WI: Pompey defeats Caesar

All valid points, but you forget about his spectacular job at clearing the seas of piracy. Also, you underestimate his job in Sicily in the civil wars.

Alright, I concede on the piracy issue; he was indeed fast in Italy and Sicily. I'm not saying he was a bad general, just that he's maybe 9th or 10th in rank instead of a solid 3rd or 4th.
 
Top