Nominee Shot Thrice: A TL of a different 1912 presidential race

Introduction
Introduction
At the end of the democratic national convention of 1912, woodrow wilson descends the stage on the sunny day of july second, however during his final speech, a shot rangs out. Suddenly the presidential nominee is bleeding out on the floor choking. Wilson, while he survives, has been shot three times, once in the right side of his ear next to his head, and twice in his arm. He is blind in one eyes, deaf in his right ear, and will never be able to use his legs or right arm ever again. A few hours later the assassin is revealed by the FBI to be ben hanford, a major socialist, and is aprehended a few days later. ONly an hour after the FBI gives this information out the Democratic convention goers, tired after the multiple days of voting quickly vote in Champ Clark.
champ-fronton.jpg


Champ Clark quickly gives a muddled speach on how the democrats will take the white house and will work on social reform, against american intervention in europe or anywhere else and the Giving of the colonial territories in the carribean and pacific liek the phillipines, Cuba, Puerto Rico, and alaska that were aquaited by "evil Terms". John Burke, a strong pro-wilson advocate, decides to campaign as an independent seeing Clark as a hinderance on the american spirit, even understanding he will probally not win because of his catholic Belief. Champ clark and burke begin fighting for the democrat vote, burke being strongly progressive, showing his furvor for the ideology, attacks champ saying he does not taken strong enough action and champ responding by accusing burke of being to interventionist.
MTE1ODA0OTcxNzcxOTg3NDY5.jpg
Roosevelt win the mean time has already lost the republican nomination, creates the progressive party, hoping to draw in the progressive politicians on both sides, many expect to Draw in both conservatives and progressives from the republican party, he instead attacks both parties for being corrupt and makes major issues of his run School Reform, Universal suffrage, and limiting big buisness. He begins to quickly becomes recognized as a major canidate.

7938-004-ABC872A5.jpg
Another proponent arises, eugene debs, who begins running under the ticket of a socialist party. He hopes to win the hearts of what is known today as the rust belt and grain belts. He is however hinderred as his original vice-president assinated nominee Woodrow wilson and now must fight against the other 3 progressive groups.

Finally Taft Runs under a mish-mash of progressive and conservative ideology trying to unify the republican party but only truly hurting his chances of presidency.

This begins the 1912 election, burke beginning his campaign in Helena, Taft and Roosevelt in New York, Clark in Philadelphia, and Debs in Ohio.

I'm writing this up but i may not be able to get the next part of the timeline/story written up until the weekend, I know where i want this to go but I have finals on friday
 
Last edited:
Burke's campaign seems unlikely. The Democrats had been out of power for 16 years, and 1912 was clearly a big opportunity for them. I can't imagine Burke (who was he? Governor of North Dakota) thinking he can win, especially since he is a Catholic. And there is little point to splitting the Democrat vote except to help Roosevelt or Taft win.
 
Burke's campaign seems unlikely. The Democrats had been out of power for 16 years, and 1912 was clearly a big opportunity for them. I can't imagine Burke (who was he? Governor of North Dakota) thinking he can win, especially since he is a Catholic. And there is little point to splitting the Democrat vote except to help Roosevelt or Taft win.
Definetly, However you also need to take into account that it's more of a game for splitting the votes, the socialists and republicans can only really split the vote for everyone else.
 
Last edited:
Ooh, a four-way race for President. On one hand, it sounds like an awesome idea that could play out with all kinds of butterflies. On the other hand...damn, that was one of my ideas, but I stick to football anyway, so Godspeed.
 
A couple of problems here...

Ben Hanford had been dead since 1910. Given your actual POD is in 1898 with, I presume, the failure of the Teller Amendment, I suppose it's not a huge stretch to somehow have Hanford avoid or recover from the illness of 1908-9 that killed him and be willing to venture out into the campaign trail for a third try with Debs.

John Burke was a long-time Bryanite ally and had been floated as an acceptable compromise candidate for Vice President, had it not been for the Indiana bargain that got Marshall the Vice Presidency. I find it hard to believe he'd break with the party in that fashion.

Additionally, Clark was one of the sharpest voices for getting out of the colonial and territorial business: his speeches against the Philippines show he had no interest in permitting them statehood, largely for racist reasons. I find it hard to believe he wants to convert occupied Caribbean possessions into states.
 
A couple of problems here...

Ben Hanford had been dead since 1910. Given your actual POD is in 1898 with, I presume, the failure of the Teller Amendment, I suppose it's not a huge stretch to somehow have Hanford avoid or recover from the illness of 1908-9 that killed him and be willing to venture out into the campaign trail for a third try with Debs.

John Burke was a long-time Bryanite ally and had been floated as an acceptable compromise candidate for Vice President, had it not been for the Indiana bargain that got Marshall the Vice Presidency. I find it hard to believe he'd break with the party in that fashion.

Additionally, Clark was one of the sharpest voices for getting out of the colonial and territorial business: his speeches against the Philippines show he had no interest in permitting them statehood, largely for racist reasons. I find it hard to believe he wants to convert occupied Caribbean possessions into states.

Fair to all three, but from some of the research I did on Burke Ben gave up the vice presidency so the Indiana delegation we would vote for wilson

Interesting
 
Lead to 1912 election
The lead up to Fate
August-November
(the last primary was held by the progressives during july,Instead of august OTL)


Major Events-

August 4- US marines are stationed in nicaragua to ease tensions between the inhabitants and conservative government

August 16- New mexico and Arizona combine into one state because of complaints that they do not have a large enough population

august 18- the michigan secessionist bill is put on Michigans ballot.
September 2- the house of representatives, after having to deal with fighting in the state of Wyoming and Idaho between mormons, natives, an anarchist cell, and other groups, he decides to divide the two states up between other states, while utah, colorado, and washington make bids on some areas, a large part goes unwanted, so Taft creates the shoshone and Nez perce territories.

September 14- Ben hanford pleads not guilty, he is eventually found innnocent as the FBI finds evidence that pedro Ivonett, a Cuban black and supporter of the PIC was also at the scene .

October 8- The First balkan war begins

October 16- The first bombing with an airplane is conducted by serbian nationalists

october 22- Pedro Ivonett is found guily after a court hearing, he is sentenced to death by electric chair the next day, soldiers are sent to cuba to
Progressives
Roosevelt decided to target the Rust belt by being a major advocate of anti-trust laws and the western united states by being for the creation of unions and spread of national schooling, He advocated for the readmittance of the states of shoshone and Nez perce and creation of the state of the Phillipines and Cuba. he lost some followers when he took back his stance on full suffrage, making it an issue of the states, but won many after making Charles E. Hughes his VP and hiram johnson his replacement in the supreme court and by his imense determination on continuing his conservation acts. He became suprisingly popular throughout the western united states even though he never set foot in that region. A major part of the campaign was his anti-isolationism anti-tariff nature.

Democrats
Clark, suprised by the sudden nomination, decided to make williams jennings bryan his VP nominee, dropping his favoring as Bryan lost to mckinley in the 1900. He begins his campaign starting in philedelphia and soon travels to richmond, much of his remaining campaign days are in richmond where he works to build up southern vote, after a terrible beginning he became a major player in the election by making it a must to apply universal suffrage, Income tax and reform in education. He is able to be a formiddable opponent to roosevelt but is greatly hinderred by his late start and burke. He

Republicans
Taft, still trying to unite the republicans, fights for universal suffrage, but loses the progressives to being ok with the trusts, conservatives see him as a weak point and instead look for better groups. He works to visit every state, this hinders him and during a Q&A after answerring a question on income tax with "NO, It is a basic violation of ur rights." However because of bad reporting the general public did not hear of this.

Socialists
Debs decides to campaign heavily in the bread basket, a unique idea to say the least, while this does get him somewhere in areas like Iowa. He stood for universal suffrage and even spoke of leading the army to murder Rockefeller, Ford, and all other buisnessmen to create the capitol of workr rights. Many turned away when he said such things, however he was still allowed to speak throughout the USA, while he did make a quick spin in the rust belt he was generally disregarded for roosevelt. He is slow when picking a VP, finally making Allan L. Benson his on Oct. 23

Independent
Burke makes Thomas Marshall his Vp quickly and begins campaigning, he focuses heavily on the eastern and northern USa, beginning in helena he begins the campaign trail in helena, quickly marching to seatle, going through montanna again, and then campaigning in Nort dakota, minnesota, over to New York, and then down to georgia. He is almost killed by a KKK member during a stop in Chicago because of his catholicism, he makes suffrage, an income tax, anti-tarrif, and anti-Trusts.

 
Last edited:
How do the Bull Moose's chances look in 1912?
Well, As wilson is gone, the real competition is the democrats and progressives, they've been equalled out at this point as Clark, a progressive who didn't really doesn't do much ever, is the leader of the democrats, It's all a question of who will get the most votes taken from them



 
Election 1912
Election
Map of 1912 election.png

The 1912 election ended with a stunning the New progressive party winning a large majority. The democrats soon began to fall apart after having lost elections for the last 20 years. Many progressive democrats flock to theodore roosevelt, while the multiple conservative republicans begin to try to find something to rally under now that their party is destroyed.

While The socialist debs deafinetly won a great part of kansas, nebraska, Illinois, and missouri, (at the least around 35%) HE loses a large portion to the progressives, only carrying iowa. BUrke also had a large following in texas, florida, and georgia, only losing by no more than 5% to the democrats. Burke took a huge bite out of the western states from roosevelt, but He was still able to hold them with his promise of unions and much more.

In roosevelts inauguration speech he urges the american people to "come together after such a rocky election so we may work together to create an america that is not only better, but truly the best it can be" In a surprise jump he makes his secretary of state Woodrow wilson. Who, while paralyzed below the hips and still in recovery, accepts the position. Howard Taft in a later speech anounces he sees Roosevelts success as "the end of democracy and the status quo" He eventually takes up home in his native Ohio.

Roosevelt success is seen by most of america, especially among the working class, of a new era where they will rise from the current poverty. Roosevelt now having won the nomination, looks across the sea at the worsening situation in europe. He and the Prime minister of Great britain meet in Montreal to speak of the situation and sign a neutrality act, stating they will not interfer in foreign affairs unless directly targeted, and if targeted both will begin war .

The future seems bright for America. But only time can tell.
 
Top