Wilson forces the UK and France to let German-Austria join Germany

What if Woodrow Wilson had forced the UK and France to let German-Austria join Germany, through economic warfare?
 
Last edited:
This is very unlikely. The actual solution that was devised at Versailles--Anschluss forbidden until and unless the League will someday give its permission--was in fact Wilson's own, though readily accepted by Lloyd George and Clemenceau:

"It was, of course, a compromise. Wilson's formula, by holding out the hope for a later consent to the union, was based on recognition of the right to national self-determination. By prohibiting it for an indefinite time, however, it acknowledged the realities of power and also the latent fear in Europe of the vanquished foe. Even Clemenceau realized that the two German states could not be kept apart forever if they really desired the union. But he was determined to keep them separate as long as possible. When President Wilson finally offered a formula which tied the Anschluss to the approval of the Council of the League of Nations, Clemenceau quickly gave his approval. He understood that France would thus exercise a permanent veto over the Anschluss. Lloyd George was likewise won over to the French point of view and promptly gave his consent. President Wilson himself, and no other American, took thus the leading role in shaping Allied Anschluss policy.

"Some German and Austrian historians, embittered about the peace treaties of Versailles and St. Germain, including the prohibition of the Anschluss, have vacillated between accusing President Wilson of having "betrayed" his own ideals and violated his pledges and belittling the president's knowledge and grasp of Europe, especially Central European affairs, history and geography. Yet President Wilson had surely never promised the Anschluss as such, though many Germans, interpreting his program quite liberally, claimed that he did. As far as the president's alleged lack of knowledge is concerned, the American historian A. J. May, a leading expert on Austrian history and a close student of American policy toward Austria, has discarded the "myth" that President Wilson was not familiar with the conditions and problems of the Dual Monarchy. According to May, Wilson in his treatise on comparative government, The State, had written with "clarity and penetration" on the Austro-Hungarian empire.

"President Wilson also had a direct voice in the decision of the Council of Four to change the name of German Austria (Deutsch-Osterreich) to Austria. This decision was reached at President Wilson's residence on May 29, 1919. The Yugoslav and Czech delegations had voiced their concern that the designation German Austria would encourage the belief that there existed a non-German Austria. They disliked this implication and the inherent claim to some or all of their territories. In their view, the name "Deutsch-Osterreich" would strengthen the ties between German Austria and the Germans in Czechoslovakia and might also give encouragement to the Anschluss movement..." https://books.google.com/books?id=1eZkToUVYisC&pg=PA326

Wilson believed in principle in self-determination even for the defeated powers, but he also took a special interest in the Czechoslovak state he had helped to create, and whose security it was (rightly) feared could be endangered if it were surrounded by Germany on three sides. As long as a door was theoretically kept open to union in the future, he was very unlikely to risk a break with the Allies over this.
 
Top