Qing Resurgent - a Chinese TL

Update time :D.


Chapter II: China and the Great War, 1914-1918.

China’s actions in 1914 were primarily inspired by Japan’s moves. In the first week of World War I Japan proposed to the United Kingdom, its ally since 1902, that Japan would enter the war if it could take Germany’s Pacific territories. On August 7th 1914, the British government officially asked Japan for assistance in destroying the raiders from the Imperial German Navy in and around Chinese waters (China had no navy worth mentioning and was deemed unable to counter the German Far Eastern Squadron). Japan sent Germany an ultimatum on August 14th 1914, which went unanswered; Japan then formally declared war on Germany on August 23rd 1914. As Vienna refused to withdraw the Austro-Hungarian cruiser SMS Kaiserin Elisabeth from Tsingtao, Japan declared war on Austria-Hungary, too, on August 25th 1914.

Yuan Shikai recognised that the Japanese wanted to expand their sphere of influence in China by taking the German concession at Tsingtao, which could project influence over all of Shandong province. On August 24th 1914, the “Empire of the Great Qing” delivered a declaration of war to the German ambassador in Beijing, complete with the imperial seal and the signature of all cabinet members, and threw out German military advisors. China immediately stopped payment of the debt it owed to Germany and Austria-Hungary as part of the Boxer Protocol (21% of total war reparations owed to the Eight Nation Alliance) and revoked the German concession at Tsingtao. The same day one New Army division – worth 12.500 men on paper and supported by 92 artillery pieces – attacked the German concession at Tsingtao, which was defended by only 3.650 German troops. This division, however, was under strength due to the suddenness of its deployment and they were repulsed by the defenders. Yuan sent reinforcements to the area. The New Army consisted of 16 divisions and 16 brigades – for a total of approximately 300.000 men, equipped with modern weapons like Krupp artillery guns – but it would take time for them to arrive. In the meantime, the Germans strengthened their defences. The city was separated from the rest of peninsula by three lines of steep hills and the Germans built a network of trenches, artillery batteries and other fortifications in anticipation of more Chinese attacks. Besides that, Shandong province was being plagued by floods at the time and that interfered with Chinese logistics.

In the meantime, printing presses and radio stations across the country were put to work to drum up support for the war, stir up Chinese nationalism and to raise popular support for General Yuan Shikai’s regime, and they were very successful. The war against Germany was declared a “people’s war” and that involved hordes of screaming Chinamen hurling themselves against German trenches, overwhelming them by sheer weight of numbers. Out of 25.000 troops deployed, the Chinese suffered 1.915 dead and 3.075 wounded, a casualty rate of nearly 20%, but Chinese officers knew they could take such losses and still come out victorious. The besieged defenders surrendered on October 21st 1914. China’s first victory over a foreign power since before anyone could remember brought about a sense of unity and pride that had been hard to find in China for a very long time. It brought support for the government, but also for the Qing since this young child Emperor had perhaps returned the Mandate of Heaven to his dynasty and would possibly prove great. A wave of nationalism went through the major cities and was expressed by hundreds of thousands volunteering for the army, buying war bonds, seeking employment in the booming armaments industry, and major demonstrations in which effigies of the Kaiser were strung up on lamp posts and set on fire. Millions of pamphlets were printed that said a time of reawakening and of reckoning had come.

The 8 year-old Xuantong Emperor, in the meantime, was busy getting lessons from Western tutors and didn’t learn about the declaration of war until several days later. Amazingly, he appeared in public alongside Yuan Shikai from late 1914 to wave at troops parading on Tiananmen Square in Beijing and he was the first Emperor of China ever to be caught on film. Yuan was one of the few of his “subjects” to appear at his court that he couldn’t boss around, couldn’t command to perform the ritual kowtow and who he couldn’t punish for minimal transgressions. In fact, Yuan was much like the occasional foreigners appearing on his court, who were required to merely bow rather than perform the kowtow and which the Emperor had to treat politely. The soldiers guarding the General only obeyed the Emperor insofar as the Emperor’s orders didn’t contravene Yuan’s. Thusly, the child ruler learned very early on that he was only a living God for as far as the military allowed it.

In the meantime, the government decided to channel the funds freed up by the cancellation of debt payments to Germany and Austria-Hungary for an ambitious military expansion program. In addition, the government loaned large amounts of money from the United States, who would displace the British as the world’s banker within the next few years. The New Army was to expand to 36 divisions, for a total of 450.000 men in two years time; if that was completed successfully it was to expand even further to 48 divisions, or 600.000 men (from 1913, military hierarchy was thus in the Chinese army: a division was only 12.500 men, which was further divided into two brigades of 6.250 men; a brigade was in turn divided into two regiments of 3.125, composed of five battalions of 625 men; each battalion was divided into five companies of 125 men each and was that the smallest unit of movement at the time). Furthermore, units of the old Qing army had to be brought up to modern standards in accordance with a Ten-Year Plan that was approved by the Ministry of War in 1915.

This provided investment opportunities for Western arms producers, which were all too eager to grab them. China needed them to develop a modern arms industry almost from scratch and wanted to pay for it, an ambitious commitment by the Chinese government that could not be anything but lucrative. The Birmingham Small Arms Company was contracted to build an enormous arms plant near Beijing. Under license this factory would produce the Lee-Enfield rifle, the fastest firing bolt-action rifle in the world, which had been selected as the army’s standard rifle. The American Colt’s Manufacturing Company was the lowest bidder on a government contract for a standard side arm, building a factory that would license-produce the M1911 semi-automatic pistol. Besides that, the army also adopted the Vickers machine gun, the French 75 mm rapid-fire field gun and the French 155 mm 1917 Schneider howitzer. Beijing, Nanjing and several other cities underwent a tremendous industrial expansion in a few years time as a result of these military expansion plans. Besides the arms industry, other sectors of the economy boomed too: the heavy machinery factories popped up like mushrooms to supply weapons factories, truck factories and tractor factories, as did coal mines, steel mills, oil refineries and power plants. Most of the development, however, was limited to the coastal cities and Manchuria. Besides an increase in their income due to the raised price of rice due to increased Russian demand, peasants barely noticed a difference compared to the pre-war years.

In 1915, one infantry brigade, one machine gun company, and one artillery battalion, for a total strength of 7.000 men, were sent to the Western Front. They were sent to serve with the British Expeditionary Force and arrived in time to receive their baptism of fire in the Second Battle of Ypres, including the experience of chlorine gas attack. Out of 7.000 men, 3.000 Chinese soldiers were killed, wounded or missing in action, a casualty rate the likes of which the New Army had never experienced. Nonetheless, they hadn’t buckled under the pressure of a prolonged German assault on their position and had distinguished themselves, though more through valour than through proficiency at modern warfare. The “Chinese Expeditionary Force” was sent to a quiet sector of the front in Alsace-Lorraine to recuperate and with reinforcements it would eventually swell to a force of four divisions, or 50.000 men, by 1917. It fought with distinction in the Battle of Passchendaele, weathered the German Spring Offensive during the Battle of the Lys, and helped achieve an Entente victory in the Fifth Battle of Ypres. During this time a “Chinese Flying Circus” was founded with 24 Nieuport 17 biplanes and 24 Sopwith Camels graciously donated by China’s Anglo-French allies, forming two fighter squadrons. That became the core of the Imperial Chinese Army Air Force founded in 1919.

The commander of the Chinese Expeditionary Force was Chiang Kai-shek. He had served in the Imperial Japanese army from 1909 to 1911 and had supported the Tongmenghui, but withdrew his support after the failed Xinhai Revolution. After a pardon by the Qing government for those willing to abandon “illegal, seditious anti-state groups” and provide intelligence on them, Chiang defected. He regarded Yuan Shikai’s militarist regime as the best way to effectuate a “revolution from within” and became a “pragmatic monarchist.” He accepted a teaching position at the Boading Military Academy in 1912 and got the rank of Colonel since he was one of the few with experience in a modern, foreign army. He didn’t much like teaching and requested a command position and he received command of a regiment, and by 1914 he had reached the rank of Brigadier General. By 1919, when he returned home to China, he had not only reached the rank of Lieutenant General. He had also learnt to speak English and to a lesser extent French and he had become China’s foremost expert in modern warfare. Besides that, he had read up on economics, law, political science and philosophy, including Karl Marx even though he rejected Marxist teachings.

Another 150.000 Chinese came to France to serve in the Chinese Labour Corps. About 10.000 Chinese prostitutes were paid by the government to follow them, setting up brothels in Chinese inhabited areas and up to 25 kilometres behind the Chinese front sector (a part of Great War history that has only rarely been paid attention to). The workers mainly aged between 20 and 35 served as labour in the rear echelons or helped build munitions depots. They were tasked with carrying out essential work to support the frontline troops, such as unloading ships, building dugouts, repairing roads and railways, digging trenches and filling sandbags. Some worked in armaments factories, others in naval shipyards, for a wage of one to three francs a day. At the time they were seen just as cheap labour, not even allowed out of camp to fraternise locally, dismissed as mere coolies. When the war ended some were used for mine clearance, or to recover the bodies of soldiers and fill in miles of trenches. Men fell ill from the strange diet and the intense damp and cold, and on occasion they mutinied against their French and British employers or ransacked local restaurants in search of food.

As China’s contribution to the war grew, the Chinese government managed to stipulate better conditions for its workers. The result was a few thousand interracial relations between French women and Chinese men, several hundred of which resulted in marriages after the grooms had agreed to convert to Catholicism pro forma (a small number, but not surprising considering the taboo on interracial relationships, even with a conversion to the local dominant religion). Slightly more accepted were relations between French men and Chinese women, including those who abandoned their profession as a prostitute to engage in such relationships. After the war, a Chinese community of a few thousand remained in Paris and many became intellectuals.

Among them was a young man named Mao Zedong. After enrolling and dropping out of a police academy, a soap-production school, a law school, an economics school and the government run Changsha Middle School, he studied independently, reading the works of Adam Smith, Montesquieu, Darwin, Mill, Rousseau and Spencer. Lacking prospects, he joined the army in 1915 and had reached the rank of Captain by 1918, commanding an infantry company near Ypres. During his time in Europe he also read up on Nietzsche, Vilfredo Pareto and Marx. Given the realities of war, he saw greater truth in Nietzsche’s teachings about the will to power and individual transcendence than in Marx’s class struggle. He also accepted Pareto’s sociology, which posited that in every society a ruling class emerged that enriched itself until it got soft, withered away and was replaced by a new one. Mao accepted Pareto’s views that human nature was primitive, emotional and unyielding, that the smarter, shrewder, abler and stronger took the lion’s share, and that therefore there ultimately was no progress in human history. The only constant factor was struggle, and in the modern context that meant the struggle between nation states for a piece of the pie in terms of resources. He published a pamphlet detailing his proto-fascist and Chinese nationalist views and a print of 2.000 saw circulation among the intellectuals within the Parisian Chinese community. It had the unwieldy title “Principles of National Consolidation and the Reconciliation of Socialism and Progressivism with Chinese Ways.” Mao’s ambitious plans for a book that would further outline and specify the new road he thought China should take never came to fruition. He was killed in action in October 1918, aged only 24, during the final days of the Great War. He and his pamphlet became a footnote in history, but the Chinese militarist regime became a lot like what he had predicted. The militarists would come to fish in the same ideological pond as this young autodidactic intellectual soldier as they witnessed the post-war world.
 
Last edited:
Tsingato is a believable win. And despite the odds favoring China so much as opposed to any other power set up in the region i cam see the Government ad people rallying to such a victory.

And the young Emperor learns some necessary lessons in the world and politics.
 
Another great update. It is certainly ominous that TTL Mao's views, which are Social Darwinism and militaristic fascism in essence, are going to be very similar to what the Qing decide to do.
 
Another great update. It is certainly ominous that TTL Mao's views, which are Social Darwinism and militaristic fascism in essence, are going to be very similar to what the Qing decide to do.

Well it is an era for radical/autocratic ideas. With any luck they won't catch too much in that pond.

i wonder how events will evolve with Japan here? Will the Rising Sun instead focus more on Anti West activity with the Qing? Will events like the end of the Monarchial rule in Thailand still happen ITTL?
 

RousseauX

Donor
This is my favorite TL atm

Have the queue being abolished yet? OTL the Beiyang army started to cut them off before the fall of the dynasty.
 
Well it is an era for radical/autocratic ideas. With any luck they won't catch too much in that pond.

i wonder how events will evolve with Japan here? Will the Rising Sun instead focus more on Anti West activity with the Qing? Will events like the end of the Monarchial rule in Thailand still happen ITTL?

It would be cool if China partnered up with Japan to form some sort of anti-Russia alliance. I doubt Japan will try to take on a stronger China considering the rate which they are modernising at.
 
It would be cool if China partnered up with Japan to form some sort of anti-Russia alliance. I doubt Japan will try to take on a stronger China considering the rate which they are modernising at.

Korea will prove to be a sticky point I expect in any such cooperation.
 
With an increased Chinese participation in the war I wonder how the Shandong problem will look. I guess they might get support for it earlier, leading to a break between China and USA, at an even earlier date. No naval conference?
 
’s actions in 1914 were primarily inspired by Japan’s moves. In the first week of World War I Japan proposed to the United Kingdom, its ally since 1902, that Japan would enter the war if it could take Germany’s Pacific territories. On August 7th 1914, the British government officially asked Japan for assistance in destroying the raiders from the Imperial German Navy in and around Chinese waters (China had no navy worth mentioning and was deemed unable to counter the German Far Eastern Squadron). Japan sent Germany an ultimatum on August 14th 1914, which went unanswered...The same day one New Army division – worth 12.500 men on paper and supported by 92 artillery pieces – attacked the German concession at Tsingtao...

In OTL Japan started to prepare for the invasion of German Tsingtao on 15th of August, and they had excellent military intelligence network in place in China. IMO men like Tanaka Giichi would certainly know about Chinese mobilization beforehand. And they would never allow the Chinese to attack the territory they plan to seize themselves without doing anything about it.

In OTL he and his supporters sponsored Sun Yat-sen and other Chinese nationalists to attack against Beijing government, and then propped up the Northern warlords to divide the Chinese factions by pitting them against one another. The more liberal Japanese political leaders like Okuma and Kato knew that unless they could show concrete results from their foreign policy, the military establishment would not be pleased. In OTL the whole 21 Points scheme was in many ways an attempt to stop the hardliners to present even more radical demands, which would certainly follow if China gets to "steal the show" with Westerners in this fashion.

Tokyo had a negative view on Chinese participation to WW1, unless it happened on their terms. In OTL Nishihara encouraged the Chinese to make substantial demands for European powers in exchange for the DoW against Central Powers, including:
-ten-year suspension of Boxer indemnities
-permissions for tax reforms in China through custom tariffs
In exchange for cooperation Japan was willing to give China substantial loans - something no other power aside the US was able to do in 1914.

Why is the US willing to loan to China, while in OTL Japan was the main source of foreign finance to Beijing. Macadoo did not want to ask Congress for authorization for a major government loan to China, and he didin't want a Chinese funding drive to compete with Liberty Bonds. The only loan he was willing to concede to China was a private sum of $55 million. J.P. Morgan announced that they would only loan money to China in cooperation with Japan.

The US did have the money to fund Chinese participation to WW1 in the manner you described, but they were really unwilling to do it in OTL and lacked a coherent vision for the future of China despite the fact that the country was a Republic. Here it's a monarchy ruled by warlords, and suddenly it receives truckloads of cash?

While China Hands like Lansing really wanted China to participate to the war and proposed modest loans for China from an international bankers' consortium in exchange for moving an army of 100 000 Chinese soldiers to France, no money ever flowed in OTL.

I liked the Mao part a lot. Social Darwinist and racialist theories were surprisingly popular in China, and in OTL they were used to fuel anti-Manchu sentiments, explaining China's woes and troubles to the fact that the Han had allowed themselves to be turned into "slaves of slaves", being bossed around by Manchus who were in turn controlled by European imperialists. The legions of veterans returning from the war in France will undoubtedly be filled with these kind of radical visions, and that will mean interesting times for the dynasty in the near future.
 
Update time :D.


Chapter III: The Peace of Versailles and China’s Russian Adventure 1918-1922.

With the Central Powers defeated, peace negotiations could begin and China had suffered enough casualties to merit a seat at the conference table, although its delegation was completely overshadowed by the Big Four (the United States, Great Britain, France and Italy). China had little proverbial weight to throw around and their delegates were almost treated like they should be grateful to be allowed to merely look on as the great powers redrew the map of the world. The Treaty of Versailles signed in 1919 confirmed the annexation of Tsingtao by China and reserved a small amount of war reparations reserved for the Empire of China. From 1914, China increasingly referred to itself that way on official documents instead of “Empire of the Great Qing”, expressing the Han Chinese nationalist nature of the regime.

It also exemplified the, at the time, irrelevance of the dynasty and of the 13 year-old Xuantong Emperor who lived as a virtual recluse in the Forbidden City in Beijing. That didn’t change that an imperial dynasty always had a certain grandeur and allure that a republican government just lacked. And there was nothing like a military victory to revive faith in the Mandate of Heaven. By 1919, the Qing dynasty still commanded the loyalty of many and could rely on an upsurge in monarchism, in sharp contrast to the anti-monarchist feelings that had reached a boiling point only 7-8 years ago. That barely translated into practical power, even within the Forbidden City, since reports continued to reach the Emperor of thefts and because he overheard frightening conversations concerning plans to assassinate him. After he had ordered an investigation into thefts from the Emperor’s storage rooms, a fire was set in June 1923 near the Palace of Established Happiness to cover up such theft. The first decision in his life that the 17 year-old ruler made on his own accord, rather than as a puppet, was to dismiss almost all of his eunuchs and have the leading eunuchs executed by beheading.

It was a harsh decision, but he felt he needed to set an example if anybody was to take him seriously, and he didn’t stop there with his reforms of the imperial court. Ever since his mother had committed suicide by taking an opium overdose, the Xuantong Emperor had come to detest opium and in 1924 he resolved to have everyone caught using it within the Forbidden City’s walls whipped (unfortunately he could do little to stop opium use in the rest of the country, which in places was a social epidemic). He also replaced many of the traditional aristocratic officers in the Household Department with outsiders to improve accountability. The young and ambitious Emperor, as a Western educated man, was a major proponent of modernization. A Western-style oil painting of himself that he ordered in 1925 depicted him wearing a modern military uniform rather than traditional Manchu robes. The uniform drew heavily from a French Colonel’s uniform – which was his honorary rank within the French army – but also incorporated the imperial yellow and Qing symbols.

Around the mid 1920s, the Emperor started to organize receptions, inviting important Chinese as well as foreign businessmen and heads of state to his palace. He combined personal charm, his lessons in Western etiquette as well as traditional Chinese customs, depending on what crowd he was entertaining at the time. Additionally, he used his considerable wealth, the renewed prestige of his imperial dynasty and his status as a God to propel many a career forward. He weaved a network of his own through political patronage and imperial favour to get a serious sway over the military regime, though no absolute power.

In the meantime, the West’s arrogant attitude was annoying, but for the moment the Chinese celebratory triumphant mood remained unperturbed, until the next insult came. The Chinese government had calculated how much money the Allies had saved by use of low wage Chinese labour, imports of cheap Chinese raw materials and supplies of cheap Chinese rice and potatoes at discount rates to the frontline troops. Additionally, through complicated calculations, the Chinese government had quantified in money how much Western human capital had been spared through Chinese casualties. The Chinese government considered this another form of paying the war reparations owed due to the Boxer Protocol, but the cash strapped British and French governments thought otherwise. They snubbed the Chinese delegation by refusing proposals for debt reduction, or at the least lowered interest rates, smaller payments or postponement of payment. A violent demonstration on July 4th 1919 in Beijing at Tiananmen Square, right next to the Beijing Legation Quarter, was the result. The West feared a repeat of the Boxers’ anti-Western violence. General Duan Qirui (who had succeeded Yuan Shikai as Prime Minister after he had died of a heart attack in February 1919, aged 59) reluctantly put down the “July 4th Movement” even though he agreed with them. He feared Western intervention in the event of escalation, knowing that the New Army couldn’t resist foreign invasion despite having doubled in size to 600.000 men in the past four years. To express his dissatisfaction, his government failed to ratify the Treaty of Versailles and instead signed a separate peace with Germany in which Germany acknowledged China’s annexation of Tsingtao.

Duan Qirui redirected Chinese frustrations to the north where China’s Tsarist neighbour had collapsed into revolution and civil war between the Bolshevik Red Army and the loosely allied forces known as the White Army, which included diverse interests favouring monarchism, capitalism and even alternative forms of socialism. Over 200.000 soldiers of the Imperial Chinese Army attacked the Russian Far East and easily pushed the disparate forces there across the Stanovoy Mountains. China annexed the entire area north of the Amur River all the way up to the Stanovoy Mountains. It had been a part of China before, namely since the signing of the Treaty of Nerchinsk between Russia and China in 1689. The Treaty of Aigun signed in 1858, as one of the unequal treaties, had reversed the Treaty of Nerchinsk and had awarded over 600.000 square kilometres (~ 232.000 square miles) of land to the Russian Empire, an area roughly as big as the Ukraine. Like the Russian government in 1858 had picked on a dying giant, the Chinese government did the same after the Great War. Admiral Alexander Kolchak, the “Supreme Ruler” of the “Provisional All-Russian Government”, signed the Treaty of Irkutsk recognizing the new border.

The fact that Kolchak was more of a warlord than a “Supreme Ruler” was signified by the fact that a “Yellow race” could force him to sign such a treaty. Kolchak considered that to be humiliating since (according to the rather racist ideas of the time) the white man was supposed to be superior and because only a few years earlier Russia could have beaten up China at its leisure. Kolchak, however, was pragmatic and used all the support he could get against the Bolsheviks: the Chinese supplied him with weapons, ammunition and food supplies, mainly rice, potatoes, bread and fish. Not only that, the Chinese deployed four infantry and two cavalry divisions or some 75.000 men because they had no interest in seeing the Bolsheviks win. Kolchak’s armies were wildly successful in spring and summer 1919: they took Archangel, Ufa, Samara and Saratov, conquering an area of 300.000 square kilometres inhabited by about 7 million people.

In sharp contrast to their major victories west of the Urals, Kolchak’s government had to tolerate the fait accompli of the Chinese sponsored declaration of independence of the SakhaRepublic. Formerly known as Yakutsia under Russian rule, the Sakha Republic declared independence on July 8th 1919 with Chinese support. With a size of nearly 3.1 million square kilometres it was a big country, bigger than Argentina in fact, but in terms of population it was tiny: in 1918 the Sakha Republic was inhabited by ~ 285.000 people, or about 0.09 per square kilometre; in other words, an area of 10.000 hectares or 25.000 acres was inhabited by 90 people on average (by comparison, Luxembourg had a population of about 263.000 or 102 people per square kilometre). 80% of the new country’s populace consisted of the Turkic Yakut or Sakha people and the second largest ethnic group were the Russians with about 10%. Ethnic Chinese were almost absent at the time, but within a decade there would be a Chinese community of about 10.000 (almost completely concentrated in the capital of Yakutsia). As far as soldiers went, the sparsely populated Sakha Republic could provide China with little reinforcements, but in terms of natural resources it would prove a boon: it contained large unexploited reserves of oil, natural gas, coal, diamonds, gold, silver, tin and tungsten. At the time, the SakhaRepublic’s main exports, however, were timber, furs, fish and meat (from game as well as the cattle owned by nomadic people).

By 1922, Kolchak’s government had subdued the Bolskeviks and most of the countries that had broken away to enjoy a short-lived independence. The “Little Russians” living in Ukraine and Belarus were forcibly returned to the fold of the motherland by their “Slavic brethren” despite their objections. Georgia, Armenia, Azerbaijan and Central Asia were also subjugated by the White Russian armies, which had been unified under Kolchak’s effective military junta. Finland, the Baltic States and Poland, however, managed to rebuff Russian military aggression and maintain their independence. An ultranationalist, xenophobic, Russian Orthodox, militaristic regime was installed in Petrograd headed by Kolchak and anti-Semitic pogroms swept through the country wherever the White Russian armies triumphed. Anti-Semitic violence killed an estimated total of 5.000 Jews, destroyed thousands of Jewish businesses and saw the burning and looting of hundreds of synagogues, Jews being seen as Bolshevik collaborators.

Tsar Nicholas II and his family, including heir to the throne Alexei, had been dead and buried for four years by the end of the civil war in 1922, and the Tsar’s brother and second in line to the throne Grand Duke Michael was presumed dead too. Sometimes there were supposed sightings of Alexei, Anastasia or even the Tsar’s entire family, but none of those were ever confirmed. At any rate, Nicholas II had abdicated in his own name as well as his son’s and Michael had abdicated after just one day of rule because there was no support for him as Tsar. As third in line to the throne, Nicholas’s cousin Grand Duke Cyril rightfully assumed leadership of the Romanov family in accordance with the house succession laws established by Paul I in 1797. In 1923, after an interregnum of five years, the government announced the restoration of the monarchy and Grand Duke Cyril was crowned Emperor and Autocrat of all the Russias in the Dormition Cathedral in Moscow as Tsar Cyril I. He was to be the rallying symbol of the extremely nationalist regime and he would give the regime a semi-sacred aura since he ruled by the grace of God. Despite Bolshevik efforts to stamp out all religion during their short-lived rule, most Russians were still religious and often also superstitious. Besides that, Tsar Cyril’s cousin Nicholas II and his family had been canonized as passion bearers by the Russian Orthodox Church the previous year.

The renewed Russian Empire, however, was a shadow of the old one. It had suffered 4.9 million military deaths and innumerable civilian casualties in the Great War and the subsequent Russian Civil War, a period of uninterrupted conflict from 1914 to 1922. This had completely disrupted Russian society and the country’s economy, bringing with it destitution, disease, famine, scarcity and the spectre of economic stagnation and hyperinflation. Radical political movements formed in response, mostly extreme right wing organizations with Bolshevism discredited. Additionally, Kolchak was now known as Vozhd, which meant as much as “boss” or “chief”, while the Tsar was just a figurehead. Besides that, Russia had lost more than a quarter of its territory and was overshadowed by a lumbering giant to the east that was finally waking up from its long slumber.

Kolchak accepted the territorial losses to the east since the lands there were just sparsely populated frozen wastelands anyway, at least as far as was known at the time. He directed the fury of a rejuvenated Russian Empire westward, exemplified most prominently by a vitriolic hostility towards the independence of Poland (Poland was considered a Western puppet that was being kept from returning to Mother Russia’s fold). Russia also took another look at its ambitions toward the Bosporus and the Persian Gulf and reignited the “Great Game” with Britain (the original Great Game was a strategic rivalry between the British Empire and the Russian Empire for supremacy in Central Asia that had lasted from 1813 to 1907). Russia engaged in serious deficit spending to jump start industrialization and to finance major public works, including a major expansion of the railroad network. Russia felt humiliated and strived to restore its great power status by reassuming its dominant position in Eastern Europe and by displacing Great Britain as the dominant power in the Middle East. China sponsored Russian ambitions, for as far as it was able to, because it distracted Beijing’s European rivals from East Asian affairs.

Another drawback of the deal with the Chinese devil, however, was that Russia couldn’t do anything about the somewhat smaller Japanese devil either, at least not any more than China was willing to do. The Japanese government witnessed Chinese success and landed 70.000 troops which seized control of Kamchatka, Chukotka, Magadan and the northern part of Khabarovsk (the part of Khabarovsk south of the Stanovoy Mountains was under Chinese control). It was an area of more than 2 million square kilometres, an area larger than Mexico, but it was inhabited by only a few hundred thousand people, which were soon complemented by tens of thousands of Japanese. A puppet regime was installed in the capital of Petropavlovsk that controlled the so-called “Republic of Petropavlovsk.” Northern Sakhalin was annexed outright by Japan. In order to stop the Japanese, the Russians would have to go through the Chinese-controlledSakhaRepublic, but China wasn’t about to let them. China feared a war with Japan, knowing Japan’s forces were still superior and that Japan was a British ally, and China allowed Japan to annex eastern Russia. A war against Britain and Japan was a bit more than China could handle at this time, but Chinese growth wasn’t over yet.
 
Last edited:
I'm sure Russian nationalists and Yellow Peril paranoids will love the new status quo in Northeast Asia.
 
How about a Central Powers' Qing Dynasty version, if you like? And, a WW1 that lasts into 1919 or longer if the Central Powers don't win.
 
Out of 7.000 men, 3.000 Chinese soldiers were killed, wounded or missing in action, a casualty rate the likes of which the New Army had never experienced.

I would have thought the assault on Tsingtao would have been comparably bloody for the troops engaged. The Germans would be dug in with machine guns, and the Chinese, lacking artillery but awash in manpower, would resort to frontal attacks. The Japanese at Port Arthur got badly chewed up by the Russian defenses in a similar situation.

The “Chinese Expeditionary Force” was sent to a quiet sector of the front in Alsace-Lorraine to recuperate and with reinforcements it would eventually swell to a force of four divisions, or 50.000 men, by 1917. It fought with distinction in the Battle of Passchendaele, weathered the German Spring Offensive during the Battle of the Lys, and helped achieve an Entente victory in the Fifth Battle of Ypres.

The commander of the Chinese Expeditionary Force was Chiang Kai-shek. ... By 1919, when he returned home to China, he... had also learnt to speak French and to a lesser extent English...
With the CEF in action almost entirely in the British sector of the front, wouldn't Chiang learn English better than French?

The result was a few thousand interracial relations between French women and Chinese men, several hundred of which resulted in marriages after the grooms had agreed to convert to Catholicism pro forma (a small number, but not surprising considering the taboo on interracial relationships...
But France didn't really have such a taboo, compared to the anglosphere. Of course what I've heard of has mostly been white male-non-white-female unions, so the reverse could be a factor. But then also France was very short of men after the War. Also, religious conversions wouldn't be a big factor. France was once intensely Catholic, but by this time, laïcité was dominant. A large proportion of marriages were civil only. Any French woman who would marry a Chinaman would be pretty much secular.

After the war, a Chinese community of a few thousand remained in Paris...
London's "Chinatown" in Limehouse dated back to about 1890; but that was because London was a seaport. Wiki sez Paris had a Chinese district before the war, in the 3rd Arrondissement.

...and many became intellectuals.

Among them was a young man named Mao Zedong... killed in action in October 1918...
There seems to be sequence error here: if Mao is KIA in 1918, he can't be among the postwar intellectuals. Also, it seems unlikely that as a junior combat officer he would have leisure to read and write, or resources to publish.
 
Last edited:
The Treaty of Versailles signed in 1919 confirmed the annexation of Tsingtao by China and reserved a small amount of war reparations reserved for the Empire of China.

And Japan does nothing and just lets things pass?

The first decision in his life that the 17 year-old ruler made on his own accord, rather than as a puppet, was to dismiss almost all of his eunuchs and have the leading eunuchs executed by beheading.

A wise move - they were an endless source of intrigue in OTL.

He also replaced many of the traditional aristocratic officers in the Household Department with outsiders to improve accountability.

Han or Manchu outsiders?

The Chinese government considered this another form of paying the war reparations owed due to the Boxer Protocol, but the cash strapped British and French governments thought otherwise. They snubbed the Chinese delegation by refusing proposals for debt reduction, or at the least lowered interest rates, smaller payments or postponement of payment. A violent demonstration on
July 4th 1919 in Beijing at Tiananmen Square, right next to the Beijing Legation Quarter, was the result. The West feared a repeat of the Boxers’ anti-Western violence. General Duan Qirui (who had succeeded Yuan Shikai as Prime Minister after he had died of a heart attack in February 1919, aged 59) reluctantly put down the “July 4th Movement” even though he agreed with them. He feared Western intervention in the event of escalation, knowing that the New Army couldn’t resist foreign invasion despite having doubled in size to 600.000 men in the past four years. To express his dissatisfaction, his government failed to ratify the Treaty of Versailles and instead signed a separate peace with Germany in which Germany acknowledged China’s annexation of Tsingtao.

If China decides to check the bluff of Western powers, Britain and France are in no position to re-enforce the Boxer protocols.

Duan Qirui redirected Chinese frustrations to the north where
China’s Tsarist neighbour had collapsed into revolution and civil war between the Bolshevik Red Army and the loosely allied forces known as the White Army, which included diverse interests favouring monarchism, capitalism and even alternative forms of socialism. Over 200.000 soldiers of the Imperial Chinese Army attacked the Russian Far East and easily pushed the disparate forces there across the Stanovoy Mountains. China annexed the entire area north of the Amur River all the way up to the Stanovoy Mountains.


Why is the Japanese policy towards China completely reversed to OTL? They did have proponents of a cooperative policy with a strong China, but in OTL Japan had the power to disintegrate the whole country - here they just somehow stay put and ignore everything that happens in China?

feared a war with Japan, knowing Japan’s forces were still superior and that Japan was a British ally, and China allowed Japan to annex eastern Russia. A war against Britain and Japan was a bit more than China could handle at this time, but Chinese growth wasn’t over yet.

Especially since China - correctly - fears the Japanese reaction that somehow never materializes through these stunning foreign policy coups.
 
Hmm, interesting. We have a revanchanistic Russia that is going to want to take back what it lost to China. My question is, wouldn't Kolchak be viewed as a traitor by Russian nationalists, as opposed to their icon? An interesting scenario here would be a less crazy Fascist Germany, Italy, and Russia vs the European allies and China. The wild card here is Japan... might I suggest a SSJW started by the Chinese? Hell, they could even do a Pacific War against the Brits. I am interested to see where this goes.
 
Top