WI King Phillip's War Was More Succesful?

Unfortunately, it's difficult to come up with that kind of scenario. The problem is that Indians quickly became dependent on a continuing supply of European trade goods. They also tended to see other tribes as the greater enemies until it was too late. And then there are the epidemics that tended to leave openings for settlers to come in to nearly vacant lands.

I did a scenario years ago where the Pequots won their war against the colonists. Even that doesn't get the colonists out of New England, though it does abort Connecticut as I recall it.

The Indians could actually do a fairly good job of scuppering the New England colonies economically in King Phillips war. They actually almost ran the colonies out of hard currency and caused a twenty year local depression. Give them another year or two of fighting and let them survive to fight again in the French and Indian wars, and while it doesn't do everything you want it does significant damage.
 
Top