post war germany

With the Marshall Plan never becoming a reality, would the Morgenthau plan (or a less extreme modified version) be put into place? Would Germany just be denied any aid and left in ruins? What would be the Soviet policy in the East?

What if after WW2, the Allies don't pursue a policy of German integration and rehabilitation. What if instead, they punish Germany in ways much harsher than ToV? What would the consequences be if the country was treated as a pariah state, even if it becomes a democracy? Let's say if the Allied...