WI/PC: Germany gets "pushed" West instead of East?

IOTL Germany lost eastern Pomerania, Silesia, and East Prussia after WWII; mostly to Poland, with the Soviets snapping up northern East Prussia as the Kaliningrad Oblast, with the understanding that it was to compensate Poland for their eastern territories which were then absorbed into the Soviet Union.

With a POD no earlier than 1920, is it possible to make it so that the reverse happens instead; that is, Germany keeps Pomerania/Silesia/Prussia, but loses part or most of its western lands. That is, instead of an Oder-Neisse line, Germany's western border is now delineated at the Rhine?
 

Deleted member 1487

IOTL Germany lost eastern Pomerania, Silesia, and East Prussia after WWII; mostly to Poland, with the Soviets snapping up northern East Prussia as the Kaliningrad Oblast, with the understanding that it was to compensate Poland for their eastern territories which were then absorbed into the Soviet Union.

With a POD no earlier than 1920, is it possible to make it so that the reverse happens instead; that is, Germany keeps Pomerania/Silesia/Prussia, but loses part or most of its western lands. That is, instead of an Oder-Neisse line, Germany's western border is now delineated at the Rhine?
That's a really tough one to pull off. I don't see East Prussia remaining German in any scenario, though it could potentially end up an independent state.
Like the Soviets do worse and the Morgenthau division plan is accepted, with the Saarland either in France or part of the international zone in west/northwest Germany, and perhaps the part of Silesia cut off in the map is instead kept in Northern Germany:
map-de-morgenthau-plan.jpg


It would be hard to maintain long term though, especially if there is a Cold War and the economic rehabilitation of Europe is hampered by Germany being divided into multiple states like that and partially deindustrialized. Plus Truman had little interest in Morgenthau's plan and purged his guys from the administration of Germany when he felt comfortable doing so.
 
I can see vengeful WALLIES giving everything West of the Rhine to France.
Luxembourg asserts an ancient historical claim on a few princely estates.
Belgium gains a few counties along its eastern border.
Holland gains a few counties along its eastern border.
Denmark reclaims a few Baltic islands plus Schlezwig and Holstein.
Perhaps the Sudetenland is seen as a convenient place to re-settle all the Volksdeutsch no longer welcome in the USSR. Whether the Sudetenland is ruled by Berlin or Prague is the source for another debate.
 
The title is totally misleading. Normally, to be "pushed west" would mean to lose territory in the east and gain it in the west! E.g., see the large number of sites saying "Poland was pushed west" in 1945: " Because the Soviet Union had already taken eastern Poland, including cities like Vilnius and Lvov, Poland was pushed west." https://www.theguardian.com/books/2002/apr/13/historybooks When I first saw the title I wondered "Is this a DBWI?"...
 
Last edited:
The mention of Morgenthau makes me think. He lived until 1967 - so he saw the West German economic miracle, German rearmament etc. Did he ever voice his opinion as to said developments?
 
Top