Grey Wolf
Donor
World War 1845
This thread follows on directly from the discursive Joubert/Carnot thread, which was used to get the timeline of the ATL moved from 1799 to 1845, and to discuss everything along the way. Many thanks to those who participated there, especially to fhaessig, Nicomacheus, Tom B, Gonzaga, and HJTulp
Please note, therefore, that the timeline/narrative that unfolds below has an ATL backstory of 45 years different to our own history. I will try to explain the 'current' state of the world in the first posts, and the position of the main 'characters' within this
I had hoped to use this as my entry for Chris' story-writing competition, but I find that I simply don't have it in me to understand enough about the technological, social and everyday side of the mid 1840s to succeed in doing this. I don't even know how to light a room, let alone describe a general's headquarters !
I prefer an ATL to use historical characters where possible, unless the divergence has been significant enough that wholly made-up characters OUGHT to be present. With regard to the latter, it has really only occurred in this timeline where royals are concerned- Queen Charlotte of Great Britain marrying Prince William of Orange has two ATL sons, George, Prince of Wales, and William, Duke of York, who of course never existed in OTL
Butterfly fans will rant and rave, no doubt, that anyone born after the POD can't exist and so on, but I still well remember a discussion I had on this many years ago with Rick Robinson, and he convinced me that any one individual's chances of coming into being is infinitessimal, so sure the events of an ATL may have rendered someone unlikely, but their coming into being is no LESS likely than whichever character we create from scratch in their place. It is only when the odds change to make someone improbable when compared to OTL that this calculation dies - ie if someone is the product of an American mother and a British father but at the time of their OTL birth, those two countries are at war in the ATL, then they will be replaced with someone else
Thus, the younger strata of characters, those who hold active military commands for instance, are for the mostpart born after the POD, but are OTL persons whose lives have been very different in this timeline. The Mississippi border, the pushing across to form the three new states, the whole question of Fredonia where OTL Kansas and Oklahoma are, all this will have given completely different career paths and outlook to such characters. The existence of a larger, modern United States Navy will also have changed things, and I make no excuses for pulling in characters from OTL Texas to populate both Fredonia, and the US fleet
After much debate and discussion I have adopted a standard of technology that takes OTL as its base but advances certain areas
- screw-driven steam-powered large warships are being purposely built by the major navies by 1845 (this is an advance of 10-15 years on OTL)
- railways have spread to the "Railway Mania" level of OTL Britain 1845, within France, other industrialised parts of Germany, and within the USA also
- telegraph is about 5 years ahead of itself, due to an earlier take-up and development of the prototype of the chap whom Morse in OTL built upon. I still use Morse here, having him build on this with government interest, not least due to the 3 Spanish-American wars, the rise in unfriendly relations with Britain, and the need to transmit orders quickly across the vast nation
My major problem with maps is that I have to trace them, then scan them in. I will copy/paste the one map of the USA that I uploaded into the previous thread. This shows the official extent of the country, though with subsequent developments, there are the issues of Fredonia on the one hand, and of the USA buying out Russia's interests in Oregon on the other
Hopefully I can make this work. If not, sorry for wasting your time !
Best Regards
Grey Wolf
This thread follows on directly from the discursive Joubert/Carnot thread, which was used to get the timeline of the ATL moved from 1799 to 1845, and to discuss everything along the way. Many thanks to those who participated there, especially to fhaessig, Nicomacheus, Tom B, Gonzaga, and HJTulp
Please note, therefore, that the timeline/narrative that unfolds below has an ATL backstory of 45 years different to our own history. I will try to explain the 'current' state of the world in the first posts, and the position of the main 'characters' within this
I had hoped to use this as my entry for Chris' story-writing competition, but I find that I simply don't have it in me to understand enough about the technological, social and everyday side of the mid 1840s to succeed in doing this. I don't even know how to light a room, let alone describe a general's headquarters !
I prefer an ATL to use historical characters where possible, unless the divergence has been significant enough that wholly made-up characters OUGHT to be present. With regard to the latter, it has really only occurred in this timeline where royals are concerned- Queen Charlotte of Great Britain marrying Prince William of Orange has two ATL sons, George, Prince of Wales, and William, Duke of York, who of course never existed in OTL
Butterfly fans will rant and rave, no doubt, that anyone born after the POD can't exist and so on, but I still well remember a discussion I had on this many years ago with Rick Robinson, and he convinced me that any one individual's chances of coming into being is infinitessimal, so sure the events of an ATL may have rendered someone unlikely, but their coming into being is no LESS likely than whichever character we create from scratch in their place. It is only when the odds change to make someone improbable when compared to OTL that this calculation dies - ie if someone is the product of an American mother and a British father but at the time of their OTL birth, those two countries are at war in the ATL, then they will be replaced with someone else
Thus, the younger strata of characters, those who hold active military commands for instance, are for the mostpart born after the POD, but are OTL persons whose lives have been very different in this timeline. The Mississippi border, the pushing across to form the three new states, the whole question of Fredonia where OTL Kansas and Oklahoma are, all this will have given completely different career paths and outlook to such characters. The existence of a larger, modern United States Navy will also have changed things, and I make no excuses for pulling in characters from OTL Texas to populate both Fredonia, and the US fleet
After much debate and discussion I have adopted a standard of technology that takes OTL as its base but advances certain areas
- screw-driven steam-powered large warships are being purposely built by the major navies by 1845 (this is an advance of 10-15 years on OTL)
- railways have spread to the "Railway Mania" level of OTL Britain 1845, within France, other industrialised parts of Germany, and within the USA also
- telegraph is about 5 years ahead of itself, due to an earlier take-up and development of the prototype of the chap whom Morse in OTL built upon. I still use Morse here, having him build on this with government interest, not least due to the 3 Spanish-American wars, the rise in unfriendly relations with Britain, and the need to transmit orders quickly across the vast nation
My major problem with maps is that I have to trace them, then scan them in. I will copy/paste the one map of the USA that I uploaded into the previous thread. This shows the official extent of the country, though with subsequent developments, there are the issues of Fredonia on the one hand, and of the USA buying out Russia's interests in Oregon on the other
Hopefully I can make this work. If not, sorry for wasting your time !
Best Regards
Grey Wolf