WI: No "Great Terror" after the killing of the French Royals

The expression was that the "Revolution consumed its own children".

How would the French Revolution have gone if the Great Terror had been halted with only a handful of Royalists (and the Monarchs) being beheaded?

Assume Robespierre, Danton and other political leaders were not executed.

Assume many successful military leaders -Dillon (murdered by his own men), Luckmer, Dumouriez (escaped), Michelsky, Pichegru (escaped), Moreau, Westermann - were not denounced and executed or exiled after "failing to do their duty".

How would these additional persons either being in power or still part of the system affect the Revolution?

What butterflies?
 
I mean, what does this mean? What's the POD? Do we still have Robespierre on the Committee of Public Safety? Do we still *have* a Committee of Public Safety? Are there still Federalist rebellions? Because most of the executions in the Terror were of rebels in the provinces, not revolutionary leaders in Paris.
 
I'm assuming Robespierre and Danton remained politically active, though perhaps their factions were pushed to the back.

As for the "Great Terror", I'm referring to an early wipeout of the Royals and some nobility but it did not eventually translate over to factions wiping out each other when they got out of line. Also, the paranoia of the "Terror" ended with a lot of successful military leaders denounced on political grounds and killed.
 
The expression was that the "Revolution consumed its own children".

How would the French Revolution have gone if the Great Terror had been halted with only a handful of Royalists (and the Monarchs) being beheaded?

Assume Robespierre, Danton and other political leaders were not executed.

Assume many successful military leaders -Dillon (murdered by his own men), Luckmer, Dumouriez (escaped), Michelsky, Pichegru (escaped), Moreau, Westermann - were not denounced and executed or exiled after "failing to do their duty".

How would these additional persons either being in power or still part of the system affect the Revolution?

What butterflies?

Let's say that the Girdonists win the battle to spare the Louis and he's thrown in the slammer in Paris.

War has already begun, perhaps with a little less fervor the Republic fares a little worse on the battlefield but Danton's still stirring up mass enlistment. In any event the war drags on, but it might end with a negotiated peace. The ex-Royal's are probably allowed to go to Vienna as part of the deal. An uneasy peace is the most likely option. Robspirre goes down as "Anti-Death Penalty Guy".
 
one word for you, "paranoia" in order to significantly decrease the severity of the Reign of Terror you need to decrease the paranoia (or you could remove the anti-christian aspect, I have no idea how you would do that though). The best way I can think of to do that is to give the other countries something else to worry about other than the republic be it internal strife or unrelated war.
 
Top