WI: Philadelphia Was Incorporated Into New Jersey, Instead of Pennsylvania?

This has been an idea proposed for a long time, that Philadelphia either be a state of its own or join with New Jersey. So what if Philadelphia was incorporated into New Jersey instead of Pennsylvania? Would Pittsburgh be larger in ATL?
 
But, Philly was established by Penn as a capital for his little colony, it makes little sense for it to be incorporated into New Jersey.
 
Philadelphia and its environs *were* Pennsylvania at the time, the only part that had any real importance. If this were to happen, it's likely the entire colony would be part of New Jersey. If anything it seems like the opposite would be more likely.
 
Top