FOR WANT OF THE HAMMER
ROMA ET ITALIA PART 10, 648 AVC
“...and truly, Publius Cornelius, I don’t see how this kind of behavior can be tolerated at all! I mean, even coming from someone like
you—if you’ll excuse my saying so, of course—it’s a bit high-handed, wouldn’t you say. And then, of course, that it came from some Picentine oaf such as that man...it—it defies all logic!”
Publius Cornelius Scipio Nasica Junior sighed. It was early afternoon and he was standing in the warm sunshine just outside the Temple of Jupiter Optimus Maximus, listing to ex-Deputy-Quaestor Marcus Milonius. Scipio Junior hugged his toga closer about him and wished he was at home, or else that he had joined his father in the dawn pontifical vigil which Ahenobarbus had forced on the pontiffs, and the conversation that would have surely followed. “I...sympathize with you, Marcus Milonius, I really do, but there’s nothing that I can do. There’s nothing anybody can do, really, unless Gnaeus Pompeius gets himself convicted on grounds of grain peculation or some other charge. Given the recent public violence, I really don’t think that’s likely at all.”
“Come on, you’re a Patrician Cornelius!” Milonius whined. “Your father’s father led the execution of Tiberius Gracchus, surely you can do something as simple as putting some Picentine oaf in his place!”
“Gnaeus Pompeius,” said Scipio heavily, “is not the kind of man I’d choose to cross.” From that opinion he would not be budged, and shortly the two men made their way down the Clivus Capitolinus; Scipio for the Palatine and home, and Milonius for temporary lodgings elsewhere in Rome.
Scipio had met Marcus Milonius when he had been the clerk of Quintus Varius, Grain Quaestor in 646 AVC, and Marcus Milonius had been another clerk. By now Marcus Milonius must have had at least five years of experience in the position, and would surely be running for Quaestor, new man though he was. While at the time, two years ago, the man had been genial enough and young Scipio Nasica had been thinking of adding him to his own tiny circle of high-climbing clients and useful men, now it was proven that Marcus Milonius was not so resourceful when times were rough.
Typically if a man wished to continue in a clerical post, he would be confirmed by his boss’s successor. Given Marcus Milonius’s experience and successful service to a variety of Quaestors—crooks like Memmius who had managed to hide things from him, whining fools such as Quintus Varius who had him do all the work, and competent devils like Lucius Appuleius Saturninus—it should have been no problem for him to be prorogued, as these matters went, through this year. The problem was the type of man he’d run into: Gnaeus Pompeius.
Though Lucius Appuleius was a Picentine, he wasn’t quite an oaf. He wasn’t big or loud or obnoxious, he didn’t shove his servants and employees aside and panic them by pretending some near deadline, and he didn’t prefer relatives and fellow Picentines; Gnaeus Pompeius did was and did all these things. Marcus Milonius was by nature a social man, so he was always asking after the latest gossip from Rome and the word of this man’s health or that man’s troubles and, anticipating no difference, had continued doing so after the first of January.
THWACK! Marcus Milonius jumped up and brought his hand to the back of his head. “Get back to work!” roared Gnaeus Pompeius. “No time for giggling like a schoolgirl, I want a tight operation and no chance of being accused of some idiocy!” The man—a servant of Gnaeus Servilius Caepio’s—who had just been gossiping about Metella Calva stood staring at Gnaeus Pompeius in shock, and then promptly turned for the door and ran out, there to deliver a letter and then journey across Italy, then the Adriatic, to join his master, who was Ravilla’s quaestor in Macedonia.
Marcus Milonius had taken this incident very hard and, after a few of the less competent clerks had been replaced by snickering Picentines who misplaced his papers and “innocently” tripped him up, he had quitted. He’d expected Pompeius to apologize and beg him not to leave, and to offer him a raise to stay and do the finances in his excellent way, and had been anticipating rejecting Pompeius; instead the man had laughed and said, “Good riddance.” So now Marcus Milonius was out of a job and, since it had been heavily hinted by a younger, more foolish Scipio Nasica that he was his client, had naturally gone to his patron for aid.
Scipio Nasica stopped in the Forum to buy a spicy treat of hot sausage surrounded by a thick warm bun, and closed his eyes in both delight and in chagrin. Yes, this incident would surely decrease his
dignitas. Ah, well; he was young—only twenty-three years old—and healthy, had a child on the way, and had time yet to accrue such clout as his father had and his anti-Gracchus grandfather had had.
It would appear to the casual observer that young Scipio Nasica rather had no talents, and was yet another aristocratic fool. This was not true. Since late childhood and early adolescence he had been enamored with the writings of and about his relatives and ancestors; men such as Scipio Africanus, the vanquisher of Hannibal; Scipio Asina, the loser of a sea battle whose perseverance won through; the first Scipio Nasica, who was chosen to escort the statue of Magna Mater from Ostia to Rome because he was the very best of the Romans; the second Scipio Nasica, who had opposed that peasant Cato the Censor and been Princeps Senatus; the third Scipio Nasica, young Scipio’s grandfather, who had opposed the populist policies of Tiberius Gracchus and had led the good Roman men against him; and others. He admired their heroic nature, their sense of adventure, and also their respect of duty and decorum. It was one thing to be the greatest, and quite another to be the greatest and yet restrain yourself and allow others the respect deserved to them; Scipio Aemilianus, who had applauded the Senate’s handling of the whole Gracchan affair though the Gracchi were his brothers-in-law, was the prime example.
Young Scipio Nasica did not have a passion for war or for horsemanship or for law or for politics; he liked to lead men, to make the policies, and to snap his fingers and be obeyed. He liked to come up with the best solution to a problem—and for a coddled patrician, he did so very often—and to hand it to others to be drafted into law or become the scene of a battle. Even now, a few years early, he was agitating to become a Tribune of the Soldiers; not because he lusted for war or loved those Third and Fourth class men who made up the rank and file, but because he wanted to get it over with, and wanted to get into the thick of social and political life in Rome. Being and being the son of a Scipio Nasica sure did help.
“Cousin Publius!” a voice called right into his ear as he felt a hand clap onto his back quickly.
He jumped and stopped, turning around. “Publius!” His assailant was Publius Servilius Vatia Junior, son of Vatia Senior and his wife Caecilia Metella, who was the elder sister of Scipio Junior’s mother Caecilia Metella. The cousins embraced and Vatia joined Scipio in the hike up the Vestal Steps, which led onto the high spur—the Germalus—of the Palatine Hill. “So, what’ve you been up to?”
Vatia Junior was only seventeen, and seemed to have interests all over the place; his hands were big but he was skinny and his limbs were long and very lanky. “Well,” he gesticulated wildly, ear-length brown hair bobbing and looking for all the world like a spider, “in a year or so I’ll be running into the law courts and speaking in the Forum in general. I should hope that some of my friends will like to debate, and then we can show off our skills to the crowd.”
“So you’ve been studying rhetoric,” Scipio Nasica nodded, smoothly sidestepping a dog turd.
“Oh, yes, absolutely!” spluttered Vatia, who greatly admired his cousin. “Isocrates, Aristotle; I mean, the guy’s a genius!”
“Mmm, you can’t go wrong with Aristotle,” panted Scipio Nasica, who had just pushed a doe-eyed, red-robed, predatory prostitute off himself.
“What I find lacking, really, is truly
Roman rhetoricians. All the big guys are Greek. Even when we’re talking about orators, the non-theorists who go out and really do the dirty work, the only famous ones are Greek. Sure, you have those Cornelii Scipiones and all sorts of Aemilii and some Valerii who are quite good at speaking this way or that, but nothing really distinguishing.”
Scipio Nasica grunted something that sounded like assent as a big, fat, slightly drunk butcher walking the other way stepped on his foot. Vatia went on, “Now of course there are flukes like Gaius Fulcinius, men that can orate in Latin; however, that just won’t cut it. What’s the use of orating if it won’t be in the most pure, most civilized tongue?”
Now, finally, was a topic on which Scipio Nasica had a substantial opinion. He squeezed close to his cousin to avoid two grunting workingmen who were precariously carrying a heavy marble paver down the steep Vestal Steps, and said, “I can agree that Greek is the most civilized tongue; after all, it’s the tongue of Aristotle and Alexander and Thucydides, not to mention Homer and some of my fellow patricians’ distant demi-god ancestors. Still, Rome is Rome, and the world changes; the government of Rome belongs to all men, though of course the best should have a greater voice. Still, every man should have an understanding of what is going on, and what topics are being discussed; how can that happen if we orate in Greek? I agree that Gaius Fulcinius is a freak, an Italian fluke in what should be a Roman system; but still, his appeal is in his popularity—literally his popularity, his appeal to the people. By going down to his level—though it’s more
across to his level, for Latin is
our tongue yet—we gain the trust and amity of the people.”
“You just said yourself,” said Vatia, deflated at this response, as they emerged from in between the high
insulae flanking the Vestal Steps and turned right onto the wide, park-like Clivus Victoriae, “that the best must rule.”
“We must rule,” said Scipio Nasica, putting his arm around the younger man’s shoulder. “I said, ‘we must
rule’, not lead. The people are not sheep or mules to be led around and given tasks and such. They are like clients and we patrons. Or, if you like, they are grown sons such as ourselves, and we are their fathers. Is that not what the senators call themselves—what you and I will be calling ourselves in a decade or so? ‘Conscript Fathers’, ‘Fathers of the Republic’.”
“It’s past that,” Vatia said, trying to assimilate this information. He’d never heard this side of his cousin before. “The Tribunes...what they’re doing is sick. Anathema to all Rome stands for.”
“Some,” Scipio’s face set, “are traitors to their ow—say! What’s going on over there?” They both stopped and saw three carts full to the brim with boxes stopped at the cargo doors of the Ahenobarbus house. Laborers were lifting the boxes—heavy, by the look of it—and moving them to the shade just inside the doors; a distinct clanging came from within.
“I wonder what’s in there. Surely—no! Not weapons? Not so soon after all the other violence.” Vatia was very anxious, and looked to his cousin for comfort.
Scipio scoffed. “I’d say that Gnaeus Domitius doesn’t have the balls. No, I’ll bet you those are boxes all full of tableware made of tin.”
”This stuff must be worth a fortune,” said Lucius Appuleius Saturninus to Ahenobarbus later that day, as the two stood indoors by the closed cargo doors and surveyed the now-open boxes.
“Not quite,” said Ahenobarbus, grinning. “Nepos inherited all those tin concessions and the rents on those pewter smithies on the Balearic Isles. So he sells the smithies tin and collects the rent from the land, which is coincidentally pretty much the only land on the Isles suited for smithing—lots of water and near ports and all that. All he did this year was give them tin for free, and demanded a certain amount of pewter cups and bowls and plates and candlesticks and stuff in return.” Since his tribunal debut on December 12th, Ahenobarbus had convened the Plebs only three more times, and never to speak on laws; all he did was stress the importance of religion in a society that was descending further and further into decadence and unnecessary frivolity, and these speeches were very well received by the public. Not surprising considering that he gave away some dear pewter item to every Roman plebeian; it even served to amuse and seduce some of the less important Equestrians. On the whole, however, feeling among both patricians and plebeians in the top two classes was not good about what Ahenobarbus was planning—and he was planning
something! Had to be! Or at least, that was the feeling.
“By the way, how is our dear friend Nepos? Gaius Servilius”—Glaucia, that is—“sometimes mentions him as...as a factor.”
“That dangerous, is he?” grinned Ahenobarbus wolfishly. “Anyway, I expected that you would have some laws of your own to draft. Well, it’s been three months and...nothing, really.”
Saturninus shrugged. “I feel as though Crassus Orator and I are playing some sort of waiting game. Who will present their law first, and who will veto first?”
“Does it matter?” Ahenobarbus rolled his eyes as he sifted through pewter plates. “Excellent quality, I’ll have to write thanking him.”
“Balearic,” said Saturninus matter-of-factly. “Anyway, of course it matters. Though, this being politics, everything can be taken two ways. Whoever moves first can be seen as constructive and good, a positive force, or else too pushy and pursuing his own ends. Conversely, whoever vetoes first can be seen as protecting the Plebs’ rights, or as being deliberately obstructive.”
Ahenobarbus shrugged. “Just make the right move. Though that Crassus Orator is a slippery fish, you’re right. He could sell a prostitute’s see-through shift to the most respectable matron in Rome, and he could convince Metella Calva to become only the second-most-lascivious woman in Rome.”
Saturninus snorted laughter. “You’re right about the damned man,
and about Metella Calva! Anyway, I have an idea for a law, and I’m sure you’d support me...it’s a bit difficult though.”
Ahenobarbus shushed him, straightened from his inspection, and hooked his arm through Saturninus’s, leading him from this wide side of the atrium, dusty from workmen’s sandals and the detritus carried by January wind, to the triclinium and calling for dinner all the way. “It’s best that I’m sitting down and eating when I get bad news,” he explained. “I daresay that I’d like to be skinny as a stick in old age.”
Saturninus raised his eyebrows with a grin in reply, shedding his toga and washing his hands in a bowl proffered by a servant. The same servant then took his senatorial boots of red calfskin off and rolled thick, warm woolen socks onto his feet; thus ungirded and shod, he reclined with Ahenobarbus on the couch as the first course, warm loafs of fresh bread and a mixture of olive oil and spices, was brought to them. “I must,” said Ahenobarbus as he chewed on a loaf and surveyed the empty room in front of him, “acquire a wife and some children.”
Saturninus reflected on this. He himself was thirty, and in the good, optimum age for marriage. Honestly, he thought he should have married sooner, as having a wife—especially a noble wife—and children added to a man’s dignity; as things stood, he’d be quite an old man before his sons grew to be elected Military Tribunes, let alone become established men, with great clout.
Is this the fate of men, to wander the Earth and wonder with anxiety whether they will live to see their sons lead armies, or whether they will die tomorrow of fever or apoplexy?
Saturninus visibly shivered, and Ahenobarbus saw him go white. “Are you quite all right, Lucius Appuleius?”
Saturninus’s eyes opened with a start and he nodded, smiling sheepishly. “Go on, Gnaeus Domitius, just a stray thought. I, too, should acquire a wife and sons.”
Ahenobarbus nodded. “Anyway, I...well, there’s not much to go on about. What’s your news; what’s your difficult idea for a law?”
“Alright,” said Saturninus, leaning forward and setting the loaf he’d been picking at down; Ahenobarbus began wolfing his own down. “You remember Gaius Fulcinius’s whole set of laws, of course.” Ahenobarbus’s eyes widened as he nodded, and Saturninus continued, “You remember his law on juries being composed only of Equestrians?”
Ahenobarbus stopped chewing. “Noooooo. Noooo waaaaay.”
“Way,” nodded Saturninus, grinning. “The Tribunes of last year were so cowed by his death that they overturned all his laws, even the good ones. Even the ones necessary for the existence of the Republic, which prevent idiot generals from murdering through negligence a hundred thousand brave and truly Roman souls, not to mention governors from exploiting their provinces and fleecing the Treasury. Not that you,” laughed Saturninus, who had no illusions about Ahenobarbus’s character, “mind fleecing the Treasury and exploiting provinces much.”
Ahenobarbus, who now had a mouthful of roast quail, only waved his arm expansively and said, “Go on, go on.”
“Well, I’m bringing the law of juries made up of Equestrians back.” He leaned forward again and looked at Ahenobarbus intensely. “I will have this law, Gnaeus Domitius. You’re of an old, anciently noble family, but I know that you know that I know that you know how absolutely necessary this is. The knights won’t care much for gubernatorial embezzlement, anyway; you know that as long as you give a few cheap, juicy contracts to the most important of them, you’ll be completely safe. No, they’ll go after the men who are bad for business; and the men who are bad for business, are bad for Rome.”
Ahenobarbus swallowed his bite of garum-soaked licker-fish and looked vacant, though this was his look when he was thinking. “Yeah,” he nodded deeply, dipping his head up and down. “You’re completely right, and I’ll support you all the way.” He shook Saturninus’s dry hand with his own greasy one, and they dug into the meal.
A row of whole roast quails
“Well,” said Saturninus, who was now quite hungry after having gotten that rough topic off his chest, “I guess I underestimated Gaius Servilius when he said that you would be supporting me every step of the way.”
“Mmm,” said Ahenobarbus, who had yet to swallow another mouthful of bread and quail. “I really became quite a free radical when they snubbed me last year—wow, it has been just a bit over a year since it happened. I’ll do anything to annoy those jerk-offs who lead the Senate.”
“The...Policy Makers, isn’t it? Who was it coined that term, Fulcinius? Gaius Servilius?”
“I’ve never heard that term used,” said Ahenobarbus blankly, then dug into a plate of salted oysters and snails. “It’s a good term, though,” said Ahenobarbus after slurping one snail up. “I’ll use it, for sure.”
They ate in silence for some moments before Saturninus began again, “So, that’s really the whole purpose of your tribunate? To make life hell for the Pontiffs and the Senate’s senior members?”
Ahenobarbus shrugged while nodding at the same time, to weird effect. “Things need to be shaken up, that’s obvious. Hell, even Scaurus and the Pontifex Maximus supported Catulus Caesar before Fulcinius gave them a bit of resistance; that shows you how bad it is. We need right-thinking men of new blood and old—old preferably, no offence to yourself—who can truly lead. Who can lead Rome competently, and into glory; men like Nepos and Sulla—and myself, if I may not be modest—come to mind.”
“And Marcus Antonius,” sighed Saturninus, who had been a good friend of his.
Ahenobarbus, who’d been an even better friend, ate faster. “Mmm, he was my good friend. Defended me at my trial. He was a real man, a man’s man, a soldier’s man; oh, but I miss him. May Gaius Servilius Glaucia live forever, for being instrumental in bringing Gaius Fulcinius and Marcus Antonius’s other murderers to their graves.” Ahenobarbus was of course neglecting to mention that Nepos had much more to do with the deaths of Fulcinius, Memmius, and Fimbria than Glaucia did.
“How are those two little boys of his, by the way? Are they doing well? Hopefully they’re too young to remember.”
“Marcus is four, and he remembers his father; he’s very quiet at times. Usually when there’s a man around, I gather from Caninia. The little one, Gaius, doesn’t remember anything. No, I mean that. He tries to bite my hand off every time I visit; Caninia says he likes trying to bite the poor wet nurse’s tits off.”
“‘...Caninia says...’?” Saturninus’s eyebrows arched. “Have you perhaps been visiting too often, Gnaeus Domitius?”
Ahenobarbus smiled, “Ah, she’s a handsome woman. She’s young, fertile, has two sons who will be healthy and—judging by their father—intelligent, and big meaty bastards, to boot. I’ll admit, I’ve been thinking of marrying her.”
“Well,” cried Saturninus, who had just this evening begun thinking about starting a family, “you’ll have to hurry, because I’m in line too!”