Recent content by Polandc4

  1. AHC/WI: (Make) BRICS First World Countries to Compete with the G7

    You would have to go back at least 200 years, and change them totaly.
  2. Comparisons between Modern America and British 20th century decline

    Its a question of size. The US is so much bigger and is so much less attached to global trade that it can't really decline as far as the British empire. The US will for at least the next hundred years be a first tier power. The UK struggles now to maintain itself as a second tier power.
  3. AHC/WI: British-American war in the Early 1900s

    The problem is due to geography they cant have an extended fight.
  4. What if the Japanese had brought an invasion force to take Hawaii after Pearl Harbor?

    See http://www.combinedfleet.com/pearlops.htm
  5. Edith Wilson widely and respectfully viewed as first women president during liberal 1940s?

    The Treaty of Versailles was more the cause of WW 2, than a League of Nations that was useless in any case. How would US involvement be seen to change anything?
  6. How Long Would a Victorious Nazi Germany Last?

    How much did they take over? Euro Russia ?, The British Isles?? North America ???
  7. How Serious Would The Lose of Moscow Have Been to the USSR in 1941?

    How strong would the Germans have been that far from the railheads ? This is 41 not 42 or 43, how far had the retracking come. They may have just pushed half a million men into a easily closed pocket causing a devastating defeat.
  8. Some questions about the 27,000 ton Yorktown Class design.

    they were 1st gen carriers nobody knew what they were doing yet
  9. The Selma Massacre

    No they would lose more than they would gain, most of the northern republican base was at least mildly in favor of the civil rights acts. The men who proposed and used the southern strategy did not care about anything but votes, they figured the few they would lose from promoting " Conservative...
  10. The Selma Massacre

    This will blow the republican southern strategy out of the water. Will they try to tie all of this mess to the Democrats?
  11. Could Jubal Early Have Captured Washington D.C. in 1864?

    If Early had attacked Washington all he would have done was kill his troops. Almost any one could have held it from any attack he could have mounted. Early's army just did not have the guns to silence or breach union positions.
  12. No major offensive toward Leningrad 1941

    How would the supply situation work? I belive quite a lot of the support in the north was by boat would there be
  13. WWI Eastern Front: How was Germany so Successful?

    Napoleon did the same, he simply did not have the supply train and "trains" the Germans did. The Germans also did not get near Moscow and settled for a negotiated peace. Even with a shattered revolutionary Russia that did not seem to have any ability to wage war. It was a accomplishment but it...
  14. A limited naval war between Iran and Saudi Arabia in 2012. Who wins?

    Iran if it is just those two, Saudi military forces are a joke.
Top