WI Elizabeth Tudor lived?

What if Elizabeth Tudor (1492-1495), second daughter of Henry VII and Elizabeth of York had lived? So who would she marry? There was talk about her marrying the future Francis I. How would this event change history? Please discuss!:)
 
Last edited:
The engagement to Francis would be called off as soon as it became apparent Claude (or Claudia) would inherit Brittany. She'd almost certainly take Margaret's place as the King of Scots intended bride.

Now, if they both lived, that would make for an interesting PoD.
 
Margaret, the elder sister, marries King James of Scots as per OTL.

Elizabeth would no doubt be employed as a marriage pawn on the continent, with the purpose of securing international recognition of Henry's title to the crown. The Tudors were eager to connect themselves with the Trastamara and Habsburg alliance at any cost - Henry VII courted both Juana la Loca and Joanna of Naples while Henry VIII was betrothed to both Catherine of Aragon and Eleanor of Austria. So I can see Henry advancing Elizabeth as a bride for Ferdinand following the deaths of Arthur and Isabella which imperiled the Anglo-Spanish alliance and devalued Catherine of Aragón as a prospective bride. If Ferdinand turned her down, Christian II of Denmark (four years older) would make the most respectable match out of all the available bachelors. Failing that John Stewart, Duke of Albany (heir to Scottish throne), Gaston of Foix, Duke of Nemours (the only nephew of King Louis XII) or Anthony, Duke of Lorraine and Bar (whose family claimed the crowns of Naples, Jerusalem and Aragon) would make more or less suitable matches. Unfortunately for her father's policy she would be far too old to be seriously considered as a bride for young Charles of Castille.

EDIT: Considering Henry VII hated spending money, he'd also consider that when it came to choosing a bride groom. A son-in-law of lower rank might make less demands than a King. Some financial deal where unpaid parts of Catherine of Aragon's dowry got factored into Elizabeth's dowry (for a Spanish match) or where arrears of Henry's own French pensions were abated as a dowry for a French match (basically transferring King Louis' debt to Henry to the bride-groom, in this case his nephew) might be of interest.
 
Last edited:
So lets say Henry VII decides to have Elizabeth marry Ferdinand II of Aragon to solve the dowry question. Would she have any children and if she had a son would he inherit Aragon? What would the 16th Century be like with an independent Aragon?
 
You can check out the TL called 'Yo, El Rey' if you would like to see the effects of an independent Aragon in the 16th century.
 
So lets say Henry VII decides to have Elizabeth marry Ferdinand II of Aragon to solve the dowry question. Would she have any children and if she had a son would he inherit Aragon? What would the 16th Century be like with an independent Aragon?

A son would inherit Aragón, part of Navarre and Aragon's Mediterranean empire (Sicily, Naples, islands). A daughter would be a 'mere' Infanta of Aragón.
 
Would a female tudor married to a Hapsburg male make much difference down the line to their inbreeding problem?

Depends which one. A daughter of Catherine of Aragón - herself a sister of the schizophrenic(?) Juana la Loca, niece of the apathetic King Enrique and granddaughter of the also crazy Isabella of Portugal - probably wouldn't help things too much; perhaps a trade: better jaws in return for obesity and schizophrenia?
 
If Elizabeth were married to Ferdinand of Aragon it would be a Tudor princess marrying a Trastamara prince. Also, Ferdinand had Juana Enriquez as a mother (who while grasping, no one records her as being insane). Isabella of Portugal was Isabella of Castile's mother, Enrique her brother. Though admittedly his father, Juan II of Aragon was likewise apathetic.
 
The idea of Elizabeth Tudor and Ferdinand is far ickier than Catherine and Henry VII... At the time of Queen Isabella's death Elizabeth Tudor would be 12, she would have around 24 when Ferdinand dies in the OTL. So it's possible they might have a child together.

Possible butterflies of this match happening:
-the relationship between Henry VII and Ferdinand may not deteriorate as badly and perhaps Catherine avoids some of the difficulties she went through between her marriages and perhaps she marries Henry earlier
-long term, the Hapsburgs have might have an eye on absorbing Ferdinand's Kingdom, so instead of primarily marrying between threeish families, they marry between four and might not get into inbreeding problems so soon
 
Last edited:
Top