WI Lee mauls the Union army at Antietam.

TFSmith121

Banned
Pretty much...

In short although "McLellan the Overcautious" was too cautious to win a total victory he was also too cautious to totally lose as well. Besides which "Lee the Overrated" never came close to winning such a victory and almost always lost a higher percentage of his men than his opponent. IIRC Lee had the highest casualty rate of any Army Commander in the ACW, North or South. He basically bled the CSA white.


Pretty much...;)

Best,
 
Top