WI: Peter of Castile wins the Castilian Civil War with Henry of Trastamara?

Enrique is painted bad because he was a weak and submisive ruler that sold the crown to a bunch of nobles and the pope. Still Enrique is a prove that not all Trastamara were anti-jewish. Not even Isabel had a hatred towards jews and defended them multiple times

Would you mind citing examples where she defended them? I'm not aware of any.
 
Would you mind citing examples where she defended them? I'm not aware of any.
This article is really good for understanding the situation of the jews in Spain.
http://infocatolica.com/blog/notelacuenten.php/1606220404-ipor-que-aun-isabel-la-catoli-5
Isabel was really projewish,the problem was that the rest of Spain loathed them and progroms were the norms. Jews were alredy fleeing Castile before she even became a queen.
As an example after hearing the execution of a jew in Trujillo Isabel sent a letter to the village in 1477 which roughly translates too
"All the jews of my kingdom are mine and it is not your perrogative to decide over their lifes. If something similar happens again I would have to act directly on the unjustice against my subjects".
In 1478 he sent the royal army to protect the jewish quarter in Seville due the insecurity that jews had in the city.
In 1479 she intervened in Avila that tried to implement local law on jews.
In 1480 she defended the rights of the jews in Murcia and La Coruña.
 
The easier POD would be Joanna of England marrying Peter the Cruel.

Bumping my own thread here, but yeah, if we butterflied away the death of Joan of England due to the Black Plague, that would be an interesting POD. Edward the Black Prince would be more willing to help and fight for his sister and her children's right to the throne (especially since she was both the favorite child of his father and his favorite sibling), rather than abandoning Peter when he squelched on his debts to Edward. Maybe Joan and her retinue head the warning of the locals in Aquitaine and turn around and then take a ship to Castile.
 
Bumping my own thread here, but yeah, if we butterflied away the death of Joan of England due to the Black Plague, that would be an interesting POD. Edward the Black Prince would be more willing to help and fight for his sister and her children's right to the throne (especially since she was both the favorite child of his father and his favorite sibling), rather than abandoning Peter when he squelched on his debts to Edward. Maybe Joan and her retinue head the warning of the locals in Aquitaine and turn around and then take a ship to Castile.

Not to mention Joanie surviving would probably remove most of Pedro's awkward marital exercises: IIRC he was married to his French wife, Juana de Castro (sister/cousin to the more famous Inez de Castro) and Maria de Padilla all at the same time. He didn't really care for Blanche de Bourbon because she was "forced" on him. AIUI he was rather entranced with Joan OTOH
 
Not to mention Joanie surviving would probably remove most of Pedro's awkward marital exercises: IIRC he was married to his French wife, Juana de Castro (sister/cousin to the more famous Inez de Castro) and Maria de Padilla all at the same time. He didn't really care for Blanche de Bourbon because she was "forced" on him. AIUI he was rather entranced with Joan OTOH

Yeah. It would certainly help to have some legitimate sons rather than the bastards he had in OTL
 
Top