Recent content by SpicyJuan

  1. What German launched 'stepped up', 'sharpened' not entirely unrestricted U-Boat warfare in 1917

    The convoys wouldn't have been formed without the Americans in the war. It was the presence of the USN which made the Admiralty feel comfortable enough to spare the shipping and escorts for it
  2. How would the USA and CSA fit into the great power alliance system after a Confederate victory?

    A German-aligned USA and a British-aligned CSA is more likely than vice versa, especially if the British were the primary means for the CSA to win its independence in the first place
  3. Historical GIS Resources Thread

    So I found an archive version of this and was able to download a zip, but they are all sbx, shp, dbf, prj files which don't seem to open in QGIS. How were you able to get it to work? https://web.archive.org/web/20210731221637/https://web.stanford.edu/group/spatialhistory/cgi-bin/site/pub.php?id=51
  4. The Collapse of Brest-Livost: An Idea for Eastern Europe in a CP Victory Scenario.

    I forget the name, but Ludendorff had a plan developed for intervening in Russia with a very large force after a successful Spring Offensive in the West. I expect that the Kaiser and Hindenburg would rubberstamp the plan. Because Germany would have a large, land border with the Russians, I think...
  5. The Netherlands if Germany won WW1

    According to the Septeberprogramme, the Germans wanted to bring the Dutch in their sphere of influence with "close economic cooperation". Keep in mind though that many German nationalists wanted to bring the Dutch into the Empire as a constituent state. I can imagine you will have some...
  6. WI Agadir Crisi escalates into a WW1

    Again, it really all comes down to how the war breaks out. It is definitely possible that Stolypin gets his way and successfully makes the case that since France was the original aggressor, Russia is not treaty-bound to join the war.
  7. WI Agadir Crisi escalates into a WW1

    Because of Stolypin and the Conservatives: under Stolypin you had the greatest moment of German-Russian détente. This was reflected in the Morocco Crisis where Russia, in stark contrast to Britain, pursued a more reserved and conciliatory policy. It is entirely possible that the Russians stay...
  8. WI Agadir Crisi escalates into a WW1

    Briey was only 6km from the German border. Longwy, 13km. Neither are particularly defensible. There is no reason to doubt German ability or desire to capture them.
  9. WI Agadir Crisi escalates into a WW1

    Having an additional 170,000 troops more or less trained and ready by the start of the war is a big deal: it was also seen as such by the German General Staff. But even so, the point remains that the steep rise in Franco-Russian military funding between 1911 and 1914 certainly improved their...
  10. WI Agadir Crisi escalates into a WW1

    I suspect that a German government set on war in 1911 will also go for such last minute shipments to tide them over. Diedenhofen was the third best protected city in Elsaß-Lothringen, right behind Metz and Straßburg. The same cannot be said for the also important French mines in Briey and Longwy.
  11. WI Agadir Crisi escalates into a WW1

    Britain will back the French to the Hilt, yes, but it is by no means clear or inevitable that you'd see British troops on the ground in France or a general mobilization of the Empire. The Germans would certainly have less fortress killer artillery, but not none. They still have the 21cm, 28cm...
  12. WI Agadir Crisi escalates into a WW1

    Which would be both sides. An early war would most certainly speed up the government's interest in ending Germany's reliance on Chilean saltpeter
  13. Awful Pre-1900 TL Ideas

    A Franco-German union along the lines or a "neo-Carolingian empire" is actually an interesting idea.
  14. The Germanic Empire: the ultimate Megadeutschland wank TL

    But will it become a centralized state or remain a decentralized confederation?
  15. The Germanic Empire: the ultimate Megadeutschland wank TL

    How strong is Dutch nationalism exactly? I can't see them included in Germany anytime soon despite the setback of the Dutch nationalists.
Top