RodentRevolution
Banned
Funny guy, not uber, just better at certain things, in this case night fighting.
Except they were not. You have been reduced to making excuses for their demonstrated simple problems with basic manoeuvres in the dark and the fact that among other things when trying to respond to attack they managed to ram and sink one of their own light cruisers (hence why I claim it for the British, an own goal is still a goal) or are you now going to argue that the Germans just routinely ran down their own shipping?
Fact is your argument rest solely on people having studied no other action than Jutland, relies on them not actually studying what happened at Jutland and more importantly is completely dependent on them not having a good idea of what was humanly possible which is something that emerges once you have studied enough actual naval actions that took place.