Recent content by Grimbald

  1. Grimbald

    Wars that could have happened, but didn't.

    As I recall there was an "almost war" between Sweden and Russia early in WWI. A Russian admiral went rogue and tried to attack the Swedish fleet. He got called back just in time. Adding Sweden to the Central Powers would have changed a great deal.
  2. Grimbald

    US - German Peace Treaty after collapse of Western Front but before US troops enter Europe in large numbers

    This is really a question and one I have often thought about. The US enters the war on schedule in April 1917 and starts building its army. France is on the verge of collapse and is staying afloat only with promises of American troops imminent arrival. The US insists that the submarine threat...
  3. Grimbald

    Russia lobs nukes at Reagan US...but Reagan doesn't retaliate

    Certainly a bad outcome for mankind. But The fleet alone is strong enough to destroy the Soviet Union. MAD
  4. Grimbald

    What should the United States, Britain, and France, have done differently regarding Germany, and Europe, at the End of World War One?

    Retain German monarchy rebuilt on UK mode. Willy II abdicates in favor of grandson No lost territory except AS-L. Plebiscites in areas of AH empire to see which areas if any wish to join Germany. No reparations except to Belgium. No other terms. France did not win this war and should not be...
  5. Grimbald

    American civil war delayed until 1869, what are the consequences?

    US post Corwin Virginia eliminates slavery of its own accord eventually and upper south follows. Deep south eventually destroys land productivity by over production of cotton and tobacco. Slavery becomes unprofitable though remains legal well into 20th century.
  6. Grimbald

    American civil war delayed until 1869, what are the consequences?

    If you graph Southern military capability vs. Northern it looks like an X where the crossing point is probably in the late 1840s or early 1850s. Time only makes the Northern advantage greater. Eventually it gets so great even deep south fire eaters see the futility of sending their sons to die...
  7. Grimbald

    Best monarch or head of state to kill off early for a more prosperous future

    Jeff Davis, by natural causes, in the summer of 1864. I believe Alexander Stephens would have seen the "handwriting on the wall" and cut a reasonable deal in the Hampton Roads conferences. My proposed solution: All Southern states readmitted immediately. Northern army withdrawn within six...
  8. Grimbald

    If you could change One event post 1900..?

    US stays out of WW1 Implies limits on submarine warfare by Germany. Germany wins quasi white peace. Keeps eastern gains. Reds deposed. Probably by joint Brit-German force. US collects debts in colonies. Mostly in Pacific, Newfoundland and Bahamas. Nuclear research goes slow - delay at...
  9. Grimbald

    Best Monarch/Head of State to keep alive for a more prosperous future

    My second bite at this apple Lincoln and Lee both living to 80 Both favored rapprochement. The country might have gotten a better outcome for everyone including the former slaves.
  10. Grimbald

    Best Monarch/Head of State to keep alive for a more prosperous future

    Kaiser Fredrich Wilhelm III -- make the German Empire more liberal German PM Hindenberg -- dilute Hitler's power longer King Edward IV -- the Cousins War was over; let it stay that way
  11. Grimbald

    What alternate history ideas you wish they were used more often?

    Lincoln says "Be gone and take your cursed economic system with you."
  12. Grimbald

    No US entry into WW1, how does it impact US in WW2 analogue?

    Without the US loans GB and France run out of money in late 1917. War over.
  13. Grimbald

    Jutland Redux - A summer soltice shootout

    Truly great read.
Top