WI/TL: A Different Russian Civil War

Russian history is a forte of mine, so I was thinking of changing the course of the Russian Civil War. Here's a few details:

1. Nicholas II survives assassination.
2. Russia is still in WWI. (OTL)
3. Reds still consolidate power. (OTL)
4. The White Movement: OTL + Czarist "faction" that still supports Nicholas II, who is still alive.
5. I was thinking of a White victory, but I will also consider a Red victory to keep with requirements to make an EFFECTIVE AH. With a White victory comes a democracy similar to Britain and France, which the Czar accepts.

Thoughts? It's in an outline form, I'll be glad to take suggestions. A lot of info will come from Mawdsley's book (for research) and Wiki.
 
Obviously it's gonna have the OTL up until the assassination of the Romanovs. Instead, I am gonna have them escape to Siberia. There, Nicholas II will be the "commander in chief" of the White forces. The Red will loose, and a new government will be modeled on the British system with Nicholas II as the "symbolic Czar" of Russia, and the Duma as a parliament with a Prime Minister.
 
It is a possibility. The Czar will have to appoint an effective military commander and then let that person run the war. It would seem that in order to defeat the Reds the Czarist forces might have to see that war with the Central Powers and the Reds is an impossibility. To defeat the Reds Russia would have to make peace with the Central Powers. Perhaps an earlier peace might result in Germany not demanding as much.
 
What would the Tsar actually do for the White movement? Everybody who was still loyal to him (and I'm defining loyalty pretty stringently: Brusilov was no anti-Tsarist, but he certainly wasn't loyal for our purposes) after he was complteley discredited was fighting the Reds as it was. Could he really serve an an effective rallying point for the disparate factions? WOuld this really offset the White disadvantages?

A working Westminster democracy is awfully optimistic in a country devestated by war. The White movement was in any case not particularly nice. I don't see what interest they have in a democracy. And a constitution representing the will of the Russian people is extremely unlikely to include a Tsar.

If the Tsar is able to make peace with the CP in 1916, I highly doubt there will be a civil war as we know it, ie, Bolsheviks and a few allies of conveniance vs mess of militant anti-Bolsheviks.
 
Top