WI Humphrey IV de Toron accepts the Crown of Jerusalem in 1186?

In summer 1186 the 5 year old Baldwin V died and Raymond III with the nobles attempted to stage a coup in order to place Isabella on the throne with her husband Humphrey IV de Toron. Humphrey, however, backed down (he was stepson of Guy's ally Raynald de Chatillon), and swore fealty to Sibylla and Guy. Raymond III, disgusted, returned home to Tripoli, and Baldwin of Ibelin went into self-imposed exile from the kingdom.
Sibylla and Guy's rule proved to be disastrous, and the kingdom was nearly wiped out by Saladin after the Battle of Hattin in 1187. Baldwin V's paternal uncle, Conrad of Montferrat, saved Tyre and carried forward the Montferrat claim to the throne, reinforced by his marriage to Isabella.
WI Humphrey IV de Toron had the guts to challenge Guy and Sibylla for the Crown? How is that changing History? Any thoughts?
 
Humphrey of Toron

He was a bigger joke than Guy of Lusignan. If he became king, then the native faction headed by Raymond of Tripoli and some of the Ibelins would have controlled the government. They would definitely have become tributary to Saladin. I suspect Guy and Sybilla would have been forced into exile. It is hard to speculate what if any western powers would have assisted them .
 
Actually if Humphrey IV accepted the Crown he would have been nothing more than a puppet King... Raymond III of Tripoli and the Barons would be the power behind the throne...
In that case the Kingdom of Jerusalem would have looked like a lot to the WRE... an uneffective and puppet ruler being manipulated by powerful Nobles and magistrates...
 
Top