alternatehistory.com

What if liberalism as we know it did not even conceptualize into mainstream consciousness?

What I am mainly looking for is the absence of personal freedom and universal rights to not get tied together with the idea of free movement of trade and the industrial revolution. I feel like the end of mercantilism is unavoidable, but I have a few ideas for an alternative to liberalism that could catch on. I am not going to focus on any sort of timeline with this bullet points, just broad ideas to help get my goal across.
  • Butterfly the Glorious Revolution and have a competent generation of nobleman lead England, not by the will of the people, but by the Grace of God.

  • The American Revolution established the United States of America, but with a considerably toned down set of beliefs. The revolution is not undertaken with the justification of popular sovereignty and the belief that a people who do not wish to be govern should not be. Instead it is seen as an issue of national sovereignty, with the American people and continent being distinct from the British and should not be ruled by them. More cynically, it was really just about shaking off mercantilism. Due to this, the right to vote is restricted to wealthy landowners until at least the 1870s.

  • The Industrial Revolution is spurred on, at a slightly slower rate than IOTL, by government owned companies. There isn't really an era where government does not have a hand in industry, with it having formed it from the beginning and maintained it as part of the structure of government like the military would be. There are privately run enterprises that spring up, but they have to work with the government to some extent. This creates a very different sort of market from our own, with the state being the main producer of goods and thus nations compete with products as opposed to companies within nations. This fails to create the free market as we know it and actually results in something a lot more restrictive and less competitive.

Anybody have ideas on what the effects of any/all of this would be? Any other ideas on how to butterfly and/or alter liberalism as it was in the 1800s?
Top