Would the nazis have been in favour or against the creation of Israel?

[Loghain]

Get Goring in Leadership. he is the only one who might actually go for it. even then the deportations will be in massively shitty conditions.

 

[Michele]

Encouraging emigration and organizing deportations were early, temporary measures.

Think it to the end. Suppose a Jewish state is allowed to exist. And suppose it is successful, thriving, and able to defend itself from its unfriendly neighbors. Something even a Nazi planner can't rule out for certain.

Wouldn't this prove that all the Nazi blather about the inferiority, depravity and social-Darwinian destiny to succumb of the Jews was nothing but a lie? If the Jews succeed, thrive and defeat numerically larger enemies half a dozen times in a row, how will Hitler, Goebbels & Co. look?

So no, it's a danger that realistic, pragmatic Nazis won't risk; while frothing-at-the-mouth, true-to-form Nazis won't contemplate it on principle, they want them exterminated.

So no.

 

[Theoretical_TJ]

I could see them calling the Warsaw Ghetto or part of the General Government as Israel out of a perverse irony similar to the the "King of the Jews" sign put above Jesus's head on the Cross. This I think could happen because much propaganda focused on the "Blood Libel" to appeal to Germany's Christian population.

 

[Just a Rube]

As noted, before the war they might have gone for it (assuming that "Israel" was located somewhere they had no interest or desire in conquering). After a victory? No way; they've won, which "proves" their superiority.

 

[Meshakhad]

The irgun, a fringe faction of Zionism, actually wrote to the Nazi leadership to make a deal against the British empire!

I think it was the Lehi, a splinter faction of the Irgun.

 

[samcster94]

It's not just Hitler that wants the Jews dead - Bormann, Himmler and Goebbels were as committed to that end as Hitler, although Himmler wavered in the last few months of the war to try and save his own neck.

His inner circle had his toxic views but not his insanity or health issues.

 

[samcster94]

I think it was the Lehi, a splinter faction of the Irgun.

Zionists and Nazis were generally mortal enemies outside of a few fringe factions.

 

[Meshakhad]

Zionists and Nazis were generally mortal enemies outside of a few fringe factions.

Which says a lot about how extreme the Lehi were.