Here's a quick list based on a Dukakis '88 Victory.
The Duke Wins: List of Presidents
40. Ronald W. Reagan (R-CA): January 20th 1981-January 20th 1989
41. Michael S. “Mike” Dukakis (D-MA): January 20th 1989-January 20th 1997
42. James “Jim” Edgar (R-IL): January 20th 1997-January 20th 2005
43. J.C. Watts Jr. (R-OK): January 20th 2005-January 20th 2009**
44. Kathleen Kennedy Townsend (D-MD): January 20th 2009-???**
Notes
41. First Greek-American President
43. First African American President
44. First Female President
The Duke Wins: List of Vice-Presidents
41. George H.W. Bush (R-TX): January 20th 1981-January 20th 1989
43. Lloyd M. Bentsen (D-TX): January 20th 1989-January 20th 1993
44. William J. “Bill” Clinton (D-AK): January 20th 1993-January 20th 1997
45. J.C. Watts Jr. (R-OK): January 20th 1997-January 20th 2005
46. Peter B. “Pete” Wilson (R-CA): January 20th 2005-January 20th 2009
47. James H. “Jim” Webb Jr. (D-VA): January 20th 2009-???
The Duke Wins: List of Presidents
40. Ronald W. Reagan (R-CA): January 20th 1981-January 20th 1989
41. Michael S. “Mike” Dukakis (D-MA): January 20th 1989-January 20th 1997
42. James “Jim” Edgar (R-IL): January 20th 1997-January 20th 2005
43. J.C. Watts Jr. (R-OK): January 20th 2005-January 20th 2009**
44. Kathleen Kennedy Townsend (D-MD): January 20th 2009-???**
Notes
41. First Greek-American President
43. First African American President
44. First Female President
The Duke Wins: List of Vice-Presidents
41. George H.W. Bush (R-TX): January 20th 1981-January 20th 1989
43. Lloyd M. Bentsen (D-TX): January 20th 1989-January 20th 1993
44. William J. “Bill” Clinton (D-AK): January 20th 1993-January 20th 1997
45. J.C. Watts Jr. (R-OK): January 20th 1997-January 20th 2005
46. Peter B. “Pete” Wilson (R-CA): January 20th 2005-January 20th 2009
47. James H. “Jim” Webb Jr. (D-VA): January 20th 2009-???