With a British Victory in the War of 1812, how would the butterflies affect Europe?

If the territory is that small I can see the Indians telling the British where to stick it. I have to think that even if Tecumseh survives the war his confederacy will outlive him. He would have been 47 in 1815, he lasts another deacde and a half at best (probably less).
Oh sure, I don't see it being in any way amicable. But really was it going to be had he and the Confederacy survived with OTL Ghent?
 
On the subject Anglo Centric tale being mentioned one reason it may have got quite a lot of support is it made a change from the standard issue Ameriwanks that dominate the subject it was covering. You can only put up with so much British Morons being crushed by American Geniuses before someone decides to write something different.

True. There's nothing worse out there in all of alternate history than Harry Harrison's:mad: abomination, surely.

BUT, if you are going to cheer on a thread that has the Axis throwing everything they have against TWO of the main Allied powers while ignoring the third as if they didn't even exist, even as they sweep up your whole reason for going to war (resources), or are crossing the Rhine-Elbe-Oder-Vistula and doing nothing about it, then you have no right yourself to do anything but turn a blind eye to the silliness of ATLs that proudly state: "Rising Tides Only Raise MY BOATS, So There!":rolleyes:

I've since discovered it was a WW2 AU. The problem wasn't that British ships were destroying American ones, it's that American ones were being sunk by Japanese ones.

Is THAT all you got from what I sent you? Did you only read and see what you wanted to see? Did you read ANY of the posts I highlighted? Or did you go into it looking for your own prejudices to be confirmed?

There was nothing wrong with that thread until the OP let his personal issues with all things American, and his pathological hatred for Franklin Roosevelt in particular (while keeping secret almost to the end of the ATL his love love for Japan and its people while at the same time screaming/repeating the "fair and balanced" nature of his TL), take what had been a good thread and throw it right off the rails.

And BTW why don't you tell everyone that I'd had no problem with the USN in that thread getting pasted up to a reasonable degree. After the OTL pasting at Pearl they were pasted worse by far at BOTH Coral Sea AND Midway, which was fine. OP's preference. It was what happened AFTER all that that the problems festered.

DID YOU READ THE FINAL POSTS I brought up or not!? Or did the thought of criticism by a Briton of a British written Britwank upset you?:confused:
 

Saphroneth

Banned
Is THAT all you got from what I sent you? Did you only read and see what you wanted to see? Did you read ANY of the posts I highlighted? Or did you go into it looking for your own prejudices to be confirmed?

There was nothing wrong with that thread until the OP let his personal issues with all things American, and his pathological hatred for Franklin Roosevelt in particular (while keeping secret almost to the end of the ATL his love love for Japan and its people while at the same time screaming/repeating the "fair and balanced" nature of his TL), take what had been a good thread and throw it right off the rails.

And BTW why don't you tell everyone that I'd had no problem with the USN in that thread getting pasted up to a reasonable degree. After the OTL pasting at Pearl they were pasted worse by far at BOTH Coral Sea AND Midway, which was fine. OP's preference. It was what happened AFTER all that that the problems festered.

DID YOU READ THE FINAL POSTS I brought up or not!? Or did the thought of criticism by a Briton of a British written Britwank upset you?:confused:
I haven't actually SEEN the post you've promised to cite where people jumped all over you for the US battleships claim - I'm intending to look at that as being the primary issue as it's what you yourself brought up specifically.

As for the rest of it - stop shouting at me for summarizing things in shortform. No, I have not read the whole thread; I want to see that post you promise to cite first.
It's pretty clear to me that you have a massive negative animus about that TL - specifically because I've seen you bring it up on at least two unrelated threads before, often apropos of nothing more than wanting to bash said TL.

So, show me the specific post where you said something innocuous and people jumped all over it inexcusably - that being the whole reason you brought it up here in the first place - or stop derailing this thread completely to bash Devolved and everyone who doesn't instantly join in bashing him.

Oh, and while I'm at it... if Devolved's thread was all you claim it to be and worse, that would still not excuse someone doing the same thing in reverse as you appear to be claiming.
 
Top