Suppose you had a WW2 era propeller fighter and tried to land it on a carrier despite it not being meant to land on a carrier at all. Let's suppose it was meant to land on a land strip exactly the same length as the carrier (you can imagine a super long carrier, an Enterprise clone that's just longer if you want).
If it was designed for a longer strip, it would likely overshoot.
So, how would the landing fail? Would it fail in a way with the plane bouncing off the carrier?