Doctors hold line, earlier knowledge of CTE, what if American football becomes 18+ in late 1960s?

GeographyDude

Gone Fishin'
Texas Jai-Alai

http://www.jai-alai.info/texas-jai-alai.html

‘ . . . The Lone Star State constructed a fronton for the world's fastest ballgame with a capacity for 12,000 spectators. It will serve to reactivate this Basque sport in Texas, and is seen to employ about 45 pelotaris. Texas Jai-alai opened in 2009. . . ’
As sports become bigger in the ‘70s and ‘80s, jai-alai might be an example of one of these “new,” expanding sports, and not just in Miami!
 
Last edited:

GeographyDude

Gone Fishin'
Last edited:

GeographyDude

Gone Fishin'
. . . and a mother’s long goodbye to youth football

Washington Post, Julie DiCaro, Sept. 12, 2017

https://www.washingtonpost.com/news...ootball/?noredirect=on&utm_term=.7a15eaf4a533

' . . . [Chris] Nowinski’s takeaway is hard to miss: It’s not the concussions that cause CTE, but thousands of blows that don’t result in concussions. “The odds that in a lifetime of 20,000 impacts, five of them are the difference makers … doesn’t make a whole lot of sense given what we know about brain trauma,” he points out.

'Luckily, both my sons stopped playing football of their own accord. I didn’t have to make the choice for them, didn’t have to be the bad guy keeping them from their friends and their favorite sport. I do, however, know lots of parents who refuse to make that very difficult decision for their children. “My son has never had a concussion,” mom after mom has told me, by way of explaining the decision to let her child play football. “Anyway, my husband played through college and he’s never had any problems.” “All his friends play.” “The league requires all the coaches to go through concussion training.” The justifications are numerous. . . '
I think this mom hits it right and explains why parents make different decisions. If parents focus on concussion management, then they might well think there are ways to make football safe. If instead, they focus on the large number of subconcussive hits, then no way, it's time to move on to other sports.
 
Last edited:
I think this mom hits it right and explains why parents make different decisions. If parents focus on concussion management, then they might well think there are ways to make football safe. If instead, they focus on the large number of subconcussive hits, then no way, it's time to move on to other sports.
Wonder why so much fear concussion, i would fear more got a paralysis by a bad hit.
 

GeographyDude

Gone Fishin'
The Big Book of Baseball Brainteasers
Wayne Stewart, Dom Forker, Robert Obojski, 1991, 1999.

https://books.google.com/books?id=e...ost office during the holiday period"&f=false

' . . . During the 1940s and 1950s, . . . '

' . . . Duke Snider, Brooklyn Dodgers outfielder, carried mail from the Brooklyn post office during the holiday period; Stan Musial, St. Louis Cardinals outfielder/first baseman, worked as a clerk in his father-in-law's grocery store in Donora, Pennsylvania; Phil Rizzuto, New York Yankees shortstop, worked as a salesman in a New York men's clothing store; . . . '
This book goes on to say that TV is what brought the big money into baseball.

PS and presumably for football somewhat later
 
Last edited:

GeographyDude

Gone Fishin'
Wonder why so much fear concussion, i would fear more got a paralysis by a bad hit.
I think people just get it wrong, like they can get other health issues wrong.

Alright, there is post-concussion syndrome (relatively common), as well as second impact syndrome (rare), and these are real and valid things to worry about. And plus, focusing on concussion involves a lot of active steps, such as training coaches, preventing some concussions, managing others (I was surprised to find out that both physical and cognitive rest are recommended, meaning less screen time with cell phones and computers during recovery and perhaps half-days at school for a while).

However, with CTE and brain damage, it looks like concussions are merely one contributing factor, and the major contributing factor is the accumulation of all the subconcussive hits. Which basically means, that if you're a teacher, coach, or administrator concerned with the health and safety of your students, including the young adults in high school, pretty much the only thing you can do is to gracefully phase out football. And then try to introduce and experiment with other sports and other seasons.
 
Last edited:

GeographyDude

Gone Fishin'


A safer game doesn't mean a boring game.

Currently: Almost every contested pass play is real close in terms of offensive or defensive pass interference.
 

GeographyDude

Gone Fishin'
GIMP-arcanum-ansonia-7-on-7.jpg


Future Possibility: The game takes out full-frontal collisions, but allows side-by-side scrapping.
 
Last edited:

GeographyDude

Gone Fishin'


Not just linebackers, but there's been some discussion of mandating the two-point stance for the offensive and defensive line. And thus . . .

Future Possibility: More scrapping on the line, less full-frontal collisions?


-------------------------------------------



Even de-emphasizing the role of the head in attack and defense, there's still going to be a fair amount of repeated head trauma.

The game remains 18+.
 
Last edited:

GeographyDude

Gone Fishin'
Superbowl III Jan. 12, 1969 Orange Bowl (in Miami), New York Jets 16, Baltimore Colts 7
Several days before the game, Joe Namath says, “We’re going to win Sunday. I guarantee it.” And then, completely unexpectedly, the Jets pull it off!
Superbowl IV dud

Superbowl V Jan. 17, 1971 Orange Bowl (in Miami), Baltimore Colts 16, Dallas Cowboys 13
with Jim O'Brien kicking last-second winning field goal​

Superbowl VI dud

Superbowl VII dud

Superbowl VIII dud

Superbowl IX dud


Superbowl X Jan. 18, 1976 Orange Bowl (in Miami), Pittsburgh Steelers 21, Dallas Cowboys 17
with Lynn Swann making four separate really good and/or spectacular catches
Superbowl XI dud


-------------------------------------------

Unless you were a fan of the winning team, a lot of the early and mid '70s Superbowls were duds.
 
Last edited:

GeographyDude

Gone Fishin'
490x_med.jpeg


Bottom of the 12th! The classic game six of the 1975 World Series between the Boston Red Sox and the Cincinnati Reds. Carlton Fisk's homer won it for Boston.

However, the Cincinnati Reds would go on to win game seven by a score of 4-3.
 
Last edited:

GeographyDude

Gone Fishin'
  • images-1.jpeg
April 1, 1970
Robertson v. National Basketball Association

https://www.timetoast.com/timelines/aba-and-nba-merger
  • ' . . the NBA Players Association, lead by Oscar Robertson, filed a lawsuit against the league in order to prevent a merger of the leagues to happen. The players saw the two leagues as competing businesses, which also meant that the player's values were much more valubale when the two leagues had to struggle to keep their players. The lawsuit was eventually settled in 1976 and served as an obstacle for the leagues. . '
So, all through the early and mid '70s, two professional basketball leagues.
 

GeographyDude

Gone Fishin'
DallasScoreboard.JPG

Sept. 21, 1971
First Interleague Game is Played

https://www.timetoast.com/timelines/aba-and-nba-merger
'The first exhibition game between private teams from the ABA and NBA is played between the Milwaukee Bucks and the Dallas Chaparrals. The Bucks, lead by Kareem Abdul-Jabbar, narrowly defeated the Chaparrals 106-103. Throughout the following seasons, the ABA tended to win more games than the NBA did, posting a 31-17 record in 1975 in interleague play.'
In OTL, basketball has arguably exceeded baseball, and is now second only to football.

In an ATL with football on the decline, perhaps it's the case that both basketball has its big growth years earlier and baseball finds a way to give it a run for its money.
 
Last edited:
In this ATL, Aussie Rules may have more participants in the US than back home in Australia.

Australian Rules Football got it's serious start in the USA in the late 1960s in Detroit when a small suburban junior competition was put together by a group of Big-3 auto executives & engineers who had previously been sent by their employers to work in Melbourne or Adelaide (Ford & GM/Holden have their Australian HQs in Melbourne, Chrysler had their HQ & main plant in Adelaide). Their children had played in suburban junior competitions during their time in Australia, and they & their families had grown to love the game, and the club atmosphere. When American football participation was restricted for those under 18, this lead to the creation of a small junior competition in the Detroit suburbs. The organizers were assisted by quite a few Australians who were on secondment to their corporate HQs, some of whom had played the game at the highest levels in the VFL & the SANFL (OTL, Aussie Rules was state-based up to the late 80's. The VFL would become the AFL in 1990. It was also mainly semi-professional until the early 90's. Up to then, most players worked a day job Monday-Friday & most games were played on Saturday afternoons.).

As the small suburban competition gathered momentum during the late 60's-early 70's, those Australians in Detroit who were assisting with coaching teams, or helping in administration, sought assistance from the VFL back in Melbourne, and those who were former players also received donations of uniforms & equipment from their former clubs in Melbourne & Adelaide. The VFL, realising they had a golden opportunity to promote & expand the participation & support of Australian football in the US, set up their first overseas office in Detroit in 1971. This lead to the setting up of similar competitions in New York, Boston & Los Angeles by the end of 1974. By 1980, there was a Australian Rules league in 20 states. The massive levels of US participation by Australian standards, lead to the VFL announcing that the 1976 season would be the first to have a weekly Sunday game, to allow this to be shown live on US television on Saturday nights as well as the Saturday game of the round shown live on Friday nights US time.

By 1985, the USFL had started with 10 teams (Detroit Demons, Boston Blues, Milwaukee Magpies, Cleveland Cats, New York Bulldogs, Louisville Lions, LA Stars, San Francisco Swans, Denver Cougars & Dallas Bigshots)

From "Australian Rules - How it conquered the US"
2010, Melbourne University Press
 
Top