The Carib islands are a grab-bag for any other European power.
Well, first of all, I voted France to be the one that get better relations with natives, but I think that "was based more on mutually beneficial trading" is not exactly the right terms. I think that was more like we aren´t suficient settlers to exterminate the indians so, we would get good (at least in terms of the society of that time) relationships with them.French relationships with the Indians was based more on mutually beneficial trading relationships. This allowed a number of tribes in the midwest and plains states to flourish as trading partners and military allies of the French - to the detrimnent of both other tribes as well as the Spanish and English.
Had the French not lost in 1763, its interesting to speculate how this would have affected the evolution of creole native societies.