Woodrow Wilson lives until 1950

GeographyDude

Gone Fishin'
@David T

"Where Wilson differed most from Griffith was in his treatment of the Ku Klux Klan. The Klan had been, Wilson observed, 'a very tempting and dangerous instrument of power for days of disorder and social upheaval.' In the beginning, 'sober men' had advised upon and curbed the activities of the hooded order. As time went on, however, such control proved increasingly impossible to exercise as the Klan was drawn deeper and deeper 'into the ways of violence and outlawry. 'Men of hot passions who could not always be restrained,' Wilson commented, 'carried their plans into effect. Reckless men not of their order, malicious fellows of the baser sort who did not feel the compulsions of honor and who had private grudges to satisfy, imitated their disguises and borrowed their methods.' The number of abuses grew: 'Brutal crimes were committed; the innocent suffered with the guilty; a reign of terror was brought on, and society was infinitely more disturbed than defended.' In contrast with Griffith's later film, which depicted the Klan as rescuing white women from the threat posed by black men, Wilson made it clear that the Klan itself arracked female targets. 'The more ardent regulators,' he wrote, 'made no nice discriminations. All northern white men or women who came into the South to work among the negroes, though they were but school teachers, were in danger of their enmity and silent onset.' According to Wilson, the Klan was deeply unchivalrous. It was also shortlived and relatively unsuccessful. Instead of overthrowing Radical regimes and restoring white suprmeacy by force, as *The Birth of a Nation* suggested, the original Klan had been effectively destroyed by new federal laws of 1870 and 1871 and the determined actions of President Grant.."

https://books.google.com/books?id=fGJFpiTjbKwC&pg=PA200


if only it was so!

After the Republicans bailed* on Reconstruction in 1877, I think the Klan was one of the factors in the South going back to the bad old days. And even more reasonable and moderate Southern politicians personally against against terror and killing may have thought of the Klan as just a fact of life and in some sense "necessary."

* some things are more important than the presidency. The Republicans should have stayed the course on Reconstruction.
 
Last edited:
so much for the view now fashionable that defines Wilson mainly by his southernness and retrograde views on race.

I think his objection to many southern Democrats was, however, their reactionary views on issues *other than race* (e.g., the idea that to maintain its competitiveness with other sections of the country, the South needed low wages, child labor, etc.). He pretty much shared their viewpoint on race, though in a much less crude version than that of some.
 
David, what do you think of the current campaign to rename buildings/remove statutes of people who held views that are rejected in modern times?
For example, belief in eugenics was common so condemning say, Alfred Deakin and demanding that Deakin University be renamed just because he held a belief that was common in his era, is rather like condemning him for drinking water.
 
Top