Recent content by Reader347

  1. WI- USA gets Singapore in 1940's Destroyers for Bases Agreement

    This makes no sense. Translate this please. Is this an actual word? What does it mean?
  2. Would the rickshaw have been useful to an Early Modern army?

    Seems as if all the stairs would get in the way, the roads were built for feet. Simple wheeled barrows might be better, similar to the big wheeled Chinese 'wooden ox' with hand grips on both ends. The roads could have ramps at the steps, in the middle or on the side.
  3. Earlier radios=no trench warfare?

    That's what I read, too. Not voice, just telegraphy, up/over/hit-etc. I just wondered how large and heavy sets like that would be. Pics from ww2 show there were back pack radios that required two men, one of them carried batteries.
  4. Earlier radios=no trench warfare?

    How large were the ones in ww1 spotter aircraft? The aircraft don't look very heavy lifting in photos.
  5. AHC/WI Useful Steam Power before 1000AD

    From reading-a series of miners friends was used. Steam piston pumps were more efficient, for sure. Horses were also used in water removal before steam-how? Treadmills, or what? Agricola showed bucket hoists.
  6. AHC/WI Useful Steam Power before 1000AD

    The first mine pumping steam engines didn't use iron, didn't have pistons-'the miners friend', just partial vacuum in a copper boiler, remember. Or that Hero copper steam engine toy could be modified to rotate a shaft to drive a series of piston pumps. But wasteful, yes.
  7. Impact of introducting new crops to the Roman Empire

    Didn't Rome trade with the Persians? They should be able to buy rice farmers on the slave market, or offer land to farmers willing to move to Roman areas.
  8. AHC/WI Useful Steam Power before 1000AD

    That's why the solar power concentrators in the 1800s were so big for the power they produced. Read 'The Golden Thread' if you can find it. Even with modern materials commercial solar steam installations are huge.
  9. AHC/WI: Germany reverse engineers Entente weapons/artillery

    The Belgians were making, and using, Lewis guns at the start of the war. And a Hotchkiss light machine gun, benet-mercie(?). Plenty of pics show Germans using captured units.
  10. How can we get a Modern Industrialized Country have Open Borders?

    Cuba? North Korea? China? USSR? Are/were there millions wanting to get in?
  11. Minerva ante portas! A Roman Scientific Revolution

    Is this why post Roman Empire Europe developed/built so many water mills?
  12. WI: Crusaders Failed to Take Constantinople in 1203-4

    Wasn't there a known way to build walls to defend against cannon?
  13. WI: More American WWII commanders had combat experience

    Philippines, supposedly army and marines had low level war with the moslems right up through ww2.
  14. Why the nazis hated Communists ?

    Don't communist countries have elections? Ain't that a democracy? And it's always for the people-ungrateful gits.
  15. Better prepared CSA?

    They had a gunpowder shortage the whole war, too, so there's another project. They still would have lost with more industry, but the longer the war drags on the more manpower losses.
Top