WI Northern Nullification is Challenged...1843

I don't quite understand why the slave runaway issue became such a problem. Given how willing slave owners where to switch their slaves from industry to industry and place to place, I'd have thought that if the wastage rate due to escape became too high they'd just transport their slaves down to old Mexico, where there would be no chance of escape to the FSA.

If you're looking to erode popular support for slavery, shifting the slave population from the states to the territories might do it, if the slave owners become concentrated outside places with Federal votes.
 
In the end, hundreds of thousands of free blacks and run-away slaves will be transported to Liberia by the end of the 19th Century. And so, even though the F.S.A. becomes a haven for run-away slaves, the actual population of blacks within the F.S.A. itself will actually decline over time. And the impact of the increased number of colonists on Africa itself will be immense. But that will be discussed elsewhere.

Are these colonies actual possessions of the FSA or are they considered seperate entities?

The FSA has already expanded as far as possible in NA. If these are territories with the option of eventual statehood I could see a portion of the immigrants from Europe coming to these colonies as well. With a larger proportion of skilled black Americans coming to Liberia and European immigrants looking for land/work the native peoples may be pushed further into the interior than in OTL.

Liberia, independent, has a greater chance of being a more substantial player in global politics just from the increase in the number of ex-slaves, but adding Europeans to the mix you now have a fairsized christian land in west Africa of the 19th century. Eventual statehood increases the FSA's power. With several other colonies trouble with the British and/or French may come about also. Thus, bringing about a need for an increase in naval power for the FSA. Neo-merchantilism was already a going concern for the north before the speration, this could just increase it.

The FSA could eventually change its name to the Federated States of the Atlantic.
 
I don't quite understand why the slave runaway issue became such a problem.

I am basing this mainly on the economic and historical analyses made by Jeffrey Hummel in his book, EMANCIPATING SLAVES, ENSLAVING FREE MEN. While the arguments made therein are controversial in some quarters...as Jared would likely point out...I find them persuasive and have decided to use them in the timeline.

Given how willing slave owners were to switch their slaves from industry to industry and place to place, I'd have thought that if the wastage rate due to escape became too high they'd just transport their slaves down to old Mexico, where there would be no chance of escape to the FSA.

If you're looking to erode popular support for slavery, shifting the slave population from the states to the territories might do it, if the slave owners become concentrated outside places with Federal votes.

There are several problems with that idea. First, there is not a really easy way to transport them there prior to the construction of a good railroad line...which won't be completed until 1869 in the ATL. Second, it would involve selling their land in their current States and buying new land in Mexico. As discussed elsewhere, some land is available in Mexico for the expansion of slave-based agriculture, but that land is limited. And, the statement you made in your last paragraph, would be one reason why the vast majority of established slaveholders suffering from the problem would not go to Mexico...they wouldn't want to lose their votes. The people going to Mexico are likely to be mostly new entrepreneurs rather than people with established fortunes.
 
Are these colonies actual possessions of the FSA or are they considered seperate entities?

Initially owned by the American Colonization Society, but later passing into the ownership of the F.S.A.

The FSA has already expanded as far as possible in NA. If these are territories with the option of eventual statehood I could see a portion of the immigrants from Europe coming to these colonies as well. With a larger proportion of skilled black Americans coming to Liberia and European immigrants looking for land/work the native peoples may be pushed further into the interior than in OTL.

Liberia, independent, has a greater chance of being a more substantial player in global politics just from the increase in the number of ex-slaves, but adding Europeans to the mix you now have a fairsized christian land in west Africa of the 19th century. Eventual statehood increases the FSA's power. With several other colonies trouble with the British and/or French may come about also. Thus, bringing about a need for an increase in naval power for the FSA. Neo-merchantilism was already a going concern for the north before the speration, this could just increase it.

The FSA could eventually change its name to the Federated States of the Atlantic.

All very possible. I will have to give the issue some thought.
 
More additions and corrections...

Additions and Corrections to Earlier Segments of the Timeline

1845 onward--The secession of the Northern States from the Union has created a major economic problem for the United States. The vast majority of the banking industry at the time of secession was located in the North, along with almost all of the nation’s reserves of specie. The U.S. is fortunate in that the Georgia Gold Belt is still producing gold in significant quantities…although the easy gold has, by now, been taken and more industrialized mining operations are now necessary to extract the precious metal…and that mints have been established at Dahlonega to coin the gold thus produced. But the relative scarcity of specie in the early years after the Secession, and lack of a banking industry, will prove significant issues.

In order to meet the demand, most States follow a free-banking policy, allowing banks to be chartered and operate with little regulation. As a result, a banking industry will evolve which will follow some highly questionable practices over the upcoming years. In particular, they will issue large amounts of paper money, in most cases backed by questionable securities such as mortgages and bonds rather than by specie. The lifespan of the majority of these banks will be, on average, about five years, and more than half of them will fail when they cannot redeem their notes.

Needless to say, this all causes a good deal of economic instability in the country. The reopening of the Mexican silver and gold mines (discussed elsewhere) will eventually bring some stability to the banking system by injecting more specie into the U.S. economy and allowing banks to rely less on mortgages and bonds as backing for their paper money, but this will take time. In the interim, several major Panics will result, leading to severe economic recessions. This will lead the Whig Party in particular to argue for the creation of a nationally regulated banking system and the establishment of a single national currency, but this will be opposed by the powerful planter aristocracy, which is shielded, to a large extent, from the effect of these recessions by the stability of the cotton market, and many of whom dabble, as a sideline, in banking as an extra source of income. These planters and their allies form the dominant faction within the Democratic Party, and they will prevent effective action to correct the defects of the banking system for many years.

The resulting recessions affect the non-slaveholding majority much more than they do the upper classes, and over time, they will contribute to the erosion of the power of the planter aristocracy in the U.S.

Meanwhile, in the F.S.A., the dominant Whig Party will pass, in 1847, legislation creating a new central bank, called the Bank of the Federated States. This is based on the old Bank of the United States, but with some additional regulations to help curb the widespread corruption and fraud which plagued it’s ill-fated predecessor. The Bank of the Federated States will not be the sole source of the nation’s money supply…only issuing about 25 percent of the banknotes in circulation in the F.S.A….but the fact that it provides the largest single source of currency in the economy allows it to exercise some control over the money supply in the country, and thus provide a degree of stability to the economy of the F.S.A. which is not enjoyed by the U.S.A. during this period. Nevertheless, like the U.S.A. (although to a lesser degree), the F.S.A. will suffer from an oversupply of bank notes issued by poorly regulated State Banks which are not backed by specie, and bank failures in the F.S.A. will be common, leading (as in the U.S.A.) to economic panics.

1853-1861--The Administration of President Jefferson Davis of the United States. President Davis, like his predecessor, is vitally interested in the development of the Western Territories, and also sees the need for greater industry in the United States in order to support the enlarged military establishment necessitated by the occupation of Mexico. As a result, his two terms in office will, despite his Democratic affiliation, see many of the programs espoused by the Whig Party passed during his administration. He will especially give support to efforts to promote railroad development, and will champion the building of a transcontinental railroad.

Probably the single most significant piece of landmark legislation passed during his term of office, however, is the 1854 Mexican Bullion Act, which will provide solution to a major issue which has plagued the efforts of the Whig Party and like-minded Democrats (such as President Davis) to promote development, both of industry within the United States, and of development in general of the Western Territories. The reopening of the Mexican silver and gold mines, and the discovery of new veins of precious metal in the region, has provided a way around this. The Mexican Bullion Act specifies that an excise tax of five percent shall be levied on all bullion extracted from the mines at the time of assaying. Furthermore, a processing fee of one dollar is charged for every twenty dollars in bullion coined by any of the mints recently established for the processing of the Mexican bullion The revenues generated by these excise taxes and processing fees, according to the Bullion Act, is to go into a fund created to finance internal improvements projects and economic development projects, both in the States and in the Territories. Thus, these projects are able to be financed without resorting to forms of taxation (such as tariffs) found objectionable by the powerful plantation class in the existing States of the United States.

It is thus that, by the end of President Davis’ term, opposition to the Transcontinental Railway Project, as well as federal subsidies for railroad development and other important improvements within the States themselves, will be significantly reduced. And, accordingly, several bills for such projects will be passed.

President Davis will also, in 1853, 1854 and 1855, go against the majority of his own party and veto bills which would have reversed the Clay Tariff of 1841 and rolled back tariff rates to a level of twenty percent...half of what they were under the Clay Tariff. Although in 1856...in order to help his chances of re-election…he does agree to a compromise measure reducing tariff rates from forty percent down to thirty-two percent, he argues, in the end successfully, that a moderately high tariff is necessary to pay for the expanded military, needed to hold down the simmering rebellions which are ongoing in many parts of Mexico. As a result, the development of industry in the United States does not lose the protection which a relatively high tariff will provide to it, which again, supports President Davis’ goal of expanding the industrial base of the United States.

However, his second term will be marred by the economic recession which begins in 1857, and, like his counterpart in the F.S.A., Davis will find this problem insurmountable. As a result, Davis will not run for re-election in 1860, and the Democrats will, for the first time since the Secession, lose the Presidency in that year.

1857-1863--Economic Depression in the U.S.A. and the F.S.A. In August 1857, the New York City branch of the Ohio Life Insurance and Trust Company…one of the largest banks in the F.S.A….fails due to large-scale embezzlement. Shortly afterward, a decision by British investors to withdraw their funds from banks in the F.S.A. is publicized in the nation’s newspapers, further eroding public confidence in the stability of the banking system. A bank panic results, resulting in the failure of numerous other banks. This does not immediately affect the U.S.A., but, the next month, the steamship S.S. VERACRUZ, carrying a load of Mexican gold and silver from the recently reopened mines to the new Washington, D.C. Mint, founders in a huge hurricane off North Carolina. This shakes public confidence in the U.S.A. as to the soundness of their money, and a full scale panic results there as well.

The effects of the Panic…which will go down in history as The Great Panic…are devastating and long-lasting. Thousands of businesses fail, hundreds of thousands of industrial workers in the cities are unemployed, and many farmers lose their land (although the large planters of the U.S.A., shielded by the stability of the cotton market, are little affected). Widespread public anger over the continuing economic misery will contribute to upset victories in both countries in their 1860 elections, bringing the Whig Party to power in the U.S.A. and the American Republican Party to power in the F.S.A.

1857-1861--The Administration of President Abraham Lincoln of the Federated States of America. President Lincoln will be chiefly remembered as the President who negotiated the treaty ending the Mormon War. He will also shepherd several significant bills through the Congress, including the landmark bill authorizing subsidies for the construction of a transcontinental railroad. One bill that does not, surprisingly, make it through during his Administration is any anti-immigration bill. Lincoln opposes such restrictions, viewing continued immigration as necessary both to provide cheap labor for the growing factories of the F.S.A., and also as a source of people to help populate and develop the West. The loose alliance between the Whig Party and the American Republican Party is thus damaged. In the end, the economic recession which begins in late 1857 and Lincoln’s failure to effectively deal with it, will doom his Presidency, and he will not be renominated by his party in 1860.
 
Some more additions and corrections

1848 onward--The settlement of the Western Territories proceeds at a much slower pace than in OTL. The fact that gold was not discovered on schedule in California means also that the phenomenon of people loading up mules with picks and shovels, heading into the wilderness, and prospecting all over the West looking for gold and silver veins, which occurred in OTL largely because the California Gold Rush of 1849 put that idea into the public mind, does not happen. And so the other Western mineral strikes...the Comstock Lode, the Black Hills, the Arizona Strikes, etc., are significantly delayed...if indeed they occur at all in the ATL (historically, the discovery of the other mineral veins was critically dependent on the California Gold Rush happening).

The end result of all this is that the West will be peopled, at a much slower rate than in OTL, primarily by farmers who have gone west, seeking free land. Nevertheless, there will be a steady stream of immigrants, ranging from 2,000 to 10,000 people per year into California, and about the same into Oregon. These Territories will therefore qualify for Statehood before the end of the 19th Century. As the Great Plains is still considered as “The Great American Desert,“ settlers will not find these regions attractive, and Dakota and Nebraska Territories, on the other hand, will be settled much more slowly. On average, between 500 and 3,000 people per year will attempt to settle in these territories, and most of the these won’t stay permanently. These Territories will remain sparsely populated as a result, and will still not have been admitted into the F.S.A. as States well into the 20th Century.

1856 onward--The Republic of Deseret, declared independent on September 22, 1856, will shortly afterward adopt the 1849 Deseret State Constitution, which had been submitted along with the proposal for Statehood within the F.S.A., as the model for a new Constitution for the Republic. Of course, there are some modifications made. Instead of a Governor, there will be a President, and the bi-cameral General Assembly is replaced by a bi-cameral National Assembly. Other changes restrict the right to vote and to hold political office to members of the Mormon Church, and guarantee the right to practice polygamy and other practices held sacred by the Church. In the first election held under the new Constitution in 1858, Brigham Young is, unsurprisingly, elected as the first President of the Republic of Deseret. He will hold the post until his death in 1877.

The Republic faces many problems in it’s early years, being surrounded by hostile neighbors with no easy access to the outside world. But the Republic is mainly self-sufficient from the outset, and President Young strongly encourages the Republic to develop self-sufficiency in all areas…a project which will be largely completed. Although immigrants find it somewhat more difficult to reach the new Republic (at least until the Intercontinental Railroad is completed), the Mormon practice of polygamy, and the resulting large families, allows relatively rapid population growth. But relations with the F.S.A., although they remained strained because of agitation by the Christian Anti-Polygamy Societies of the F.S.A., will remain peaceful, and some useful agreements will be concluded. The most important of these is the Intercontinental Railroad Treaty. The F.S.A., having reviewed possible routes for the proposed railway, decided that the best route for the first Intercontinental Railroad built by that nation would run through the territory of the Republic of Deseret, and an agreement is reached allowing this to proceed. This will allow imports and immigration to reach the Republic more easily.

One interesting development within the new Republic is the adoption, in 1859, of the Deseret Alphabet by the Republic as the standard of communication within the Republic. The Deseret Alphabet was a phonetic alphabet developed in 1854 at the direction of Brigham Young, by the board of regents of the University of Deseret (founded in 1850 at Salt Lake City). Aimed to reform the representation of the English language, not the language itself, the new phonetic system offers a number of advantages. First, it reinforces the cultural exclusivism of the new Republic and heightens the difference between Mormon and Gentile, breeding national feelings within the population of the Republic. It also serves to keep secrets from curious non-Mormons, control what children are allowed (and indeed, able) to read, and in a largely unlettered society that includes many non-English speaking converts, eliminates the awkward problem of phonetic spelling. The 1859 law which promotes this policy mandates that the Deseret Alphabet be the standard alphabet taught in schools throughout the Republic. All newspapers, court documents, and all other official publications are ordered to be printed initially in both the Latin and the Deseret Alphabets, with the Latin versions to be phased out within 20 years. Important texts currently in the Latin Alphabet are ordered to be translated into the new Alphabet and distributed. As a result of these policies, the Deseret Alphabet will be one of the few “created” alphabets to succeed and survive (the Cherokee Alphabet being the other prime example of such an occurrence), and by the end of the 19th century, it will be in almost exclusive use within the Republic of Deseret.
 
Since there is no California Gold Rush at the same time as OTL and greater immigration to Liberia, how about a Liberian Diamond Rush. While not as great as South Africa, Liberia has a significant amount of Alluvial diamond deposits. (It has a decent amount of gold deposits also.)
This could help pay for the needed resources for the growing population. If FSA itself or FSA held companies own the majority of mines they will want protection, meaning a proper military presence to ward off potential attack from unassimilated natives or foreign countries. This was also mean an increase in the need for merchant ships and subsequent naval presence to ward off raiders.

Another thing I was thinking about in regards to possession of Liberia is the availablity of Rubber trees. This could potentially help with a slightly earlier start for a plastics industry and/or electronics.
 
One thing that would lengthen the depression is the fact that in 1861, there was an overproduction of cotton. In fact, there was so much cotton that the mills in Manchester were able to run for all of 1862 with cotton that was shipped in 1861.

If there had been no Civil War, it is quite possible that the glut of cotton would cause a slump in the South and would have forced more small time plantation owners out of business.
 
One thing that would lengthen the depression is the fact that in 1861, there was an overproduction of cotton. In fact, there was so much cotton that the mills in Manchester were able to run for all of 1862 with cotton that was shipped in 1861.

If there had been no Civil War, it is quite possible that the glut of cotton would cause a slump in the South and would have forced more small time plantation owners out of business.

That's all very likely. Indeed, the problem might be worse in the ATL because by this time, at least some Mexican land would have been brought into cultivation, and the internal improvements projects funded under the Davis Administration would have opened up more land in the States themselves.
 
Since there is no California Gold Rush at the same time as OTL and greater immigration to Liberia, how about a Liberian Diamond Rush. While not as great as South Africa, Liberia has a significant amount of Alluvial diamond deposits. (It has a decent amount of gold deposits also.)

This could help pay for the needed resources for the growing population. If FSA itself or FSA held companies own the majority of mines they will want protection, meaning a proper military presence to ward off potential attack from unassimilated natives or foreign countries. This was also mean an increase in the need for merchant ships and subsequent naval presence to ward off raiders.

Another thing I was thinking about in regards to possession of Liberia is the availablity of Rubber trees. This could potentially help with a slightly earlier start for a plastics industry and/or electronics.

All good ideas that I will have to consider. Thanks again!
 
Part Three of the Timeline...with additions and corrections...

ADDITIONS AND CORRECTIONS TO EARLIER SEGMENTS

1857--Samuel Clemens, a 22-year old young man living in Hannibal, Missouri, takes a steamboat trip to New Orleans. During the trip, the pilot, a man named Bixby, persuades him to pursue a career as a river-boat pilot, which is a richly rewarding profession paying the princely sum of $250 a month (equal to about $155,000 a year today). Clemens loves his new profession, and is very good at it, and he will ply the waters of the Mississippi for the remainder of his life. He will be killed when the boiler of his steamboat accidentally explodes in 1889. Other than a few humorous letters published in the HANNIBAL JOURNAL (a newspaper owned by his brother, Orion…who, like Samuel, will never go west), he will never publish anything of note.

Part Three: 1861-1880

1861-1898--Indian Wars in the West. From 1861 to 1898, the U.S.A., the F.S.A., Deseret, or all three, will be at war almost constantly with some group of Native Americans in the West. In the end, the natives will be almost exterminated in most places, with the pitiful survivors confined to reservations.

March 1861--In Washington, D.C., Robert Augustus Toombs is sworn in as the fourteenth President of the United States of America. At New York, Levi Boone is sworn in as the fourth President of the Federated States of America.

May 1861--The U.S.A.’s transcontinental telegraph line is completed.

1861-1869--The administration of President Levi Boone of the Federated States of America. Boone’s administration starts off well, as several pieces of banking reform legislation are passed in his first year of office which go a long way toward correcting the conditions which lead to the Great Panic. Boone, like his counterpart in the U.S.A., Robert Toombs, will also sponsor public works projects as a way of absorbing much of the unemployed labor in the country and injecting cash into the industrial sector as a means of “jump-starting” the business sector. These policies will have an effect, and the Great Panic will end in the F.S.A. by 1863. This will be enough to get Boone re-elected for a second term in 1864.

However, in the end, Boone’s administration will be remembered, not for ending the Great Panic, but for it’s anti-immigration laws and policies. Toward the end of Boone’s first administration, draconian new anti-immigration laws are finally passed by the Congress of the F.S.A. Small quotas are set up for each European country. The combined quota for all Catholic countries in Europe is set at a level less than that of England alone. All immigration from anyplace other than Europe is banned. Immigrant entry stations are set up at all major ports (the one at New York on Ellis Island), these stations staffed by confirmed Republican Party members who have absolute authority to deny entry to any immigrant they deem “undesirable.” In some places, these officials commit atrocious abuses of their authority, demanding bribes or worse from immigrant applicants…some particularly unscrupulous officials will demand sexual services from female applicants…in exchange for being allowed into the country. Other immigrants are subjected to beatings during “entry interviews” by these officials. When news of these abuses finally becomes public in President Boone’s second term, it will create a huge scandal.

Domestically, Know Nothing gangs will terrorize immigrants many F.S.A. cities, rioting and looting immigrant-owned businesses, burning Catholic churches, and administering beatings to any immigrants they find alone on the streets at night. In response, immigrant communities will form their own vigilance committees which exact retribution against these gangs for their attacks on immigrants. This will, of course, be used by the Boone Administration to justify even more severe restrictions on immigration, as well as draconian laws…couched as “necessary law enforcement measures”… restricting the freedom of immigrants within the F.S.A. itself.

As a result of these policies, the level of immigration falls dramatically during Boone’s second term of office. This will quickly begin to impact business expansion in the F.S.A. Industrialists in the F.S.A. had depended on a steady supply of immigrant labor, willing to work long hours in horrible conditions for extremely low pay, to keep their factories running and competitive with British manufacturing (which abuses it’s labor force even more than do the industrialists in the F.S.A.). Now they no longer have access to this labor force, and native Americans are simply not willing to work in the horrible conditions of the factories for the ridiculously low wages being offered. Industrialists are faced with a stark choice: either pay higher wages and hire native Americans…which will make their goods even more uncompetitive with British goods…or shut down. Allies of the industrialists in Congress try to provide a quick fix by raising tariffs again to the highest rates which will ever be seen in history, effectively shutting out British imports and severely impacting imports from other countries as well. But Britain and other countries respond by raising their own tariffs, sparking an international trade war. By the end of Boone’s term, the country is back in the throes of economic recession as a result.

1861-1865--The administration of President Robert Toombs of the United States of America. President Toombs will be significant in U.S. history as the first President to publicly advocate loosening restrictions on the Castizo/Mestizo population of Mexico as a means to take the steam out of the ongoing rebellions in many areas of Mexico. He is not successful in getting such legislation passed, but his advocacy of this course of action starts a public debate on the issue which will, eventually, bear fruit.

Concerned by the increasing toll being taken on American troops in Mexico by fighting with Mexican insurgents, Toombs will also be the first President to make serious attempts to negotiate with the leaders of the various Mexican rebel factions and the Mexican “government in exile” for which most of the rebels are, at least officially, fighting. These negotiations, although they will not be successful during his term, will eventually lead, within the next two decades, to an agreement which re-establishes an independent, although much abridged, Mexico.

Toombs will also be remembered for his strong espousal of internal improvements and public works projects as a means of combating the effects of the Great Panic. During the first two years of his administration especially, several major bills for public works projects in the States and Territories will be passed. Although these measures will be, in some measure, successful (most historians place the official end of the depression caused by the Great Panic in 1863...although, in many areas, the effects continued for some time after that…and credit the infusion of cash into the economy resulting from Toombs‘ public works projects with a major share of the credit for this), they will, along with Toombs’ advocacy of greater rights for Mexicans, doom his Presidency. Since Mexican migrants flocking north to work on these projects are often seen as the beneficiaries of these policies, the Democrats will seek to whip up white fears of Mexican migration as a campaign tactic in the 1864 election, leading them to victory.

November 1864--National Elections in the U.S.A. and the F.S.A. In the U.S.A., President Toombs is renominated by the Whig Party, while the Democrats nominate Robert M. T. Hunter of Virginia. The nomination of Hunter marks a revolt within the Democratic Party by the powerful planter class against the pro-internal- improvements and pro-industrialization wing of the party (epitomized by former Democratic Presidents Benton and Davis). Democratic candidate Hunter, the candidate of this privileged elite, wants to lower the tariff to pre-1841 levels and use the revenue being derived from the Mexican Bullion Act to offset the reduction in tariffs.

However, the Democrats recognize that the tariff issue is not “sexy” enough to woo the majority of voters, and as the main focus of their campaign, they try a new strategy, playing on increasing fears of Mexican migration into the cities of the United States. The Whigs, seeking to promote industrialization and development, have generally supported the encouragement of migration by Mexicans northward and the use of cheap Mexican labor by the developing industries of the U.S. As a result of these policies, the number of Mexicans living in U.S. cities is rapidly increasing and they are becoming a significant minority in many areas, which is alarming many whites. The Democrats portray the Whigs as a party which “values dirty Greasers over good White Men.”

President Toombs and the Whig Party find it difficult to counter this Democratic strategy, and their arguments, unfortunately, do not successfully convey to the common voter the value of using the revenue created by the Mexican Bullion Act as specified in the Bullion Act…to fund internal improvements projects in the States and the Territories so as to spur economic development. Even though President Toombs is endorsed in the election by the popular former President Jefferson Davis…a Democrat who often found himself at odds with the planter aristocrats within his own party during his own term as President because of his support of the Mexican Bullion Act and of internal improvements in general…he loses the election by a significant margin.

In the F.S.A., the American Republican Party renominates President Boone. The Democratic Party nominates Horatio Seymour of New York, while the Whigs, in an attempt to co-opt the anti-immigration vote from President Boone, nominate Henry B. Anthony of Rhode Island. The key issue of the election is the immigration issue, with Democratic candidate Seymour arguing for relaxing restrictions on immigration, while both Boone and Anthony argue against it. In what will prove to be a historic decision, in order to avoid splitting their own vote and thus handing the election to the Democrats, the Whigs and the American Republicans hold a joint convention in September 1864, following their own party conventions which were held the previous month. In a backroom deal, it is agreed to combine the two tickets, with Boone running for President and Anthony for Vice President (the Vice Presidential candidates selected by the respective parties at their own conventions are forced by their party leaderships to withdraw from the election). The ticket of Boone and Anthony proceeds to defeat Horatio Seymour in the general election. Thus begins the process which will lead, within two years, to the formal merging of the American Republican and Whig parties in the F.S.A.

December 1864--Thomas Nast, a moderately successful political cartoonist for the F.S.A.’s largest newspaper, LESLIE’S ILLUSTRATED WEEKLY (HARPER‘S WEEKLY, the paper where in OTL Nast did his most significant work, was never founded in the ATL), takes ship with his family and moves to Australia. Although Nast, in OTL, was both anti-Irish and anti-Catholic, and thus would seem a natural ally of the American Republican Party, he is a German immigrant and in the ATL, along with other German immigrants, has been harassed by Know Nothing toughs and generally made to feel like a second-class citizen by the Boone Administration. During the recent election, Nast campaigned against Boone through a series of vicious editorial cartoons. He received threats to his life from some of Boone’s cronies as a result, which played a major part in his decision to leave the country. He will never return to the F.S.A. The departure of Nast will have impacts both cultural and political.

Culturally, the departure of Nast will drastically affect how Christmas is celebrated in the Federated States and, indeed, the world. This is because, at the time of his departure, Nast has not completed his series of Christmas drawings featuring Santa Claus, and many aspects of the Santa Claus legend which we take for granted in OTL…Santa’s costume and appearance as we know it in OTL, the idea of Santa having a workshop staffed by elves who make toys, the idea of Santa living at the North Pole, the idea that Santa gives gifts only to “good” children and denies them to “naughty” ones, and the custom of writing letters to Santa…never come into being in the ATL. The custom of kissing under mistletoe also never catches on in America (although the custom was known in Europe prior to Nast's engravings, it was through his engravings in America that the custom caught on there in OTL). Santa Claus ends up looking very different, and customs for celebrating Christmas end up being very different.

Politically, the departure of Nast will be one of several factors which will enable a New York politician of Irish ancestry…one William Magear Tweed…to have a very different political career in the ATL. More on this elsewhere.

March 1865--In a ceremony held at Washington, D.C., Robert M. T. Hunter is sworn in as the fifteenth President of the United States. At New York, Levi Boone is sworn in for a second term as President of the Federated States.

May 1865--Susan B. Anthony and Elizabeth Cady Stanton form the National Woman Suffrage Association. The primary goal of the organization is to achieve voting rights for women by means of a Congressional amendment to the Constitution of the F.S.A.

1865-1873--The administration of President Robert M. T. Hunter of the United States of America. Hunter will sponsor attempts in Congress to pass legislation restricting the ability of business owners in the U.S. to employ Mexican migrant workers. These attempts, however, will not be successful. Hunter also fails to repeal the various internal improvements laws which had been passed by earlier administrations, but he and his allies in Congress do prevent any new ones from being passed. Hunter’s major legislative victory, however, is the passage of an amendment to the Mexican Bullion Act, which allows funds from Mexican Bullion taxes to be used for purposes other than internal improvements. This allows the planter party in Congress to successfully lobby for a reduction in the tariff to pre-1848 levels. Hunter’s policies will have deleterious effects on the economic development of the United States in the upcoming years, and by the end of his second term, the United States will, once again, be in the throes of a severe recession.

President Hunter also continues the negotiations with the Mexican rebels and their “government in exile” which had begun under President Toombs. Like Toombs, however, Hunter will not successfully complete these negotiations during his term of office. Last but not least, under Hunter’s term of office, serious fighting will break out between U.S. forces and the Apache in the Southwest.

May 1866--At a joint convention held in Chicago, Illinois, the American Republican and Whig Parties agree to formally merge. The new organization will call itself, simply, the Republican Party. As a condition of the merge, the leadership of the former Whig Party guarantees full support for the anti-immigrant agenda of the American Republicans. This will lead to a defection of many former Whigs from the ranks of the new party, strengthening the Democrats. Nevertheless, the new Republican Party will be the dominant party of the F.S.A. for most of the remainder of the 19th century.

November 1866--Lucy Stone, Henry Blackwell, and others form the Woman’s Suffrage Association of the Federated States. This group focuses exclusively on gaining voting rights for women through amendments to individual state constitutions.

May 1868--The F.S.A.’s first transcontinental railroad is completed. The line links Council Bluffs, Iowa with San Francisco, California, the line running through the Republic of Deseret (passing through the capital at Salt Lake City).

July 1868--U.S. troops corner and decisively defeat the rebel Juan Cortina in Nuevo Leon Territory, killing Cortina in the process.

August 1868--James Gibbons named by Pope Pius IX as Vicar Apostolic of North Carolina.

September 1868--Oregon is admitted into the Federated States of America as that nation’s 17th State.

November 1868--National Elections in the U.S.A. and the F.S.A.

In the U.S.A., the Democratic Party renominates President Hunter, while the Whigs nominate Zebulon Baird Vance of North Carolina. As Whig candidate Vance is on record as supporting the use of Mexican labor in industry, the Democrats once again run their “Greaser-loving Whigs” campaign. Vance proves an able opponent, however. Noting the fact of the increasing gulf between the interests of the planters and the interests of just about everybody else in the U.S.A., Vance takes the bold step of actively campaigning against the “fat, greedy plantation aristocrats” and presenting himself and the Whig Party as the champions of the interests of the common man. However, in the end, the fear-mongering of the Democrats wins out, and President Hunter is re-elected by the narrowest of margins. This victory, however, will prove to be the last hurrah of the old planter aristocracy and it’s influence over politics in the U.S.A.

In the F.S.A., President Boone declines to run for a third term, throwing the field open to new candidates. The Republican Party nominates Vice President Henry B. Anthony of Rhode Island as it’s candidate for President. The Democrats nominate William Magear Tweed, a New York politician of Irish ancestry who has championed the cause of immigrants. Anti-immigrant feeling is still strong in the F.S.A., and despite the recession and the scandals relating to abuses committed as a result of the Boone Administration’s immigration policies, the election is a close one. But in the end, anger at the renewed recession and disgust at the anti-immigrant excesses of the Know Nothings combine to give the Democrats a victory, and William M. Tweed is elected President of the Federated States of America.

January 1869--The U.S.A.’s first transcontinental railroad is completed.

March 1869--At Washington, D.C., Robert M. T. Hunter is sworn in for a second term as President of the United States of America. At New York, William Magear Tweed is sworn in as the fifth President of the Federated States of America.

1869-1877--The administration of President William Magear Tweed of the Federated States of America. The Presidency of William Magear Tweed will leave a mixed legacy which historians will ponder to this day. Tweed’s administration will be marked by a rollback of the worst of the Know Nothing immigration laws passed during the Boone Administration. Important currency reform legislation will also be passed, which will greatly reduce the volatility of the F.S.A.‘s economy. Other important events during his administration will include the admission of California as a State, and a protracted series of Indian Wars in the West.

However, the legacy his administration will most be remembered for is rampant corruption. Tweed will sponsor lavish spending on internal improvements projects, most of which will be riddled with graft and corruption at a cost of millions of dollars to the taxpayers. As a result of shady dealings primarily by his political appointees, his second term will be marred by several major corruption scandals. In the biggest of these, two members of Tweed’s cabinet , his Secretary of the Treasury and Secretary of War (who also happened to be the President and Vice President of a railroad company which was receiving government subsidies and were guilty of embezzling those funds), will be imprisoned. The extent of Tweed‘s own involvement in this feeding frenzy of greed and corruption may never be known, but the lavish personal expenditures he will make during his term…palatial homes in New York City, Long Island, and Albany, New York; a large yacht; a private train car; and others…will be more than enough to convince a majority of the voters that “where there is smoke, there is fire.“ And indeed, there will be enough “smoke” from Tweed’s financial dealings that Tweed will be brought before impeachment proceedings in early 1876. However, he will narrowly avoid conviction in the Senate, and will serve out the remainder of his term, albeit in disgrace.

March 1870--California is admitted into the Federated States of America as that nation’s 18th State.

April 1870--The new transcontinental railroad is proving a boon to Anglo settlement in Mexico, especially Sonora Territory, whose citizen population has grown to the point by April 1870 that the U.S. Congress admits Sonora territory to the Union, the first of the Mexican Territories to achieve Statehood status.

July 1871--The 1870 Census reveals that California Territory has finally met the minimum population requirements for admission into the Federated States, and the F.S. Congress passes legislation creating the new State of California.

1872--James Gibbons becomes Bishop of Richmond, Virginia. Upon moving to this industrial center, Gibbons becomes aware of the plight of Mexican Catholic factory workers, who face many forms of discrimination. Over time, he will begin to work, quietly and behind the scenes, on their behalf.

March 1872--Susan B. Anthony submits to the Federated States Congress for consideration a draft Constitutional Amendment granting Women’s Suffrage. The Congress takes no immediate action.

November 1872--National Elections in the U.S.A. and the F.S.A. In the U.S.A., President Hunter decides not to run for re-election. The Democrats nominate Clement C. Claiborne of Alabama, while the Whigs nominate Henry Watkins Allen of Louisiana. The Democrats once again trot out the “Greaser-loving Whigs” mantra which served them well in the past two campaigns, and the common wisdom is that Claiborne will easily win election. The campaign of Whig candidate Allen, however, strikes a cord with an increasing segment among lower and middle-class whites who have suffered under Hunter’s economic policies and also increasingly found themselves frozen out of the slaveholding planter aristocracy by increasing slave prices, and who have thus begun to question why they should blindly support the political and economic agendas of the planters above their own interests. And so, in a landmark political upset, Henry Watkins Allen wins the election by a large majority.

In the F.S.A., the Democrats renominate President Tweed, while the Republicans nominate John Sherman of Ohio. The popular President Tweed will easily win re-election to a second term.

1873--Grasshopper plagues devastate western farms in both the F.S.A. and the U.S.A.

March 1873--In a ceremony at Washington, D.C., Henry Watkins Allen is sworn in as the sixteenth President of the United States of America. At New York, William Magear Tweed is sworn in for a second term as President of the Federated States of America.

1873-1881--The administration of President Henry Watkins Allen of the United States of America. Allen’s term will once again see the passage of internal improvements legislation by Congress, and, while the amendment to the Mexican Bullion Act which was passed under Hunter’s Administration will not be repealed, Allen will successfully lobby for in increase in the tariff for the purpose of fostering industrial growth in the U.S. Allen’s policies will prove to be just the stimulus the U.S. economy needs, and he will be remembered as the President who ended the “Planter Recession,” as the economic downturn caused by the policies of President Robert M. T. Hunter and his plantation aristocrat supporters in Congress has come to be called in the United States. He will also go down in history as a peacemaker, after successfully negotiating a treaty which ends the ongoing insurrection in Mexico, in the process re-establishing an independent Mexican state.

May 1874--Bishop James Gibbons starts an educational program to teach English to Mexican workers and their families in the Richmond area.

1875--The National Women Suffrage Association and the Women Suffrage Association of the Federated States merge to form the National Woman Suffrage Association of the Federated States (NWSAFS). As the movement's mainstream organization, NWSAFS wages state-by-state campaigns to obtain voting rights for women.

June 1875--California del Norte and Nuevo Leon are admitted by the U.S. Congress into the Union as States.

November 1876--National Elections in the U.S.A. and the F.S.A. In the U.S.A., President Henry Watkins Allen is renominated by the Whig Party, while the Democrats nominate Robert Lowry of Mississippi. Lowry is a rich planter and another candidate of the powerful plantation aristocracy which controls the Democratic Party, and does not run an effective campaign. Allen easily wins election to a second term.

In the F.S.A., disgraced President William Magear Tweed declines to run for re-election. Instead, the Democrats nominate Grover Cleveland of New Jersey, while the Republicans nominate J. Neely Johnson of Indiana (in OTL, Johnson had gone west during the California Gold Rush, where he won election as Governor of California in 1856 on the American Party/Know Nothing ticket. In the ATL, he never left Indiana and became involved with the American Republican Party there, eventually rising to Governor of Indiana by 1860 and later serving in the Senate as a Republican. He also does not experience the decline in health which killed him in 1872 at the age of 47 in OTL, and so is still alive to run for President in 1876). Promising an “honest and trustworthy administration,” with a “kinder and gentler, but still firm” policy on immigration, Johnson takes advantage of general public disgust with the corruption of the Democrats to win a landslide victory.

March 1877--In a ceremony at Washington, D.C., Henry Watkins Allen is sworn in for a second term as President of the United States. At New York, J. Neely Johnson is sworn in as the sixth President of the Federated States of America.

1877-1880--The administration of President J. Neely Johnson of the Federated States of America. Johnson proves to be somewhat of a genial non-entity, and although he promised somewhat tougher, but still “kinder and gentler” immigration laws, none are passed during his administration. He will die in office before the end of his first term.

August 1877--Death of President Brigham Young of the Republic of Deseret. Young is succeeded in office by Vice President John Taylor, who will serve out the remainder of Young’s current four year term, which ends in 1879 (the next Deseret general elections are to be held in November 1878).

October 1877--James Gibbons become Archbishop of Baltimore. He will use the authority given him by his new post to expand the education program for Mexican workers, which he founded in Richmond, Virginia while serving as Bishop there, to all the cities whose Catholic churches are under his leadership.

November 1878--In General Elections held in the Republic of Deseret, John Taylor is elected as President (the first time he has been elected on his own account as President). Taylor will continue to serve until his own death in 1887.

April 1879--The Treaty of Mexico City is signed, whereby the U.S. agrees to withdraw, over a five year period, from all the Mexican Territories except California del Norte, New Mexico, Nuevo Leon, Coahuila, Chihuahua, Sonora, and Baja California. The United States agrees to the re-establishment of an independent Mexico, in exchange for economic concessions (specifically the right to continue to exploit Mexico’s gold and silver mines) by the new Mexican government. The Mexicans agree to grant legal protection to the lives and property of Anglos who have made their homes in Mexico, in exchange for an agreement to relax legal restrictions on Mexicans living in the United States (in practice, neither side will live up to that portion of the agreement with any great enthusiasm, and many Anglos who have made their homes in Mexico will return to the U.S. over the succeeding years. Since the Mexicans already living in the U.S. are pretty much used to living with restricted rights, however, few of them choose to return to Mexico).

1880-1881--The Nez Perce War. When the government of the F.S.A. demands that the Nez Perce Indians of the Wallowa Valley, in Oregon, remove to a reservation, a band led by Chief Joseph defies the order and flees to Canada. F.S. Army units are sent to pursue, and are defeated by Chief Joseph in several battles. In one of the rare Native American victories of the long, sad period of the Indian Wars, Joseph and his band elude their pursuers and escape to Canada.

May 1880--California is the first State of the F.S.A. to grant women the right to vote.

June 1880--President J. Neely Johnson of the F.S.A. dies in office (his health problems which killed him in OTL having been delayed, but not stopped, finally catch up to him). He is succeeded by his Vice President, John Sherman of Ohio, who becomes the seventh President of the Federated States of America.

June 1880-March 1881--The administration of President John Sherman of the Federated States of America. President Sherman will, like his predecessor, have an unremarkable, and short, administration.

November 1880--National Elections in the U.S.A. and the C.S.A. In the U.S.A., President Henry Watkins Allen declines to run for a third term. In his stead, the Whig Party nominates John Joseph Martin of North Carolina, while the Democrats nominate James Black Groome of Maryland. The nomination of Groome represents a revolt by the pro-internal-improvements and pro-industrialization wing of the Democratic Party, which has been suppressed by the power of the plantation aristocrats since the election of 1864. There is not much to choose from between the two candidates, and in a narrow election, Groome wins. His victory will effectively seal the fate of the plantation aristocracy as the controlling political force in the U.S.A. With both political parties in the control of those opposed to the aristocrats and their agenda, the aristocrats find themselves out in the cold and helplessly watch as the full agenda of their opponents is enacted into law over the next few decades.

In the F.S.A., the Republicans nominate President Sherman, and the Democrats nominate Thomas Reed Cobb of Indiana. In a narrow election, Cobb defeats Sherman to win the Presidency.

map1880.GIF
 
Last edited:
I can see the FS putting a National Bank Clause into their Consitution,
Thyis will lead to major differences later on
 
page 2
1848 onward--The settlement of the Western Territories proceeds at a much slower pace than in OTL. The fact that gold was not discovered on schedule in California means also that the phenomenon of people loading up mules with picks and shovels, heading into the wilderness, and prospecting all over the West looking for gold and silver veins, which occurred in OTL largely because the California Gold Rush of 1849 put that idea into the public mind, does not happen. And so the other Western mineral strikes...the Comstock Lode, the Black Hills, the Arizona Strikes, etc., are significantly delayed...if indeed they occur at all in the ATL. And the result of all this is that the West is peopled, at a much slower rate than in OTL, primarily by farmers who have gone west, seeking free land. Large areas of the West remain sparsely populated as a result, and much of the West will still not have been admitted into the F.S.A. as States well into the 20th Century.
I see the debate over Slavery in the west as somewhat academic, given the few number of people there.
This fewer palefaces, will inpact the indian Lands also.

Mexico banned slavery in 1824, with it's new consitution, and has a decent number of free blacks.
?How do they take to the US attemp to reinpose slavery to the areas?
 
Last edited:
I really liked the update. This is one of my favorites on the board right now.

While I see no real animosity between the US and FS, after looking at the map, I would imagine the Pennsylvania-Ohio border (and Ohio as a whole) is one of the more highly guarded areas of the FSA. If the two nations ever get into a full blown war the nation would be cut in half. Deseret is also handicapping the FSA's defense against the USA. All those supplies and men must travel up and around Deseret when they need to be moved east or west.


I'm interested on what will happen with Cuba and Puerto Rico, so I hope you touch on them soon. They would most likely go the the US if Spain gives up possession of them, but I think it would be interesting if the FSA some how got them. It gives them more territory, aside from Liberia, and it would reinforce their need/presence as a growing naval power (Great Lakes, Pacific Ocean, and the Atlantic to get to Africa).

I was also wondering if you are going to give any information as to the goings-on in the rest of the world.
 
Page three

Why would the FS go with so many Ironclads, This is the time of the Warrier and Black prince in GB, and the Gloria in France.
All Steel ships like these is what the FS would build.


I can see the 1850's rising anti immigrtion deverting a larger percentage of Irish to South Africa, and Austrilia
post ACW is the start of the Italian Migration. Given a anti Immigration mood in the FS, I see most of these going to South america.
Argentina was OTL the second largest destination, with some going to Uraguay and Brazil.
ITTL I could see a Majority Italian Uraguay by 1900.
I also the majority of TTL's post ACW Germans going to Brazil, which was OTL's second choice.

?Was there a Crimian War ITTL? ?Did the no Pacific War agreement hold ITTL?

A Larger BC may not be as willing to join Canada.

I don't see San Francisco as the Termius of the Trans Continitial.
I think the Northern Pacific from Chicago to Portland would be more likely to be built first. This avoids the Deseret Problem for a while.
 
4
1873--Grasshopper plagues devastate western farms in both the F.S.A. and the U.S.A.
? Will TTL have the great Bird catching programs as OTL?. Penny for a small bird, nickel for a large bird.
Why there are so many Sea Gulls in Kanas and Nebraska.
 
I can see the FS putting a National Bank Clause into their Consitution,
This will lead to major differences later on

Why would they need to put it in their Constitution, when they can just pass laws in Congress?

page 2

I see the debate over Slavery in the west as somewhat academic, given the few number of people there.
This fewer palefaces, will inpact the indian Lands also.

The slavery issue pretty much died when the Union was divided. As for the Indians, yes, it does impact them, but not as much as you'd probably think. The Indians still end up on reservations, just takes a bit longer, and the reservations are probably somewhat larger (especially the ones in Nebraska and Dakota, where the white population is especially low)

Mexico banned slavery in 1824, with it's new consitution, and has a decent number of free blacks. How do they take to the US attemp to reinpose slavery to the areas?

This would, without doubt, be a contributing factor to the insurrection in Mexico against U.S. rule.

Page three

Why would the FS go with so many Ironclads, This is the time of the Warrier and Black prince in GB, and the Gloria in France.
All Steel ships like these is what the FS would build.

Warrior and Black Prince were indeed all steel ships, but La Gloire was a true ironclad (i.e. a wooden ship with a covering of iron armor). Also, the term "ironclads" was somewhat of a generic term in the 1860s and 1870s for an armored warship...some of the Union "ironclads" in the OTL ACW (the monitors, for example) were really all-iron, or nearly so, but were still called ironclads. So most of what the F.S.A. (and the U.S.A.) are building would in fact be all-steel ships, even though they might still be popularly called "ironclads."


I can see the 1850's rising anti immigrtion deverting a larger percentage of Irish to South Africa, and Australia. Post ACW is the start of the Italian Migration. Given a anti Immigration mood in the FS, I see most of these going to South america. Argentina was OTL the second largest destination, with some going to Uraguay and Brazil. ITTL I could see a Majority Italian Uraguay by 1900. I also the majority of TTL's post ACW Germans going to Brazil, which was OTL's second choice.

To a large extent everything you say here is probably true. However, remember that although there was a large anti-immigration sentiment in the F.S.A. which allowed the Know Nothings to gain political prominence, until the Boone Administration in the 1860s there were no actual anti-immigrant laws passed. So a lot of the immigration still ended up in the F.S.A.

?Was there a Crimian War ITTL? ?Did the no Pacific War agreement hold ITTL?

Yes to both.

A Larger BC may not be as willing to join Canada.

That may be...I haven't yet thought about that aspect of it.

I don't see San Francisco as the Termius of the Trans Continitial. I think the Northern Pacific from Chicago to Portland would be more likely to be built first. This avoids the Deseret Problem for a while.

True, but San Francisco is a much better seaport, and the winters along the central route are a bit less savage than the ones on the northern route, which is why the central route to Frisco was chosen. Also, the telegraph line already was run along that route, and the F.S. Government wanted the first transcontinental line to follow the same route.

4

? Will TTL have the great Bird catching programs as OTL?. Penny for a small bird, nickel for a large bird.
Why there are so many Sea Gulls in Kanas and Nebraska.

I would imagine so.
 
Top