John C. Fremont (Republican from California) / William L. Dayton (Republican from New Jersey) - 163 EV
James Buchanan (Democrat from Pennsylvania( / John C. Breckinridge (Democrat from Kentucky) - 122 EV
Millard Fillmore (American from New York) / Andrew J. Donelson (American from Tennessee) - 10 EV
John C. Fremont (Republican from California) / Abraham Lincoln (Republican from Illinois) 160 EV
John Bell (Constitutional Unionist from Tennessee) / Samuel Houston (Constitutional Unionist from Texas) 36 EV
Stephen A. Douglas (Democrat from Illinois) / Andrew Johnson (Democrat from Tennessee) 23 EV
William H. Seward (Republican from New York) / Hannibal Hamlin (Republican from Maine) 149 EV
Robert E. Lee (Constitutional Unionist from Vandalia) / Francis P. Blair, Jr. (Constitutional Unionist from Osage) 44 EV
Thomas A. Hendricks (Democrat from Indiana) / George H. Pendleton (Democrat from Ohio) 39 EV
William H. Seward (Republican from New York) / Hannibal Hamlin (Republican from Maine) 135 EV
Andrew Gregg Curtin (Constitutional Unionist from Pennsylvania) / Francis Harrison Pierpont (Constitutional Unionist from Vandalia)
James E. English (Democrat from Connecticut) / Sanford E. Church (Democrat from New York)
Election sent to House of Representatives.