Zhukov's SU 1945

Stalin is shot dead on 9th of May 1945 by a Polish nationalist. Beria takes control of the Soviet Union within 7 days.

What I want to know is how would this affect the situation in central and eastern Europe? How would things be different in the years right after the war? How would boarders and forced expulsions be different?
 
Last edited:
If Zhukov does this, it will be without precedent in Soviet Union. Eventually he will have to assume more political (civilian) disposition and distance himself from the Army directly. He might possibly be a bit more consolatory in his approach to the West, possibly averting the Cold War or at least making it less intensive and competitive. Or may not, which would in large part depend on the West view of him. Eastern Europe would, I hazard to guess, be pretty much as in OTL.
 
He wouldn't. OP is not clear if he's behind the assassination or just seizes the opportunity.

If former then that's not going to happen. Red Army has been neutered in political aspirations and they didn't have much of theose from the start.

If latter then that's unlikely since whoever was behind it wouldn't want Zhukov to take over. Soviet Union (and Russia before) didn't have a tradition of puppet rulers so there would be no desire to havwe Zhukov serve as such.

Plus Zhukov had little to no political conenctions, which would eman he'd face opposition from start.

The best way to elevate Zhukov up, but not to the top, is to have somebody depose stalin and have Zhukov throw his weight behind it. Similar to what happened when beria was removed.

"Zhukov in charge" pops up from time to time but it's not happening.
 
He wouldn't. OP is not clear if he's behind the assassination or just seizes the opportunity.

If former then that's not going to happen. Red Army has been neutered in political aspirations and they didn't have much of theose from the start.

If latter then that's unlikely since whoever was behind it wouldn't want Zhukov to take over. Soviet Union (and Russia before) didn't have a tradition of puppet rulers so there would be no desire to havwe Zhukov serve as such.

Plus Zhukov had little to no political conenctions, which would eman he'd face opposition from start.

The best way to elevate Zhukov up, but not to the top, is to have somebody depose stalin and have Zhukov throw his weight behind it. Similar to what happened when beria was removed.

"Zhukov in charge" pops up from time to time but it's not happening.

That's fair enough. I just chose Zhukov at random so I will change it to Beria. I forgot to say in the OP Stalin was killed by a Polish nationalist. I will edit the OP along those lines.
 
The politicians in Moscow will fear and revile Beria taking over while the Soviet Generals will fear that maybe Beria will try to complete the purges that Stalin put off when the zag errands were getting close to Moscow....
 
The politicians in Moscow will fear and revile Beria taking over while the Soviet Generals will fear that maybe Beria will try to complete the purges that Stalin put off when the zag errands were getting close to Moscow....

Pretty much. I suspect Beria survives until others can get their shit together and enlist Red army. Then Beria gets lethal dose of lead poison.
 
Zhukov isn't a good candidate without a much earlier POD. The Bolsheviks were afraid of Bonapartism, which is where military officers seize power from revolutionary governments. Zhukov doing this would be almost the definition of Bonapartism. Zhukov wouldn't have the support of either the Party or the army, which by 1945 was made up of many Party men. What would probably happen is what others have said: everyone rallies together and with the Red Army give Beria a lead shower. Then either Zhdanov or Molotov takes over, which means Molotov takes over (Zhdanov was a severe alcoholic by this point, and he would be dead by '47 or '48).
 
(1) Given Stalin's reclusiveness and ultra-tight security, how does the "Polish nationalist" get to him?

(2) On the more general matter of the succession to Stalin if he were to die in 1945, Andrei Zhdanov http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Andrei_Zhdanov was often mentioned as a possible successor to Stalin at the time. The problem, however, is that his health was already poor, due in part to heavy drinking. My guess is that even if he does come to power (he could indeed become General Secretary, though if he does so it might be as part of a deal limiting the General Secretary's power) he will not last too long. (Stalin is sometimes accused of killing him, but it is just as plausible that without Stalin around, Zhdanov will die even earlier, since apparently Stalin did at least try to restrain Zhdanov's drinking [1]). After his death, a Malenkov-Beria alliance will (as in OTL with the "Leningrad Affair") probably take vengeance against his supporters. Molotov might serve as Prime Minister--a position not as powerful as it sounds (the fact that Rykov was kept on in the post well after the defeat of the "Rightists" and Bulganin for some time after the defeat of the "Anti-Party Group" is evidence of this). Khrushchev might survive the factional strife; he was helped by the fact that people tended to underestimate him, to think of him as a dumb muzhik, etc.

(3) I agree that in view of the party leadership's suspicion of "Bonapartism," Zhukov has virtually no chance. Certainly none of becoming leader by "legal" means, and to attempt a coup would be way too risky.

[1] At least according to Khrushchev: "Before his death, Zhdanov had been in poor health for some time. I don't know what he was suffering from, but one of his ailments was that he had lost his will power and was not able to control himself when it came to drinking. It was pitiful to watch. I even remember that in the last days of Zhdanov's life, Stalin used to shout at him to stop drinking. This was an astounding thing because Stalin usually encouraged people to get drunk. But he compelled Zhdanov to drink fruit water and suffer while the rest of us were drinking wine or something stronger." http://spartacus-educational.com/RUSzhdanov.htm
 
Top