WI: Princess Beatrice of Portugal marries Edward of Norwich?

In 1380-1381, King Ferdinand I of Portugal secretly allied with King Richard II of England and John of Gaunt, and agreed to a betrothal between his daughter and heir, Beatrice, and Edward of Norwich, eldest son of Edmund, Duke of York. The eight-year-old Edward was even brought to Lisbon for the betrothal.

In the end, she married King John I of Castille, but was driven out and never recognised as Queen by the Portuguese nobles, who instead named John, Grand Master of the Order of Aviz and an illegitimate half-brother of Ferdinand, as King. Edward of Norwich, meanwhile, married Philippa de Mohun (who was 20 years older than him and had, between two husbands, had given birth to just one son) before he was killed at the Battle of Agincourt saving the life of King Henry V.

What if the planned marriage between Beatrice and Edward had gone through? There would be no fear by the Portuguese nobles of a Castillian union, so not as much opposition to it as the marriage betwen Beatrice and John I of Castille. Would Edward still have been allowed to become Duke of York upon his father's death, or would the title have passed to his younger brother, Richard, instead?

Any thoughts?
 
Would Edward still have been allowed to become Duke of York upon his father's death, or would the title have passed to his younger brother, Richard, instead?
Richard would certainly act as Edward's steward/lieutenant for York.
I doubt Edward would necessarily be deprived of the Duchy unless he fails in his duties hence setting up his brother to act in his stead. John of Gaunt wasn't deprived of Lancaster while campaigning for Castile after all.
When Edward dies it would probably depend on his heir and relationships with the English king and "Steward of York".
Even if the title remains with Portugal, the lands themselves are more likely to become held by the king and/or steward.
 
You still have the problem of having the King half-brothers and the nobility would favor them over a foreigner.

With her married you won't have John of Portugal murdering his wife because the Queen won't be able to trick with the promise of him marrying the princess and OTL even after that he was popular enough in the country to be considered a possible successor to Ferdinand.

Edward would probably ending up being forced to gather an army to try to gain a crown if the Cortes decide to crown the eldest of Ferdinand's brothers instead of his daughter.
 
Top