Search results for query: *

  • Users: Trevayne
  • Content: Threads
  • Order by date

Forum search Google search

  1. Could nuclear weapons have gotten Germany to surrender in 45-47 without a Western Allies invasion of Germany?

    In the ASB forum, there is an ongoing thread regarding the impact of a seriously improved German U-boat campaign. The thread is as follows: https://www.alternatehistory.com/forum/threads/the-slimmest-of-victories-rewrite-of-the-narrowest-of-margins-ww2-u-boat-atl.546418/ Given the premise...

  2. Soviet artillery question - was Lend Lease essential for Soviet artillery effectiveness?

    I recently saw a youtube video The Red God of War. It made some very interesting claims and was wondering if they have been checked out. If this has already been discussed here, could someone please provide a link? Specifically, it states that Soviet Artillery was crippled during the war by...

  3. Question: Did the US military ever seriously examine the possibility of the US getting invaded between say 1870 and 1945?

    I have been wondering about this for a while. I have seen multiple timelines where various people are worried about a potential invasion. Note, I am talking about an invasion by somebody other than the British or Mexicans. They have a much easier time because of the land borders. The invading...

  4. British Amphibious question

    When was the last time the British Army participated in a) an amphibious assault with all the bells and whistles including landing medium or heavier tanks across the beach? b) an amphibious landing exercise where main battle tanks were landed across the beach? AFIAK the last all up landing...

  5. The Craziest Idea

    I posted the below response to the post by @Tyr Anazasi in the Fandom AH forum. Then I thought that this would be a better fit in Post 1900 since I don't think any of these are actually ASB. The intent is assess which of these is the craziest idea, and provide a list from craziest to least...

  6. Two Clinton alternate questions

    This maybe too early to post here, but the 2016 election is over for better or worse. I do not want to argue its merits, but ask opinions on two possible alternates: 1) Barack Obama, for whatever reason, decides not to run in 2008. Given the popularity of Bush 43 at that point, I think Hillary...

  7. Pacific War Question

    Suppose a senior individual in the Japanese government had an inkling of how badly the Pacific War could go for Japan and decided to accept tactical risk and avoid strategic doom. Specifically, the Japanese deliver an unequivocal declaration of war citing their grievances with the US, especially...

  8. Best German Pre-WW2 strategy against Britain?

    (adapted from another post) If Germany had seriously prepared to fight Britain in the 1930s, what could they have usefully done? They can't build a big fleet, because it would tip off the British, who would then out build them; and it would also divert enough resources from the Heer and the...
Top