1980 Iowa Caucuses
"...the candidates have made their cases, entered the race, sized each other up... consider this something of the starting line..."
- Ted Koppel, ABC
A caucus is, by its very nature, an unpredictable and volatile thing. Caucus-goers gather in small rooms or high school gymnasiums and spend hours trying to persuade one another to join a certain candidate, and that eventually produces results from which delegates are allocated. Iowa, more than any other state, takes great pride in its caucuses and its ability to sort real contenders from also-rans; 1980, for both parties, proved how fickle a thing caucuses can really be.
Republican front-runners like Ronald Reagan or John Connally had largely eschewed Iowa, for one particular reason - Vice President Bob Dole, a native of nearby and demographically-similar Kansas, had gone all-in on the state, viewing it as the centerpiece of his plan to retake momentum and initiative and re-orient the campaign around one as him as Ford's inevitable successor. Phil Crane, from neighboring Illinois, had also made the caucuses his focus, both due to proximity for his volunteers (including coveted Eagle Forum activists) but also due to its numerous college campuses, seeking to forge himself as the candidate of choice for Young Americans for Freedom, a President of the future rather than a figure of the past, which was how he portrayed his five chief opponents. John Anderson, the most moderate candidate, made a play as a Midwestern candidate, as did Donald Rumsfeld. Three Illinoisans on the offing presented Iowans with three candidates who were always nearby and could campaign there whenever they so chose.
Democrats had a similarly muddled picture. Jimmy Carter four years earlier and George McGovern four before that had shown the importance of caucuses in the navigation of the new primary system designed after the unhappy and contentious 1968; Mo Udall practically camped out in Iowa, hoping to ride the same wave of young, progressive and anti-establishment votes that had earned the two previous Democratic nominees the ring and that had also powered Eugene McCarthy's insurgent campaign. Reuben Askew, though focusing on mopping up the South, made a late play for the Iowa caucuses, but found his staffing on the ground insufficient compared to bigger, better-heeled campaigns that had a hard time converting their resources into the kind of on-the-ground enthusiasm that powered caucuses - campaigns such as those of Lloyd Bentsen, Scoop Jackson or Jerry Brown.
The caucus results rolled in and everybody found something to hate. On the Democratic side, three candidates practically tied, all leaving Iowa with an identical 22% of the vote - Udall, who came in first, Hugh Carey, in second, and Askew, in third. The rest of the pack failed to even break 10%, with a clog of candidates winning between 7-9%, and Scoop Jackson surprisingly finishing last, behind even gadflies like Cliff Finch. It was a humiliation for the
eminence grise of Senate defense policy and Jackson dropped out of the race the next day - and endorsed Carey, whose close finish ahead of the surging Askew and a hair behind the populist Udall introduced his name to millions of potential voters for the first time. Udall failed to get the dominating result he needed to vault him into frontrunner status and Askew's momentum was badly blunted.
For the Republicans, meanwhile, the results were somewhat useless - Dole came in first with 28%, Crane in second with 24%, and Connally in third with 17% despite spending little time in the state. Reagan, who had similarly barely campaigned there and chosen to coast on his "above the fray" frontrunner image, panicked with his fourth-place finish and the victory laps of both Crane and Connally declaring themselves as the "future of the conservative movement" - in the four years between his insurgent challenge to Ford and now, he had gone from conservative icon to has-been in a blink, or at least he would if he did not quickly do something to resuscitate the campaign. The headlines out of Iowa were a disaster for Reagan, and unfriendly personalities both in the media and other wings of the GOP gleefully piled on, smelling blood, and hoping that they had sunk "that doddering old B-list actor" for good. But it was hard for Dole to take much of a breather after somehow placing first; he was, for better or worse, now officially the candidate of continuing to carry the flag for the unpopular Ford administration, and even if Reagan was badly wounded, Crane and Connally lurked, sensing his clear weakness. Even worse, Howard Baker and John Anderson both declined to drop out after Iowa, thus denying Dole the "establishment" lane and its considerable financial resources entirely to himself.
For Democrats, Maine's caucuses lurked ahead, while Republicans would compete in Puerto Rico and Alaska before the critical bipartisan New Hampshire contest on February 26th...