Iron and Longships, Another Vinland TL

This will be another take on my first TL, Iron and Longships, A Vinland TL, it will be both similar and different to the first TL. That being said please enjoy my work and comment if you want to see more.


The beginning of this section is in the year 1000 Anno Domini with the origin story of Leifsbuðir (Or Leifsbudir using modern letters). The story is known as the Vinland sagas to those modern Norsemen who live in what became Vinland. The Vinland Sagas are a tale of historical importance that were only written down after the events happened, so what is discussed here may not be entirely accurate from a historical context as history is written by the victors. The first section of what is traditionally known as the Vinland Sagas is also called the Saga of the Greenlanders as it describes the discovery and colonization of Greenland by Erik the Red, however for the purposes of this book that Saga has been skipped and can be read in my book, A history of the Birth, Collapse, and Rebirth of Greenland. The Vinland Sagas themselves have been altered several times by historical revisionists to give a more accurate telling of the past, it is those revised versions of the Vinland Sagas that will be used in this book.

-Author’s note in, A history of early Vinland, 4th Edition, by Professor Jónatan Ármannsson of the University of Miklagard


Book I, Vinland Sagas, approximately 1000 AD – approximate 1001 AD

It is said that Leif Eriksson first learned of the land that would become Vinland from a fisherman, whose name has been lost to the annals of history, that was blown off course westwards and sighted land that is now believed to be the coast of Markland due to a description of large amounts of trees along the coastline. Leif Eriksson departed with 4 ships and 160 men along with the fisherman as their guide. Their first landing was a rocky area that Leif eventually named Helluland. The men were getting a bit demoralized by their failure to find the lands the fisherman had described on their first try. However after a few more weeks at sea they sighted a forested land that they disembarked on to gain supplies, of which they were running out. While they were on the land searching for food Leif decided to name the place Markland, due to the woods along the coastline. By the time his men returned it was almost nightfall and 3 of them had lost their lives in a skirmish with what we now know were the native Innu or Dorset people, it is unknown which tribal group it was. Apparently the men had won the skirmish and taken 5 natives as prisoners to replace the 3 lost Norsemen as rowers. They also returned with the bodies of their dead, which were burned.

It is at this point that the word Skraeling as a word to describe the natives of Vinland enters the vocabulary of the Norse. Skraeling in Old Norse means foreigner or barbarian; it is believed that this name was given to them due to initially hostile interaction between the Old Norse and Native populations. The men of Leif’s company camp on the coast for the night with armed guards, though there is no incident that night. The men get back on their boats and sail southwards, charting the coastline along the way so they can return safely. They spend a bit more time then they originally intended to though and end up having to spend the winter at the tip of a peninsula in the south when one of their ships collides with some rocks and breaks the Keel, making it unable to be repaired. The land they disembark in is named by Leif Eriksson as Vinland, as he had been planning how to colonize the region and decided to follow in his father’s footsteps and make the name appealing to future settlers, Vinland roughly translates to grapeland/wineland or pastureland in Old Norse. He chose this name also due to wild berries he observed in the region.

While they winter they name the settlement they construct out of the broken ship and felled trees Leifsbuðir, or Leif’s booth, with booth referring to what passed for a house to them. Leifsbuðir survived off of hunting the plentiful game in the region and picking wild berries. Apparently it was a good idea that they had those 5 Skraeling from Markland with them, they had been forced to cooperate with the Norsemen for their own survival and showed them what was safe to eat and several hunting and tracking methods unknown to the Norse. The two groups communicated through use of hand signals and a rudimentary understanding of Old Norse by the Skraeling. Leifsbuðir had been attacked by another native group, now known by modern historians as the Beothuk, around 3 times throughout the winter and each time was met with defeat at the hands of the Norse due to superior Iron weaponry and armour. A raid against the local tribal group led my Leif Eriksson made it clear that the tribe was suffering from an outbreak of Smallpox and was forced to raid nearby people to sustain itself due to its loss of available manpower. Leif supposedly took pity on them and killed all of the sick and burned the bodies, taking the rest of the tribe to Leifsbuðir to work with the Norse for mutual survival. It may seem like killing the sick and burning the bodies isn’t exactly pity but Leif understood that if the people kept on tending to the sick they would never survive, he also knew that Smallpox could still spread by a dead body and that burning it was the best treatment. By the time winter was over the Skraeling had become fluent in Old Norse but had mixed in some of their own native words for things that the Norsemen had not known about. Leif Erikson leaves Leifsbuðir once the ice melts with 3 ships and 110 men, leaving behind 47 Norsemen and an unknown number of Skraeling, though it is known that he brought with him 2 Skraeling back to Greenland and that several of the Skraeling left in Leifsbuðir were women. It is also known that the 2 Skraeling he brought with him were from different tribes, one an Innu or Dorset from Markland and one Beothuk from Vinland.
 
Subscribed, please keep it coming :)

But two problems, one edit your grammar (or find a friend to do so), please. I kept stumbling over minor mistakes.

Second, smallpox had not reached greenland at this point, much less iceland. So it would be impossible to cause a smallpox outbreak.
 
It's a good idea to restart this TL, because your first try had a major problem. Instead of concentrating on the exploration and colonisation of Vinland you have made too many changes in Europe, changes which cannot explained with the PoD. After the end of age of Vikings (which happened around the PoD) events in western Skandinavia had no impact on the Holy Roman Empire or other European realms.
So I hope that such things like muslim conquest of America (suggested by some in the old TL), major changes in the ruling dynasties of the HRE in the 11th and 12th century etc. will not happen. I believe that a larger and permanent settlement in Vinland will affect the rest of Europe several centuries later when Age of Exploration starts. The expedition of Corte-Real and Pining in the 15th century for example will either not happen because contact with Greenland was never lost or will bring back news of a new continent.

EDIT: there is a big mistake in your TL. Vinland does not mean land of wine but land of pasture. Vin does not mean wine but pasture. Vín means wine.
 
They spend a bit more time then they originally intended to though and end up having to spend the winter at the tip of a peninsula in the south when one of their ships collides with some rocks and breaks the Keel, making it unable to be repaired.
Is this the PoD?
 

Is this the PoD?

The POD is that the Vinland colony succeeds rather than fails. It failed IRL because of lack of trade with the natives and too much war with them. ITTL they are able to make good relations with several nearby natives and start up some small-scale trading. At least it's small-scale now.
 
Subscribed, please keep it coming :)

But two problems, one edit your grammar (or find a friend to do so), please. I kept stumbling over minor mistakes.

Second, smallpox had not reached greenland at this point, much less iceland. So it would be impossible to cause a smallpox outbreak.

1) Will do, I have King Nazar read them over but he seems to miss stuff.

2) Fascinating, I did not know this. I should edit to something else, like the flu (as per Faeelin's suggestion). Do you know when smallpox did hit Greenland? Cause that disease is kind of important.
 
Fascinating, I did not know this. I should edit to something else, like the flu (as per Faeelin's suggestion). Do you know when smallpox did hit Greenland? Cause that disease is kind of important.

I could be wrong on this, but I don't think smallpox ever did affect greenland in a major way. it wasn't until the 13th-14th century that it hit Iceland.

And considering the Norse did interact with the natives for nearly 500 years, I don't see a pandemic being very likely. (long voyages tend to weed out the sick people rather quickly). But that being said, i would go with a flu of some sort. The norse did have pigs, and did bring them to Vinland, and their way-stations along the way (ie, north newfoundland, etc). So...maybe invent a sort of "swine-flu"?
 
And considering the Norse did interact with the natives for nearly 500 years, I don't see a pandemic being very likely. (long voyages tend to weed out the sick people rather quickly). But that being said, i would go with a flu of some sort. The norse did have pigs, and did bring them to Vinland, and their way-stations along the way (ie, north newfoundland, etc). So...maybe invent a sort of "swine-flu"?
And this year's apple product shall be called Angry Ravens! :D
 
[FONT=&quot]Book I, Vinland Sagas, approximately 1001 AD – approximate 1003 AD[/FONT]
[FONT=&quot] [/FONT]
[FONT=&quot]Leif returns to Eystribyggð (Greenland colony’s eastern settlement) and eagerly tells his father Erik the Red of the lands discovered to the west at his family estate of Brattahlíð. There the two Skraeling that Leif brought with him were put to good use to prove that the lands were habitable and better than anything in Greenland, which was partially true. The Skraeling told stories of their homelands, how they lived, what they ate, and who they worshiped. Erik the Red was said to have become fascinated in converting the Skraeling population to Christianity as a form of penance after his banishment from Norway. As such Erik sponsors a second expedition to Vinland, this time laden with colonists from Greenland, mostly families who no longer had a livelihood due to the harsher than normal winter this year. This expedition was to be headed by Leif’s son Thorgils, who became incredibly fascinated by the lands to the west.[/FONT]
[FONT=&quot] [/FONT]
[FONT=&quot]Rather soon after arriving the very boats that returned are now going back to Vinland, though not with the same crew. Now the 3 ships are laden with colonists, supplies of preserved foods, seeds to start farms, metal tools (Leif’s original men only had weapons and axes, no hoes or hammers or anything like that), and a host of other equipment. Notable colonists include Norse women, as several family units are being sent over. Thorgils lands at Leifsbuðir and deposits the families, some of them with children and pregnant woman, and aids in the overseeing of the settlement and construction of houses and farms. Thorgils’ journal describes that several of the native women from the tribe Leif encountered were pregnant or with very young children of light complexion compared to their mothers. It is now assumed that these women were some of the first to bear mixed race children in Vinland. Part of why Thorgils is there is to construct a Church, even bringing with him a holy man from Eystribyggð. Construction only begins after the necessities to support the influx of people are taken care of.[/FONT]
[FONT=&quot] [/FONT]
[FONT=&quot]Supposedly the church was built entirely out of wood, as there was quite a surplus of the material due to clearing of forests for farmsteads. The holy man that accompanied Thorgils was reportedly upset, as he thought that the house of god should have been built out of stone since it was deemed more important than the homes of the peasant people, at least by the holy man. Thorgils supposedly countered with the fact that there were no stonecutters or quarries nearby with which to gain stone of a quality to construct anything, let alone the house of god. The church can always be upgraded later, but getting it operational was seen as more important by Thorgils. By the time the church was finished winter was upon them and the settlement survived the winter with relative ease.[/FONT]
[FONT=&quot] [/FONT]
[FONT=&quot]When the winter months end Thorgils departs with his ships and men and sails southwards to chart out the nearby area and plan some locations for settlement. During this voyage Thorgils hugs the coastline so as to properly chart it and at the farthest east and south he finds what was written down as, “More fish than even the fattest of Norwegian nobility could consume in a lifetime.” This was the discovery of Vinland’s grand banks, a very large area with an extreme surplus of fish, primarily Atlantic Cod. Thorgils was surprised by the bounty of this new world, the amounts of lumber and fish seemed almost too good to be true, his men had even been brought samples of Bog Iron from the coastline when they needed to forage for supplies to supplement their existing stocks of food in their ships. Thorgils continued to follow the coast and chart it until he eventually ended up back at Leifsbuðir, having discovered that Vinland is in fact an island, one which he claimed was larger than Ireland.[/FONT]
[FONT=&quot] [/FONT]
[FONT=&quot]Returning to the settlement Thorgils spun tales of the bounty of fish to the south, several of his sailors and some settlers in Leifsbuðir travel south to set up a colony there with one of Thorgils’ ships. Thorgils sailed back to Greenland to discuss the bounty of Vinland with his Grandfather and Father. Leif Eriksson had spent the year in Europe, he traveled eastwards to spread word of discovery and to gain favour with the King of Norway to allow for larger scale colonization. The king was reluctant at first but the two Skraelings that were brought with Leif seemed to convince him, though records do not seem to agree on the detail as medieval artists do not know how to properly illustrate what a Skraeling looks like, so manuscripts from the time period have them as white as any European. It also doesn’t help that medieval artists don’t know anything about perspective or any basic fundamentals to art. The King, Sweyn Forkbeard, gives his blessing to the colony and a lump sum of cash from his personal treasury.[/FONT]
[FONT=&quot] [/FONT]
[FONT=&quot]The next thing the colony needs is bodies, people willing to sail to the edge of the known world to a land they barely know. For that Leif turns to England, England had become relatively impoverished due to continued Viking raids on the region and rather recently the King Æthelred II had given the order to massacre all Danes within his domain in the St. Brice’s Day massacre. So when Leif landed in York he didn’t exactly find a warm welcome. News of war was brewing between England and Denmark (Denmark and Norway were both under the same monarch, so Leif was in Roskilde when he had his discussion with Sweyn Forkbeard). Using the excuse of, “People will be invading soon; you should get the hell out of here.” Leif and his token crew convinced many a denizen of York to get the hell out of Dodge and used their money to purchase supplies and boats for their travel. As news arrived that Sweyn had landed in England in the spring of 1003 most of York and the nearby area panicked, and the colonization fleet tripled in over a night. With a number of boats of varying size and a number of people lost to the annals of history Leif Eriksson left York, bound for Vinland.[/FONT]
[FONT=&quot] [/FONT]
[FONT=&quot]The most significant effect of Leif’s visit to York was not the initial gain of settlers but the spread of the word of a land of bounty far to the west, for which if you could get to, untold riches would await you as well as a life of freedom and security, far away from the wars of Europe.[/FONT]
 
Book I, Vinland Sagas, approximately 1003 AD – approximate 1006 AD

Once Leif returns to Greenland and hears what his son has discovered he is pleased. He sails out with the many colonists picked up from Northern England and lands in Vinland for his second time at Leifsbuðir and drops off the colonists he can. Several ships leave on their own to set up smaller settlements in the nearby area both on Vinland and on Markland. Leif spends the rest of the year governing the colony, since as it was discovered by him it is his right to rule it. Plus, unlike all of the colonists, he is of noble blood, however minor.


Leif navigates southwards to the settlment set up at the Grand Banks to view for himself the abundance of fish. When Leif arrived at the settlment, located on the far eastern tip of Vinland, he is also astounded by the plenty of fish. Leif’s firsthand account indicates that fish breached the water wherever they went and that in order for them to fish all they had to do was sail nearby and fish would just hop into the boat. No lines or bait were needed. The settlment had more food than it needed and had been exporting it to Leifsbuðir in exchange for cut stone and immigrants. Since now Leifsbuðir had some skilled labour in the colony. This settlment on the far eastern tip of Vinland was named Thorgilsvik, Thorgils being the man who discovered it and the suffix –vik meaning bay or port.


Leif spent a considerable amount of time organizing Thorgilsvik to get its fish production to increase in order to be exported to other colonies to survive until the crops could grow. Leifsbuðir and Thorgilsvik did have active farms but Skraeling raids on farmsteads made living there dangerous. Leif decided that both colonies needed to be safe from their neighbours and studied the native situation with help from Skraeling who had immigrated into the colonies. Leif found that most Beothuk people don’t really care and that raiding their neighbours was a normal thing for some of the more aggressive and warlike tribes. Though violence had been increased in recent years with the introduction of Smallbox from Norse settlers forcing people to fight out of necessity.


Leif decided that due to this he could control the natives, rather than fight them. Many were friendly and enjoyed trade with Vinland by hunting for them Bog Iron in exchange for the metal tools made out of them. Using native trade contacts Leif organized the first Viking raids in the New World. With native warriors from different tribes working under him as well as Norsemen Leif took a fleet of what is assumed to be 2 or 3 ships and circumnavigated the island of Vinland, raiding the coast of hostile Skraelings along the way as well as going significantly inland near Leifsbuðir and Thorgilsvik.


This initial culling of the Skraeling population of Vinland set a precedent for future Skraeling relations. Trade and form mutually beneficial contacts first, if that fails then steal all their stuff. In Leif’s case many of his Skraeling and Norse crew took native women with them from the raided tribes to marry. It is assumed that this was more out of desperation and sexual urges, due to the significant lack of females in Vinland. Early records show that there was one woman for every 10 men, most of them of Skraeling descent.


Leif returned to Leifsbuðir with many goods that would be considered valuable back then but not exactly now. Skraelings did not have gold for Leif to steal but they did have artwork and furs, which Leif sold to contacts in Europe through intermediaries in Greenland. While in Leifsbuðir Leif started construction of his own home, larger than most buildings and made out of a mix of stone and wood. The local church would be smaller but had recently added stone to its structure to update the building and make the house of god more secure. Thorgilsvik’s church was still under construction and the stoneworkers in Leifsbuðir were busy and the craft’s product was in high demand.


By the time Leif’s ‘palace’ (so called with quotes due to its small size compared to contemporary European royalty) was completed it was 1008 and Vinland has been in existence for 5 years (Leifsbuðir being founded in the early winter of 1000) and the colony was thriving. A steady trickle of immigrants from Greenland and several strait from Europe were helping to boost the population of Vinland and the debt to the king had been paid off via profits made from trade win Europe. Europe paid good money for Skraeling crafts and furs, Greenland and Iceland also paid for lumber from Vinland, which was extremely cheap. Regular contacts along the route led to a connection with Northern Europe that was beneficial to the early Vinlanders. Immigrants from Europe, primarily the British Isles and Scandinavia, brought with them their culture and religion. Vinland was very much a Germanic cultural area though there were pockets of Celtic languages such as Irish Gaelic, Scottish Gaelic, Welsh, and Breton as well as token bits of Norman. Most immigrants were Christians but there were also a great many Norse Pagans. In fact many pagan Norse people thought that Vinland would be a place where they would not try to be converted to Christianity and free from harassment by their now Christian lords.


They were wrong, but they were also more religious than other Norse Pagans and not easily converted. Christian churches popped up in Vinland near to Norse Pagan shrines, Skraeling converted Christianity or kept their native beliefs or in some rare cases adopted Norse Paganism. Leif’s father Erik the Red had died in late 1003 and left his title, Paramount Chieftain of Greenland, to his son Leif. Leif however didn’t care about Greenland, he wanted Vinland. Though the title was his Leif rarely went back to Greenland, supposedly he found Vinland a much more appealing climate as well since it was further south and therefore warmer. Theoretically Leif was a vassal of the King of Norway, in reality though Leif acted independently of his lord’s wishes. Though to be fair, the Norwegian King never asked anything of him, since Leif had no soldiers to donate or money to give, at least in large amounts, which made him less important of a lord in the eyes of the king. The distance involved in communication was also a reason for lack of any significant payments to the King. Vinland also lacked a nobility below Leif, there was no Serfdom in Vinland, people lived on farmsteads that they owned themselves. They still had to pay a tribute to their lord for protection but that lord was in Leifsbuðir, and getting the money was occasionally quite difficult.
 
It lives again! I loved the orginal and can't wait to see what you do this time around! If you keep the level of setail you have now with the story and butterlfies you had before, you will have an even grander TL this go around! Consider me subscribed!
 
Book I, Vinland Sagas, approximately 1006 – approximately 1011


Leif Eriksson decides to pass several local laws in Vinland to help in regulating how the region operates. For one he bans the construction of all forms of fortifications on the island of Vinland, the only exception to this rule being the walls of Leifsbuðir and Thorgilsvik, which are currently under construction. His reasoning behind this is to prevent the possibility of noble revolts on Vinland’s core territory. If the lords cannot hold up within their castles then they can’t effectively lead a rebellion against Leif’s rule. This has become a legitimate concern for Leif due to the immigration of Saxons from England to Vinland, most of them having some sort of money or connections involved to get passage to Vinland. As such the only nobles under Leif end up being a mix of Saxons and Norse, mostly Saxons but the Norse lords hold more territory since Leif is in charge of its distribution.

Leif ends up with a semi-feudal state similar to that in England where the first born son inherits all titles and lords pledge vassalage to higher lords. The reason this is semi-feudal is due to the roll of the Althing. Borrowing heavily from Iceland’s Althing, Vinland’s Althing acts as an advisory council to the Paramount Chieftain but can override the king’s authority if two thirds of its members are in agreement. Leif is looking to the future and would prefer to set the precedent of the local lords to help dictate policy rather than absolute power of the Paramount Chieftain. Leif understands that the land he has discovered is really big, and he also understands that his future successors cannot be trusted to make good decisions about land that they know nothing about and could be radically different from what they know on the island of Vinland.

By the year 1008 Vinland’s population had reached what is assumed to be around 3,000 people, roughly equal to the population of Greenland at the time. The majority of people within the country were males due to lack of immigration by women from Europe, the issue of not having many women would be a problem for Vinland’s growth for a very long time and influence their relations with the local Skraelings, as Skraeling women are still women. Settlements by now had become spread across the island of Vinland with a few token communities across the strait between Vinland and Markland. The Urban centers (using the word loosely) were primarily Norse cultured and a blend of Christian, Norse, and Skraeling religions. The only urban centers to note are the Capital of Leifsbuðir, the main fishing community of Thorgilsvik, and a new center based around the mining of iron in central Vinland called Jonsstaðir.

Up until Jonsstaðir’s founding Vinland had relied on bog iron for its production of metal tools. Once Jonsstaðir opened up an iron mine the price of iron dropped in Vinland and bog iron became less important due to mined iron ores being preferred for forging iron tools. Now that Vinland finally had iron it could be resource independent from Europe. Vinland no longer needs to import very many goods other than live animals, as the current stock of animals in Vinland was rather small genetically. Cows, Horses, Dogs, Cats, Sheep, Pigs, Chickens, and more… all of them needed to be imported due to the low population of these animals. Different breeds as well were needed, the Norse horses were not designed for speed, they were draft animals, breeds of English, French, Spanish, and German horses were needed as well. Breeds of dogs needed to be imported that were better guard dogs than hunting companions or better at herding sheep or tracking.

Vinland’s economy was very much agriculturally based but did make money off of trade. Skraeling trappers would sell beaver furs and other goods to Vinlander merchants who would then sell them to contacts in Europe in exchange for money or for other goods with which to sell to Skraelings to get more furs and so on and so forth. This trade was very much useful for keeping Vinland in contact with developments and goings on in Europe. The most important nexus of trade with Vinland was most likely York, from there Vinlander goods would spread across Europe to as faraway lands as Constantinople, though it would be rare for goods to travel that far it still happened.

The average farmer in Vinland was known to be more wealthy and better treated than anywhere in Europe. Vinland did not have many people, so each life was precious and labour was small and restrictive. As such the peasants could demand better payment in Vinland than anywhere else in Europe. Vinland’s distance from the violence and war of Europe helped it to grow economically much faster than any nation in Europe. If a Vinlander has 3 sons, each one will need a farmstead for their livelihood. With so much open land available, getting the land necessary to start them up was not difficult at all and many youths in Vinland had futures laid out before them.

It is known that several Vinlanders went and lived among the Skraelings, finding their way of life to be more enjoyable than that of a peasant farmer. While their number was small their impact was large. The spread of the genes of Europeans into Skraeling tribes allowed for them to have a small resistance to new European diseases, though this did not stop the mass deaths of many Skraelings at the hands of smallpox and other diseases. Several tribes had actually sworn loyalty to Vinland, abandoning their nomadic ways for those of the settled farmer. This normally came accompanied with conversion to Christianity and the ascension of the tribal chief to the position of Jarl, which allowed for Skraeling nobility to exist in Vinland.

Leif did not care who his lords were so long as they were loyal, Skraelings had saved his life several times and he felt were essential to the survival of Vinland, if some of them wanted to be Jarls then so what?


Hierarchy of Vinland:
Paramount Chieftain, position held by Leif Eriksson, sworn vassalage to King of Norway, sort of like a Duke.
Jarl, lords over small areas and people, sworn vassalage to Paramount Chieftain and responsible for collection of taxes from peasantry. Title very similar to a count in Europe.
Mayor, lords over an Urban center rather than a spot on the countryside, smallest noble rank with only a dozen or so members.
Peasant, Sworn fealty to their local lord in exchange for protection, largest group in Vinland’s Semi-Feudal society.
Thrall, indentured servants who have to repay a debt through labour due to lack of money, lowest rank in society.
 
Last edited:
Great update! Bringing in the English reminds me of one of the scenarios in What If? 2, a fascinating little book discussing various Alt. History scenarios.
 
Great update! Bringing in the English reminds me of one of the scenarios in What If? 2, a fascinating little book discussing various Alt. History scenarios.

Wait till the next few updates, Vinlanders will become a mix of a crapton of North Sea people and the language will be the language of badasses (In my opinion).
 
Top