distance caught his eye. He immediately glanced about, and notices several brightly lit candles dotting the German trenches. Where the Huns up to something? Fearing that the enemy might be preparing for some sort of sneak attack, Coals hollered out for his superior. “Lieutenant Scott! Lieutenant Scott!” Shouted Coals down into the trenches. Soon, Lieutenant Horatio Scott came up the ladder, calling out, “What is is Sergeant Coals? Are the Germans moving?”
“I don’t rightly know sir. They are lighting lanterns and moving about more than they have the past few nights.” Scott joined Coals on the parapet, and gazed over towards the German trenches. Sure enough, dozens of Candles were dotting this part of the line, in plain view of the British forces. This was most unusual.
“Do you hear that?” asked Scott. Coals listened hard, and sure enough, he did hear something drifting over from the enemy.
“Sounds like they are shouting something in unison sir. But I can’t make out....” the noise was louder now, and Coals could make it out:
”Stille Nacht, heilige Nacht; Alles schlaft, einsam wacht....”
Scott chuckled a bit. “Well, what do you know. The Huns are singing Christmas carols. Maybe the Christmas spirit will make it out to the trenches this year.” Lieutenant Scott smiled, then excused himself. Coals continued his watch, listening first to the Germans sing, and then to his own fellow soldiers in the British trenches. Lt. Scott appeared to be right. The Christmas spirit had made it out to the trenches. Little did Coals, Scott, or any of the British or German soldiers realize that night as the sang carols and shouted “merry Christmas” back and forth, that the next 48 to 72 hours would change the course of the War, and with it, the course of modern history.
-Springer, Thomas. All Silent on the Western Front. London: Macmillan Publishers, 1925.

TO: Imperial Command, Berlin
FROM: Army HQ, Western Front

Commanders in Field are reporting a large scale truce developing spontaneously with enemy forces at multiple locations along the Western Front, believed to be due to the Christmas holiday. Troops are meeting the enemy in “no-mans land” to trade goods and to collect the dead.
Requesting instructions.
-Communique from German Army HQ on the Western Front to the German General Staff in Berlin, 11:25 a.m. December 25, 1914. Deutsch Kaiserlichen Historisches Museum, Berlin.

It feels so strange. We’ve been fighting since the summer ended, and have seen horrible carniage and unimaginable losses in life. And now, peace has overtaken the trenches. My comrades and I went out and traded food with German soldiers. I heard that some men in another unit actually started a football match with some Germans. If you’d told me last week that this would happen I’d have called you a liar. But here it is, solid reality, Brit and Hun being friendly. I’ve even heard that in some areas the French have laid down their arms.
What’s even more remarkable is the talk I’m hearing more and more as the day goes on. Lots of the men, even some officers, are saying things like “if we can stop the fighting today, what’s to keep us from stopping it tomorrow?” I’m shocked. Can they be serious? How can we mere soldiers stop this bloody war. Sure we’ve paused today, but when dawn comes tomorrow, will it not start again?
Diary entry of an unknown British Soldier, December 25, 1914. British National Archives, London.

The War of 1914, also known as the Last Great European War, had the potential to become the bloodiest war in the history of mankind. By the end of 1914, there were upwards of a million dead on the Western Front alone, and that was just from the combined military deaths of the belligerent countries, not counting the civilian losses. Half of those deaths came from the Battle of the Marne alone, where a solid week of fighting chewed through the armies of Britain, France, and Germany right up to the outskirts of Paris. By the time the cold winter of 1914 set in along the trench lines, there was a great frustration with the war and it’s seeming pointlessness and destructiveness. It also seemed like it might never end, at least according to some soldiers who wrote about their experiences afterwards.
Then, almost out of nowhere, the guns fell silent. It was after sunset on December 24. In several locations German troops began to light candles and sing Christmas carols. Their British and French counterparts soon took notice, and began to sing songs of their own. The soldiers could be heard calling out “Happy Christmas,” Frohe Weihnachten,” and “Joyeux Noel” across No-Mans Land to the enemy trenches. The officers on both sides were a little uncomfortable at first, but felt that the men needed the morale boost of the Christmas spirit, so did not reprimand their men.
When dawn broke on Christmas Day 1914, the now apparent “Christmas Truce” was in full swing. German and British officers met under flags of truce to agree to burial details. Then the men began to wander into the desolate landscape that lay between the opposing trenches and began to talk with one another, trading food, souvenirs, even addresses to get in touch after the war ended. As the day wore on, several Christmas services were held, some of them joint services with British and German soldiers in attendance. In some places, friendly games of football broke out, with the opposing armies facing each other in peaceful competition. One observer reportedly said, “Too bad we couldn’t just decide the war with a football match.”
What few could have predicted as this impromptu peace broke out was what kind of affect it would have on the men. And not just the foot soldiers, but the officers as well. They began to ask one another, “why must this war continue?” “why are we fighting in the first place?” and “how many more of my comrades must die before the people in high places are satisfied?” In addition, they fraternization with the enemy essentially shattered the myth that government propaganda had been feeding the soldiers for months, that the men on the other side of the trenches were not really the boogymen that they’d been led to believe they were. In several different places on the line, these questions and new discoveries began to take root, and many began to contemplate more than just idle thoughts but tangible actions. And it is because of these men that the Christmas Truce of 1914 forever altered human events.
Franklin, Dr. David. Peace on Earth: Christmas 1914. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1975.

TO: British High Command, London
FROM: BEF Command Post, France

We are getting scattered reports from several key positions on the front line that our soldiers, many of whom participated in yesterday’s spontaneous and unsanctioned cease fire with the enemy in marking the Christmas holiday, are refusing to fight. Offices are involved. Need direction as to how to proceed. Afraid that ordering loyal troops to fire on those refusing to fight might cause more men to mutiny. No violence has been reported. We believe that this may be occurring in some places amongst the enemy troops as well.
-Communique from British Expeditionary Force HQ on the Western Front to the British General Staff in London, 9:30 a.m. December 26, 1914. British National Archives, London.

December 26, 1914- I’m still in shock at the news coming in from Field Marshal French and the BEF. It seems as though more than 20,000 of His Majesty’s troops have refused to pick up their weapons and fight in light of yesterday’s reported truce. TWENTY THOUSAND! And from the reports it seems as though this is occurring with the French and maybe even the German troops up and down the line. The cabinet isn’t sure what to do, and neither is the King. Protocol dictates action against these mutineers, possibly even firing on them. But there are so many. And I fear that ordering our loyal troops to fire on those refusing to fight could backfire greatly. We are going to meet again tomorrow. I pray God grant myself and my fellow leaders some way to resolve the crisis.
- From the personal papers of Herbert Henry Asquith, former Prime Minister of Great Britain (1908-1915). British National Archives, London.

Enjoy!
 
Part 1: From Holiday Truce to Mutiny

WAR IN EUROPE HALTED BY CHRISTMAS, TRUCE LINGERING​
LONDON, DEC 26- Although the British Government has yet to say anything officially, there are confirmed reports that the fighting on the Western Front of the current European War has stopped. There are not a lot of details as of yet, but it appears that an informal truce broke out in the trenches in western France on Christmas Day, and it now appears that some soldiers, not only from Britain but France and Germany as well, have refused to reengage in the fighting. There has not been any official statement about this latest war development, and it would appear that the government is attempting to keep word from leaking out. Not a single paper here in the British capital has reported any news of the truce. That fact that fighting halted in light of the Christmas holiday in and of itself seems to be a miracle. That soldiers are now possibly wanting peace to continue is hardly fathomable. There is something that warms the heart, however, at the idea that the “Spirit of Christmas” seems to have the power to stop the fighting, even if only for a moment. Maybe it is a sign of things to come.
EDITORS NOTE: this article was written originally with the intent to be run on the day after Christmas, but agents of the British government attempted to stop it from being sent by wire until our correspondents there complained to the American Embassy in London.
-”War in Europe Halted By Christmas, Truce Lingering,” The New York Times, December 27, 1914.

When Prime Minister Asquith and his government met on December 27, 1914, they were not in a good mood. They’d hoped that over night the mutinying soldiers would come to their senses and return to their posts, and had given instructions to the BEF commanders to allow them to do so. Instead, the number of those refusing to take up arms had doubled to nearly 50,000, and it was rumored that the officers among that number were conspiring with their enemy counterparts that were also refusing to fight. Conspiring to do what, they didn’t yet know. But the idea frightened them. What frightened them worse was that they didn’t know what to do about it. They couldn’t very well just let the troops refuse to fight. But with that number, they could fight back. And what would the loyal troops do if ordered to fire on their comrades? Ultimately, Asquith decided he and his government could decide nothing without the King. In a meeting with King George V later that evening, a decision was made. If the mutineers did not return to their posts by sunrise on December 29, loyal troops would go in and arrest them, and be authorized to use lethal force if necessary. The decision would come back to haunt the men within days.
-Franklin, Dr. David. Peace on Earth: Christmas 1914. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1975.

"On this day when we remember the slaughter of innocent young children whose only crime was to be present in Bethlehem when Herod's soldiers came, we remember with sadness that many innocent people both in uniform and out of it have been killed in this terrible war. Just as Herod's murder of these young innocents served no useful purpose other then to assauge the political desires of an evil king to remain in power, so this war has served no purpose other then to further the political and economic goals of a few people. It is time for peace. It is time for Christians who truly understand what it is to be peacemakers to speak. "Blessed are the peacemakers for theirs is the Kingdom of Heaven." This was spoken by the One whose Nativity we just celebrated and on whose day this glorious movement of peace began. We call upon all the faithful throughout the world to offer their prayers and support to these brave men who are now seeking to be peacemakers and we call on the whole Church to stand with them in this hour."
-From Pope Benedict XV’s message on the Feast of Holy Innocents, December 28, 1914. Vatican Archives, Vatican City.

WAR HALTED BY COMMON SOLDIERS! GOV’T REMAINS SILENT​
LONDON, DEC 28 - We have now confirmed that upwards of 50,000 troops, possibly more, of His Majesty’s Armed Forces have refused to resume fighting on the Western Front in France after an impromptu truce broke out on the 25th in observance of the Christmas holiday. Reports state that soldiers from the British, German, and French armies hoisted white flags and met one another between the two opposing trench lines to trade food, burry the dead, hold Christmas services, and even to play football. It appears that the following day, many of the troops refused to go back to their posts, and that this number has been increasing in the few days since the truce started, and it appears that soldiers in the French and German armies are also refusing to return to their posts. As of yet, the government has made no official statement about the developing situation in France, and it would appear that there was a concerted effort on behalf of the Asquith government to prevent word of this “Christmas Truce” from making it to press. An unnamed official at the War Office stated that it was the hope of the government that the Truce would just go away on it’s own before it was reported in the press.
-”War Halted By Common Soldiers! Gov’t Remains Silent,” The Times (London), December 29, 1914.

FIGHT HALTS ON FRONT IN THE WEST​
BERLIN, DEC 28- The Imperial government has confirmed that a Truce broke out on Christmas Day on the Western Front in France between the armed forces of the Reich and that of Great Britain and France. This truce was not sanctioned by the General Staff or the Kaiser. Instead it seems to have been started spontaneously by the foot-soldiers. There has been some rumor of socialists being involved, but this has yet to be substantiated. What is most disturbing is that there have been unconfirmed rumors circulating in some circles that this “Christmas Truce” has not ended yet, that there are some soldiers refusing to reengage the enemy now that Christmas has passed. We do not at this time know just how many are involved or if this is also occurring on the enemy side of the trenches, and all requests for more information from officials at the Palace have been ignored.
-”Fight Halts on Front in the West,” Frankfurter Zeitung, December 29, 1914.

When dawn broke on December 29, the number of British troops alone now refusing to fight numbers over 80,000. Field Marshal French ordered troops loyal to the army to head to mutinying areas and begin to arrest those refusing to return to their posts. When they arrived, the men they were supposed to arrest greeted them with guns raised, saying that they were not going to return to the fighting. Some called out for the loyal troops to join the “Christmas Army,” as the men had started to call themselves. After several tense moments, one of the loyal officers ordered his men to open fire. A few did, and some of the mutineers were injured, but what happened next was the worst fears of those sitting in London. The loyal troops turned on the officer who’d ordered them to fire. And some of the other officers joined their men. What was supposed to have been an arrest soon backfired. When word began to spread through the ranks that the higher-ups had ordered troops to fire on their fellow troops, things began to unravel. By the end of the 29th, mutinying troops numbered over 100,000, and this number nearly doubles by the end of the next day, and by then the officers in the mutinying forces from all three armies were organizing what would become the official Christmas Army and later the Christmas Republic. And public response to the shootings would be just as violent.
-Franklin, Dr. David. Peace on Earth: Christmas 1914. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1975.

December 29- We’ve gone and blown it. We should never have ordered the troops to fire on the mutineers. From the reports that keep flooding in from the War Office, things are now unravelling pretty quickly. The loyal troops don’t like the idea that they might be ordered to shoot on the mutineers. This is the last thing we needed. And now there are confirmed reports that the mutinying officers are meeting with their counterparts from France and Germany to organize this little rebellion. And the public is likely to learn of this soon and I fear what their reaction will be. In the morning we intend to rescind the authorization to use lethal force, but I think it may be too late.
-From the personal papers of Herbert Henry Asquith, former Prime Minister of Great Britain (1908-1915). British National Archives, London.

POPE’S CALL TO ACTION STIRRING UNREST
NEW YORK, DEC 29 - In many Catholic neighborhoods in this city, the word’s of Pope Benedict XV’s message yesterday on the Feast of the Innocents, which commemorates the babies killed at King Harrod’s command in the biblical Christmas story, has caused quite a stir. There have been discussions to form a march in Manhattan to call attention to the Christmas Truce and Mutinies that have occurred on the Western Front in France, and to call for American support for the mutineers. And this idea isn’t just popular among Catholics. Minister’s everywhere have been heartened by the news that the Christmas holiday has caused the soldiers on the front lines to try and bring about peace. And it isn’t just the public at large that are starting to speak out. Some members of Congress have spoken out in favor of sending aid to the mutineers, and still others saying that the United States should offer to broker a peace deal between the warring states in Europe.
-”Pope’s Call to Action Stirring Unrest,” The New York Times, December 30, 1914.

SHAME! TROOPS ORDERED TO FIRE ON “TRUCE FIGHTERS”!
LONDON, DEC 30 - It has been confirmed that troops that remained loyal to the Crown were ordered to fire upon those troops who’ve refused to return to their posts. The government apparently set a deadline for sunrise on the 29th for all troops to return without facing punishment. Shortly before noon on that day, loyal troops were sent out to arrest the Truce Fighters, which at the time was estimated to number around 75,000 of His Majesty’s troops. The Truce Fighters refused to surrender, and an unknown officer acted on orders coming ultimately from, shockingly, King George V, ordered the loyal troops to open fire. Most did not, but instead turned against their commander. As word of this travesty has spread through the troops in France, more and more have joined the Truce Fighters, and it is now estimated that over 150,000 British troops now count themselves among the Fighters. Things seem to be on the edge of unravelling. If the government does not act quickly to quell the crisis, there may be a vote of no confidence in Parliament.
-”Shame! Troops Ordered to Fire on “Truce Fighters!,” The Times (London), December 31, 1914.

Okay, here's the next update :)
 
Here is a rough basic outline that I'm looking at using for this TL:


Any other ideas or critiques are of course also welcome.

I liked this, but the notion that everyone makes peace but Germany still gives up A-L is silly. Germany believed it was rightfully theirs as much as the French did, and back then, there wasn't any clear answer to whose claim was better. We got that drilled into our brains because the Entente won.

A real 14 or 15 Christmas truce peace would have absolutely been status quo ante bellum, not "Germany loses but we call it white peace". There's no way that that would fly, especially given the map of war favored the CP at the time. I'll still read the rest, though, I'm still on page 1, but had to offer this comment.
 
I liked this, but the notion that everyone makes peace but Germany still gives up A-L is silly. Germany believed it was rightfully theirs as much as the French did, and back then, there wasn't any clear answer to whose claim was better. We got that drilled into our brains because the Entente won.

A real 14 or 15 Christmas truce peace would have absolutely been status quo ante bellum, not "Germany loses but we call it white peace". There's no way that that would fly, especially given the map of war favored the CP at the time. I'll still read the rest, though, I'm still on page 1, but had to offer this comment.

Hey thanks for reading and for your input!

The idea for making A-L independent in the peace was thought up as a means for taking the main territorial dispute between France and Germany away, and making it the seat of the new peace movement. I'll admit it's not the most likely scenario, and for the reasons you listed. But I don't think it's 100% impossible though. There was actually a failed attempt in 1918 as the war ended to set the region up as independent from what I've read, but that fell apart and didn't have outside support.

Hope you've enjoyed everything overall though. :)
 
And here's the new update that I just put up on my blog as well.

Part 2: From Mutiny to Revolution and Peace

Anti-War Riots Rock London!​
LONDON, DECEMBER 31- In response to the attack on British Truce Fighters by loyalist troops, thousands upon thousands of angry Londoners took to the streets of the British capital today to protest the actions of the government. In most quarters of the city, the police simply stayed out of the way, concentrating their presence around Buckingham Palace and around the Houses of Parliament, which seemed to be the target of the marches. The crowds were calling for, among other things, the resignation of Prime Minister Asquith, for his part in the orders to fire on the Truce Fighters who refused to surrender on December 29th. Since that act, things have been unraveling on the Front, and it is now estimated that close to 180,000 British soldiers have taken up the so-called “Truce Banner,” a white flag that often has a Christmas tree in the center, and are refusing to reengage the enemy army. All told, between German and French and British troops, it is estimated somewhere between four and five hundred thousand men now are refusing to fight on the Western Front. This unprecedented event has left leaders in London and Paris stunned, unable to find a proper course of action.
-”Anti-War Riots Rock London!” The New York Times, January 1, 1915.

The New Years Peace Riots of 1915 are often considered the tipping point in the Christmas Truce Movement. Over the course of New Years Eve 1914 and New Years Day 1915, the cities of London, Paris, and Berlin were all paralyzed with angry mobs demanding an end to the war. In addition, there were organized protests in New York and Washington D.C., calling on the American government to try and help the peace process. Some of the strength and legitimacy for these riots can be attributed by the outspokenness of Pope Benedict XV, who cried out against the attacks the British made on their own troops on the 29th of December, and announced on the 30th that he would be more than willing to host a peace conference in Rome.
The situation in Paris was especially volatile. The French government had managed to keep news of the Truce out of the press for days, but the story finally broke on December 31st, and the people were outraged that the government had kept them in the dark, and support for the Truce exploded across the city. The police refused to combat the riots in most parts of the city. Jean Juares and the French Socialists were the most vocal about their anger towards the government and their support of the Truce. On New Years day, after they learned of the Truce, Juares and the French Socialists call for a nationwide general strike to show solidarity with the soldiers of the “Christmas Revolution.” Within days, much of France is paralyzed, especially in Paris.
-Franklin, Dr. David. Peace on Earth: Christmas 1914. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1975.

TRUCE FIGHTERS ORGANIZE​
PARIS, JAN 1 - The official word circulating the French capital is that the officers taking part in the Christmas Truce have organized into what is supposedly being called the “Army of the Christmas Republic.” Several riders entered the city and were escorted by the so-called “Red Guard of Freedom” (or GRL), a socialist paramilitary group that seems to have replaced the police in the French capital every since word of the Truce broke here on New Years Eve, and were taken to the French government to supposedly present terms from the leaders of this “Christmas Army.” From what we have been able to gather and confirm, it appears that the army officers from the French, British, and German armies met at Rheims over December 30 and 31 and have established preliminary organization to their forces that now number over 200,000. In addition, the leaders meeting at Rheims also have apparently established what they call the “Christmas Republic,” which is being led by 3 men, one from each nation, who style themselves as “Consuls of the Republic.”
Not much else is know about this so-called Christmas Army, and we are just now beginning to piece together their intentions. From sources inside the French government, it is believed that the Three Consuls have demanded that France, Germany, and Great Britain immediately declare a ceasefire, and then agree to meet to work out a formal peace agreement.We are not sure if that is all they are calling for, or what they plan to do if their demands are not met.
- “Truce Fighters Organize,” The Times (London), January 2, 1915.

“Under no circumstances will the government of France meet with these traitors, nor will we give into their demands. By order of the Government, all French soldiers participating in this mutiny are to surrender by noon on January 3, 1915. At 1:00 in the afternoon all French forces are to engage all mutinying troops as if they were the enemy.”
-Order Issued by President Raymond Poincare and the French Government, January 2, 1915. Musee de la Revolution, Paris, PRF.

The January 2nd Order, as it is commonly known, spurred the Christmas Army into action. They knew that the British, despite earlier failures, were considering trying a more forceful action against the mutinying forces, as were the Germans. With the French giving a new ultimatum first, the Truce Fighters had to act, and quickly. The Consuls of the so-called Christmas Republic met and decided that an army of up to 90,000 men should be dispatched towards Paris to force the issue of a cease fire with the French. at the same time, action was needed against the Germans. The French member of the Consulate, Charles Dumont, would lead an army of 80,000 mostly French troops (augmented by British soldiers) to march on Paris. Then the rest of the Christmas Army, under the leadership of Consul Henry Martin of Great Britain and Consul Friedrich Bauer of Germany would march into Germany, initially with the aim of occupying Frankfurt am Main.
The Paris Army marched out from Rheims at approximately 11:00 a.m. on January 3, 1915, first encountering loyal French troops just before noon. They mostly dispersed, being outnumbered, and some actually joined the ranks of the Christmas Army. The First and only real battle of the Christmas Truce Movement would occur on January 4, 1915 near the town of Barcy.
-Franklin, Dr. David. Peace on Earth: Christmas 1914. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1975.

FRENCH BATTLE CHRISTMAS ARMY!​
PARIS, JAN 4 - The French Army has put up a major defensive line at the town of Barcy, East of Paris, in an attempt to stop the advancing Christmas Army troops that are marching on the French capital. It is believed that this branch of the Christmas Army, being led by Frenchman Charles Dumont, has some 80,000 French and British troops that intend to force the French government to agree to a cease fire. This move has sent shockwaves through Paris, where the French Socialists, led by agitator Jean Jaures, has taken total control over parts of the city and are calling for the resignation of President Poincare and the entire government, and for the nation to embrace a ceasefire with Germany at once. So far, it appears that the French Army have stalled the advance of what they refer to simply as “the mutineers,” but have sustained heavy losses. In addition, there are reports that many men are running over and joining the forces of the Christmas Army. If the Truce Fighters break through and make it to Paris, which isn’t an impossibility by any stretch of the imagination, it is possible that the civilian rioters could overthrow the government, sending France to even more chaos.
-”French Battle Christmas Army!” The New York Times, January 5, 1914.

PRESIDENT WILSON: WAR IN EUROPE MUST END​
WASHINGTON, JAN 5 - After days of speculation in the capital, President Wilson has spoken out about the impromptu truce that has thrown the continent of Europe into disarray. Since Americans have learned of the “Christmas Truce,” there have been dozens of rallies across the country calling for support of the Truce Fighters and their cause. Ministers of every creed have said that it was a sign from God to end the fighting. This was of course bolstered by the Pope’s own declaration of support for the Truce on December 28. On New Years Eve, there was a massive rally in New York City calling for American support of the Truce. Many of those demonstrators were waving around the so-called “Christmas Flag,” a white banner with a green Christmas Tree in the center, a variation of what the Truce Fighters are now using. And in response to French action, there was another large march in the nation’s capital yesterday rallying for peace.
In light of all of this, President Wilson came before members of the press and announced that, “This war has already seen nearly one million lives lost, and for what? For national pride? for a few hundred acres of land? I do not think the gains outweigh the cost in this war. And America can no longer remain silent. I call on the belligerent nations of Europe to put down the sword of war, and come to the peace table to negotiate and end hostilities. This war in Europe must end. As President of the United States, I offer these warring states our services as mediators to help end this conflict. In addition, I am now asking the members of Congress to act quickly to make American aide to the Christmas Fighters in any way possible. Along with all of this, I have directed Secretary of State Bryan to travel to Europe to meet with the leaders of this “Christmas Republic,” and to meet with European leaders to help speed up the peace process.”
-”President Wilson: War in Europe Must End.” The Washington Post, January 6, 1915.

With America lending its support to the Christmas Army on January 5, and the planned economic sanctions that the leaders of Congress were preparing, the days of the War of 1914 were numbered. What became the death blow to any serious plans of continuing the war happened on January 7, 1915. That morning, the Christmas Army, fresh from victory over the French at Barcy, arrived in Paris. The pre-revolutionary mood that had gripped the city since the first of January exploded into outright Revolt. the Red Guard seized control of the government quarter and kept the government under guard as the Truce Fighters, led by Consul Dumont, was escorted into the city, greeted mostly as heros. In many places, Parisians waved the Christmas Banner and cheered the soldiers as the occupied key areas of the city. At noon, Consul Dumont and his staff met with President Poincare and head of the Socialists, Jean Juares. About an hour and a half later, church bells rang out across the city, as it was announced that Poincare and his ministers had signed official orders declaring a cease fire for the French Army. The following morning, Juares announced that President Poincare had dissolved the government, and then went on to declare the birth of the People’s Socialist Republic of France. Juares and his fellow socialists leaders who would, in the coming days, work to pacify Paris and try to stabilize the country in the face of radical nationalist opposition groups led by men like George Clemenceau, in addition to confirming their commitment to the Christmas Peace and the terms agreed to by President Poincare.
-Franklin, Dr. David. Peace on Earth: Christmas 1914. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1975.

PEACE! KAISER DECLARES CEASE-FIRE!​
BERLIN, JAN 9, 1915 - In light of the turn of events in France, which saw rebel fighters belonging to the Truce Army arrive in Paris and destabilize the government in that country and lead to a socialist revolution, the Kaiser has agreed to declare a general cease-fire on both the Western Front and the Eastern Front, effective at 10:00 a.m. on January 10th. Foreign Minister Gottlieb von Jagow has been in contact with London, and the British government has agreed to issue an official cease-fire at the same time, bringing the current war to a possibly permanent close. However, even though the war is ending, all is not stable or peaceful. Socialist agitation in the capital and in numerous other cities continues, and is believed to be why the Kaiser agreed to a cease-fire, to avoid a repeat of what occurred in France. In addition, there are over 150,000 German soldiers currently aligned with with the Christmas Truce Army, technically committing treason and desertion. A good portion of that Army is also on the march within Imperial territory, believed to have been originally bound for Frankfurt, although now it appears to have shifted course to the south, possibly to Strasbourg, capital of Elsass-Lothringen, the territory that France has refused to recognize belongs to the German Empire since the Franco-Prussian War. There is some speculation that the Christmas Army and it’s so-called Republic wish to occupy this territory and call for it to be independent, neither part of Germany nor France.
- “Peace! Kaiser Declares Cease-Fire!” Frankfurter Zeitung, January 10, 1915.
 
Thank you! Glad you like it as well.

The next few updates will be fairly easy to get out. Basically going to work out the peace negotiations that end the war and immediate aftermath in that regards. What happens past that.....pretty wide open.

Someone last year suggested going with some sort of "peace-wank," and while I don't think I'll go quite that far, it may not be far off the mark. With this amazing example of what the common soldier can accomplish, leaders will fear wielding large armies in costly wars, afraid of a repeat of 1914. I'm also thinking we will see some sort of development along these lines in several countries.

There are all sorts of other possible butterflies. One thing I am considering is that, due to his support of the shooting of mutineers, there could be a strong movement for King George V to abdicate. If he does, that places the very young Edward, Prince of Wales on the thrown at age 20. Just for an interesting twist.

That's just some of what I'm considering. Any input is always welcome. :)
 
Top