Albania as Islamic State?

How, with a POD after the slicing of Albania from the Ottomon Empire in 1912, could Albania have become a state governed along Islamic religious lines? It doesn't have to be the Taliban, by any means, but I mean a much more religious government with clerics playing a role in government, a conservative Islamic society, and the implementation of Sharia law.

Bonus points if it's also a democracy.
 
If it had become a Islamic state it would just have been invaded by it's neighbors. No one could have tolerated such barbarism in Europe at the time.
 
You have the grounds for it in Albania, the last tribal society in Europe (discounting Scottish football). Then again Islamist Republics have a tendency to arise, much like Bolshevism, in the place wouldn't assume. I doubt Afghanistan would have gone the Taliban route without Soviet intervention both as a catalyst for militancy and setting up the bureaucratic framework. Iran is the perfect analogue to Communism in un-industruial states in that it was without a doubt the most western, secular Muslim country on earth, including Pakistan, indeed ironically it still is very secular, with Islam more a political than theological force there. Even Libya, its Islamism is/was mixed in with Arab Socialist doctrine, in an urban coastal society, used to Westen culture and then forced on the interior.

Any POD you're looking to?

Without major timeline change, I cant see a chance for an Islamist Albania before 1990 onwards and then without the USSR, the Yugoslav wars would be a precedent for NATO/UN/EU to stamp down on such extremists.

Actually depending on what you want, Hoxha might be your man. He was a stern Marxist but frankly if his power was threatened I can see him pulling a Saddam and pulling faith into his secular dictatorship for strength. Say post-Tito, Yugoslavia decides to pressure Albania by now abandoned by both the USSR and non-Maoist China, in attempt to flex muscle, unite the nation against a frankly evil enemy (mellowed parallels between Doi Moi Vietnam and Khmer Rouge Cambodia are welcome).

No invasion because the Warsaw Pact would step simply to retain a balance of power before the Yanks did, simply Belgrade sabre-rattling for some short-term "look over there" problem hiding propaganda.

However, after envoking Islam for his benefit, there's no way Hoxha or more accurately Albania could ignore it, particularly as its been raised in a nationalist tone. Horrible images of a far worse Kosovo are flashing in my mind. Post-USSR, and post-Hoxha, I can see an Istan style corrupt pseudo-Soviet dictatorship rising, however relying on Islam as a way to keep Albanians isolated and feel threatened by the Christian west. Let this build, come Milosevic and Kosovo this could boil over into an Islamic Albanian Republic being formed, no doubt for pragmatic reasons, but it wouldn't take long for a shrewd cleric to push things further or take total control. Picture grandiose plans of uniting the Balkans Muslim population and you have a Balkan War and Genocide in one.
 
I would say an early POD would be needed. You can't really have it happen after '45 with the Soviets and Tito in the picture, and the 90s are a bad atmosphere fopr an Islamic Republic with everyone thinking of Iran and Saudi Arabia.

A role for the clergy in the constitution would not be unusual for the pre-WWI setting. It is kind of expected. There were already established academic institutes of Islamic law in the area (I'm not sure whether Albania had one, but the one in Sarajevo goes back to the 1880s) and received wisdom held that a degree in theology was as respectable as any 'proper' one (not the funny ones like engineering). A post-WWI Republic, too, could also make provisions like that. At that point, you're already looking at a strong Communist and Socialisat influence in the area, so how about a nationalist hard-right Islamist movement, like the Slovaks, Hungarians and Croats had Catholic-style?
 
I was actually thinking in terms of the pre-World War II era; I imagined communist influence afterwards would be too strong. A Zog-like figure who uses Islamic symbols and rhetoric to strengthen his hold on power. Or an Islamic equivalent to Fan Noli.

But I like carlton_bach's idea of a nationalist, hard-right Islamist movement, possibly with strong ideological ties to fascism. It could be a movement supported by Mussolini, to strengthen his influence over the country.
 
I was actually thinking in terms of the pre-World War II era; I imagined communist influence afterwards would be too strong. A Zog-like figure who uses Islamic symbols and rhetoric to strengthen his hold on power. Or an Islamic equivalent to Fan Noli.

But I like carlton_bach's idea of a nationalist, hard-right Islamist movement, possibly with strong ideological ties to fascism. It could be a movement supported by Mussolini, to strengthen his influence over the country.

The Greeks, the Yugoslavs and the Italians could all see the quest to "save Europe from oriental barbarism" as an excuse to invade Albania.
 
The Greeks, the Yugoslavs and the Italians could all see the quest to "save Europe from oriental barbarism" as an excuse to invade Albania.

In the 1920s, they weren't exactly in any shape to do that. And it isn't like Italy needed the excuse to invade when it eventually did. The whole 'oriental barbarism' thing is convenient, but much of the Balkans were under the rule of an Islamic state until the late 19th century and everybody in Europe could live with it just fine whenever they didn't need a casus belli.
 
Barbarism ?

Give me that weed yer smokin'

Of course that would only be the language Albania's neighbors would use to launch an attack. Don't forget the Serbs and Greeks already considered Albania an unlawful nation as it was IRL, with an ideology praising an unchristian religion they would have all excuses they'd need to invade. Sure the Yugos and Greeks were not prepared for a major war, but it's Albania we're talking about. Neither were they, and they're much smaller.
 

ninebucks

Banned
Its not going to happen any time prior to 1960s/70s, before then, the idea of an 'Islamic State' just wasn't very popular. Islam globally went through a very secular phase in the early 20th Century.

In fact, its probably just impossible. The Albanians identify with Islam but very few of them take it seriously, most Albanians believe in an assortment of minor heresies and unorthoxies - a theocratic government that extolled one exclusivist religious philosophy over an other wouldn't win much popular support.

Also, there's the fact that Albania is the least religious country in Europe. Yes, some of that is due to the forced Atheism of Hoxha's reign, but unlike over formerly Atheist nations, the Albanians haven't rushed back to organised religion when the liberty to do so has presented itself, which leads me to believe that there's something more fundamental in their culture which would make this untenable.
 
Top